AFL fans call out Demons over Simon Goodwin's farewell snub as club great in shock
There were suggestions Goodwin would be let go if Melbourne lost to West Coast on the weekend. The demolition of the lowly Eagles seemed to quell the noise momentarily with a decision to be made at the end of the season.
Although the win didn't save Goodwin from the axe with the timing of the move leaving supporters in shock. Goodwin coached Melbourne to their first premiership in 57 years years back in 2021 having taken over from Paul Roos.
But Goodwin had only managed to coach the Demons to seven wins in 2025 and performances across the last few years had prompted calls for change. And Lyon admitted he was struggling to get his head around the decision to pull the trigger with three games left to go.
Speaking on SEN Radio as the news dropped, Lyon suggested there might not be a farewell game for Goodwin who deserved a send off having delivered the side their only premiership in recent times. 'I'm stunned, shocked, totally shocked,' Lyon said on SEN Radio.
'I had no heads up on this whatsoever. Absolutely just shocked, I can't get my head around it. He won't be coaching a farewell game, that's something I can promise you.' And fans have echoed Lyon's confusion to why the decision happened now.
Many feel the Demons had left the decision so late it was only right to let Goodwin see out the season and have a farewell. With little to play for, the fans could have got behind the coach with three games left if they let him ride out the season. Unfortunately, it appears Goodwin and Melbourne will go their separate ways immediately with the supporters most likely not given an opportunity to get behind their premiership-winning coach one last time.
I think a parting of ways at the end of the season would have been more respectful to our only premiership coach in nearly 70 years but a change was needed.Thank you Simon Goodwin for helping turn our club around and the memory of 2021 ❤️💙@melbournefc #AFL
— Julian Cross (@CrossJulian) August 4, 2025
Shocked by the decision to sack Goodwin right now. Hope he is remembered as a legend of the footy club. What the Demons do next is very interesting…Do they see this as an opportunity to challenge again with a fresh voice? Or is it a total wipe out of star players?
— Matt Nevett (@matt_nevett_) August 4, 2025
Can't but feel like we could've waited until the end of the year & given our only living premiership coach a bit of a send off. 100% the right call but jeez this man delivered something that I never thought we'd ever see. Thanks Goody that day in 2021 will be forever the greatest
— James Plunkett (@jplunkett21) August 4, 2025
Lyon felt the call came prematurely with Goodwin's stature as a premiership winner going to see him reach the end of the season. 'I'm absolutely stunned. I thought there would be a long review at the end of this year and then determine whether he would coach out his final year,' he added.
'Premiership coaches are pretty rare at the Melbourne footy club. He's one of four. He will be a hero of this football club forever and a day, but that obviously doesn't guarantee your tenure. This is a massive call.'
Melbourne making moves with Simon Goodwin axing
After Melbourne capitulated in round 20, Goodwin shut down outside noise and said he was fully committed to the job at hand. "I feel incredibly supported by the board, I have for nine years," Goodwin said last Thursday. "We've been able to go through these challenges before with clarity and strength and stability to create success."
Goodwin won the 2021 flag with one of the youngest teams of the modern era and started their 2022 title defence in solid form. However, Goodwin couldn't get past the early stages of the finals since the flag having exited in straight sets in 2022 and 2023. Last year, Melbourne finished in 14th and they currently sit in 12th and are out of finals contention.
The Demons hierarchy may have called time on Goodwin's season with three games to go in a bid to get ahead of their rivals in the search for a new head coach. There are suggestions a number of teams could be looking at change for the 2026 season and the Demons have made their move first.
Only last week, AFL great Matthew Lloyd claimed he didn't think a win against the Eagles would ease the pressure on Goodwin's tenure as coach. "I don't think so, no," Lloyd said when asked on Nine's Today Show. "Moreso if they lost that game, that could spell the end for Simon Goodwin you would think, if they were to lose to West Coast who have won one game for the season. They have been off for a couple of years now, there is something not quite right."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News24
8 hours ago
- News24
Major boost for Wallabies as overseas player rule lifted for Springbok tour
Rugby Australia has scrapped the 'Giteau Law,' allowing more overseas-based players to represent the Wallabies. This gives head coach Joe Schmidt full freedom in selection for the Rugby Championship. The change also supports future plans under incoming head coach Les Kiss for the 2027 Rugby World Cup. Rugby Australia has signalled that more overseas-based players will be allowed to represent the Wallabies, shifting away from a strict policy that has heavily favoured domestic players. For more rugby news, click HERE. The so-called 'Giteau Law' - named after former flyhalf Matt Giteau - has for years put restrictions on overseas-based players being selected for the Wallabies. But with Test stars such as lock Will Skelton, flanker Tom Hooper and prop Taniela Tupou all joining an exodus to Europe, Rugby Australia has indicated the Giteau Law has been dropped. That gives head coach Joe Schmidt a free selection hand when he names his squad for the Rugby Championship this week. 'Joe's got no impediment to select whoever he wants,' Rugby Australia head of high performance Peter Horne said. 'The Giteau Law, it's kind of redundant right,' Horne added in comments reported by Schmidt is due to name his squad Thursday for the Rugby Championship which begins this month. Scrapping the rule would also benefit incoming head coach Les Kiss, who takes over the Wallabies next year tasked with preparing for the Rugby World Cup on home soil in 2027. The Giteau Law was adopted by the Wallabies in 2015, allowing overseas-based players to represent the side only if they had played 60 Tests for Australia and seven seasons of Super Rugby. It enabled players such as Matt Giteau, who was then starring for Toulon, to be picked for the 2015 Rugby World Cup. Before then, Australia had a blanket ban on overseas-based players representing the Wallabies. The Springboks host the Wallabies in the first two rounds of the Rugby Championship in Johannesburg (16 August) and Cape Town (23 August).
USA Today
9 hours ago
- USA Today
Iowa football: Three breakout candidates for 2025 season
Like every other sport, college football is a team game. You could argue that more than any other sport, college football requires an entire team to contribute to succeed. And that's most definitely the case for the Iowa football team entering the 2025 season. The Hawkeyes have many well-known and established stars on their 2025 roster. From preseason All-Americans like Logan Jones and Gennings Dunker to fan-favorites like Kaden Wetjen and Rhys Dakin. All of those players will be critical to Iowa's success this season. But, they can't do it alone. They'll need the rest of the roster to step up and match their level. This includes players who may be flying under the radar right now, just waiting to break out. Who exactly are those players for the Hawkeyes in 2025? Let's take a look at three breakout candidates for Iowa football this season. Reece Vander Zee Iowa fans have been waiting a long time for a star wide receiver to break out. The last wide receiver to eclipse 1,000 receiving yards in a season was Marvin McNutt back in 2011. The Hawkeyes have had great receivers like Matt VandeBerg, Ihmir Smith-Marsette, and Brandon Smith since then, but none of them have passed that 1,000-yard mark. I think Vander Zee could do that at some point during his Iowa career. The 6-foot-4, 207-pound sophomore made some splash plays as a true freshman last season, catching 14 balls for 176 yards and three touchdowns. He only played in nine games due to injury and played with a rotating carousel of middling quarterbacks. Vander Zee has the size and speed to be a matchup nightmare on the outside, and another year in Tim Lester's West Coast system should help. Add in some better and more consistent quarterback play, and I think Vander Zee could be in for a huge 2025 season. Maybe not 1,000 receiving yards this season, but I think he'll establish himself as a great wide receiver with the potential to reach that mark in the coming years. Derek Weisskopf Derek Weisskopf was a stud in high school. The 6-foot-3, 235-pound redshirt freshman linebacker was an Adidas All-American at Williamsburg High School. As a senior, he was the Gazette's Co-Player of the Year and District MVP, as well as being invited to the Shrine Bowl. Weisskopf was a four-star signee in Iowa's 2024 class, the 197th-best prospect in the country and the top recruit in Iowa's class. Weisskopf's resume certainly speaks for itself, but that's not the biggest reason why I'm predicting him to break out in 2025. The linebacking room is thin entering this season following the departures of Jay Higgins and Nick Jackson. While Weisskopf is listed as a backup to Jaxon Rexroth right now, there will be an open battle for playing time. And I think Weisskopf could be on the field more than many fans might expect. With that additional playing time, don't be surprised if Weisskopf shows why he was so highly touted coming out of high school. I think Hawkeye fans have their next great linebacker on the roster in Weisskopf, and he'll get to show off his talent this fall. Zach Lutmer If you asked me the player I'm most confident in to break out this season, my answer would be Zach Lutmer. The 6-foot, 205-pound sophomore safety impressed a ton on special teams last season and will now get the chance for an increased role on defense. Lutmer had 14 tackles last season and snagged his first career interception against UCLA. And I think the sky is the limit for Lutmer. Lutmer is currently projected as the backup to Koen Entringer (who I think will have a great season), with senior Xaver Nwankpa on the other side. I think Lutmer will be hard to keep off the field, and I wouldn't be surprised to see a lot of three-safety sets in 2025 with Lutmer, Entringer, and Nwankpa on the field at the same time. I think Lutmer has the mindset, physical traits, and knowledge of the game to be a great safety at Iowa. I'm predicting a breakout for Lutmer and for him to be the Nwankpa replacement in 2026. The coaches think highly of him, his teammates respect him, and I think many Iowa fans will learn Lutmer's name in 2025. Contact/Follow us @HawkeyesWire on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Iowa news, notes and opinions. Follow Zach on X: @zach_hiney
New York Times
9 hours ago
- New York Times
How Steve Smith was rebuilt with a New York state of mind
A broad grin has replaced the anxiety and tears that accompanied the darkest moment of Steve Smith's career. One of Australia's greatest ever cricketers looks fit, healthy and, most important of all, happy, rejuvenated partly by time spent in New York City, which has become his second home. Gone, too, is the quirky cricketing obsessive who would 'shadow bat' — practising shots in front of a mirror without a ball — all night in hotel rooms in preparation for a match the following morning. Now, Smith is just as likely to have a golf club in his hand, having taken up the sport in recent years as a way of escaping cricket's pressure-cooker. Advertisement 'I'm pretty relaxed at the moment,' he tells The Athletic via a Zoom call from his New York apartment, as he prepares to fly to the UK to play in the short-form Hundred tournament. Smith has come a long way since his emotional press conference at Sydney International Airport in March 2018, when he admitted that his failures as captain were responsible for a cheating scandal that had engulfed his Australia team. His team-mate Cameron Bancroft had been caught by television cameras tampering with the ball during a Test match against South Africa. Bancroft was pictured using sandpaper to rough up one side of the ball in an illegal attempt to induce it to swing. A Cricket Australia investigation found that Smith and David Warner, the team's opening batter, had known about the plan and attempted to cover it up. The controversy sparked an existential crisis in Australia's national sport, even prompting the country's then-Prime Minister, Malcolm Turnbull, to express his outrage. Smith was sacked as captain, and he and Warner were banned for a year. Bancroft received a nine-month suspension. It was a nadir for Smith who, at the time of 'Sandpaper-gate', was the world's best batter and apparently untouchable as Australia's golden boy. Watching Smith convulsing with sobs in front of the media, the hand of his father, Peter, on his shoulder, many wondered if he would ever be quite the same player again. It was in New York that Smith sought sanctuary during his exile from the sport. He was already a devotee of the city, having proposed to his then-fiancee Dani Willis at the top of the Rockefeller Center in 2017, but the anonymity of Manhattan life was a balm in a time of crisis. 'We love this city,' Smith says. 'We first came here for a visit in 2016 and we were drawn to it. We come here to chill out and relax. There's so much to see and do. Yes, there are a lot of ex-pats, people from Australia, England and India who want to talk about cricket, but I'm largely anonymous. Advertisement 'I've realised as I've got older how important the mental side of cricket is and it takes a lot out of you so you have to try and keep as much in the tank as you can for when the games come around. Hitting loads of balls adds to mental fatigue, so I'm trying to strike a balance between the physical aspect with the mental side of it. 'I still do little bits of shadow batting here and there, but I'm just as likely to get the golf clubs out now. Look, I still train exceptionally hard when I'm around cricket and I still hit a lot of balls in practice but probably less than I did in the past. 'I'm in a place where I'm able to focus for long periods during a five-Test series and that's something I've learnt over a period of time and want to continue.' It is to the United States that Smith, now 36, looks when he considers the last great ambition of a stellar career that has seen him score more than 10,000 Test runs and recover his standing in Australia. Smith wants to play in the Los Angeles Olympics in 2028, the first time cricket will feature at the Games since 1900, when Great Britain defeated France. Given the LA 2028 format will be Twenty20 — where each team faces 20 six-ball overs — Smith, who will be 39 when that competition rolls around, is determined to play as much short-form cricket as he can, even retiring from 50-over internationals to free up time in his calendar. 'It would be cool and quite something to play in an Olympics,' he says. 'I think the shortest format is the one I haven't quite conquered, so it's one I'd like to improve in. I know the Australian coach Andrew McDonald laughs every time I score a run or two in the Big Bash (Australia's T20 competition) or other short-form tournaments. I send him texts saying, 'Did you see that, mate?' so hopefully I'll be sending plenty of texts and getting my name in that format.' Advertisement There is no question over Smith's place in the Australian Test side and he will again be at the forefront of their attempt to retain the Ashes, the Test series with England that has been the marquee event for both countries since it was first contested in 1882. He has followed England's recent series against India closely from the States and talks with admiration over the achievement of Joe Root in eclipsing his countryman Ricky Ponting to become the second-highest run-scorer in Test history. Smith and Root were part of a so-called 'Fab Four', alongside India's Virat Kohli and New Zealand's Kane Williamson, who all emerged at the start of the last decade and established themselves as the sport's pre-eminent batters. Yet, while Root had, for a long time, been ranked well behind the other three, he is now the undisputed world No 1. 'He's batting on another level at the moment,' says Smith. 'Joe looks in such a calm place when he's batting and he's making consistently big scores. For the last few years he's been beautiful to watch. His plans in all sorts of different conditions are spot on and he's scored big runs.' The one blot on Root's record is his failure to make a Test century in Australia. Might Smith be reminding him of that when the pair meet later in August as opposing Hundred players, Smith for the Cardiff-based Welsh Fire and Root for Trent Rockets? 'I don't think he needs reminding; he probably knows it,' says Smith. 'I do think it will be challenging for the English batters in this Ashes because the wickets we've played on in Australia over the last three or four years have been as challenging as anything I've seen in my career. It will be tricky for them, that's for sure.' At last Smith has stopped being Mr Nice Guy and is playing one of those psychological shots Australians specialise in when an Ashes series looms. Well, sort of anyway. Did he not say to the BBC recently that England's 'Bazballers' — the name given to the ultra-attacking philosophy instilled by head coach Brendon McCullum — have changed the way they play and are now trying to win rather than merely entertain? Advertisement 'I saw a lot of comments having a go at me for that but it was supposed to be a compliment!' smiles Smith. 'I just think the way they're going about it now is playing the situation better in terms of trying to win a Test. 'I think what England used to say about being the great entertainers was a bit of a cop out but me saying they are trying to win the game, and playing the situations well, is a compliment to them. 'It's going to be a wonderful atmosphere in Australia. The last Ashes at home was during Covid so a lot of English fans couldn't travel and the atmosphere suffered but it won't be like that this time.' Was that not the Ashes series which Stuart Broad, England's combative fast bowler, said should have been declared void because of Covid restrictions? 'Of course he said that!' says Smith. Sadly for England, Australia's 4-0 win still stands but, as long as captain Ben Stokes regains fitness, England really do have a decent chance of winning their first series in Australia since Andrew Strauss and Andy Flower's 3-1 triumph in 2010-11. Does Smith agree? 'I think they've got a pretty good side,' he says diplomatically. 'Root has been outstanding and Harry Brook is a quality player. Ben Duckett has been outstanding, too. We know what Stokes is capable of with both bat and ball and I think their fast bowlers are as good as they've been for a while. 'Conditions-wise it will be challenging for our batters but it will be challenging for them too because a lot of wickets England have been playing on have been pretty flat and ours will be a bit spicy. I can assure them they will be tricky to bat on.' For now, more Ashes talk can wait. Smith is preparing for his first experience of the Hundred, which began yesterday, having also featured in the US for what has become Welsh Fire's sister team, Washington Freedom, when they won the Major League Cricket title last year. The former Australian captain was due to play for Welsh Fire when the Hundred was first devised but it was postponed because of Covid. Now, finally, he is ready to make his debut in Welsh Fire's first match against Northern Superchargers on Thursday, even though when we speak he is still wearing a splint on the finger he damaged playing against South Africa in the World Test Championship final in June. Advertisement Will it be different to T20? 'Good question!' says Smith. 'It probably just takes out a few overs of the potential rebuilding that can happen in T20 cricket if you lose a few wickets. It's probably going hammer and tongs the entire time and trying to hit as many boundaries as you can, so I'm looking forward to that.' One of the fascinating features of the modern world of franchise cricket is seeing players from rival countries in the same team. In Smith's case that means joining forces with Jonny Bairstow, the England player whose dismissal in the Lord's Test in 2023 — he was run out by wicket-keeper Alex Carey as he walked out of his crease, thinking the ball was dead — was one of the great Ashes rows of recent times. Do they have to put that behind them? 'From my point of view it's forgotten,' Smith insists. 'I'm looking forward to playing with Jonny. He's been a wonderful player for a long time and gives the white ball in particular a real smack. I've read recently that he's trying to get back in the England white-ball team and he's probably got a bit of a point to prove.' For all the Ashes rivalry it is good to see Smith put those bad times behind him and clearly relish all he is doing. 'While I'm still enjoying cricket I will stick around to try to help the team win as many matches as I can,' he says. 'I go about my business, work hard and try to do my thing.' Steve Smith is in a good place and will be doing his thing for some time yet. Click here to read more cricket stories on The Athletic, and follow Global Sports on The Athletic app via the Discover tab. (Illustration: Kelsea Petersen / The Athletic; William West / Getty, Stu Forster / Getty, Gary Herschorn / Getty)
