Almost half of refugees suffering from 'occupational downgrade' 10 years after settling
But he fled after the Islamic State group threatened him, putting his life and career on hold.
He spent two years in a refugee camp in Turkey before finally resettling in Australia in 2015.
"As an automation engineer, I was really hopeful to find something in my field in Australia," he said.
But his engineering bachelor's degree from Iraq was not recognised in Australia, and instead he spent the next two years working in casual jobs, cleaning construction sites and catering at aged care homes.
"You feel disheartened," he said.
Sam's story has been echoed in a new report from the Department of Social Services' Australian Institute of Family Studies (AIFS).
The report found that after arriving in Australia, most refugees struggled to have their skills and qualifications recognised.
Before arriving in Australia, 30 per cent of women and 19 per cent of men worked in managerial or professional roles.
But after a decade of residency in Australia, those figures dropped to 17 per cent and 10 per cent respectively.
Lead author Dr John van Kooy said the study aimed to uncover how long it took for refugees to make the transition into employment and what kinds of jobs they eventually found.
"What we observed in the study is 'occupational downgrading'," he said.
"This means people had managerial or professional roles, white-collar jobs in business, human resources, marketing or IT — in their home countries, but they have been unable to reach that same occupational status or even a similar occupational status even after 10 years of permanent residency in Australia."
For refugee women, the downgrade was even more pronounced.
Among those who had been managers or professionals in their home countries, more than two-thirds (67 per cent) were not in paid work after 10 years of living in Australia.
The remainder were mostly working as carers, cleaners, education aides or sales assistants.
About 2,400 humanitarian migrants were surveyed over a 10-year period — starting when their first visas were granted in 2013 — as part of the study.
A 2024 report by national not-for-profit service provider Settlement Services International found there was potential for a "billion-dollar benefit" in the employment of refugees and other migrants whose skills were thought to be chronically under-utilised.
"There are around 37,000 refugees in Australia right now … working below their level of skill and qualification," said Dane Moores, SSI's head of strategic relations.
The daughter of Vietnamese refugees, Nhi Tran moved to Australia in 2017 after studying business and customer service.
She worked for eight years in operations and sales roles in both France and Vietnam.
Despite her experience, finding work here became challenging and her university qualifications were not recognised.
Ms Tran, now 36, worked for two years in hospitality for less than the minimum wage, shattering her confidence.
"Especially when in your home country you already have manager work experience and you move to a new country trying to give you a different perspective and more opportunities," she said.
"I don't complain about it because I understand if you face [a] language barrier, it's very hard for employers, but it deeply affects your confidence."
According to Mr van Kooy, a surprising outcome from the AIFS report was the impact of social connection.
"We found that participants who had friends from a mix of ethnic backgrounds — diverse friendship groups — were more likely to be employed than those who only had friends from their own ethnic background, or no friends," he said.
The report recommended more coordinated recognition of skills and qualifications gained overseas, as well as inclusive recruitment practices and language support.
Mr Matti, whose skills have become better utilised in his current job as an infrastructure project manager with Australia Post, said simplifying the path for refugees could make things easier.
"Some of the skills and the experience locally is so meaningful and so important, but people with overseas qualifications also have experience," he said.
"A bridge is a bridge … there are basic principles everywhere you go.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
36 minutes ago
- ABC News
The businesses abandoning America over US tariffs
Australian businesses are halting exports to the US, as the Trump administration closes a tax loophole for low-cost goods entering America on August 29.
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
ASX steadies as banks lead recovery after CSL shock
Australia's sharemarket edged higher on Wednesday, bouncing back slightly after a two-day slump driven by CSL's record one-day fall. The S&P/ASX 200 rose 21.8 points, or 0.25 per cent, to 8,918, while the broader All Ordinaries added 3.6 points to 9,177.4. The Australian dollar slipped slightly to 64.7 US cents. Over the past five days, the index has gained 1.03 per cent and sits just 0.5 per cent below its 52-week high. Banks continued to support the market, with all four major lenders climbing. Commonwealth Bank added 0.79 per cent to $172.40, Westpac jumped 2.47 per cent to $38.23, NAB surged 3.68 per cent to $42.03, and ANZ rose 1.95 per cent to $33.41. IG analyst Tony Sycamore said the ASX 200 had performed 'really well'. 'The ASX 200 is insulated because we don't have the concentration of tech stocks that hit the US markets,' Mr Sycamore said. 'One of the reasons why we're seen as a more defensive market is because we've got the banks, and the banks have done well again today.' Seven of the 11 sectors higher. After Tuesday's shock fall of 16.89 per cent in CSL shares, the healthcare giant continued to weigh on the sector, which slipped 1.28 per cent. Other sectors on the decline included information technology (-2.32 per cent), materials (-1.16 per cent), and energy (-1.23 per cent), while consumer discretionary (+1.93 per cent), real estate (+1.80 per cent), and financials (+1.43 per cent) led the winners. 'Elsewhere, we saw some fall in CSL extent today, so there is certainly an exodus which continues from that particular stock, and it does feel like the market's the wrong way around with regards to CSL,' Mr Sycamore said. 'It was certainly a shock yesterday, and in terms of early season bombshells, probably the biggest one I can recall in recent memory.' Top performers on Wednesday included HMC Capital, up 17.74 per cent to $3.85, and Centuria Capital Group, which gained 11.63 per cent to $2.40. Synlait Milk (+8.11 per cent), Service Stream (+7.92 per cent), and Strickland Metals (+7.69 per cent) also posted strong gains. However, some high-profile falls highlighted ongoing volatility. James Hardie plunged 27.83 per cent to $32, while Arafura Rare Earths (-13.64 per cent), Elsight (-13.53 per cent), and Electro Optic Systems (-13.09 per cent) were among the biggest decliners. Mr Sycamore said after recent market jitters and high-profile earnings shocks, investors were seeking safer options. 'The lure of the banks is proving to be appealing,' Mr Sycamore said. 'Given recent uncertainty, investors are moving towards stocks with cheaper valuations. For example, CBA trading at $172 now compared to $192 a couple of months ago makes it look more attractive. 'We're moving into a period where people are going to be more selective and favour cheaper, more defensively valued stocks.' Miners gave back some of Tuesday's gains. BHP, which rallied 1.57 per cent on Monday, retreated slightly in Wednesday's session, reflecting a broader pullback in the sector. 'Big mining stocks had a bad day today, but their valuations aren't expensive by any stretch of the imagination,' Mr Sycamore said. 'We're seeing more stock selection based on value rather than just momentum, which has been driving markets for a while.'
SBS Australia
2 hours ago
- SBS Australia
The employee skills 'mismatch' leaving Australia $9 billion poorer each year
More than half a million permanent migrants in Australia are working below their skill level, despite concerns that widespread workforce shortages are impeding productivity. It's a topic of discussion this week, as 30 leaders from business, unions and civil society convene in Canberra to debate the country's economic future. Former Treasury secretary Martin Parkinson, who presented on skills at the roundtable this week, said there was agreement on the need for skilled workers, but how to achieve that remains a challenge. "It's about how we break down the barriers. Everybody at the roundtable today could see the benefits of building better systems for workers and what skilled immigration can bring to the table. The challenge is how to operationalise it," he said. Skilled migrant 'mismatch' In its submission to the roundtable, the Activate Australia's Skills campaign has suggested that a national governance system for all overseas skills and qualifications recognition is needed. Activate Australia's Skills is an alliance campaign of businesses, unions, social services and community groups pushing a skills and qualifications recognition policy. 620,000 permanent migrants are currently working below their skill level in Australia, according to government figures. Dane Moores is the head of strategic relations at Settlement Services International and is also the campaign manager for Activate Australia's Skills. He told SBS News migrants face a range of obstacles to finding employment. "It's what we call the migrant skills mismatch," he said. "Some of the barriers include a lack of local work experience, limited professional networks and social capital in some cases, language barriers, and in many cases, discrimination in the labour market." LISTEN TO Moores said the group has a number of recommendations to improve the skills recognition process. "We're calling on the government to provide financial support for those migrants who can't afford to go through the system. And secondly, to reduce information barriers by creating an online portal with all the information migrants need to get their skills and qualifications recognised." The organisation's research has found Australia's economy could grow by $9 billion every year or $25 million a day if the skills of migrants were put to better use. There are currently 39 skilled migration assessing authorities approved to undertake assessments for 650 occupations, according to the Australian Council of Trade Unions (ACTU). "Current skill assessment processes are expensive, complex, lack transparency, and prevent migrant workers from having equal employment opportunities," the ACTU told SBS News in a statement. "Thousands of people are being needlessly locked out from filling skills shortages due to barriers unrelated to their skills: excessive fees, bureaucratic red tape, and slow and confusing processes throughout the skills recognition system." Critical sector hampered by 'red tape' Sectors that rely on engineers to support construction and infrastructure have been a focus of the roundtable. Engineers Australia, which does skills recognition for overseas-born engineers, estimates that two-thirds of Australian-born engineers are working directly in engineering roles, compared with half of overseas-born engineers working in engineering roles. The organisation says its recent research found some 47 per cent of migrant engineers actively seeking a job in the sector are unemployed. "Engineers Australia welcomes efforts to make skills recognition clearer and more consistent, but it has to be profession-specific. Alongside recognising overseas qualifications, the real challenge is getting national harmony and consistency across states and territories," Engineers Australia CEO Romilly Madew told SBS News. Madew added that the government needs to address "the red tape" around licensing and registration between different states, to better realise the "full benefits" of the engineering workforce. A spokesperson for the Skills and Training Minister, Andrew Giles, told SBS News the government is "already doing critical work". "Programs like Free TAFE have provided the opportunity for hundreds of thousands of people to upskill in areas where we need more workers – including in housing construction, nursing and aged care. "On top of that, our Government's Advanced Entry Trades Training program will see the skills of 6,000 people recognised."
