'No concept of judges' permanent transfer'
The petitioners have contended that the June 20 verdict of a constitutional bench of the SC has misinterpreted the Constitution and wrongly inferred the concept of a permanent transfer from the Article 200 of the Constitution.
Article 200 of the Constitution deals with the transfer of high court judges. It outlines the process for transferring a judge from one high court to another.
According to the article, the president can transfer a judge, but only with their consent and after consultation with the chief justice of Pakistan and the chief justices of both high courts involved.
The petitioners have contended there is no provision of a permanent transfer of a superior court judge in the Constitution and only the Judicial Commission of Pakistan (JCP) is entitled to fill vacant positions in high courts and the apex court.
The petitions also argue that the president also does not have the authority to determine seniority of judges and urged the SC to revisit its order and declare it null and void.
In a majority verdict, an SC constitutional bench on June 20 upheld the transfer of three provincial high court judges to the IHC, noting that these transfers could not be declared new appointments.
However, the majority judges partially remanded the matter to the President of Pakistan to determine the seniority of the transferred judges after examining and vetting their service record "as soon as possible, including the question of whether the transfer is on a permanent or temporary basis".
Later on June 29, President Asif Ali Zardari named Justice Sardar Muhammad Sarfraz Dogar as the senior-most judge of the IHC, following a determination of judicial seniority.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
Proposed amendment on LGs: NA Secretariat asked to issue reminder to all parliamentary party leaders
ISLAMABAD: A parliamentary body on Tuesday directed the National Assembly Secretariat to issue a reminder to all parliamentary party leaders to submit their opinion on the proposed constitutional amendment aimed at strengthening local governments. The Senate Standing Committee on Law and Justice, which met with MNA Chaudhry Mahmood Bashir Virk in the chair, discussed 'The Constitution (Amendment) Bill, 2025' (Article 140-A) moved by MNA Muhammad Jawed Hanif Khan, seeking to make local government institutions more viable and effective in line with the aspirations of the people of Pakistan. The parliamentary body observed that, in compliance with its previous directions, letters were issued to the provincial governments as well as to the parliamentary leaders of all political parties, seeking their views regarding the proposed amendment in Article 140-A. However, the committee has so far not received a response of any parliamentary leader in this regard. The committee directed the secretariat to issue a reminder to all parliamentary leaders to submit their opinions as soon as possible to proceed further in the matter. The meeting also considered 'The Qanun-e-Shahadat (Amendment) Bill, 2025' moved by MNA Shazia Marri. During detailed deliberations, the mover informed the committee that, in light of the discussions held during the previous meeting, the proposed bill had been redrafted. The revised draft of the bill was placed before the parliamentary body for consideration, she said. The members of the committee observed that, since the bill now contained substantive amendments, it was not feasible to deliberate upon the revised draft without prior examination. Therefore, the committee decided to defer consideration of the bill till its next meeting to allow members sufficient time for a thorough review. The committee also considered the 'Constitution (Amendment) Bill, 2024' (Article 25) moved by MNA Nafeesa Shah and 'The Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Bill, 2024' (Section 54-A) moved by MNA Sofia Saeed Shah but due to the non-availability of the movers, the committee decided to defer consideration of both bills to its next meeting, with the observation that no further deferment shall be granted. The committee decided that, in case of continued absence of the movers, the bills shall be taken up and decided upon in absentia. MNAs Zahra Wadood Fatemi, Kiran Haider, Syed Ibrar Ali Shah, Syed Naveed Qamar, Syed Hafeezuddin, Hassan Sabir, Ali Muhammad Khan, Umair Khan Niazi, Changaze Ahmec Khan, Sardar Muhammad Latif Khan Khosa, Aliya Kamran, Shazia Marri, Jawed Hanif Khan, and senior officials of Ministry of Law and Justice attended the meeting. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
Punjab opposition leader, 32 PTI workers sentenced to 10 years
SARGODHA: An Anti-Terrorism Court (ATC) in Sargodha has sentenced Punjab Assembly Opposition leader Ahmed Khan Bhachar and 32 other Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) workers to 10 years of imprisonment each in the May 9 riots case. As per details, the verdict was announced by Anti-Terrorism Court Judge Muhammad Naeem Sheikh. Among those convicted are Punjab Assembly Opposition Leader Malik Ahmed Khan Bhachar, MNA Rana Bilal, and MNA Ahmed Chattha. The verdict was issued after the court heard nine separate cases related to the incident. The case, registered at the Musa Khel police station, pertained to the violent protests and vandalism that erupted in Mianwali following the arrest of PTI founder Imran Khan in a graft case. The ATC found Ahmed Khan Bachar and the other accused guilty of participating in the unrest, which targeted state institutions and public property. Violent clashes were broken out across Pakistan after former prime minister Imran Khan was arrested on May 9, 2023. The protests were held in remote and major cities as the party workers were agitated due to their chairman's arrest, with Balochistan, Punjab, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and Islamabad summoning the armed forces to ensure law and order. Army installations, including Corps Commander's house in Lahore, had come under attack during the protests by PTI workers. It is pertinent to mention that the PTI founder is named as main accused in all the May 9 riots cases. The verdict came at the time when the opposition MPAs allegedly caused disruption and damaged property during a Punjab Assembly session on June 27, 2025. In response, Malik Muhammad Ahmad Khan suspended the membership of these 26 SIC lawmakers. Later on June 28, the speaker announced his decision to refer the matter to the ECP for the disqualification of the suspended members. The court had granted exemption from personal appearance to all 32 accused, including Malik Ahmed Khan Bhachar. PTI lawyers and supporters have rejected the court's ruling, calling it unfair and politically motivated. The members suspended by the speaker included Malik Fahad Masood, Muhammad Tanvir Aslam, Syed Riffat Mehmood, Yasir Mehmood Qureshi, Kalimullah Khan, Muhammad Ansar Iqbal, Ali Asif, Zulfiqar Ali, Ahmed Mujtaba Chaudhry, Shahid Javed, Muhammad Ismail, Khayal Ahmed, Shehbaz Ahmed, Tayyab Rashid, Imtiaz Mehmood, Ali Imtiaz, Rashid Tufail, Murtaza Iqbal, Khalid Zubair, Ijaz Shafi, Saima Kanwal, Muhammad Naeem, Sajjad Ahmed, Rana Aurangzeb, Shoaib Mir and Usama Asghar Ali Gujjar. Meanwhile, talking to a private television channel, Bhachar strongly criticized the ATC decision and announced plans to challenge the verdict in the Lahore High Court. 'The court has ruled against me in a politically driven case that completely deviates from the Constitution,' said Bhachar. 'This decision was pronounced without following due legal process. Once I receive the written verdict, I will immediately approach the High Court.'
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
Concerns voiced over govt decision to lay off daily wage, contractual employees
ISLAMABAD: The Standing Committee on Cabinet Secretariat has expressed serious reservations over the government's decision to lay-off contractual and daily wages employees and decided to refer the matter to the Parliament for further deliberations. The 3rd meeting of the National Assembly Standing Committee on Cabinet Secretariat was held under chairmanship of Ibrar Ahmed. While responding to 'the Protection of Rights of Regularised Civil Servants and Employees Bill 2024,' moved by MNA Khursheed Ahmed Shah, Inamullah Khan said the government has abolished 60 percent of the vacant vacancies since the government is no more in a position to bear the cost of these vacancies. He apprised the members that as per the judgement of the Islamabad High Court (IHC) on 01.11.2017, 'No one is allowed to hire any person on daily wages, contract basis, in any project, organisation Office, Ministries/ Divisions, etc.; except in accordance with law.' He said that in the judgement, it was also mentioned that all persons have to be appointed on permanent post only and appointment on ad-hoc basis could not be considered for regularisation and no individual could claim any legal right for regularisation under any consideration while appointed on ad-hoc basis. 'All project employees who are appointed in BS-16 and above on projects could not claim regularisation of their services unless their projects have been converted from development to non-development phase by the government of Pakistan. The secretary said the Supreme Court also upheld the IHC's stance in its judgement on 13-09-2024. By stating: 'Foregoing in view, it is concluded that the High Court correctly understood the controversy at hand and made a well-founded decision based on the relevant laws on the issue.' He said in the appointment letter of contractual employees it is clearly mentioned that during the service they will not seek permanent employment. Khurshid Shah, on this occasion, said that the Parliament is above the judiciary and the judiciary could not overrule the legislation passed by the Parliament. He said the daily wagers and contractual employees working in the government departments deserved to be regularised. The chairman committee said majority of daily wages and contractual employees become overage for civil service exams and if their services would be terminated then it will be great injustice. Pir Ameer Ali Shah Jeelani said one of the ministers assured us that no employee of Utility Stores Corporation would lose their jobs and they would be accommodated in other departments. But now these 17,000 Utility Stores employees are protesting on roads in such harsh weather conditions for the restoration of their jobs. The members said syllabus of Public Service Commission exams changed after every two to three years which made it very difficult for the contractual or daily wages employees to pass. They said how the government can abolish the posts of lower grades such as of drivers and gardeners when they needed them. The committee also recommended to the Establishment Division not to take any action against any employee which came under the purview of the legislation till its final outcome. On this occasion, commending the Establishment Division and Finance Division on attaining ISO 9001 certification, the committee has recommended that all the ministries should follow suit and get them certified as per international certification standards. The secretary Establishment Division apprised the committee about the working of the division and its core functions. He apprised that management of four occupational groups of services of Pakistan came under its purview besides regulation of all matters related to the recruitment, promotion, verification of character and antecedents, conduct and discipline and terms and conditions of civil posts in connection with affairs of the Federation. Apprising about the last five years performance of the Division, he said that special professional pay scales were introduced, head hunt was conducted to meet professional manpower requirements for technical posts, rules for promotion of civil servants were revised besides revision of policy for upgradation/ re-designation of posts and other rules were carried out. He informed that with technological advancement, Establishment Division had adopted human resources management information system. Apprising about the ongoing initiatives, the secretary said that deputation policy was being revised, updating of Esta Code, Establishment Manual and Secretariat instruction was being carried out. The meeting was attended by MNAs; Tahira Aurangzeb, Nuzhat Sadiq, Dr Nelson Azeem, Ali Asghar Khan, Khurram Munawar Manj, Syed Raza Ali Gillani, Shahida Begum and Rana Ansar, Ehsanul Haq Bajwa, Muhammad Aslam Ghumman, through Zoom, movers; Syed Khursheed Ahmed Shah, MNA and Sahibzada Sibghatullah, MNA, the secretary Establishment Division and other officers of other concerned departments also attended the meeting. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
