Milwaukee Police's 'Shady' Deal: Trading Millions Of Mugshots For Facial Recognition Tech
The Milwaukee Police Department is mulling a cartoonishly 'shady' deal where it is willing to trade 2.5 million mugshots to a private company in exchange for free access to facial recognition software. According to a report in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, police officials announced the potential deal at the city's Fire and Police Commissions meeting last week.
Under the proposed deal, the department would receive two free search licenses from Biometrica, a software company already working with other law enforcement agencies in the US -- in exchange for mugshots and jail records spanning decades.
"We recognise the very delicate balance between advancement in technology and ensuring we as a department do not violate the rights of all of those in this diverse community," Milwaukee Police Chief of Staff Heather Hough said during an April 17 meeting.
"While we would like to acquire the technology to assist in solving cases, being transparent with the community that we serve far outweighs the urgency to acquire," she later said in an email.
The proposed agreement has so far made no mention about informing individuals or asking for their consent. Although Wisconsin is an open records state, meaning arrest records, including mughsots are available in the public domain, the legal purview of the deal remains sketchy.
Social media reacts
Reacting to the proposed deal, the majority of social media users called out the Milwaukee PD for compromising the privacy of people.
"One shady organisation acting in self-serving faith with another shady organisation. Poetic," said one user while another added: "Woof. Is this not a plot point in the TV show Class of '09?'
A third commented: "These systems are notoriously poor. Bias is significant. Bias is worse with people of colour. Also, surveillance bad."
Studies have shown that facial recognition systems exhibit bias, especially against people of colour. Additionally, the facial recognition companies often train their systems on stolen or borrowed datasets. In 2023, it was revealed that Clearview AI, which helped the US police during the January 6 riots, had scraped 30 billion images from platforms such as Facebook without permission from the users.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
6 days ago
- Hindustan Times
Milwaukee man watched creepy Netflix episode on first date, then killed teen the same way
A Wisconsin man was found guilty on Saturday of killing and dismembering the body of a 19-year-old student on their first date after the two watched a Netflix documentary with an eerily similar theme. 34-year-old Maxwell Anderson killed Sade Carleena Robinson, a criminal justice student, in April 2024 murder after the two met for dinner. They went out to a restaurant and bar before Anderson invited her back to his Milwaukee home. This was the last time she was seen alive. The next day, she did not show up to work at a local pizzeria and was reported missing. The police checked her home and found no trace of her. Police found a leg that matched her DNA, along with other body parts like a foot and human flesh scattered throughout the city. Prosecutors showed bloodied photos recovered from Anderson's phone to prove he was the killer. The images, initially deleted by Anderson, showed him holding one of Robinson's chopped-off breasts. Describing it as 'his trophy', juror Melissa Blascoe told the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel that the pictures will be in her mind "for quite some time.' The jury was also told that Anderson turned on a Netflix animated series named 'Love, Death & Robots" the night he brought Robinson home. One of the episodes in the series showed a dismembered corpse, which was discovered on the beach. Police also discovered a 'sex dungeon' in Anderson's home with "a sex sling, restraints and handcuffs." The photos found on the phone physically affected people in the courtroom, some of whom were shaking and crying, Blascoe added. Anderson is believed to have spent months planning the murder, even preparing a space lined with plastic sheeting. According to Associated Press, surveillance video shows Anderson driving Robinson's car to a county park near Lake Michigan. It is here that he cut her body into pieces, prosecutors argued, before setting her car on fire and taking a bus back to his apartment. The 15-member jury took 45 minutes to reach a guilty verdict. Anderson has been found guilty of first-degree intentional homicide, mutilating a corpse, hiding a corpse and arson. No motive behind the killing has been revealed yet. Anderson faces a mandatory life sentence on August 15.
The Hindu
18-05-2025
- The Hindu
Tough timing: on ISRO PSLV-C61 mission, India's space programme
In contemporary spaceflight, cost, reliability and time form a tense triangle. Whether more money can ensure more reliability is tricky to answer, more so following the failure of ISRO's PSLV-C61 mission to launch the EOS-09 earth-observation satellite into a sun-synchronous polar orbit. EOS-09 was designed to produce high-quality radar images for civilian applications such as land-use mapping and hydrology studies and for defence surveillance, even if inclement weather prevailed over the areas of interest thanks to a synthetic aperture radar and a C-band data-link. Against the backdrop of tensions with Pakistan, such all-weather data would also have informed tactical decisions. The Department of Space had also invited several Members of Parliament to the launch event, which would have been unusual for a strictly civilian earth-observation satellite. ISRO chairman V. Narayanan later said that his team noted a glitch in the vehicle's third stage minutes after liftoff that prevented the satellite from reaching its intended altitude. While the cause is yet to be ascertained, the failure is a reminder that a 'textbook' launch of a rocket even as well-understood as the PSLV is not a given. India is just embarking on its ambitious Space-Based Surveillance-3 programme to launch 52 surveillance satellites; 31 are to be built in the private sector, which still needs ISRO's guidance. Focus on the programme also comes against the backdrop of Operation Sindoor, which revealed at least one gap in the country's space-based military surveillance capabilities when it depended on a foreign commercial operator for more frequent data. Small margins of error in a rocket components' operations separate success from failure, and thus cost from reliability. Time, however, is a separate matter: the pressing need for surveillance capabilities, if not improving the understanding of climate change and disaster risk over India, means that developers lack the luxury of time while also coming under greater pressure to deliver across both civilian and military domains. The PSLV-C61 failure follows the failure in January to place the NVS-02 navigation satellite into its designated orbit. Between an increasingly crowded launch manifest, research and development, data acquisition and processing pipelines, limited access to manufacturing capacity, and the human spaceflight programme, it will not be remiss to increase the resources available to ISRO if only to ensure its ability to meet India's military needs while carrying on with other enterprises, all of which are becoming time-sensitive in a highly competitive global industry.
The Hindu
18-05-2025
- The Hindu
Top news of the day: At least 17 dead in Hyderabad Gulzar Houz fire accident; ISRO says PSLV-C61/EOS-09 mission could not be accomplished due to third stage pressure issue, and more
At least 17 killed in fire at a building in Gulzar Houz near Charminar A major fire broke out inside a home near Gulzar Houz of Charminar area of the Old City on Sunday morning (May 18, 2025), claiming at least 17 lives, as per preliminary reports from multiple hospitals. 'The death toll has increased to 17,' confirmed GHMC Commissioner R.V. Karnan during his visit to the Osmania General Hospital mortuary. So far, 15 bodies have arrived at the mortuary, with the remaining expected to be brought in shortly. Emergency services, including private and government hospitals, rushed to the scene to aid rescue operations. PSLV-C61/EOS-09 mission could not be accomplished due to third stage pressure issue: ISRO The Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) could not accomplish its 101st launch, the PSLV-C61/EOS-09 mission, on Sunday (May 18, 2025). Minutes after PSLV-C61 with the EOS-09 earth observation satellite lifted off from the Satish Dhawan Space Centre in Sriharikota at 5:59 a.m., the space agency said that the mission could not be accomplished due to an 'observation' in the third stage of the launch vehicle. Constitution of India supreme, its pillars must work together: CJI Gavai Chief Justice of India B.R. Gavai on Sunday (May 18, 2025) stressed that neither the judiciary nor the executive, but the Constitution of India was supreme and its pillars must work together. The Chief Justice said he was glad that the country has not just strengthened but has also developed on the social and economic fronts and continues to do so. Defence, trade and geopolitics on the cards at U.K.'s 'reset' summit with EU U.K. Prime Minister Keir Starmer will host the first U.K.-EU Summit since Brexit, as the Labour government attempts to 'reset' ties with the bloc, some nine years after the U.K. left the EU. The two sides, which will meet in London on Monday (May 19, 2025), are expected to announce a defence and security pact, agreements related to trade and a joint statement on the geopolitical situation. Gaza talks in Doha now include ending war or truce: PM office Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu signalled on Sunday (May 18, 2025) that Israel was open to a deal with Hamas that would include 'ending the fighting' in Gaza, laying out conditions for such an agreement. IPL 2025, RR vs PBKS: Wadhera, Shashank hit half-centuries as Punjab make 219/5 against Rajasthan Nehal Wadhera and Shashank Singh struck fine half-centuries to rescue Punjab Kings and help them to a competitive 219 for 5 against Rajasthan Royals in an Indian Premier League match here on Sunday (May 18, 2025). PBKS, currently on 15 points and in a good position to make the playoffs, were reduced to 34/3 in only the fourth over with RR's right-arm pacer Tushar Deshpande (2/37) getting rid of openers Priyansh Arya (9) and Prabhsimran Singh (21). Stalin requests CMs to oppose Presidential reference; underlines need to evolve a coordinated legal strategy Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M.K. Stalin has written to CMs of seven States and a Union territory, not ruled by BJP, urging them to oppose the Presidential Reference to the Supreme Court on time frames for Governors and Present to act on Bills referred to them under Article 200 of the Constitution. He underlined the need for a coordinated legal strategy before the court and present a united front to preserve and protect the basic structure of the Constitution. Bahujan Samaj Party appoints Akash Anand as chief national coordinator The Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) president Mayawati on Sunday (May 18, 2025) appointed Akash Anand as the party's chief national coordinator, during a special meeting held in New Delhi. The meeting was attended by the BSP central executive committee, senior office bearers at both the national and State levels, and representatives from across the country. Stop misusing patriotism as a political weapon: Assam Congress to CM Himanta Biswa Sarma The Assam Congress has advised Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma to stop 'misusing patriotism as a political weapon' by targeting MP Gaurav Gogoi and his British wife with 'vague accusations'. The party reacted to the Chief Minister's post on X, questioning the inclusion of Jorhat MP Gaurav Gogoi in a Congress list of leaders for delegations to be sent abroad to explain India's position on Pakistan-based terrorism. Preparations underway for Kailash Mansarovar Yatra from Sikkim after five years The Sikkim government has accelerated infrastructure development for the Kailash Mansarovar Yatra through Nathu La, a mountain pass in the Himalayas that connects the state with China's Tibet Autonomous Region. The pilgrimage to Mount Kailash and Mansarovar Lake, set to resume after a gap of five years, holds religious significance to Hindus as well as Jains and Buddhists. U.S. Embassy in India warns people staying beyond their authorised period to face deportation or ban on travelling to U.S. The U.S. Embassy in India on Saturday (May 17, 2025) warned that people who stay in the U.S. beyond their authorised period of stay will face deportation or a permanent ban on travelling to the U.S. in the future. In a post shared on X, the U.S. Embassy in India stated, 'If you remain in the United States beyond your authorized period of stay, you could be deported and could face a permanent ban on traveling to the United States in the future.'
