
Rachel Reeves 'limping' from one event to the next, head of the Institute for Fiscal Studies warns in brutal assessment of Labour's economic record
Helen Miller said while Labour came into office on the promise of 'mission-driven government' and 'long-term thinking', reality proved different.
Fears about small downgrades to Britain's growth prospects meant that the Budgets and statements were dominated by concerns about the parlous state of the public finances and if tax hikes or spending cuts would be needed, she said.
'We continue to limp from fiscal event to fiscal event, obsessed with whether run-of-the-mill revisions to the economic and fiscal outlook have reduced the fiscal headroom and whether tax or spend takeaways will follow,' said Ms Miller. 'We need to break out of this cycle.'
The remarks add to the increasingly negative perceptions of Labour's handling of the economy after a year in power, with business leaders and economists unsettled by the direction being taken by Ms Reeves – and bond markets also becoming anxious.
Ms Miller made the comments as she steps up from deputy to replace Paul Johnson as director of the IFS, a respected financial think-tank.
Economists and businessmen continue to wonder whether Ms Reeves will have to put up taxes in her autumn Budget after Labour's U-turns on welfare and winter fuel payments.
Growth also looks to be deteriorating, and defence spending must be increased as per new Nato rules and the Prime Minister's pledge. These shortcomings may open a financial black hole.
Ms Miller said it was 'safe to assume the Chancellor will stick to her fiscal rules' on bringing down debt and borrowing. She added: 'But that alone doesn't automatically equate to sustainable public finances.'
Last week the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) warned Britain was effectively living beyond its means, saying it 'cannot afford the array of promises that it has made to the public'.
Ms Miller said: 'There are lots of reasons that demands for government spending could run far ahead of tax revenues.
However much this – or any future – Government is willing to tax and spend, it won't be enough. We need better designed policies.
'And we desperately need economic growth. While that wouldn't eliminate the need for trade-offs it would make them more palatable.'
Ms Miller also echoed the OBR's warning that the abandonment of planned spending cuts was leaving the UK's finances more vulnerable.
She said: 'Politicians need to level with voters about the scale of the challenges and to make the case for bold reforms.
'Lessons must be learned from the recent disability benefits U-turn, and learned quickly, so that reform efforts in other areas land more successfully.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


BBC News
3 minutes ago
- BBC News
Reading's carbon emissions have fallen by 57%, data shows
Carbon emissions in Reading have fallen by more than half over an 18-year period, new government figures Berkshire town has seen the 12th biggest reduction in emissions out of the UK's 384 local authorities between 2005 and 2023, according to the Borough Council said it was currently working on "major projects" to reduce its own carbon footprint and "create a net zero borough".John Ennis, the authority's climate lead, said the government figures showed "Reading's commitment to taking positive climate action". "It is only through organisations, businesses, communities and residents working together that Reading has achieved a 57% drop in emissions and maintained its position as 12th in the country for carbon reduction," he Ennis said the council was "leading by example", including the work to upgrade the Hexagon major construction project, which started this week, includes plans to install ground and air source heat pumps across the building, replacing gas council said it has cut its own emissions by almost 75% since 2009, adding that it only accounts for roughly 2% of the town's overall Reading Climate Change Partnership, of which the council is a key member, is also currently asking people for their thoughts on how the town can achieve net zero."We all need to keep up the momentum in the face of rising temperatures, wetter winters and extreme weather conditions occurring more frequently," Mr Ennis said. You can follow BBC Berkshire on Facebook, X (Twitter), or Instagram.


The Sun
3 minutes ago
- The Sun
Lidl to sell £20 dupe of £350 Ninja tool that is perfect for summer garden parties
LIDL are selling a dupe of a popular Ninja tool - and it's £330 less than the branded version. The product is perfect for summer garden parties and costs just £20 for Lidl Plus members. The Ninja SLUSHi Frozen Drink Maker is an immensely popular product and is capable of transforming fruit into delicious iced slushies. It can be used to make everything from smoothies to frozen cocktails and frappés. However, the branded product costs an eyewatering £350. Meanwhile, Lidl has started selling another kitchen device named the Silvercrest Slushy Maker. The slushy maker can blend ice so that it is either fine or coarse, allowing you to customise your drinks. It also comes with a 1.1 litre blending capacity which means it is perfect for making many drinks at once. The Silvercrest Slushy Maker is on sale for just £20 for Lidl Plus members. Non-members only have to pay £24.99, which is still £325 less than the Ninja version. As the weather heats up, Brits are heading outside for garden parties and drinking more iced drinks than ever. The summer is expected to remain hot too, following a series of thunderstorms this weekend. Lidl reveals two per customer rule as £4 item returns to shelves in Scotland The Met Office has issued four weather warnings for parts of the UK, due to the risk of heavy flooding in some areas. Despite the wet weekend, Brits have enjoyed bright, balmy weather so far - with temperatures exceeding 30C in some parts of the country. In June, Heathrow experienced temperatures of 32C and areas in Yorkshire were treated to temperatures of 29C. The warm weather has meant that gardenware from brands like Lidl has been popular throughout the summer. The budget supermarket has gone viral several times in recent months for its range of garden products. Lidl is selling a plant bundle for just £1.99 which flowers all year and is beloved by bees and butterflies. It is also selling a barbecue pizza oven which is ideal for outdoor parties. Costing just £29.99, the oven is available in the store's famous middle aisle. 3


Telegraph
3 minutes ago
- Telegraph
MoD has fired most civil servants in Whitehall over poor performance
Only the Scotland Office, the Wales Office and the Northern Ireland Office registered no dismissals for poor performance in the time frame. Ministers at the Cabinet Office and the Department for Education said they did not know how many civil servants had been dismissed because the data was not centrally held. The MoD employed a total of 55,435 civil servants at the start of this year, according to the latest data from the Office for National Statistics. It has long been one of the biggest Government departments by staffing level, along with the Department for Work and Pensions, the Home Office and the Ministry of Justice. An email from the department containing the personal details of thousands of personnel in Afghanistan, including spies and soldiers, was leaked in 2022. When the MoD realised the leak in September 2023, it obtained a super-injunction from the High Court to stop journalists reporting on the leak. The department also launched a secret resettlement scheme to bring those put at risk from the Taliban in Afghanistan to Britain. The super-injunction, the first ever obtained by a British government, prevented journalists from reporting on the leak and prevented them from reporting on the existing of the injunction, leading to an enforced media blackout. It was lifted by the High Court on Tuesday after a Government-commissioned review found the effects of the leak were less severe than originally feared. 'We have a machine that is not delivering' Peter Bedford, the Conservative MP who obtained the data through written parliamentary questions, told The Telegraph: 'I think Civil Service reform is way overdue. 'We have a machine that is not delivering and often cocking up, with politicians always getting the blame. 'If you compare the public sector to the private sector, it's clearly much more difficult to get rid of poor performers. 'The number of dismissals in the Civil Service is very few – it's a few hundred among hundreds of thousands of employees. In the private sector, you'd expect around 10 per cent to go each year for poor performance. 'In the Civil Service, poor performers are simply moved on to other departments, so the system stays stale, inefficient and unfit. I'd like to see this Government, or a future government, overhauling the way our Civil Service works.' The MoD has been contacted for comment.