Sukuk and bond pricing remains correlated as spreads narrow despite volatility
Fitch Ratings - Jakarta/Dubai: The pricing of comparable sukuk and bonds analysed by Fitch Ratings remained highly correlated in 2024 for the fifth-year running with spreads between the two instrument types further narrowing despite regional geopolitical tensions, economic volatility and sharia-compliance uncertainties, says Fitch Ratings. It is unclear whether these dynamics will impact this trend over 2025 and 2026.
The pricing correlation was about 0.95 (on a scale of 0 to 1) for 56 comparable sukuk and bonds analysed by Fitch between 2019 and 2024, based on yield-to-maturity (YTM). The full-year 2024 correlation dropped to 0.91, which is still high given the relatively small size of the analysed pool. At the same time, average spreads between comparable sukuk and bonds narrowed to 10bp in 2024 from 25bp in 2023 and 27bp in 2022. Between 2019-2024, sukuk had lower yields on average than comparable bonds in about 50% of the analysed cases, while 39.3% of sukuk had similar yields to comparable bonds, and 10.7% had higher yields.
This analysis can offer insights into investor perceptions of credit risk between sukuk and bonds. The instruments were mostly issued by entities from the Gulf Cooperation Council, Indonesia, and Turkiye, covering sovereigns, financial institutions, corporates, and international public finance. Still, there have been instances where pricing correlation fell, at least for a brief period before reverting, due to macroeconomic or sharia-specific events. Also, it should be noted that there are few directly comparable sukuk and bonds with close similarity in payment priority, issuance dates, maturity, and currency denomination from the same issuer.
These findings are also observed with the S&P MENA sukuk and bonds indices, which had a correlation of 0.99 over the five years ending December 2024 based on YTM with a 27bp spread between sukuk and bond yields. The spread also further narrowed in 2024, averaging 15bp.
Among the uncertainties facing the market is AAOIFI Sharia Standard No. 62 which, while still in draft format, could be finalised and issued in 2025. Among key proposals is the transfer of legal ownership and associated risks of the underlying sukuk assets to the sukuk holders, granting investors asset recourse to ensure closer adherence to shariah principles. Any impact of AAOIFI Standard 62 implementation on sukuk pricing compared to bonds depends on the final version, which jurisdictions and entities adopt it, and, most importantly, how it is reflected in sukuk documentation.
New sharia-related requirements in sukuk documents, which are not usually seen in conventional bonds, did not appear to have an impact on pricing in 2024. These includes terms in the sukuk documentation related to asset-inspection, asset takeover, sharia-compliant hedging, and partial payment of the periodical distribution amount in certain circumstances and for limited period.
Fitch expects global sukuk to surpass USD1 trillion outstanding in 2025, remaining a key part of the debt capital market in a number of Organisation of Islamic Cooperation countries. Investor demand for many sukuk remains intact, mainly from GCC Islamic banks that have adequate liquidity.
Global outstanding sukuk rose 10% to USD930 billion at end-2024 year on year despite regional geopolitical tensions. The use of sukuk is also expected to remain a significant tool in emerging markets having totalled 12% of all emerging market US dollar debt issued in 2024 (excluding China). About 81.4% of Fitch-rated sukuk are investment-grade as of end-2024. Sukuk default rates globally are very low, at only 0.19% of all sukuk issued as of end-2024.
-Ends-
Media Contact:
Matt Pearson
Senior Associate, Corporate Communications
Fitch Group, 30 North Colonnade, London, E14 5GN
E: matthew.pearson@thefitchgroup.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Khaleej Times
4 hours ago
- Khaleej Times
Global markets on tenterhooks as 'new cold war' turns hot
As military spending ramps up around the world and countries rush to ringfence critical industries, political rhetoric appears to have darkened from one sketching geopolitical risks to outright preparation for war. Whether global markets should take more note is a moot point. Investors are already preoccupied with a full-blown trade war, which has aggravated international tensions and is much like the latest ratchet in U.S. steel and aluminium tariffs. But it is not hard to find the 'safety' trades thriving. Gold is less than 2% from a record close set a month ago, having climbed almost 30% so far this year. The Swiss franc , also up almost 10% this year, is pushing higher too. Most obvious of all is the nearly 50% rise in European defence stocks since January. Safety trades that have not barked are just as interesting. The dollar's haven status has been undermined by U.S. trade and tax worries and President Donald Trump's domestic institutional upheavals. And government bonds are pressured precisely because the additional defence spending associated with another generational arms race is exaggerating outsized post-pandemic debt loads even more. Global government debt indexes remain in the red for 2025. "Elevated geopolitical risk affects issuers through multiple transmission mechanisms," credit rating firm Fitch said on Friday, adding it "put upward pressure on defence spending, making fiscal consolidation more challenging for certain sovereigns." War drumbeat But at whatever part of the market risk dial you put world war worries, there is no doubt the temperature has risen. Even in the last few days, the language surrounding future major power conflicts has been alarming. Goading Asian allies to match European moves to boost military spending, U.S. Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth warned on Saturday that Chinese military moves to take Taiwan were "imminent". "There's no reason to sugar coat it. The threat China poses is real, and it could be imminent," Hegseth said, adding that any attempt by China to secure Taiwan militarily "would result in devastating consequences for the Indo-Pacific and the world". Beijing reacted angrily and said Hegseth "vilified China with defamatory allegations". But senior U.S. officials have repeatedly briefed that they believe Chinese President Xi Jinping has ordered his military to be ready to invade Taiwan by 2027, even if they say no direct decision appears to have been made. Back in Europe, the drum beat about the need to lift military spending is even louder, more fearful of a threat from Russia. Nearly a trillion euros ($1.14 trillion) of extra German and European-wide defence spending have been earmarked this year. Only last week, Chancellor Friedrich Merz said Germany and its NATO partners were prepared to defend every inch of the alliance's territory. "Anyone who threatens an ally must know that the entire alliance will jointly defend every inch of NATO territory," Merz said on Thursday at a military ceremony in Vilnius to mark the establishment of a German brigade in Lithuania. Britain's strategic defence review on Monday also addressed threats from Russia, nuclear risks and cyberattacks by outlining investment in drones and digital warfare. But the plan also expands the UK's fleet of attack submarines, which are nuclear-powered but carry conventional weapons, and will spend 15 billion pounds ($20.3 billion) by 2029 on replacement of nuclear warheads for its main nuclear fleet. And again, the rhetoric was alarming. "We are being directly threatened by states with advanced military forces, so we must be ready to fight and win," Prime Minister Keir Starmer. 'NEW COLD WAR' TURNS HOT If securing the funding needs political alarm, then maybe that explains some of the high-octane public relations. But there is no shortage of deeply entrenched conflicts raging across the globe and threatening to spill over to varying degrees. Multilateral solutions seem distant as the globe breaks in the blocs. Even with negotiators exploring a ceasefire in Istanbul, Ukraine's forces made an extraordinary move this weekend to attack strategic bomber aircraft at bases deep inside Russia. Israel's devastation of Gaza in reprisal for the 2023 massacres by Hamas shows no sign of ending. More than 30 more Palestinians were killed and nearly 170 injured on Sunday near a food distribution site. Reports continued to circulate last week that Israel is threatening to disrupt nuclear talks between Washington and Tehran by striking Iran's nuclear facilities. And nuclear-armed India and Pakistan have just stepped back from another tense border conflict that marked the fiercest fighting in decades. The expansion of 'hot' conflicts is a mounting concern in political circles, with extraordinary territorial claims thrown into the mix. Trump's public ambition to take over Panama and Greenland have jarred allies, with the latter being part of rivalry over access to rare minerals and also amid strategic plays for the Arctic. Even J.P. Morgan boss Jamie Dimon gets the drift, reportedly telling Barron's last week the United States should not be stockpiling Bitcoin, but instead be stockpiling "guns, bullets, tanks, planes, drones, you know, rare earths." That the world is a dangerous place is not in doubt. A world at war is a different proposition. A worse case scenario is that tariff wars are just the opening act.
Zawya
5 hours ago
- Zawya
Fitch downgrades Afreximbank to one notch above 'junk'
LONDON - Fitch downgraded Afreximbank's credit rating to one notch above junk on Wednesday, with a negative outlook, citing high credit risks and weak risk-management policies. The one-notch downgrade to BBB- comes as the African lender battles to protect its loans from restructuring in Ghana, Zambia and Malawi, claiming that as a multilateral lender it has preferred creditor status. Fitch pegged Afreximbank's non-performing loans at 7.1% at the end of 2024, while the bank itself reported a first-quarter NPL ratio of 2.44%. "The revision of risk management to 'weak' reflects low transparency in the recent reporting of loan performance relative to multilateral development bank peers and that Fitch's definition of NPLs differs from the bank's approach, which makes use of flexibilities offered by IFRS 9," Fitch said. A lower credit rating can increase the borrowing cost for an issuer, which can in turn impact how much they can lend and at what rates. Fitch attributed the negative outlook, which effectively puts the bank on downgrade watch, to the risk that some of its debt to sovereign borrowers might be included in restructuring. "This would put pressure on our assessment of the bank's policy importance and heighten the risk associated with its strategy," Fitch said. Afreximbank did not immediately comment on the downgrade. The bank, whose shareholders include African sovereigns as well as private investors, is viewed by many as an important source of capital for African countries, particularly when international bond markets are closed to them and as rich countries cut aid and concessional lending. But ongoing debt restructurings in Ghana, Zambia and Malawi have put greater focus on the terms Afreximbank offers and whether its loans are "concessional", particularly when compared with the International Monetary Fund and World Bank, whose lending is protecting from restructuring. Fitch said the bank's business profile risk remained "medium" but was negatively impacted by low transparency in reporting loan performance. Reuters reported last week that Afreximbank told investors in a call that Ghana was "up to date" on its loan facilities and that it would not participate in restructuring loans to its member countries. But Ghana said it had not made debt service payments in two years and that it wants to restructure its Afreximbank debt. Fitch said that inclusion in sovereign debt restructurings "would likely lead us to revise our currently 'low risk' assessment of the bank's policy importance."
Gulf Today
10 hours ago
- Gulf Today
elegant hoopoe Spotlights GCC Franchise Investment with Strategic Expansion
DUBAI, UAE – Esteemed weight loss and aesthetics clinic, elegant hoopoe, today announced a pivotal strategic move into franchising across the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC), with a pronounced emphasis on the dynamic UAE market. This initiative is strategically designed to elevate the brand's social proof and capture heightened investor interest in its continued growth narrative. Mr. Shahriar Shahir Barzegar, the Founder and CEO of elegant hoopoe, has successfully guided the Dubai-based company to its current position of operational strength. With three flourishing branches already serving a discerning clientele, the brand has validated its business model and demonstrated significant market appeal for its specialized, high-end services. Further underscoring its expansionary vision, elegant hoopoe is advancing with plans for new clinic inaugurations in two key UAE locales: Abu Dhabi and Damac Hills. These developments are crucial components of the company's strategy to enhance the accessibility of its signature client experience, which harmoniously blends a welcoming ambiance with elegant and aspirational service delivery. "Our strategic entry into franchising is a transformative step for elegant hoopoe," remarked Mr. Shahriar Shahir Barzegar. "We have meticulously engineered a scalable and successful operational blueprint that consistently delivers superior client results within a sophisticated clinic setting. We are now inviting forward-thinking investors and partners who resonate with our vision to introduce elegant hoopoe's acclaimed services to a wider audience across the GCC. This is more than expansion; it's about cementing a leadership position as a credible and sought-after brand in the wellness and aesthetics landscape." The long-range strategy for elegant hoopoe is focused on achieving significant market presence and brand recognition throughout the GCC. Central to this is a franchise model developed to provide robust support to partners, offering a transparent and effective framework for operational success and investor value. elegant hoopoe is committed to empowering its franchisees with the comprehensive tools and in-depth knowledge necessary to consistently deliver its high service standards. This targeted franchising program is poised to attract investors and strategic allies eager to collaborate with a progressive brand dedicated to making meaningful contributions to personal wellbeing and aesthetic enhancement. elegant hoopoe remains firmly dedicated to principles of sustainable growth, unwavering brand integrity, and the delivery of exceptional value to its clients and franchise network. About elegant hoopoe: elegant hoopoe is a leading clinic in weight loss and aesthetics, headquartered in Dubai, UAE. Founded by Mr. Shahriar Shahir Barzegar, the clinic offers a curated selection of specialized services, enabling clients to achieve their wellness and aesthetic goals within a uniquely welcoming, elegant, and aspirational setting. With a steadfast commitment to innovation and client-centric care, elegant hoopoe is strategically positioned for significant growth and market leadership across the GCC. Discover more at .
