logo
The slippery slope of political iconography

The slippery slope of political iconography

Indian Express25-04-2025

Earlier this month Brendan Carr, the chair of the Federal Communications Commission, decided to swap out his usual American flag lapel pin. Instead of the stars and stripes, he pinned a gold medallion in the shape of President Donald Trump's profile, about the size of a quarter, to his blue suit and wore it to meet with a Georgia congressman, Buddy Carter, and later to a meeting at the Justice Department. He then memorialized the meetings on the social platform X.
The pin was noticed by Benny Johnson, a conservative YouTuber, who posted a shot of it on X along with the line 'Do you even understand the level of fit that Brendan Carr has?' to his 3.6 million followers. Carr reposted it. And so a mini social media moment was born.
Rumors flew across the internet that Trump was requiring members of his administration to wear the pins. 'Fake news' wrote Steven Cheung, the White House communications director, in an email a few days later. Carr has not been seen wearing the pin since.
Yet the mere fact that someone who worked for Trump thought it might be a good idea to display his boss's likeness on his lapel, no matter how briefly, is notable.
Especially because it is not the only Trump likeness popping up in the administration. Trump's face also graces an example of what he has called the Trump 'Gold Card': a mock-up of the proposed green card for those willing to pay $5 million, which Trump unveiled the same day Carr modeled his Trump lapel pin and which Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said should come into effect in the next week or so.
'It's a real departure from the norm, especially because of the precedents,' said Richard Thompson Ford, a professor at Stanford Law School and the author of 'Dress Codes: How the Laws of Fashion Made History.' 'To the extent such symbolism matters, it portends a change. A shift from the veneration of the rule of law, to the veneration of an individual.'
When asked why Carr wore the pin, and where he got it, a spokesperson for the FCC emailed back, 'Chairman Carr has focused on delivering great results for the American people.' Then he added, 'The New York Times has chosen to focus on … lapel pins.'
However, lapel pins of all kinds, whether the flag pin, the Légion d'Honneur in France, the poppy in Britain or the multiple color-coded ribbons for different causes, have long been repositories of meaning.
They sit at the knotty place where history, the culture of consumption and the power of merch meet.
A Brief History of the Lapel Pin
Lapel pins have long been beloved tools across the political spectrum. At the 2024 State of the Union address, Democrats wore lapel pins to show their support of abortion rights, to protest gun violence and police violence, or to support Ukraine, while Republican lawmakers sported pins paying homage to Laken Riley, the college student who was killed by a migrant.
Because they are worn close to the heart, and on view for anyone to see, they have become de facto signs of value systems and allegiances. Not to mention 'a way to distinguish between the in group and the out group,' said Joshua Arthurs, an associate professor of history and museum studies at the University of Toronto.
The pins have their roots in military culture, with its practice of wearing the insignia of rank and status on the front of the chest. In Benito Mussolini's Italy, for example, Arthurs said a wide variety of lapel pins was often on display, including '1919 pins' that differentiated original members of the fascist party from those who joined later, and who often wore pins with elaborate party insignia.
But they became particularly potent in China under Mao Zedong, where wearing a lapel pin in the form of Mao's profile became a widespread sign of commitment.
'The person becomes the embodiment of the cause,' said Karl Gerth, a professor of Chinese Studies and history at the University of California, San Diego, and the author of 'Unending Capitalism: How Consumerism Negated China's Communist Revolution.' The implication being, he said, that loyalty to the state is loyalty to the person, or loyalty to the person is loyalty to the state.
Such prominent symbols, Arthurs said, suggest familiar displays of patriotism shifting into something like a 'secular religion.' One built around a charismatic figure, the power of ritual and iconography. Or stuff. 'Clothing becomes very important,' Arthurs said, as 'a way to show you are a true believer' and a member of the tribe, whether or not it is officially required. This is part of the allure of the MAGA hat — and why Trump could sell off swatches of his mug shot suit like souvenirs.
What's in a Face?
Trump lapel pins are not particularly hard to get. One such gold-plated style is currently available on the official Trump 2024 store for $19.95, while another is on Amazon for $6.99; more than 300 of those pins have been sold in the past month, according to the e-commerce site.
It's not hard to imagine why such a pin may seem attractive for anyone who has taken note of the amount of time Trump spends discussing appearance, and his dislike of what he considers improper dress (see his scolding of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy for not wearing a suit for his Oval Office meeting). The president obviously both pays attention to and cares what those around him wear.
Indeed, it does not seem like a coincidence that so many Republican officials, including Vice President JD Vance, Secretary of State Marco Rubio and House Speaker Mike Johnson, have adopted the de facto Trump uniform of blue suit, white shirt and red tie.
It is also very clear that Trump loves gold (see the redecoration of the Oval Office). That he is concerned with his own likeness, as his recent complaints over a portrait that he believed was unflattering and that was briefly hung in the Colorado Capitol demonstrated. And that he values loyalty. What better way to show fealty than to wear a gold pin of his likeness?
He does not have to actually instruct people to do so. They can figure it out all on their own. It's no different from young Bernie Sanders supporters getting tattoos of his face (as some proudly did after the 2016 campaign), or Barack Obama fans buying T-shirts with Shepard Fairey's Obama portrait on the chest — unless it becomes something more ubiquitous and bureaucratic. Which is where the gold card comes in.
While presidents such as George Washington, Thomas Jefferson and Abraham Lincoln all have their likeness on the U.S. currency, that happened after they were either dead or at least out of office; in 1866, Congress passed a law that prohibited using the 'portrait or likeness of any living person' on legal tender. To have a leader put his face on an official instrument when the person is actually in power is, like the lapel pin, Ford said, 'a bad sign.'
'When Caesar put his face on a coin, it was a personal, rather than a civic, assertion of power,' Ford said. It was also when Rome moved from republic to empire.
That is why Carr's pin matters. 'It's a reflection,' Ford said, 'of the mindset of someone working in the administration.' When that person is also the person charged with overseeing communications laws and regulations, it seems especially — well, pointed.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

LA protests: Newsom moves to block Trump's use of National Guard, Marines
LA protests: Newsom moves to block Trump's use of National Guard, Marines

India Today

time29 minutes ago

  • India Today

LA protests: Newsom moves to block Trump's use of National Guard, Marines

California Governor Gavin Newsom has filed an emergency motion in federal court seeking to block the Trump administration from using National Guard troops and US Marines in immigration raids across Los Angeles, escalating a fierce standoff between state and federal authorities.'Trump is turning the US military against American citizens,' Newsom wrote on X (formerly Twitter), as he accused the president of weaponizing troops against Californians in the wake of days-long protests over immigration I just filed an emergency motion to block Trump's illegal deployment of Marines and National Guard in Los is turning the U.S. military against American courts must immediately block these illegal actions. Gavin Newsom (@GavinNewsom) June 10, 2025advertisementNewsom's legal filing, submitted on Tuesday, comes as President Donald Trump ramps up his controversial deployment of roughly 4,000 National Guard members and 700 Marines to the city. While initially tasked with protecting federal buildings and personnel, the new filing says military support is shifting toward direct assistance in immigration operations, including securing raid locations and controlling surrounding streets. A declaration from Paul Eck, deputy general counsel for the California Military Department, submitted as part of the filing, warned that 'the Pentagon plans to direct the California National Guard to support immigration operations,' blurring the line between civil assistance and immigration enforcement.'It's a sense of intimidation and fear that is just so unnecessary and so corrosive to our city,' Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass said at a Tuesday press conference. She added that ICE raids are expected to continue for 30 days or said she planned to personally ask Trump to halt the operations. Meanwhile, Los Angeles police confirmed over 100 arrests in connection with the protests, and acknowledged the use of "numerous less-lethal rounds" to disperse Trump on Tuesday issued a stern warning to anyone planning to protest during the upcoming military parade on June 14, which marks the US Army's 250th anniversary in Washington. The large-scale event, scheduled to take place on the National Mall and through the streets of Washington, also coincides with Trump's 79th birthday.(With inputs from Associated Press)Tune InMust Watch

Will be met with big force: Trump warns protesters ahead of Army parade
Will be met with big force: Trump warns protesters ahead of Army parade

India Today

time30 minutes ago

  • India Today

Will be met with big force: Trump warns protesters ahead of Army parade

President Donald Trump on Tuesday issued a stern warning to anyone planning to protest during the upcoming military parade on June 14, which marks the US Army's 250th anniversary in Washington. The large-scale event, scheduled to take place on the National Mall and through the streets of Washington, also coincides with Trump's 79th birthday. It will feature a military parade, an Army birthday festival, and a special enlistment and re-enlistment ceremony overseen by the president those people that want to protest, they're going to be met with very big force," Trump told reporters during unscheduled remarks in the Oval Office. The president emphasized that Saturday's parade is intended to be a patriotic celebration and suggested that dissenters would be treated as hostile IN: President Trump sends a STRONG message those planning to disrupt the Army Parade in DC this weekend'YOU WILL BE MET WITH VERY HEAVY FORCE!' Nick Sortor (@nicksortor) June 10, 2025Law enforcement officials are preparing for what could be a massive turnout. According to US Secret Service Special Agent in Charge Matt McCool, 'thousands of agents, officers and specialists' from federal, state, and local agencies will be deployed. McCool added that 'at least nine permits have been issued for protests' on that day, although the FBI and Metropolitan Police have found no credible threats so One group organizing nationwide protests is called No Kings, which has openly criticized the administration's policies. "They've defied our courts, deported Americans, disappeared people off the streets, attacked our civil rights and slashed our services," the group states on its website. "The corruption has gone too far. No thrones. No crowns. No kings."Trump, meanwhile, reiterated his support for a strong military presence in response to public unrest, including his controversial decision to send 4,000 National Guard troops and 700 Marines to Los Angeles. The deployment followed protests triggered by immigration raids targeting workplaces."We're going to celebrate big on Saturday," Trump declared, before doubling down on his warning to demonstrators. "If any protesters want to come out, they will be met with very big force.""This is people that hate our country," he continued. "They will be met with heavy force."TRUMP SAYS OPEN TO INVOKING INSURRECTION ACTDuring an Oval Office exchange with reporters, Trump signaled he may consider invoking the Insurrection Act: one of the most extreme emergency powers available to a president, in response to ongoing immigration protests in Los Angeles. The Act allows the deployment of military forces within the United States to suppress rebellion, domestic unrest, or enforce federal law in specific the scale of Saturday's planned celebration, Trump added, "It's going to be a parade, the likes of which I don't know if we've ever had a parade like that. It's going to be incredible." He also touted the spectacle of military equipment, old and new, on display: "We have many tanks. We have all sorts of new ones and very old ones old from World War I and World War II,' Trump was quoted as saying by ABC News."We have a lot of those army airplanes flying over the top, and we have tanks all over the place," the president said, suggesting the event would rival global military parades in grandeur and patriotic spirit.(With inputs from Reuters)Tune InMust Watch

US Army's 250th Anniversary on June 14: 6,500 troops, 50 aircraft, 28 Strykers—Inside Washington DC parade lineup
US Army's 250th Anniversary on June 14: 6,500 troops, 50 aircraft, 28 Strykers—Inside Washington DC parade lineup

Mint

timean hour ago

  • Mint

US Army's 250th Anniversary on June 14: 6,500 troops, 50 aircraft, 28 Strykers—Inside Washington DC parade lineup

he US Army is set to mark its 250th anniversary on Saturday (June 14), with a large-scale celebration in Washington, D.C., that will feature a military parade, flyovers, equipment displays, and a public festival. The event will also coincide with President Donald Trump's 79th birthday, although the Army has said there are no official plans to recognise his birthday. Nonetheless, Trump is expected to play a central role in the day's ceremonies. The celebration will begin with a wreath-laying ceremony at Arlington National Cemetery, followed by a fitness competition and an Army birthday festival on the National Mall. The festival will include interactive displays, military demonstrations, and public engagement events aimed at showcasing Army history and capabilities. The day will culminate in a massive parade through Washington, D.C., with Trump presiding over an enlistment and re-enlistment ceremony. Fireworks are scheduled for the evening, and the U.S. Army Golden Knights parachute team will drop in to present Trump with a flag. More than 6,500 troops, 150 military vehicles, and 50 aircraft will take part in the parade. Equipment highlights include: 28 Stryker armored vehicles Paladin self-propelled artillery units M777 and M119 artillery pieces The flyover segment will include Apache, Black Hawk, and Chinook helicopters, as well as historic World War II-era aircraft such as the B-25 bomber and P-51 Mustang. Also featured in the parade: 34 horses, two mules, and a dog. With hundreds of thousands expected to attend, security will be extensive. The US Secret Service is overseeing the effort, which includes: 18.5 miles of anti-scale fencing 17 miles of concrete barriers Drones and surveillance systems

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store