Denis O'Brien received €5.8m from State Claims Agency for legal costs
The payment is a full and final settlement of his costs application, following an order by the tribunal in March 2021.
It is understood that the payment, first reported in the Irish Independent, is the largest of its kind ever to a tribunal witness.
The Tribunal of Inquiry into certain payments to politicians and related matters was established in September 1997, and examined payments to former taoiseach Charles Haughey and then-Fine Gael TD Michael Lowry.
Chaired by High Court Judge Michael Moriarty, his first report was published in 2006 and dealt with the former taoiseach.
It found that Mr Haughey received cash for favours and lived a life vastly beyond the scale of his earnings as a public representative.
The Tribunal's second and final report was published in March 2011.
It dealt with payments to Mr Lowry, and in particular his links with Mr O'Brien.
Ireland's second mobile phone licence was awarded to Mr O'Brien's consortium Esat Digifone in 1995, when Mr Lowry was minister for communications.
The Tribunal's report found it was "beyond doubt" that Mr Lowry imparted substantive information to Mr O'Brien, which it said was "of significant value and assistance to him in securing the licence".
The report described Mr Lowry's role as "disgraceful and insidious".
It also summarised payments to Mr Lowry made or facilitated by Mr O'Brien, totalling £447,000 and support for a £420,000 loan, as well as donations by Mr O'Brien or his companies to Fine Gael.
The findings were strongly rejected by those at the centre of the conclusions.
Mr O'Brien said the report was fundamentally flawed and insisted he never made any payment to Mr Lowry.
Mr Lowry said the report was "factually wrong and deliberately misleading", adding that Mr Justice Moriarty's opinions were "not substantiated by evidence or fact".
Mr Lowry's dealings with the tribunal came to an end just over a year ago when he reached a settlement over his legal costs.
The 2011 report was referred by the government to An Garda Síochána, and the Criminal Assets Bureau began an investigation.
Fourteen years on, it will now be for the Director of Public Prosecutions to decide if any criminal charges will be laid against any individual as a result.
The final cost of the inquiry has still not been determined, but the latest figures published by the Government show that it has cost more than €71 million up to June last year.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
4 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Heather Humphreys likely to be second confirmed candidate to enter Áras race
Heather Humphreys is likely to be the second confirmed candidate to enter the race for the Aras and yesterday she received the backing of a government minister. Independent TD Noel Grealish has said he believes the former social protection minister would make an excellent president if she were to put her name forward. The Minister of State at the Department of Agriculture said Ms Humphreys is vastly experienced and well regarded by TDs across parties. He said: "Heather was a vastly experienced Minister at cabinet, having served in a number of different portfolios and representing the interests of all Irish people. 'She was very well regarded by TDs across all political parties and she would appeal to a broad base of voters,' said Minister Grealish. 'Heather has an in-depth knowledge of the Constitution and the role of President and she would represent our country with distinction both at home and abroad if she were to be elected as President of Ireland.' So far independent TD Catherine Connolly is the only confirmed candidate after formally launching her bid to become Ireland's next president last month. During the week former justice minister Frances Fitzgerald ruled herself out of the presidential race shortly after Mairead McGuinness' departure from the election contest on health grounds. Senior Fine Gael party members will meet over the coming days to consider its next steps and it is likely Ms Humphreys will be urged to become a candidate. The former Cavan-Monaghan TD had been linked with a presidential bid before, and while she said she was flattered to be considered before withdrawing her name. Former GAA chief and MEP Seán Kelly is another possible Fine Gael candidate after saying he will "most likely reconsider" his possible candidacy in the presidential campaign in light of Mairead McGuinness' withdrawal. Meanwhile presidential hopeful Gareth Sheridan, who claims he has the backing of two local councils, has criticised what he claimed are Catherine Connolly's 'aggressive nationalism' and her attack on Ireland's allies. He said: Catherine Connolly is wrong to engage in a form of aggressive Nationalism and worse, attacking our long-established allies. 'I fear this is evidence of her Anti-EU politics. Ms Connolly is hoping to be our next President and her claim that Ireland can't trust the United States, the United Kingdom and France is an ill-judged over-step. 'We will have a new President in less than thirteen weeks and here is Deputy Connolly, a Party candidate endorsed by the Social Democrats and People Before Profit, on the weekend of a US – Russian Summit to achieve peace in Ukraine, expressing what could be interpreted as a pro-Putin stance. 'Ukraine President Zelensky is on record numerous times thanking the EU, USA and UK for their financial and military aid to defend his country against the Russian invasion. 'For myself, as a non-party, a-political candidate not beholden to any ideology, seeking a nomination under Article 12.2.2. of our Constitution, I am calling for an immediate end to invasions of Ukraine and Gaza. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
The Journal
16 hours ago
- The Journal
Presidential campaigning ramping up as potential candidates take stock after McGuinness withdrawal
NO WEEKEND REST today for public figures with their eyes on the forthcoming presidential election. Campaigning is picking up pace as potential candidates take stock of a changed election landscape after the unexpected withdrawal of Fine Gael nominee Mairéad McGuinness, who has taken herself out of the running due to health reasons after spending time recently in hospital. Fine Gael is now faced with deciding who will replace her to run against left-wing candidate Catherine Connolly and others who may secure a place on the ballot between now and the official start of the election period. Some potential contenders within the party include former MEP Seán Kelly, who previously signalled his interest in the role but ultimately did not challenge McGuinness' bid , and former TD Heather Humphreys. Speaking on Newstalk's Anton Savage show this morning, Kelly said that given the 'goalposts have changed', he will 'reconsider' whether to campaign for the nomination. Advertisement He said he believes discussions about who the next Fine Gael nominee will be haven't taken off yet because it is 'unfair on Mairead, having had such a trauma all of a sudden and having to withdraw'. He said there will be time next week to 'reflect properly on that and take action'. Meanwhile, Catherine Connolly, the only formally confirmed candidate, has clarified some of her views on international issues, criticising both Nato countries for 'warmongering' and Russia for its 'horrific assault' on Ukraine. Catherine Connolly launched her campaign last month. Sasko Lazarov / © Sasko Lazarov / © / © Speaking to the Irish Times , she said that Ireland should 'resist' the European Union becoming 'increasingly militarised', adding that the EU has 'lost its moral compass'. The article referenced a Dáil session in February in which Connolly indicated, in the context of whether to keep or remove the triple lock, that Ireland 'cannot trust' countries like the US, UK and France in terms of their foreign policy positions. In her new remarks, Connolly reaffirmed her position that 'the US, England and France are deeply entrenched in an arms industry which causes bloodshed across the world' and said that 'as a staunch advocate for neutrality, this behaviour must be condemned'. Related Reads Frances Fitzgerald not entering Áras race for Fine Gael as Sean Kelly mulls bid Connolly also criticised Russia, saying that it is 'conducting an illegal invasion of Ukraine' and 'must immediately end its horrific assault'. Asked if she would meet with US President Donald Trump if she was elected, she said she 'would meet all heads of state as mandated by the Constitution and the office of President'. Gareth Sheridan, a millionaire pharma boss who launched a campaign this week but has not formally secured a nomination to date, took a swipe at Connolly this afternoon in response, accusing her of engaging 'in a form of aggressive nationalism' and 'attacking our long-established allies'. He called her comments about the US, UK and France an 'ill-judged over-step', though acknowledged that we do 'need the EU, the US and the UK to do more' to stop the wars in Ukraine and Gaza. 'The Ireland that I would like to represent is the one which forged strong international ties on the world stage,' he said. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Agriland
17 hours ago
- Agriland
Former agri journalist Mairead McGuinness to run for presidency
Former MEP and European Commissioner Mairead McGuinnes, who started her career as an agricultural journalist, has secured the Fine Gael nomination to run as a candidate to become President of Ireland. Current President, Michael D Higgins will finish his second seven-year term at Áras an Uachtaráin in November. The President of Ireland (Uachtarán na hÉireann) is Ireland's Head of State. Every seven years the public elect a new president who can serve two terms in total. According to the electoral commission, some of the president's constitutional roles include: Representing the people of Ireland; Appointment of the Taoiseach, members of the government, judges and other officials; Summoning and dissolving the Dáil, and convening the Oireachtas; Signing legislation into law and/or referring Bills to the Supreme Court; Supreme Commander of the Defence Forces. To be nominated as a Fine Gael candidate, a candidate required the nomination of at least 20 members of the Fine Gael Parliamentary Party, 25 councillors and five members of the Fine Gael Executive Council. McGuinness's name will go forward for ratification at a party event in September. This will be the start of the Fine Gael presidential election campaign. Tánaiste and Fine Gael president Simon Harris said: 'The Fine Gael party is pleased to confirm Mairead McGuinness has been nominated as our candidate for the Presidential election and will be ratified by the party in September. 'Mairead has secured the support of the parliamentary party and the wider Fine Gael organisation. I look forward to working with her over the coming months. 'Presidential elections are always an important point for the country. I believe Mairead possesses all the attributes to bring our nation together at this important time.' Commenting on being nominated as the Fine Gael candidate for the role, Mairead McGuinness said: "I am conscious of the opportunity and challenge ahead, given the very important constitutional role of the President, and the esteem in which the office is held by the people. "Subject to my candidacy being ratified by the party in early September, I very much look forward to setting out my vision for the Presidency. And I look forward to working with you all over the coming weeks and months. "The campaign when it starts will be full-on," she added. A native of Ardee, Co. Louth, from a strong Fine Gael family, Mairead McGuinness is married to Tom Duff and they have four children. They now live near Drumconrath, Co. Meath. McGuinness was educated locally at the Convent of Mercy National School and Ardee Community School. She studied agricultural economics at University College Dublin (UCD), the first woman to qualify in the discipline and served as recording secretary of the Agricultural Society (Ag Soc) at the college. She began her career in journalism in RTÉ immediately after college. She worked initially as radio producer and later in research on 'The Late Late Show'. In more recent times McGuinness became well known as a presenter and driving force behind the 'Ear to the Ground' TV series. She also held the role of editor of the Farming Independent. Mairead McGuinness served two terms as chairperson of the Guild of Agricultural Journalists and helped develop the guild as an important network for those in food and farming communications. She also chaired the Consumer Liaison panel set up by the Minister for Agriculture and Food. This panel spearheaded changes in food labelling and traceability initiatives. Related Stories McGuinness was first elected to the European Parliament in 2004 representing the Midlands North-West region of Ireland. She was elected by European counterparts as vice-president and was also previously a full member of the Agriculture & Rural Development/AGRI Committee and a substitute on Environment, Public Health & Food Safety/ENVI Committee as an MEP. She was voted by her colleagues as MEP of the Year for Agriculture in 2011. In 2014 she was awarded the UCD Foundation Day Alumni Award in Agriculture and Food Science. In 2020, she was appointed European Commissioner for Financial services, Financial Stability and Capital Markets Union until 2024.
