WHL Commissioner Dan Near reignites NCAA vs. AHL hockey debate
A simmering hockey development debate that has been around for a long time has erupted once more—and this time it's personal. WHL Commissioner Dan Near came out swinging in his podcast appearance this week, likening NCAA hockey to "business class" and challenging whether or not it properly prepares players for the ruggedness of pro hockey existence in the AHL.
Dan Near's "business class" insult of NCAA draws criticism
On July 16, WHL Commissioner Dan Near caused a stir when he made an appearance on the Pipeline Show podcast and offered a blunt analogy comparing NCAA hockey to flying business class. He maintained that players, after being introduced to the comfort of the college game, might not be prepared for the pro-level grind and the turbulence associated with it.
'I know people who have flown coach their whole life and then had an opportunity to get upgraded, and they sat in business class.
Do you know how hard it is to go back to coach once you've sat in business class?' he said. 'Well, the American Hockey League versus the NCAA environment—I'm not sure that playing a Friday-Saturday schedule and then pumping iron and drinking smoothies all week is necessarily the best segue into what the AHL grind is like.
'
His words prompted instant backlash on the web, particularly given the timing—just days after the league's best WHL star, Gavin McKenna, pledged to Penn State, the first marquee CHL player to leap to NCAA hockey under the new eligibility standards.
NCAA advocates make the case that additional time, schooling, and focus on comprehensive development can be to the benefit of both the player and the individual. Detractors contend it has the potential to shelter players from pro-grade adversity.
Bottom line: No easy path to
NHL
Dan Near's comparison is inflammatory, perhaps, but it raises a legitimate question: Is NCAA hockey readying players for professional hockey's strain, or is it too cushy?
Also read:
Future NHL stars: Ranking top 10 goaltenders under age 25, including Dustin Wolf and Spencer Knight
With more CHL players looking to the college path and the AHL still pumping out NHL-ready talent, the argument isn't disappearing anytime soon. And while leagues vie for the future stars, the only thing certain is that the road to the NHL will continue to be anything but smooth.
Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
IND vs ENG 4th Test: Manchester weather update – Will rain disrupt play at Old Trafford?
Heavy rains hit manchester Persistent heavy rain threw India's preparations for the crucial fourth Test against England into disarray as their first training session in Manchester was forced entirely indoors. The Old Trafford nets, which started as optional, saw several key players—including captain Shubman Gill , KL Rahul , and Jasprit Bumrah—skip practice altogether. The rest of the squad reported to the ground amid downpours and gloomy skies, leaving the press and onlookers with no view of the team's indoor activities. Manchester's famously unpredictable weather is proving a real challenge. Over the past three days, the city has swung from brief sunshine to steady rain. The forecast for the Test's opening day, July 23, predicts a 60% chance of morning showers and temperatures dropping to 17°C, raising concerns about start-time delays and tricky playing conditions. Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! The uncooperative weather is just one of several headaches for the Indian camp. Fresh injury concerns have emerged in the fast-bowling ranks. Arshdeep Singh has a hand injury, and Akash Deep, who starred at Edgbaston, is now a doubtful starter with an ongoing back problem. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Struggling With Belly Fat? Try This at Home Home Fitness Hack Shop Now Undo India camp hit by more injuries, Playing XI TENSION before Manchester Test vs England In response, Haryana pacer Anshul Kamboj has been called up and could be on the cusp of a Test debut. Jasprit Bumrah , however, is expected to be fit and ready despite skipping the optional nets, providing a much-needed silver lining. Heavy rain in Manchester With the rain narrowing preparation windows, tough calls loom. The management is considering dynamic changes and a possible reshuffle at number three in the batting order, assessing Karun Nair's place, and debating whether to bring back Sai Sudarshan. Rishabh Pant 's fitness is a topic of discussion, with the team weighing the option of deploying him solely as a batsman, perhaps handing wicketkeeping gloves to KL Rahul or giving Dhruv Jurel his chance. Selection dilemmas and weather uncertainty now dominate the narrative. As both teams chase the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy, all eyes remain on the Old Trafford skies, knowing they could play as decisive a part in the Test outcome as any player on the field. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Oriental Cup school football tournament from July 21-29
Ambedkar Stadium The third season of the Oriental Cup, a school football tournament in the national capital, will be held from July 21-29, the organisers said on Thursday. Started by student-athlete Fareed Bakshi, the tournament will take place at the Ambedkar Stadium, bringing together 36 teams from schools across Delhi. Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! There will be 24 teams in the boys' (U-15) category and 12 in the girls' (U-19) category. The 2025 edition will have a three-stage format, starting with the qualifying rounds followed by the league phase and the finals for both boys' and girls' category. Air Force School, Subroto Park, and Apex School have claimed the boys' titles in 2023 and 2024 editions respectively, while Sanskriti School has maintained a dominant presence in the girls' division, winning on both occasions. Co-founder Bakshi emphasised the tournament's larger mission, saying, "The Oriental Cup goes beyond just competition. It's about building a space where school athletes across Delhi can play, grow, and feel a sense of community through football . "We're excited to welcome new teams and continue expanding the legacy we began just two years ago." Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
ESPN analyst Mina Kimes slams coach rankings, backs Sean McDermott after shocking PFF snub
Sean McDermott backed by ESPN's Mina Kimes after PFF snub (Image via AP) Buffalo Bills head coach Sean McDermott was left off Pro Football Focus' top 10 returning NFL coaches for 2025. The omission didn't sit well with ESPN's Mina Kimes, who stepped up with a powerful public defense. Her comments felt more like family than media — personal, sharp, and unapologetically honest. In a league obsessed with wins, someone finally spoke about what McDermott truly brings. ESPN's voice challenges NFL's bias In a league where headlines favor playoff records, McDermott's day-to-day consistency often gets ignored. The PFF snub only proved how undervalued foundational coaching has become in today's flashy NFL coverage. That's when Mina Kimes delivered a strong rebuttal on ESPN, saying, 'He consistently gets the best out of his players.' It wasn't just commentary — it felt like a personal statement defending a coach with few media allies. — OneBillsLive (@OneBillsLive) McDermott's legacy is bigger than stats Since 2017, McDermott has built the Bills into one of the most disciplined and competitive teams in the league. While others chase viral moments, he has quietly developed stars and delivered consistent wins year after year. Kimes pointed to his ability to adapt, saying, 'He knows how to build around strengths and elevate his roster.' by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Ready for a Glow-Up? [Get Your Reading Now] Undo Glow-Up Packages from $15 [Sign Up] Undo Affect Your Future Now! (Book Today) Undo His impact extends beyond numbers — he creates team culture, player belief, and week-to-week stability. When a comment feels like family To some fans, Kimes' words felt more like something a daughter might say to defend her father. It wasn't PR — it was a heartfelt take on a man who leads without demanding attention or spotlight. She added, 'He deserves more credit,' giving voice to what Bills Mafia and players have long felt. In a moment when silence would've been easier, Kimes chose to speak up. Also read: Who is Faith Ward? Everything You Need to Know About the First-Ever Kiwi Dallas Cowboys Cheerleader FAQs 1. What NFL team does Sean McDermott coach? He is the head coach of the Buffalo Bills, leading them since 2017. 2. Why did Mina Kimes defend Sean McDermott? She felt he was unfairly left off PFF's top-10 coach list and highlighted his consistent leadership and player development. 3. What is Sean McDermott best known for? He's respected for building a strong team culture, developing talent, and keeping the Bills playoff-relevant every season. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
