Smacking ban is needed to protect children, health experts say
Leading health experts have urged parliamentarians to give children the 'fundamental right to safety and protection' by backing a smacking ban.
Experts from a number of medical specialties, including children's doctors and psychiatrists, said that decades of research shows the 'detrimental effects of physical punishment'.
According to the Children Act 2004, it is unlawful to hit your child, except where it is 'reasonable punishment', and this is judged on a case-by-case basis.
But experts said these laws are 'vague and dangerous'.
Now 13 health organisations are calling on the Government to back an amendment to the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill which would remove the 'reasonable punishment' defence from law in England.
They said that the Bill reaching committee stage in the House of Lords is a 'pivotal moment' in the smacking ban campaign.
Baroness Finlay has proposed an amendment to eliminate the 'reasonable punishment' defence.
In an open letter, the organisations said this defence is 'archaic' and 'allows for the physical punishment of children'.
'This leaves them with less protection from assault than adults, an unacceptable disparity in our modern society,' they wrote.
'The evidence is clear: physical punishment is harmful, ineffective, and has no place in a society that values the well-being of its children.'
The organisations called on the Government to 'stand on the side of our children and ensure their fundamental right to safety and protection', adding: 'By removing this archaic defence, we can send a clear message that violence against children is never acceptable.'
Professor Andrew Rowland, child protection officer at the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health and a consultant paediatrician, said: 'There is now strong agreement from health and social care professionals that the current laws around physical punishment of children, including smacking, are unjust, vague and ultimately dangerous.
'It is time to bring protection from physical assault for children in line with the protection afforded to adults.
'Every child deserves the best possible start to life, and eradicating physical punishment of children is a key part of that aim.'
Dr Elaine Lockhart, head of the Child and Adolescent Faculty at the Royal College of Psychiatrists, added: 'The physical punishment of children is not just cruel, it is dangerous: the practice has been shown to be detrimental to children's mental health and leads to poor developmental outcomes.'
Dr Tamasin Knight, from the British Medical Association's public health medicine committee, added: 'We believe that children should have full legal protection from all forms of physical punishment.'
The full list of signatories on the letter are: Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health; Faculty of Public Health; Royal Society of Medicine; School and Public Health Nurses Association; Institute of Health Promotion and Education; Institute of Health Visitors; Royal Society for Public Health; British Association for Child and Adolescent Public Health; British Medical Association; Royal College of Psychiatrists; Aldey Hey Hospital Charity; Alliance 4 Children and Barnardo's.
The Government has been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
42 minutes ago
- The Independent
Gladiator Giant says prostate cancer blood test could save lives
Gladiators star Jamie Christian has said there are no 'warning signs' for prostate cancer and has urged men to take a blood test that 'could save their life' if diagnosed early. Known as Giant on the hit BBC show, the bodybuilder has been raising money for Prostate Cancer UK and took part in The Big Golf Race where he played 72 holes of golf and walked more than 26 miles in a single day, completing the challenge in just under 15 hours. This comes after his uncle, Colin Tomlinson, was diagnosed and later recovered from prostate cancer eight years ago. Speaking during Men's Health Week, which runs from June 9-15, he said: 'That was just a true example of it can happen to anyone, no matter how fit or healthy you are there are no warning signs for this. 'If people aren't getting the necessary checks, then it could be too late.' Around one in eight men in the UK will get prostate cancer in their lifetime, according to Prostate Cancer UK. It occurs when cells in the prostate start to grow in an uncontrolled way with the risk of spreading if not detected early. One cancer screening is a PSA blood test which checks the level of prostate specific antigens in the blood and, if high, may be a sign of a prostate condition, according to the NHS website. He said: 'By doing a simple blood test, by going to your GP and having a simple blood test to check your PSA levels, that's like the first step, and it's something really, really easy. 'It could save their life. 'I think men, being men, we're very private individuals especially with certain body parts. So I think the stigma attached to prostate cancer is that men have to go to the doctors and have the prostate exam with the finger up the bum, without being too graphic. I think that puts a lot of people off. 'Having the knowledge of a simple blood test will give you all you need to know that is far, far more beneficial than surely finding out one day that you might have cancer.' Because prostate cancer often does not have any symptoms, it is important to get checked especially for men over the age of 50, black men and men with a family history of prostate cancer who are at higher risk. Christian added: 'It's much more powerful to prevent something than to have to cure it, because the cure isn't something that we can have full control over, but prevention-wise, that is in our control to go and get the necessary checks to look after our lifestyle, our diets, our activities, shall we say. 'When you put it like that, a few minutes of your day, why would you not go and do it? Peace of mind.' The Big Golf Race is the biggest golf fundraising challenge in the UK which encourages participants to choose from the Half Marathon (36 holes and approximately 13 miles of walking), the Marathon (72 holes and over 26 miles), or the Ultra Marathon (100 holes in one day and 35 miles) to raise money and awareness for the charity. Speaking about the sport Christian added: '(The golf course) is a great place where men can be in a safe space and talk to one another. And these conversations on a golf course are private and respected. 'I think the more people that come on board, the more people that listen, more people that talk, more people that go out and play a game of golf and have those conversations with each other, the better. 'And hopefully, the rates of the actual deaths from prostate cancer will start to fall.' Christian is best known as Giant on the sports and entertainment show Gladiators which sees professional athletes take on contestants as they try to complete physical challenges. Prior to being a Gladiator, he was the tallest professional bodybuilder in the world at six feet five and consumed up to 10,000 calories a day. He has since reduced his intake to around 5,000 calories.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Reform's new chairman once called Farage an idiot
The new chairman of Reform UK once called its leader Nigel Farage an 'idiot' and criticised comments by him as 'dangerous'. The remarks by Dr David Bull have emerged after his appointment to the role was announced on Tuesday. He replaces Zia Yusuf, who resigned as Reform's chairman last week before rejoining the party just two days later to take up a different senior position. Dr Bull previously publicly disagreed with Mr Farage over comments he made in 2014 about migrants with HIV. He also shared several posts on his Twitter profile criticising Donald Trump, including calling his first inauguration speech in 2017 'awful'. During his time as Ukip leader, Mr Farage suggested HIV-positive immigrants should not be allowed to come to the UK and receive treatment on the NHS. He said it should not be used as a 'global health service' because of a lack of resources. Sharing an article about Mr Farage's comments, Dr Bull wrote: 'Nigel Farage's comments are ill-judged, prejudiced and dangerous. HIV can affect anyone regardless of sex, race and class'. In the post, still visible online, he added: '#idiot #unhelpful'. Dr Bull, 56, is a long-time ally of Mr Farage and has previously held roles in both Reform and its former iteration the Brexit Party. He served as an MEP for North West England between 2019 and 2020. Speaking at a press conference on Tuesday, Mr Yusuf said he was 'hugely excited' that Dr Bull was taking up the role, adding: 'This party is no longer a start-up. 'I think it's gone to a scale-up phase... the reality is what we need now in a chairman is someone who is an incredible communicator, someone who's loved universally across the party... someone who's going to I think do a better job than me at energising volunteers on the front line.' Mr Yusuf added: 'I wholeheartedly congratulate him, and I know he's going to do an incredible job for us.' Meanwhile, Mr Farage said Dr Bull would come to the chairman's role with 'terrific verve, energy, enthusiasm'. He described him as a 'terrific communicator' and said his 'job is not to get involved with the admin, is not to get involved in the tech' but to 'give leadership to that volunteer army out there of people'. Dr Bull's negative comments about Mr Trump, who is close to Mr Farage, included calling him a 'fool' for saying during the 2016 presidential campaign that he wanted to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare. Commenting on the Republican's first inauguration speech in January 2017, he wrote: 'It's…… um….. awful'. He also condemned Lord Mackinlay, the former Conservative MP, for opposing LGBT-inclusive sex education in schools. Sharing an article by Pink News, an LGBT-led media outlet, in 2017, Dr Bull called him a 'total idiot' and said that 'inclusive' sex education 'must be compulsory'. In 2014, Ukip, when led by Mr Farage, proposed banning sex education in primary schools. But Mr Farage said at the time that he had ' never advocated that policy '. Last year, Mr Farage said there 'perhaps' was not a 'straightforward answer' to what age children should be taught about sex and relationships. In May last year, he told GB News that there was 'little doubt that there are some schools that have been teaching very inappropriate material'.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Common pill is putting millions at risk of life-threatening breathing problems, doctor warns
They are pills prescribed to millions in the UK to treat heart conditions and anxiety. But beta blockers may pose a hidden risk to the 7.2 million people living with asthma, an NHS GP has warned. According to the British Heart Foundation, UK doctors issue more than 50 million prescriptions for beta blockers every year. However, Dr Sooj, a family doctor with over 250,000 TikTok followers, cautioned that the drugs can interfere with the way asthma medications work—potentially putting some patients at risk during an attack. Asthma causes symptoms such as wheezing, coughing and chest tightness. While generally manageable, it can become life-threatening, when severely inflamed airways make it extremely difficult to breathe. Asthma UK reports that around 1,200 people die from asthma attacks each year in the UK, while in the US the figure is over 3,500. In a TikTok, Dr Sooj explained: 'If you have asthma you need to be cautious and we need to make sure you're aware of any of the risks and potential complications of taking a beta blocker.' He continued: 'The medications we use in an acute asthma attack are called beta agonists—these help to dilate the pipes in your lungs.' Dr Sooj explained that these beta agonists, found in many common inhalers, work by relaxing the muscles in the airways, making it easier to breathe. But beta blockers—used to slow the heart rate and lower blood pressure—can blunt this effect. 'By doing that, they can worsen the symptoms of asthma,' he said. And it's not just people with asthma who may be affected. Inhalers are also routinely prescribed to those with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), an umbrella term covering long-term lung conditions such as chronic bronchitis and emphysema. These incurable conditions can also cause severe breathing difficulties, and for this group too, beta blockers may pose a risk. The NHS advises patients with asthma or lung disease to inform their doctor before starting beta blockers, to ensure the medication is safe. That said, Dr Sooj added: 'I've seen lots of patients with COPD or asthma who are on beta blockers and they're completely fine with them.' 'But this is a discussion that you should be having with your own doctor.' Dr Sooj added that he still believed beta blockers to be 'excellent medications', and explained developments in the drugs that has improved them. 'We now have cardio selective beta blockers, which... affect the body a bit less.' The new warning follows concerns that a type of beta blocker called propranolol can put patients at risk of 'toxic overdose'—triggering seizures, depression and even cardiac arrest in high doses. Recent research showed the number of prescriptions for propranolol to treat anxiety in the UK doubled between 2003 and 2018. In theory, by keeping blood pressure low, feelings of panic and anxiety are reduced. However some experts have claimed there 'no evidence' that drugs are effective for mental health, and that patients often aren't adequately warned about risk of an overdose. In a recent letter to The Guardian, pharmacist Christopher Sullivan warned that the drug 'is associated with significant adverse outcomes' and urged GPs to exercise 'extreme caution when prescribing these medicines for anxiety'. 'Prescribing these medicines for anxiety is not recommended in national evidence-based guidelines,' he added. It followed comments from GP Dr Amir Khan, who told the newspaper that propananol had been linked to 'higher rates of depression' and warned GPs not to prescribe it to anxious patients who also suffer low mood. 'If you are taking them long term, you can't suddenly stop them,' he added. 'You need to be weaned off them.' The risks are not thought to pertain to those taking the medicine for heart problems and other physical issues like migraine—but experts say patients with mental health troubles are vulnerable to either accidentally or purposefully taking an overdose.
