logo
Cultural backlash hits Auckland kava business Vibes Kava

Cultural backlash hits Auckland kava business Vibes Kava

NZ Herald12-05-2025

Both say they discovered kava during the Covid-19 pandemic and credit it with helping them shift away from alcohol.
'We wanted to create something that brings people together in a healthier way,' the pair said.
However, their vision has been met with growing criticism, with people saying the business lacks cultural depth, misrepresents tradition, and risks commodifying a sacred practice.
Context and different perspectives
Tensions escalated after Vibes Kava posted a promotional video on Instagram, describing their offering as 'a modern take on a 3000-year-old tradition' and 'a lifestyle shift, one shell at a time'.
On their website, Hillen is referred to as a 'kava evangelist,' while videos feature Byram hosting casual kava circles and promoting fortnightly 'kava socials.'
The kava they sell is bottled, with tag names referencing the effects of each different kava bottle - for example, 'buzzy kava' and 'chill kava'.
Their promotional content was later reposted on TikTok by a prominent Pacific influencer, prompting an influx of online input about the legitimacy of their business and the diversity of their kava circles.
The reposted video has since received over 95,000 views, 1600 shares, and 11,000 interactions.
In the TikTok caption, the influencer questioned the ethical foundations of the business.
'I would like to know what type of ethics was put into the creation of this...who was consulted, and said it was okay to make a brand out of a tradition?'
Speaking to RNZ Pacific anonymously, the influencer criticised the brand's aesthetic and messaging, describing it as exploitative.
'Their website and Instagram portray trendy, wellness-style branding rather than a proud celebration of authentic Pacific customs or values,' they said.
'I feel like co-owner Charles appears to use his Samoan heritage as a buffer against the backlash he's received.
'Not to discredit his identity in any way; he is Samoan, and seems like a proud Samoan too.
'However, that should be reflected consistently in their branding. What's currently shown on their website and Instagram is a mix of Fijian kava practice served in a Samoan tanoa. That to me is confusing and dilutes cultural authenticity.'
Fijian academic Dr Apo Aporosa said much of the misunderstanding stems from a narrow perception of kava as simply being a beverage.
'Most people who think they are using kava are not,' Aporosa said.
'What they're consuming may contain piper methysticum, but it's detached from the cultural framework that defines what kava actually is.'
Aporosa said it is important to recognise kava as both a substance and a practice - one that involves ceremony, structure, and values.
'It is used to nurture vā, the relational space between people, and is traditionally accompanied by specific customs: woven mats, the tanoa bowl, coconut shell cups (bilo or ipu), and a shared sense of respect and order.'
He said that the commodification of kava, through flavoured drink extracts and Western 'wellness' branding, is concerning, and that it distorts the plant's original purpose.
'When people repackage kava without understanding or respecting the culture it comes from, it becomes cultural appropriation,' he said.
He added that it is not about restricting access to kava - it is about protecting its cultural integrity and honouring the knowledge Pacific communities have preserved for upwards of 2000 years.
'We can't just gatekeep; we need to guide'
Dr Edmond Fehoko is a renowned Tongan academic and senior lecturer at Otago University who garnered international attention for his research on the experiences and perceptions of New Zealand-born Tongan men who participate in faikava.
He said these situations are layered.
'I see the cultural appreciation side of things, and I see the cultural appropriation side of things,' Fehoko said.
'It is one of the few practices we hold dearly to our heart, and that is somewhat indigenous to our Pacific people - it can't be found anywhere else.
'Hence, it holds a sacred place in our society. But, we as a peoples, have actually not done a good enough job to raise awareness of the practice to other societies, and now it's a race issue, that only Pacific people have the rights to this - and I don't think that is the case anymore.'
He explained that it is part of a broader dynamic around kava's globalisation - and that for many people, both Pacific and non-Pacific, kava is an 'interesting and exciting space, where all types of people, and all genders, come in and feel safe.'
'Yes, that is moving away from the cultural, customary way of things. But, we need to find new ways, and create new opportunities, to further disseminate our knowledge.
'Our kava practice is not the same today as it was 10, 20 years ago. Kava practices have evolved significantly across generations.
'There are over 200 kava bars in the US... kava is one of the few traditions that is uniquely Pacific. But our understanding of it has to evolve too. We can't just gatekeep; we need to guide,' he said.
He added that the issue of kava being commercialised by non-Pacific people cannot necessarily be criticised.
'It's two-fold, and quite contradictory,' he said, adding that the criticism against these ventures often overlooks the parallel ways in which Pacific communities are also reshaping and profiting from the tradition.
'We argue that non-Pacific people are profiting off our culture, but the truth is, many of us are too,' he said.
'A minority have extensive knowledge of kava... and if others want to appreciate our culture, let them take it further with us, instead of the backlash.
'If these lads are enjoying a good time and have the same vibe...the only difference is the colour of their skin, and the language they are using, which has become the norm in our kava practices as well.
'But here, we have an opportunity to educate people on the importance of our practice. Let's raise awareness. Kava is a practice we can use as a vehicle, or medium, to navigate these spaces.'
'Getting judged for the colour of my skin'
'I completely understand the points that have been brought up,' Byram said in response to the criticism.
Tearing up, he said that was one of the most difficult things to swallow was backlash fixated on his cultural identity.
'I felt like I was getting judged for the colour of my skin, and for not understanding who I was or what I was trying to accomplish. If my skin was a bit darker, I might have been given some more grace.
'I was raised in a Samoan household. My grandfather is Samoan...my mum is Samoan. It's tough to be this person and then get hurt online, without having a conversation with me. Nobody took the time to ask those questions,' he said.
The pair also pushed back on claims they are focused on profit.
Advertisement Advertise with NZME.
'We went there to learn, to dive into the culture. We went to a lot of kava bars, interviewed farmers, just to understand the origin of kava, how it works within a community, and then how best to engage with, and showcase it,' Byram said.
'People have criticised that we are profiting - we're making no money at this point. All the money we make from this kava has gone back to the farmers in Vanuatu.'
Hillen thinks those criticising them represent a minority.
'We have a lot of Pasifika customers that come here [and] they support us.
'They are ecstatic their culture is being promoted this way, and love what we are doing. The negative response from a minority part of the population was surprising to us.'
Critics had argued that the business showcased confusing blends of different cultural approaches.
Byram and Hillen said that it is up to other people to investigate and learn about the cultures, and that they are simply trying to acknowledge all of them.
Byram, however, added that the critics brought up some good points - and that this will be a catalyst for change within their business.
'Yesterday, we joined the Pacific Business Hub. We are [taking] steps to integrate more about the culture, community, and what we are trying to accomplish here.'
They also addressed their initial silence and comment moderation.
'I think the cycle was so self-perpetuating, so I was like...I need to make sure I respond with candour, concern, and active communication.
'So I deleted comments and put a pause on things, so we could have some space before the comments get out of hand.
'At the end of the day...this is about my connection with my culture and people more than anything, and I'm excited to grow from it. I'm learning, and I'm utilising this as a growth point. We're just doing our best,' Byram said.
Hillen added, 'You have to understand, this business is super new, so we're still figuring out how best to do things, how to market and grow along with not only the community.
'What we really want to represent as people who care about, and believe in this.'
Byram said they want to acknowledge as many peoples as possible.
'We don't want to create ceremony or steal anything from the culture. We really just want to celebrate it, and so again, we acknowledge the concern,' he added.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Airport provides site for new HQ
Airport provides site for new HQ

Otago Daily Times

time10 hours ago

  • Otago Daily Times

Airport provides site for new HQ

Wakatipu Search and Rescue (LandSAR) has unveiled plans for a new headquarters at Queenstown Airport. Build committee member Russell Tilsley says the airport company has agreed to provide LandSAR with a site, next to the Heliworks and Alpine Helicopters bases, on the northern side of the runway. Now based in a corner of a Heliworks hangar, the organisation's 80-odd volunteers need a dedicated building where they can run operations, train and store equipment, Mr Tilsley says. "We've never had our own base, and with the increase in search and rescue that's happening around the region — summer and winter — we need one." With suitable land in and around the airport being rapidly snapped up, it's a case of "striking while the iron's hot". Architect Mary Jowett has completed a design for a two-level, 400sq m building with incident management and comms rooms, a training space, a kitchen/lounge area, two bunk rooms for use during multi-day operations and storage space. The committee is about to get the build priced, but Mr Tilsley expects it will cost somewhere between $2 million and $3m. A fundraising campaign will be launched in the next few months. He hopes construction can start within 18 months, and the building be up and running a year after that. Formerly based in Queenstown police station, LandSAR had to move out in 2020 during Covid, and squeezed into the Alpine Cliff Rescue team's base in a converted garage in Lucas Pl, he says. "There was a group of nearly 80 people operating out of a tin shed." Heliworks owner Nick Nicholson came to the rescue in 2021, providing the organisation with its current base in one of the company's hangers. However, it's always been a temporary measure, Mr Tilsley says. The organisation runs rescue operations — which can last a week — out of Heliworks' boardroom, and its volunteers sleep in the company's office space. It has benefited from the "incredible" generosity and support of Nicholson, Jowett and the airport company just to get this far, and will be relying on the community to get the build over the line, he says. LandSAR volunteers do a huge amount for the community, applying high-level expertise and training to save lives. "These people are vitally important, and this is our opportunity to future-proof the organisation for the next 20 to 30 years."

‘Act Responsibly For Humankind' – Palau President On Deep Sea Mining Order
‘Act Responsibly For Humankind' – Palau President On Deep Sea Mining Order

Scoop

time18 hours ago

  • Scoop

‘Act Responsibly For Humankind' – Palau President On Deep Sea Mining Order

Palau's president says the US order to fast-track deep sea mining is not a good idea., RNZ Pacific Journalist Palau's president says the US order to fast-track deep sea mining is not a good idea. Deep sea mining frontrunner The Metals Company (TMC) has since confirmed it will not apply for a mining license through the International Seabed Authority (ISA), instead opting to apply through US regulations. Surangel Whipps Jr. said the high seas belongs to the entire world so everyone must exercise caution. 'We should be responsible, and what we've asked for is a moratorium, or a temporary pause ….until you have the right information to make the most important informed decision,' Whipps told RNZ Pacific. Whipps said it's important for those with concerns to have an opportunity to speak to US President Donald Trump. 'Because it's about partnership. And I think a lot of times it's the lack of information and lack of sharing information. 'It's our job now as the Pacific to stand up and say, this direction could be detrimental to all of us that depend on the Pacific ocean and the ocean and we ask that you act responsibly for humankind and for the Pacific.' Trump's executive order states: 'It is the policy of the US to advance United States leadership in seabed mineral development.' The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) was directed to, within 60 days, 'expedite the process for reviewing and issuing seabed mineral exploration licenses and commercial recovery permits in areas beyond national jurisdiction under the Deep Seabed Hard Mineral Resources Act'. It directs the US science and environmental agency to expedite permits for companies to mine the ocean floor in the US and international waters. The Metals Company has praised the US deepsea mining licencing pathway. In a press release, its chief executive Gerard Barron made direct reference to Trump's order, titled 'Unleashing America's Offshore Critical Minerals and Resources'. He said he was heartened by its call 'for a joint assessment of a seabed benefit-sharing mechanism' and was certain that 'big ocean states' like Nauru would continue to play a leading role in the deep sea mining industry. There are divergent views on deep sea exploration and mining in the Pacific, with many nations, civil society groups, and even some governments advocating for a moratorium or outright ban. However, Tonga, Nauru, Kiribati and the Cook Islands have exploration contracts with mining representatives. Vanuatu's Climate Minister Ralph Regenvanu told RNZ Pacific in 2023 that Vanuatu's position is for no deep sea mining at any point. 'We have a lot to think about in the Pacific. We are the region that is spearheading for seabed minerals,' he said. The Cook Islands has sought China's expertise in seabed mining through 'high-level' discussions on Prime Minister Mark Brown's February 2025 trip to China. Whipps said 'you have to give [The Metals Company] credit' that they have been able to get in there and convince Donald Trump that this is a good direction to go. But as the president of a nation with close ties to the US and Taiwan, and the host of the PIF Ocean's Commissioner, he has concerns. 'We don't know the impacts to the rest of what we have in the Pacific – which is for us in the Pacific, it's tuna [which] is our biggest resource,' Whipps said. 'How is that going to impact the food chain and all of that? 'Because we're talking about bringing, first of all, impacting the largest carbon sink that we have, which is the oceans, right? So we say our islands are sinking, but now we want to go and do something that helps our islands sink. 'That's not a good idea.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store