Ron DeSantis Says Drivers Have Right to Hit Protesters—Is He Right?
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has been accused of "overstating the protections that drivers have" if they hit individuals who surround their vehicles during a demonstration.
Tray Gober, the managing director of the law firm Lee, Gober & Reyna, told Newsweek that the governor appeared to "conflate civil protections with criminal immunity" and risked "sending a dangerous message."
Why It Matters
Since June 6, Los Angeles has been rocked by a series of protests against Immigration and Custom Enforcement raids. Some of the demonstrations have turned violent, with individuals burning vehicles and throwing rocks at the police. In response, President Donald Trump ordered the deployment of 4,000 National Guard soldiers and 700 Marines against the wishes of California Governor Gavin Newsom. Anti-ICE protests have since spread to other cities, and Texas Governor Greg Abbott has also deployed National Guard troops in his state.
On Saturday, the Trump administration is holding a military parade in Washington, D.C., to commemorate the 250th anniversary of the U.S. Army. The "No Kings" movement has organized more than 1,500 demonstrations across the country to take place on the day, which is also Trump's 79th birthday. A large number of protests nationwide could mean increased interactions between drivers and people demonstrating on roads.
What To Know
During an appearance on The Rubin Report on Wednesday, DeSantis said drivers could legally hit demonstrators with their vehicles if fleeing for their safety.
"We also have a policy that if you're driving on one of those streets and a mob comes and surrounds your vehicle and threatens you, you have a right to flee for your safety," DeSantis said. "And so if you drive off and you hit one of these people, that's their fault for impinging on you."
Gober, who has worked as a criminal defense attorney and covered civil cases involving vehicle collisions, said the governor's comments were based on a misunderstanding of the law.
"Governor DeSantis' comments appear to conflate civil protections with criminal immunity, which are distinct in both intent and effect," Gober said. "Florida's HB 1 passed in 2021 provides an affirmative defense in civil lawsuits for injuries caused to someone 'acting in furtherance of a riot.' But that is not the same as granting drivers a carte blanche to hit protesters without consequence."
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis speaking during a news conference at an ICE Enforcement and Removal Operation office in Miramar, Florida, on May 1.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis speaking during a news conference at an ICE Enforcement and Removal Operation office in Miramar, Florida, on May 1.
Joe Raedle/GETTY
In 2021, DeSantis signed House Bill 1, nicknamed the "anti-riot" bill, into law. The legislation grants drivers some civil protection if they hit protesters with their vehicles while feeling threatened but not criminal immunity.
"In a civil context, the Florida statute (HB1) provides that if a person is injured while participating in a riot, and they then sue for damages, the defendant can raise the plaintiff's riot participation as an affirmative defense," Gober said, adding: "In a criminal context, HB 1 does not create blanket immunity for drivers who injure protesters. Florida criminal law still requires that use of force is justified only when it meets the legal standard for self-defense."
"So while DeSantis's rhetoric suggests a driver can simply 'drive off' and harm someone without legal risk, that's not what the law actually says," he continued.
Gober added, "DeSantis is overstating the protections drivers have. The law he's citing offers limited civil protection in very specific cases. It does not give blanket criminal immunity for injuring or killing protesters. It also risks sending a dangerous message that civil unrest justifies indiscriminate harm."
What People Are Saying
Bryan Griffin, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis' communications director, told Newsweek: "It's simple: don't protest in Florida by blocking traffic or threatening people in their cars, and you won't have a problem. Even you Newsweek activists and your Experts™ should be able to keep that straight."
Lorella Praeli, a co-president of Community Change Action, which is backing Saturday's protest, previously told Newsweek: "Look around—Trump and his allies are deploying the tools of authoritarianism: silencing dissent, targeting immigrants, punishing oversight, and even staging military displays for personal glorification. These aren't isolated incidents; they're part of a broader effort to delegitimize democratic norms.
"This isn't normal. It's manufactured chaos, designed to instill fear and consolidate power. When a sitting U.S. Senator is handcuffed for asking a question, it should be a five-alarm fire for anyone who believes in democracy. We have to name this moment for what it is—and organize with the clarity and courage it demands."
What Happens Next
Demonstrations are expected across the U.S. on Saturday. Organizers of the No Kings protests have said: "All No Kings events adhere to a shared commitment to nonviolent protest and community safety. Organizers are trained in de-escalation and are working closely with local partners to ensure peaceful and powerful actions nationwide."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
5 minutes ago
- Boston Globe
Was Trump right to send National Guard to Washington, D.C.?
David Bumcrot Belmont Heather Mac Donald cites several shooting incidents in Washington, D.C., including two heinous crimes involving the shooting deaths of innocent young children. Nowhere does she mention how Republicans block every effort at enacting gun-control legislation. Also left out is the number of convicted felons that President Trump has pardoned. Let's stop pretending this isn't just Trump's attempt to initiate martial law. Advertisement Robyn King Get The Gavel A weekly SCOTUS explainer newsletter by columnist Kimberly Atkins Stohr. Enter Email Sign Up Ipswich In Trump's political theater, Washington becomes a prop President Trump's National Guard deployment to Washington, D.C. is less about public safety and more about political theater. D.C.'s violent crime rates have fallen sharply since 2023. Cherry-picking a few brutal crimes to paint the city as in crisis ignores the data and serves a narrative, not the truth. If homicide rates alone justified military involvement, other US cities — some worse off than D.C. — would already be occupied by federal troops. The National Guard's limited 'command presence' won't fix longstanding issues of gun violence, juvenile crime, or car theft. Lasting reductions come from targeted policing, intelligence-driven enforcement, and community partnerships — not a 30-day show of force. Advertisement Worse, the move undermines D.C.'s elected leadership and sets a dangerous precedent for federal overreach. Washington's majority-minority residents have endured decades of over-policing. Imposing military oversight without an emergency inflames mistrust, chills cooperation with police, and treats citizens like subjects. Real safety is built, not staged. This deployment is a political stunt masquerading as crime control — and Washington deserves better than to be used as a prop in someone else's campaign. Paul Swindlehurst Londonderry, N.H. For this administration, an easy distraction It seems our president has found the secret for making the Jeffrey Epstein controversy go away: Invade Washington, D.C. It's amazing how short the media's attention span is. They are so easily distracted by the next outrageous thing President Trump and his representatives do or say. There is no follow-up, no accountability — essentially just narration and public relations. Former Trump adviser Steve Bannon was so right: 'Flood the zone,' and you can do anything. Patricia Fabbri Lynnfield
CNN
36 minutes ago
- CNN
Execution date set for Florida man who killed estranged wife's sister and parents, set fire to house
A Florida man who fatally stabbed his estranged wife's sister and parents and then set fire to their house is scheduled for execution in Florida under a death warrant signed by Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis. David Pittman, 63, is set to die Sept. 17 in the record-extending 12th execution scheduled for this year. DeSantis signed the warrant Friday, as two other men, Kayle Bates and Curtis Windom, await execution later this month. The highest previous annual total of recent Florida executions is eight in 2014, since the death penalty was restored in 1976 by the US Supreme Court. Florida has already executed nine people this year, more than any other state, while Texas and South Carolina are tied for second place with four each. A total of 28 people have been executed so far this year in the US, exceeding the 25 executions carried out last year. It ties 2015, when 28 people were also put to death. Pittman was convicted and sentenced to death in 1991 on three counts of first-degree murder, according to court records. Jurors also found him guilty of arson and grand theft. Pittman and his wife, Marie, were going through a divorce in May 1990, when Pittman went to the Polk County home of her parents, Clarence and Barbara Knowles, officials said. Pittman fatally stabbed the couple, as well as their younger daughter, Bonnie. He then set fire to the house and stole Bonnie Knowles' car, which he also set on fire, investigators said. A witnessed identified Pittman as the person running away from the burning car. A jailhouse informant also testified that Pittman had admitted to the killings. The Florida Supreme Court is already scheduled to hear an appeal. An appeal will also likely be filed with the US Supreme Court.
Yahoo
42 minutes ago
- Yahoo
I visited Birmingham's Soho Road to hear the real story beyond the drugs, drunks and sex work
Three men slump in a bus shelter, rambling and swigging from beer cans. Across the street, a stumbling group shout in disagreement, drinks in one hand, cigarettes in another. It's a sight more fitting of a Saturday night on Broad Street. Sadly, this is the reality at 9am on a Tuesday morning in one of Birmingham's busiest high streets. Here on Soho Road, Handsworth, the spiralling problem of alcohol and drug abuse is only getting worse. In a concerning video, up to six people were seen passed out in the street amid a 'bad batch of black mamba'. Read more: Police warning over specific family car targeted by criminals as 'flavour of the month' Though an arterial route through the city, it's one that's now synonymous with prostitution, anti-social behaviour and lately, the "huge boom" of exempt housing. Locals have become scared to shop there, and some now even want to move from the area they've called home for decades. But behind the scenes are those who are here to stay, a community that's fighting to survive in an increasingly challenging climate. We took a walk along the busy mile-long strip with resident and community activist, Shuranjeet Singh, to hear the real story of Soho Road as locals battle for a brighter future. With every new betting shop, or new exempt housing that's approved for the area, there's another that was rejected thanks to those residents who fought back, he points out. READ MORE: In pictures: The real story of Soho Road as community fight to survive amid challenges As we walk along, the main issue of drink and drugs is impossible to miss. Most bus shelters we pass are occupied with intoxicated men huddled under cover. Those awake enough to move make their presence known by shouting aggressively at one another. "This is the kind of mild peril we're seeing intensify," Mr Singh explains as we begin the walking tour. "Bus stops that should be shelters are now used by people who are incredibly intoxicated. "That in itself, particularly for elderly women, is enough to not feel as safe stood in close proximity. "I speak to people who want to come spend time on their high street, but don't feel safe making their way here or while they're there. But so many communities are still fighting which gives me a lot of hope and energy. So much work goes on behind the scenes to improve the area, he says, but unfortunately a recent project adding artwork to each bus shelters has only helped to hide the anti-social behaviour going on inside them. "I helped out and designed all of them, then you find out what it means in reality, police then can't see what's going on behind them," he says. An area steeped in history, Handsworth is full of beautiful, five or six bed Victorian homes. However, as more residents move out, more of these are fast becoming HMOs and exempt accommodations. "With a dwindling perception of the area, people want to move out but don't want to sell their properties, and families don't want to move in, so it's a bit of a spiral," he adds. Despite the problems, Mr Singh stresses that new businesses are choosing to open up here in an area boasting one of the city's most diverse food scenes. Via Delhi, Bocadias and Arya are just a handful of the new places to pop up in the street. In any other area, he argues empty shops would stay derelict, bringing down the appearance. Here however, each time a shop closes up to 20 enquiries will flood in to occupy the space. Shops that have been open since the late 70s are still going too. As we talk about up and coming businesses, a man with a beer can behind us shouts in the street about prison fights - such is the bizzare complexity of Soho Road. "When people talk about opening up opportunities, this has been that space for the last 70 years and it still is. People are so innovative, industrious," he continues. "The fascinating paradox of Soho Road is that there are challenges, but it's still seen as a place of opportunity. "Handsworth is just a historically very unique place, it's somewhere many have come to make their home when they've just moved to the country - with that came a lot of community work and organising. "In the 70s it wasn't a particularly transient place, that's changed a lot in 15 years. It was somewhere people saw their future, but sadly now I don't think a lot see their future here." Mr Singh, born and bred in Handsworth, chose to return to the area after University while his friends moved out to work in London. "I wanted to build where my roots are. My family are all within a ten minute walk of this point," he explains. "It's one of the most thriving places in the city, you only have to look down and see. We have eight places of worship, but then there's also six or seven bookies and that doesn't look towards an optimistic future, that doesn't make us feel excited, it's a bit of a negative stamp on the local map. "You have people who really like their area, but they're almost going through boxing rounds, one they've just been battered, another they've won." The building housing Monga's, a bridal shop, was due to become yet another betting shop. But thanks to the community, it was rejected and it instead now houses the bespoke store. "It's a really good example of what could have been vs. what is," he comments. Residents are also fighting to reclaim the derelict Bill House as new social housing for the elderly and families. However, the large building, which marks the "gateway to Soho Road", was purchased by an American company who are claimed to be "land-banking" and said to want £3.5million for it. "No developer wants to take it on because they know they won't get the money back," he says as we walk by. "That's been ongoing for two years. We're still pushing for something to happen with the building." Locals, alongside police, are also battling another application for an aparthotel near to primary schools and a nursery. There are already problems with drunks being abusive towards parents picking up their kids, he says. "There are businesses and community organisations offering opportunities, but then in the middle of that, we have issues with waste, housing related issues, and crime and anti-social behaviour," he added. "Everywhere has their challenges, but there are so many amazing things that are being done. There's this sense of warmth here. "There are things that happen behind the scenes, but really communities are doing so much to bring the place up. There's so much civic pride here, but there's a limit, and I worry we'll reach that. To rebuild civic pride is very difficult."
