logo
Egyptian tycoon wins bid to throw out UK lawsuit over singer's murder

Egyptian tycoon wins bid to throw out UK lawsuit over singer's murder

Arab News2 days ago
LONDON: Egyptian real estate tycoon Hisham Talaat Moustafa on Friday won his bid to throw out a London lawsuit brought against him by a former kickboxing world champion for ordering the murder of a Lebanese pop star in 2008.
Talaat Moustafa, CEO of Talaat Moustafa Group, was convicted in Egypt of paying a former police officer to stab Suzanne Tamim, 30, to death at her luxury apartment in Dubai.
He was initially sentenced to death in 2009, before his conviction was overturned on appeal. Following two retrials, Talaat Moustafa was convicted again and jailed for 15 years. He was pardoned by Egyptian President Abdel Fattah El-Sisi in 2017.
Tamim, who rose to fame after winning a television talent show in the 1990s, had been in a relationship with Iraqi-British kickboxer Riyadh Al-Azzawi before she was killed.
Al-Azzawi sued Talaat Moustafa at London's High Court in 2022, seeking damages for the psychological and emotional damage he said he suffered as a result of Tamim's murder.
Talaat Moustafa sought to have the case thrown out, arguing Al-Azzawi's lawyers did not provide all relevant evidence when they were given permission to bring the case and that it should be heard in Dubai, rather than London.
In a ruling dismissing the case on Friday, Judge Christopher Butcher said Al-Azzawi did not disclose relevant information about whether the lawsuit was brought too late when he sought permission to serve the case on Talaat Moustafa in Egypt.
The judge also said that 'the courts of Dubai are clearly and distinctly more appropriate' if the case were to proceed.
Talaat Moustafa's English lawyers did not immediately comment. Al-Azzawi's lawyers could not be contacted for comment.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Rights activists welcome Pakistan Senate move to scrap death penalty for two crimes
Rights activists welcome Pakistan Senate move to scrap death penalty for two crimes

Arab News

time3 hours ago

  • Arab News

Rights activists welcome Pakistan Senate move to scrap death penalty for two crimes

KARACHI: Rights activists in Pakistan on Saturday welcomed Pakistan's Senate decision to abolish the death penalty for two criminal offenses— publicly stripping women and harboring hijackers— but stressed the need for stronger legislation and better enforcement to ensure justice for survivors and prevent violence. The reform amends Sections 354-A and 402-C of the Pakistan Penal Code and replaces capital punishment with life imprisonment for the two crimes. Lawmakers say the move is part of a broader effort to align Pakistan's criminal justice system with international human rights standards, particularly under the European Union's Generalized Scheme of Preferences Plus (GSP+), which grants preferential trade access to countries that uphold certain rights commitments. 'Publicly stripping women of their clothes is one of the most heinous crimes and must be met with the harshest punishment,' Mahnaz Rahman, woman's rights activist and former executive director of the Aurat Foundation, told Arab News. 'While we strongly advocate for severe punishments for such acts, we do not support the death penalty for any crime, including this one.' She said life imprisonment itself was an 'extremely severe' punishment, though she insisted the change must be accompanied by comprehensive and robust legislation to prevent this and all other forms of violence against women. 'Ultimately, it is the effective enforcement of laws and accountability that will deter such crimes and help ensure that women feel genuinely safe and protected in our society,' she added. Sarah Belal, Executive Director of Justice Project Pakistan (JPP), said the reform aligned Pakistan's criminal justice system more closely with the principles of fairness and the rule of law. 'The death penalty has never been enforced for this offense, but its mere presence has discouraged convictions and denied survivors meaningful redress,' she said. 'Harsh punishments may appear tough, but they often let perpetrators walk free.' 'Removing the death penalty for these offenses does not mean they are being decriminalized,' she added. 'It simply means we are pushing for stronger, more proportionate implementation of the law.' Senator Talal Chaudhry of the ruling Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) party who introduced the bill said the amendments had been thoroughly discussed and approved by a standing committee with cross-party input. 'Replacing the death penalty with life imprisonment under both sections is part of Pakistan's legal reforms,' he said. The bill must now be passed by the National Assembly before it can receive presidential assent and become law. Under existing law, Section 354-A allows for capital punishment or life imprisonment for anyone who assaults and strips a woman in public, while Section 402-C applies the same punishment to individuals who knowingly harbor hijackers. The new bill eliminates the death penalty option for both. However, some lawmakers have voiced concern over the move. Senator Samina Mumtaz Zehri of the Balochistan Awami Party warned that Pakistan's low conviction rates and weak enforcement mechanisms could make reduced punishments ineffective as a deterrent. 'This is not right,' she was quoted as saying by Dawn newspaper. 'This is not going to help the country or its people.' Chaudhry defended the move, pointing to the misuse of capital punishment laws enacted during the military regime of General Zia-ul-Haq. 'Life imprisonment is by no means a minor punishment,' he said, noting that the law had often been abused by police to settle personal vendettas. Federal Law Minister Azam Nazeer Tarar emphasized that the changes did not affect death sentences for more serious crimes like murder or rape. 'We are only removing the death penalty from offenses that do not constitute the 'most serious crimes,' a key requirement under the GSP+ agreement,' he said in response to a query by Senator Shibli Faraz. Pakistan has long faced international scrutiny over its broad application of the death penalty. At least 31 offenses are currently punishable by death under Pakistani law. While executions have not taken place since 2020, over 6,100 people remain on death row, according to the Justice Project Pakistan. Between 2015 and 2019, more than 500 people were executed following the end of a moratorium in 2014. Senator Quratulain Marri of the Pakistan People's Party, a coalition partner of the ruling PML-N, said her party opposed the death penalty on principle. 'There are numerous studies on how capital punishment is not an effective deterrent,' she told Arab News. 'While the need for reforms cannot be ruled out, we have to consider bringing changes that better society in the long run. The aim is to rid society of the crime and not just the criminal.'

Police arrest more than 50 Palestine Action demonstrators in London
Police arrest more than 50 Palestine Action demonstrators in London

Arab News

time16 hours ago

  • Arab News

Police arrest more than 50 Palestine Action demonstrators in London

LONDON: More than 50 protesters have been arrested in central London supporting the banned group Palestine Action. Protests were held across the UK on Saturday, including in Manchester, Edinburgh and Bristol after the group was outlawed as a terrorist organization. The main demonstration was in Parliament Square in Westminster, where numerous people held up signs reading 'I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action.' Supporting a proscribed group in the UK is illegal. The protesters in London were detained under Section 13 of the UK's Terrorism Act, which carries a possible jail term of six years. On X the Metropolitan Police stated: '55 people were arrested in Parliament Square for displaying placards in support of Palestine Action which is a proscribed group.' Eight people were also arrested in Truro, Cornwall for a similar protest. Several others were detained in Manchester. Defend Our Juries, the group behind the protests, said before the demonstrations that 120 people in the UK had been arrested for supporting Palestine Action so far. The group was banned after activists broke into a Royal Air Force base at Brize Norton on June 20, causing an estimated £7 million ($9.38 million) of damage to military aircraft. Membership of direct support for Palestine Action now carries a prison term of up to 14 years. Displaying the group's name on clothing could lead to a six-month jail sentence. A hearing into a permission to bring a judicial review into the ban will be held at the High Court in London on Monday.

UK to fight compensation claims after massive Afghanistan data leak
UK to fight compensation claims after massive Afghanistan data leak

Arab News

time18 hours ago

  • Arab News

UK to fight compensation claims after massive Afghanistan data leak

London: The UK will resist paying compensation to thousands of Afghans caught up in a data leak scandal, The Times reported on Saturday. The names and details of around 100,000 people in Afghanistan who worked with UK Armed Forces as part of the US-led coalition in the country were accidentally revealed online by a Ministry of Defence employee in February 2022. It led to a massive covert program to bring large numbers of Afghans to Britain for fear they could be targeted by the Taliban, it emerged this week. But the MoD will fight five-figure claims against it for endangering the lives of Afghans caught up in the leak following a review by former civil servant Paul Rimmer, ordered by Defence Secretary John Healey, which suggested that the risk to their safety had 'diminished.' Lawyers for the ministry say taxpayers have already paid enough after billions of pounds were set aside for the repatriation scheme of around 24,000 Afghan personnel and their families to the UK, a source told The Times. Thousands of Afghans still trapped in their country have been left in fear for their safety after learning about the data breach on July 15. The leak and accompanying repatriation scheme were kept from public knowledge after the government used a legal device called a superinjunction to prevent reporting on it. Before the superinjunction was lifted by a court, the government announced a small compensation scheme for victims of a separate, smaller data leak from 2021, of £4,000 ($5,364) per person. The MoD will contest compensation claims by law firms representing Afghans affected by the 2022 breach. The biggest lawsuit, brought by Barings Law, involves over 1,000 Afghan clients. The Times said it has seen WhatsApp messages sent to people in the UK, Afghanistan and Pakistan urging them to register with Barings to join the lawsuit. The firm's head of data protection, Adnan Malik, said around 100 people a day are signing up to sue the MoD, and the firm expects to be able to win payouts of 'at least five figures' for those who can prove they had been contacted by the ministry confirming that their details were leaked. Law firm Leigh Day is also suing the government on behalf of hundreds of Afghan clients. 'We are currently acting for a number of existing clients and are also being approached each day by dozens more people who have been affected,' Sean Humber, a partner at the firm, told The Times. The MoD confirmed that around 5,400 Afghans still in their country are eligible for flights to the UK under the Afghan Response Route and the Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy. It expects to have relocated all those deemed at risk from the Taliban and with a right to come to Britain under its various programs by 2029. An MoD spokesman told The Times: 'We will robustly defend against any legal action or compensation. The independent Rimmer Review concluded that it is highly unlikely that merely being on the spreadsheet would be grounds for an individual to be targeted, and this is the basis on which the court lifted its super injunction this week.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store