Poverty plagues rural Sindh
According to official statistics obtained by the Express Tribune, the Sindh government has spent nearly Rs20 billion in five years on a single poverty alleviation project, yet at least 70 per cent of the population across ten districts is still living below the poverty line.
The Multi-Dimensional Poverty Index compiled by the Planning and Development Department's Research and Training Wing has shown that across five districts, more than 80 per cent of people are stuck in poverty. Surprisingly, poverty levels in these five districts exceed those in Tharparkar. The worst-affected districts are Thatta, Sajawal, Kashmore, Badin, and Jacobabad.
The survey also revealed alarming rates of malnutrition among women in these districts. While 50 per cent of women in Tharparkar suffered from nutritional deficiencies, the rate was even higher in the five poorest districts. In fact, 66 per cent of women in Thatta and Jacobabad, 59 per cent in Kashmore, 56 per cent in Badin, and 51 per cent in Sajawal were living with malnutrition.
Similarly, child mortality rates under the age of five were also highest in these five districts. According to the survey, 15.6 per cent of children under five died in Thatta, while the rates in Badin, Kashmore, and Sajawal were 11 per cent, 12.2 per cent, and 5.2 per cent respectively.
When contacted by the Express Tribune, Dr Sono Khanghrani, a board member of the Social Protection Authority, explained that a key reason behind persistently high poverty levels was the government's monopoly over service delivery in areas such as education, health, water, electricity, and employment.
"Improvement is unlikely as long as these sectors remain under direct government control hence there is a need to involve non-governmental organizations (NGOs) in service provision. Furthermore, poor law and order conditions in certain districts, namely Jacobabad, Kandhkot, and Kashmore are also contributing factors to the failure of poverty reduction programs," assessed Dr Khanghrani.
On a similar note, Dr Kaiser Bengali, a renowned economist, attributed the failure of poverty alleviation projects largely to the absence of effective monitoring systems. "For instance, Sajawal, one of the districts with persistently high poverty levels, had a government-backed poverty eradication initiative funded by international donors with an investment of Rs4 billion. This ultimately yielded no results," noted Dr Bengali, while talking about the district from where influential minister, Haji Ali Hassan Zardari was elected and holds the important portfolio of Works and Services.
Data from the Sindh Finance Department has indicated that with the support of the World Bank and United Nations, the government had launched an Accelerated Action Plan in 23 districts of Sindh to address malnutrition. Between the fiscal years 2012-13 and 2016-17, over Rs20 billion were spent, with a further Rs10 billion allocated to various social protection programs afterwards. Despite this, neither malnutrition nor poverty levels have improved.
The Planning and Development Department's poverty index report noted that during the 2018-19 fiscal year, the budget for nutrition was increased by 112 per cent, from Rs2.4 billion to Rs5.1 billion. However, nutritional outcomes only deteriorated further, with the proportion of stunted children rising from 48 per cent in 2014-15 to 50.2 per cent in 2018-19.
Later in 2022, the Sindh government also established the Department of Social Protection and the Social Protection Authority to oversee social welfare, which was previously managed by the Social Protection Unit within the Chief Minister's Secretariat. This department was allocated a budget of Rs15.43 billion in its first year, 2022-23, which was increased to Rs16.9 billion by 2023-24.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
20-07-2025
- Express Tribune
New budget ignores woes of poor patients
The Sindh government has once again claimed improvements in healthcare, asserting increased health sector allocations while paradoxically achieving little in terms of improving patients' access to affordable healthcare. Sindh's public hospitals, facing increasing patient pressure, had submitted a formal written request to the Sindh government for a substantial increase in grants in the annual budget. However, the government rejected this request and instead allocated only an 8 per cent increase in grants for public hospitals. In contrast, a significant amount was allocated for NGOs working in the health sector, including public-private partnerships (PPP's) which were promised 50 per cent more funds. According to sources of the Express Tribune, for the 2025-26 budget, the Sindh government has allocated Rs326.5 billion for the healthcare sector, which is a steady rise from the previous year's budget of Rs302.2 billion. The budget for the People's Primary Healthcare Initiative has been increased from Rs12 billion to 16.5 billion, while the Gambat Institute's budget has been increased by Rs3 billion to 10 billion. In essence, instead of improving the state of government hospitals, the Sindh government has allocated a total of Rs146.9 billion for over 60 NGOs operating under public-private partnerships, an increase from Rs90 billion. Experts believe that this amount could have been used to provide health insurance to patients across Sindh, who remain deprived of adequate healthcare facilities. This is particularly imperative in a province where existing health facilities have seen no improvement in terms of bed capacity, despite annual budget increases. At the Sindh Government Children's Hospital near Nagan Chowrangi, which operates under a Public-Private Partnership (PPP), Sabir, the father of 8-year-old Zohaib, shared his concerns. "The hospital staff and administration act as if the facility is privately owned. They often show a lack of attention toward patients and display a disrespectful attitude towards their attendants. It is a common issue at PPP hospitals that essential medicines are frequently unavailable, and emergency services are often not provided during night hours. The attitude of doctors and staff is generally indifferent," said Sabir. Senior photographer at a daily, Jalal Qureshi, shared his recent experience of taking his granddaughter to the emergency department of NICVD's children's unit, where the guard and staff behaved extremely rudely with his son-in-law. "When I attempted to report the incident to the hospital director, I learned that the emergency department had been handed over to an NGO under the PPP model. The NGO staff gave the impression that the facility was a private hospital, with guards and staff appointed at the NGO's discretion," said Qureshi. "No new hospital has been established in Karachi in the past decade, while the bed capacity of existing hospitals has not been increased either. Even in hospitals like Civil, Jinnah, and Lyari, the number of beds remains the same as it was before. Despite the Sindh government increasing the budget for these hospitals every year, no measures have been taken to increase the number of beds. There is no accountability in this regard. Under public-private partnerships, the Sindh government has handed over buildings of public hospitals to various NGOs, which use electricity, water, and manpower free of cost. Although the Sindh government allocates significant funds to these NGOs in the annual budget, patients do not benefit from it," claimed Dr Nighat Khan, Chairperson of the Women Care Foundation. Former Caretaker Health Minister of Sindh, Dr Saad Khalid Niaz opined that the same funds could have been used to offer health insurance to the people. "Despite the Sindh government's annual claims of improving the healthcare sector, poor patients still face difficulties in accessing treatment. The number of government hospitals in the metropolitan city is insufficient for a population of over 20 million," said Dr Niaz.
Express Tribune
16-07-2025
- Express Tribune
Homeless people scramble for survival
Listen to article Most of the people habitually complaining of the harsh weather or loadshedding schedule are comfortably resting on their memory foam mattresses in their air-conditioned rooms at night. However, for the homeless people spending their nights desperately seeking shelter while escaping police crackdowns, sleep takes over before they can even think about complaining. During the tenure of the previous elected government, Panah Gah or night shelter homes were established to help homeless people sleep safely at night. However, over the last three years, the Punjab government has shut down these facilities, as a result of which homeless people sleeping on roads and sidewalks are exposed to harsh weather conditions during the winter and summer months. In just Lahore alone, nearly 1,700 homeless people have lost their lives over the past three years. A homeless couple, Inam and Asiya, who now sleep near Lal Pul along the canal, shared their experience. 'A few years ago, we used to go to a shelter near the railway station at night where we'd get a bed and food. Then we'd go back to work the next morning. But for the last three years, the shelters have been shut. We've made a temporary place near Lal Pul. Sometimes the police hassle us, and we change our spot for a day or two. Although we can manage during the day, nights are our biggest enemy,' shared the couple. Edhi Foundation spokesperson Muhammad Younis Bhatti confirmed that the death rate among those sleeping on footpaths during the winter and summer months has significantly increased over the past three years, mainly due to the lack of shelters. 'Previously, shelters provided 8 to 10 hours of rest daily, but their closure has complicated the situation. In the summer, the footpaths are searing, while in winter, the frost intensifies the cold. Hence a spike in death occurs during these three to five months,' noted Bhatti. Read More: At least 12 killed, six injured in Lahore as rain lashes city According to sources of the Express Tribune, the highest number of unidentified deaths are reported from areas including Data Darbar, Bhati Gate, Tibbi City, Qila Gujar Singh, Muslim Town, Kahna, Shahdara, Kot Lakhpat, Lari Adda, Mozang, and Garden Town. While more than 170 permanent and temporary shelter homes were built across Punjab, including 13 in Lahore, there is now only one functional shelter home each in Multan, D.G. Khan, Taunsa Sharif, Rawalpindi, Faisalabad, Bahawalpur, and Sargodha, and just six remain operational in Lahore. Director Social Welfare, Muzammil Yaar, revealed that more than 50 per cent of the shelter homes were initially built in collaboration with philanthropists, but over time, most of them were closed. 'Even some of the shelters originally run by the Social Welfare Department have been shut down. A shelter home has a staff of over 10 people and caters to over a 100 people daily. The government has not allocated a significant budget to expand the shelter network. As a result, in Lahore and across Punjab, the closure of shelters over the past three years has directly contributed to the rising death toll among homeless individuals, especially those exposed to harsh weather or struggling with drug addiction,' conceded Yaar. 'A significant percentage of deaths reported among the homeless occur due to drug abuse, which is worsened by extreme weather. Many of these individuals become addicted simply to kill time, and in the past three years, drug abuse among them has increased by over 40 per cent,' claimed Syed Zulfiqar Hussain, a drug rehabilitation consultant. In the meanwhile, a spokesperson for the Punjab government claimed that although in the past, temporary arrangements were made for sheltering homeless people, the current government was working on a permanent solution to the problem.
Express Tribune
11-07-2025
- Express Tribune
Poverty plagues rural Sindh
Despite the Sindh government spending billions of rupees on social protection programs, poverty remains deeply entrenched in the province's rural areas. According to official statistics obtained by the Express Tribune, the Sindh government has spent nearly Rs20 billion in five years on a single poverty alleviation project, yet at least 70 per cent of the population across ten districts is still living below the poverty line. The Multi-Dimensional Poverty Index compiled by the Planning and Development Department's Research and Training Wing has shown that across five districts, more than 80 per cent of people are stuck in poverty. Surprisingly, poverty levels in these five districts exceed those in Tharparkar. The worst-affected districts are Thatta, Sajawal, Kashmore, Badin, and Jacobabad. The survey also revealed alarming rates of malnutrition among women in these districts. While 50 per cent of women in Tharparkar suffered from nutritional deficiencies, the rate was even higher in the five poorest districts. In fact, 66 per cent of women in Thatta and Jacobabad, 59 per cent in Kashmore, 56 per cent in Badin, and 51 per cent in Sajawal were living with malnutrition. Similarly, child mortality rates under the age of five were also highest in these five districts. According to the survey, 15.6 per cent of children under five died in Thatta, while the rates in Badin, Kashmore, and Sajawal were 11 per cent, 12.2 per cent, and 5.2 per cent respectively. When contacted by the Express Tribune, Dr Sono Khanghrani, a board member of the Social Protection Authority, explained that a key reason behind persistently high poverty levels was the government's monopoly over service delivery in areas such as education, health, water, electricity, and employment. "Improvement is unlikely as long as these sectors remain under direct government control hence there is a need to involve non-governmental organizations (NGOs) in service provision. Furthermore, poor law and order conditions in certain districts, namely Jacobabad, Kandhkot, and Kashmore are also contributing factors to the failure of poverty reduction programs," assessed Dr Khanghrani. On a similar note, Dr Kaiser Bengali, a renowned economist, attributed the failure of poverty alleviation projects largely to the absence of effective monitoring systems. "For instance, Sajawal, one of the districts with persistently high poverty levels, had a government-backed poverty eradication initiative funded by international donors with an investment of Rs4 billion. This ultimately yielded no results," noted Dr Bengali, while talking about the district from where influential minister, Haji Ali Hassan Zardari was elected and holds the important portfolio of Works and Services. Data from the Sindh Finance Department has indicated that with the support of the World Bank and United Nations, the government had launched an Accelerated Action Plan in 23 districts of Sindh to address malnutrition. Between the fiscal years 2012-13 and 2016-17, over Rs20 billion were spent, with a further Rs10 billion allocated to various social protection programs afterwards. Despite this, neither malnutrition nor poverty levels have improved. The Planning and Development Department's poverty index report noted that during the 2018-19 fiscal year, the budget for nutrition was increased by 112 per cent, from Rs2.4 billion to Rs5.1 billion. However, nutritional outcomes only deteriorated further, with the proportion of stunted children rising from 48 per cent in 2014-15 to 50.2 per cent in 2018-19. Later in 2022, the Sindh government also established the Department of Social Protection and the Social Protection Authority to oversee social welfare, which was previously managed by the Social Protection Unit within the Chief Minister's Secretariat. This department was allocated a budget of Rs15.43 billion in its first year, 2022-23, which was increased to Rs16.9 billion by 2023-24.
