How did a jet flip upside down on a Toronto runway and everyone survive?
Investigators are probing the causes of an unusual plane crash at Canada's largest airport on Monday, when a regional jet flipped upside down upon landing during windy weather, sending 21 of the 80 people on board to hospital.
Video shows the Delta Air Lines plane belly up and missing its right wing at Toronto's Pearson Airport, and of the crash that involved no fatalities, circulated widely on social media. The Transportation Safety Board of Canada said on Tuesday that parts of the plane -- a Bombardier-made CRJ900 -- separated after impact and the fuselage came to rest slightly off the right side of the runway, upside down, facing the other direction.
The TSB said it is too early to know what happened and why. Here is what we know about this accident and similar crashes.
HOW DOES A PLANE LAND UPSIDE DOWN?
U.S. aviation safety expert Anthony Brickhouse said aircraft are normally designed to land first on the two main landing gear, and then the nose gear. While the cause of the accident is unclear, the type of impact on the runway likely damaged the landing gear, leaving the plane imbalanced.
Brickhouse said that the plane ending up pointing in the opposite direction speaks to the amount of force and speed that led it to change direction.
"With all the forces and everything going on, if that wing is not there to support the aircraft it's going to go over," Brickhouse said. "It's not something that we see regularly, but when structures start failing they can't do their job and the aircraft is going to react to the different forces on it."
HOW DID EVERYONE SURVIVE?
Passengers say they were hanging upside down in their seats after the crash.
"All of the passengers were wearing the safety belts. This prevented more serious injuries from occurring," said Mitchell Fox, director of the Asia Pacific Centre for Aviation Safety.
Airplane seats are designed to withstand the force of 16 times the normal pull of gravity, or 16Gs, in a crash, whereas wings and fuselage are designed to handle 3-5Gs.
"In an impact-survivable crash, it's more important for the seats to hold up, giving passengers the best chance of survival," said Raj Ladani, a program manager for aerospace engineering at Australia's RMIT University. Good evacuation is key to air accident survivability, as witnessed last year when all 379 people escaped a burning Japan Airlines plane after a runway collision.
"The crew did a remarkable job of evacuating all of the passengers expeditiously," Fox said of the Delta crash.
HAS THIS HAPPENED BEFORE?
While rare, there have been cases of large jets flipping over on landing, including three accidents involving McDonnell Douglas' MD-11 model.
In 2009, a FedEx freighter turned over on landing in windy conditions on the runway at Tokyo's Narita airport, killing both pilots. The left wing was broken and separated from the fuselage attaching point and the airplane caught fire.
In 1999, a China Airlines flight inverted at Hong Kong while landing during a typhoon. The plane touched down hard, flipped over and caught fire, killing three of 315 occupants.
In 1997, another FedEx freighter flipped over at Newark in the United States, with no fatalities.
Brickhouse said it is too early to draw any conclusions from these earlier cases, especially as the MD-11 is a three-engine aircraft and the CRJ900 has two engines mounted toward the back of the aircraft, producing different flight dynamics.
HOW WILL THE INVESTIGATION PROCEED?
Unlike other investigations in which parts of the plane have gone missing, and there are mass fatalities, investigators will be able to interview all 76 passengers and four crew. Investigators have access to the fuselage and wing, which are on the runway, and the black boxes -- the flight data and cockpit voice recorders -- have been sent for analysis.
"This is going to be a textbook investigation," Brickhouse said. "Some accidents, a lot of the pieces of the puzzle are missing. But right now looking at this accident, all the puzzle pieces are there. It's just you piecing them back together at this point."
(Reporting By Allison Lampert in Montreal and Lisa Barrington in Seoul; Editing by Bill Berkrot)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Etihad
6 days ago
- Al Etihad
German city evacuates 20,000 after unexploded World War II bombs are found
4 June 2025 21:10 BERLIN (AGENCIES)Some 20,500 people were being evacuated from the city of Cologne in western Germany as explosives experts prepared to defuse three unexploded World War II bombs found during construction work this evacuation, which comes after the discovery Monday of three American-made bombs, is the largest in Cologne since the end of World War II, the city administration said.A crucial industrial, cultural and logistical hub for Nazi Germany, Cologne was a primary target of Allied bombers during World War authorities cordoned off a 3,280-foot radius around Deutz, a busy district next to the Rhine river, across from the Old discoveries of unexploded World War II ordnance - 80 years on from the end of the conflict - are not uncommon across Germany and parts of Europe, the proximity of the bombs to downtown Cologne and other densely populated areas was large bomb was fitted with an impact fuse, meaning the bomb is less likely to go off on its own over time, but it is still dangerous if disturbed."In that respect, they are dangerous, yes. But it's definitely not the case that we need to panic,' Kai Kulschewski told local radio station WDR 5 on is the head of neighboring city Dusseldorf's explosive ordnance disposal department, which is overseeing the evacuation and businesses, government buildings, 58 hotels and nine schools are within the evacuation zone, the city said. The area also includes the busy MesseDeutz train station and a major hospital, whose intensive-care patients were moved to nearby hospitals by disposal experts plan to defuse the devices later Wednesday, once the entire zone is cleared. City authorities began the evacuations at 8am, conducting door-to-door checks and warning that people who refused to evacuate could be escorted by force and face steep on Wednesday afternoon showed that streets usually teeming with people and traffic were empty. Public transport was severely disrupted, with roads closed and train services halted. Flights at Cologne Bonn Airport continued operating, but access to the airport was landmarks, including the Cologne Philharmonie and museums, were forced to close for the day. More than a dozen couples scheduled to wed at Cologne's city hall had to relocate their ceremonies, WDR Wednesday afternoon, WDR reported that few people had arrived at the shelters for displaced residents; people had instead taken advantage of the good continued to sail on the Rhine, although authorities warned that they would clear a stretch of the river once the defusing told WDR that around 1,500 to 2,000 unexploded bombs from World War II are found every year across North Rhine-Westphalia, the state in which Cologne is located. In 2010, three workers died trying to defuse a bomb in the city of Göttingen when it exploded. Also that decade, in the city of Euskirchen, a construction worker was killed when he detonated an explosive from the war while digging.
Al Etihad
10-05-2025
- Al Etihad
Abu Dhabi launches instant camel grazing license service through TAMM platform
10 May 2025 14:06 ABU DHBAI (ALETIHAD)The Environment Agency – Abu Dhabi (EAD) has launched an instant service for eligible individuals to obtain a camel grazing license through the TAMM agency also announced the start of the grazing season in the emirate, which will run from May 15 to October 15, launch of the service falls within the requirements of Law No. (11) of 2020 and its executive regulations, regulating grazing in the Abu Dhabi emirate. EAD seeks to ensure the sustainable use of natural resources in accordance with the highest environmental standards, while meeting the needs of the local community and preserving pastoralism as a traditional practice and an integral part of the UAE's national on the executive regulations of the Grazing Regulation Law, EAD issues licenses to camel owners and breeders who meet specific criteria. To obtain a camel grazing license, the applicant must be a UAE citizen, at least 21 years' old, and employ a ranger of at least 18 years of age for the camels. The applicant must also have a valid livestock inventory certificate approved by the Abu Dhabi Agriculture and Food Safety Authority (ADAFSA).License holders are required to graze in open wilderness areas and to stay at least two kilometres away from nature reserves, forests, residential and private areas, military and oil and gas facilities, roads, and prohibited areas. They are also required not to leave camels grazing without the supervision of a ranger and to adhere to the grazing period specified in the breeders and owners who have a grazing license must adhere to several environmental requirements, including not introducing invasive plants, animals or any harmful substances into grazing areas. According to the new service, the breeders must not uproot, burn, move, cut, destroy, harvest, remove or collect grazing plants or any part thereof in those areas, and must undertake not to harm biodiversity or cause any environmental damage. Leaving fences, tools, materials or other waste is prohibited in the grazing areas, and they must not approach water well sites. The use of bicycles, cars, or any type of vehicle or machinery that negatively impacts the vegetation cover is not permitted. Transferring the grazing license to another person is also has coordinated with several relevant entities to ensure smooth access to the service via the TAMM platform. This coordination underscores the agency's commitment to the wise leadership's directive to provide efficient and prompt environmental licensing services. The agency recognises the valuable role of the local community in sharing their traditional grazing knowledge and experiences with its specialists, which informs the planning and formulation of effective grazing policies, legislation and procedures. Source: Aletihad - Abu Dhabi
The National
24-02-2025
- The National
Delta flight fills with smoke and returns to Atlanta airport
A Delta Air Lines flight returned to the Atlanta airport soon after taking off on Monday when crew members reported a smoky haze inside the cockpit, according to federal officials. Delta Flight 876 to Columbia, South Carolina, returned safely to Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport on Monday morning 'after the crew reported possible smoke in the flight deck", the Federal Aviation Administration said in a statement. Images on social media showed passengers standing on a wing of the plane. The FAA said it is investigating the incident, which came after a Delta plane flipped over last week while crash-landing in Toronto, injuring 21 people. Delta released a statement saying 94 passengers were on board the Boeing 717 aircraft departing Atlanta on Monday morning 'when a haze inside the aircraft was observed". It said pilots declared an emergency to get priority handling from air-traffic controllers. When the plane landed, slides were engaged so that passengers could quickly exit. Delta spokeswoman Samantha Moore Facteau said by email that 'EMTs attended to two customers". 'Nothing is more important than the safety of our customers and people,' the airline's statement said, 'and we apologise to our customers for the experience.'
