CCTV shows Tom Niland entering shop two hours before men allegedly broke into his home
Garda Niall McDonald told the court he created a montage from hours of footage downloaded from various CCTV systems in Sligo and Mayo following the assault on Mr Niland on January 18th, 2022.
Garda McDonald described the movements of a white van travelling around Dromore West and Ballina that morning and afternoon. He said the van appeared to be a Vauxhall Vivaro and he noted distinctive characteristics, including a yellow number plate, writing on the side and a green stain on the roof.
Just after 1.30pm, a van with those markings pulled into Casey's garage in Ballina. The garda identified the driver as Francis Harman (58), of Nephin Court, Killala Road, Ballina, Co Mayo, and the passenger as John Clarke (37), of Carrowkelly, Ballina.
READ MORE
Tony McGillicuddy, prosecuting, previously told the jury that the prosecution intends to prove that Mr Harman, Mr Clarke and the man on trial, John Irving (31), of Shanwar, Foxford, Co Mayo, assaulted Mr Niland later that evening, leaving him with fatal injuries. It is further alleged that they stole Mr Niland's wallet.
At Casey's, Garda McDonald said Mr Clarke put fuel into the van before entering the shop. From footage inside the shop, said the garda, Mr Clarke can be seen attempting to buy cans of alcohol at the till, but then returning the cans to the off-licence section of the store. He said Mr Harman entered the shop and engaged with staff and the manager before driving off.
At 4.35pm, said Garda McDonald, Mr Niland arrived at Feeney's Centra in Dromore West, about 7.5km from his home.
Between 6pm and 7pm, the prosecution alleges, Mr Irving, Mr Harman and Mr Clarke broke through Mr Niland's door, assaulted him and left.
Garda McDonald said that at 6.01pm a van similar to the one driven earlier by Mr Harman, with Mr Clarke in the passenger seat, did a U-turn at an agri-store and travelled towards Mr Niland's house. The van was not seen again on cameras further along the same road, said the garda.
Mr Irving faces four charges in total. It is alleged that he unlawfully killed Mr Niland by assaulting him at the victim's home at Doonflynn, Skreen, Co Sligo, on January 18th, 2022.
Mr Niland was admitted to hospital after neighbours discovered him crossing the N59 covered in blood and with his eyes swollen shut. A doctor has told the jury that Mr Niland suffered bleeding to the brain, a fracture to the orb of his right eye and multiple fractures to the ribs on the right side.
Despite initially making progress in hospital, he deteriorated on January 26th and required a ventilator to breathe. He died on September 30th, 2023, aged 75.
Mr Irving is accused of entering Mr Niland's home as a trespasser and causing him serious harm. He is further alleged to have intentionally or recklessly caused serious harm to Mr Niland and to have falsely imprisoned him.
Mr Irving has pleaded not guilty to all four charges.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
24 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Farmer found dead on Cork road lost his home in fire recently
A 77-year-old retired farmer who lost all of his possessions following a house fire two months ago was found dead on a road in Bandon, Co Cork on Saturday morning. Gardaí in the town are investigating the circumstances surrounding the death of Gus Dempsey. They were alerted after the pensioner was found unresponsive in the Kildarra area of Bandon shortly after 6.30am yesterday. He was pronounced dead at the scene a short time later. The coroner has been notified and the deceased has since been removed to the mortuary at Cork University Hospital. A postmortem examination will determine the course of the garda investigation. However, foul play is not suspected. Mr Dempsey, who was a bachelor, lost his home in Horsehill, Ballinadee near Bandon on May 5th after a blaze broke out on-site. READ MORE He stayed with a neighbour following the fire and was also approved for emergency accommodation by Cork County Council. Mr Dempsey was featured in a recent edition of the Southern Star newspaper where he said that he farmed all his life and wanted to stay living in the countryside. He said he was fortunate not to have been home when the fire broke out at his rural property. 'Thank God I was out when the fire took hold but it has left me without anything. All the top floor went. There was smoke and water damage and everything downstairs was destroyed. It is gone. 'I was living there since early 1993 so it was a bit of a shock. I wouldn't wish it on anybody. I had little bits and pieces, mementos inside that were precious. They were lost which is an awful shame. I was very sad about it.' Independent Ireland TD Michael Collins recently raised his plight in the Dáil. While commenting on a housing motion he spoke of the absence of social housing in west Cork and said Mr Dempsey was keen to remain living in a rural community. Meanwhile, gardaí are appealing for witnesses to come forward over his death. In particular, they are seeking information regarding a male observed cycling on roads in the vicinity of Kildarra in the early hours of Saturday morning Additionally, any road users who may have camera footage (including dashcam) and were travelling in the area at the time asked to make it available to investigating officers. Anyone with any information is asked to contact Bandon Garda station on 023 885 2200, the Garda Confidential Line on 1800 666 111, or any Garda station.
Sunday World
3 hours ago
- Sunday World
‘Keep Carey out of Croker' – Victim urges GAA not to honour cancer conman at All Ireland
Victim of DJ's cancer scam calls on GAA bosses to ban hurling legend from ceremony at today's All-Ireland final A BUSINESSMAN defrauded out thousands of euro by cancer conman DJ Carey has warned the GAA it would be '100 per cent wrong' to honour the disgraced hurler in Croke Park today. Noel Tynan, owner of The Celt bar in Dublin and one of the 80,000 strong crowd who will be in attendance for today's All-Ireland Final, said: 'It would be, completely, 100 per cent wrong. 'I'll be in Croke Park and to watch him walk out there waving and nodding, you couldn't do it. 'They recommended on the day of the court that a psychiatric report on him be carried. 'Well, if he turns up on and waves to the crowd, there certainly should be a psychiatric report on him … that's how I would see it … he'd need some balls. 'You couldn't do it, in front of 80,000, not knowing if you're going to be booed off the pitched. 'And at the least he should be booed off the pitch.' DJ Carey admitted to deceiving 13 victims The GAA have failed to comment ahead of today's clash between Cork and Tipperary as to whether Carey will be included when tribute is paid to the Kilkenny team that lifted the Liam McCarthy 25 years ago. Calls to the GAA's director of communications were not returned. A traditional part of All-Ireland final day is the presentation of the winners from 25 years ago to the crowd in Croke Park. Carey was man of the match in his teams All-Ireland win over Offaly in 2000. It's unknown whether Carey will attend but even those not in attendance traditionally have their name read out, followed by a description of their contribution during the game. But Mr. Tynan, who is one of the 13 people Carey pleaded guilty to approaching for money after faking a cancer diagnosis, believes the conman's action, and in particular the targeting of a woman with cancer with his cancer lies, are 'unforgiveable and can't be overlooked.' Noel Tynan says GAA should not honour Carey 'If DJ Carey wasn't who was he was, superstar that he was and the whole lot, people would be saying throw the book at this criminal,' Mr. Tynan said. 'But he's no better or worse than any other criminal. 'He's a criminal … full stop and just because he won five All-Irelands and nine All Stars, it doesn't change things 'The bottom line is he purposely set out to defraud people. 'He met me in 2017 and that's when he told me about his cancer and then he didn't hit me for six years. 'He kept me in cold storage for six years before I got the call on a Monday morning. 'And some of the lies he told me that morning … 'He didn't have to even blink. 'The big word was the deception. 'He came across as such a humble fella but he was setting me up. 'It was a form of grooming. 'The All Star, the All-Ireland winner and then to use that and say you had cancer, it's just unforgiveable and there's no excuse for him. 'What angered me more than anything is when I found out about the woman who had cancer … he conned this woman and her husband … and that to me is unforgiveable. 'That was way worse than what happened to me. 'To con that poor woman that had cancer … that's inexcusable.' DJ Carey in his heyday before he disgraced his sporting legacy Carey pleaded guilty on July 3rd to dishonestly by deception, inducing victims to make monetary payment to him after he fraudulently claimed to have cancer and needed finances to obtain treatment. The offences happened at unknown locations within the State on dates between 2014 and 2022. The 13 victims named in the case were Mr. Tynan, Owen and Ann Conway, Mark and Sharon Kelly, Denis O'Brien, Aidan Mulligan, Tony Griffin and Christy Browne, Thomas Butler, Jeffrey Howes, Edwin Carey and Aonghus Leydon. He admitted to dishonestly persuading people to give him money by fraudulently claiming he was suffering from cancer and saying he needed funds for treatment. He was remanded on bail and is due to be sentenced on October 29th. DJ Carey faked having a cancer diagnosis Last week, Carey's ex-partner Sarah Newman spoke out about the scandal, insisting a major chance had been missed to stop Carey in his tracks as far back as 2012. She told the Sunday Independent newspaper she had contacted Blackrock Garda station to complain about Carey stealing from her, but that this was never followed up by gardai. She said: 'That trauma could have been stopped. These victims should not have become his prey if the gardaí had taken proper notice of me when I made formal complaints back in 2012 about DJ's conduct, lies and deception. 'They [my complaints] went untreated and there has been a black cloud over my judgment and reputation for many years, which I feel has now been lifted. victims of his crimes. 'There are people who will have met me and taken statements from me over that period of time. And it is they who have to look at themselves. They know the truth and they had the facts and they did nothing about it. 'Sometimes the legal system fails people. 'Whether it's domestic violence or a heinous criminal act, sometimes the judicial system gets it wrong. 'And that starts at grassroots with the gardaí when people make complaints. 'I think all over the world there are miscarriages of justice, there are people that get away with absolutely dreadful things — and I guess that's just the way things are.'
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Woman with black eye and newborn baby claims husband ‘kicked me and dragged me up and down'
A woman who had a black eye when she came to the emergency domestic violence court with her newborn baby claimed her husband 'kicked me and dragged me up and down'. Two other women who brought separate emergency applications under the Domestic Violence Act to the court at Dolphin House, Dublin, on Friday, also had babies with them. When Judge William Aylmer remarked on the first woman's black eye, she said her husband kicked her and dragged her up and down and was abusive many times during their long marriage. She had given him 'loads of chances' to change his behaviour but he had not. 'I don't feel safe. I've had enough.' READ MORE 'He reckons the drink and drugs make him do this.' He also blamed his behaviour on trying to deal with several suicides in his birth family, she added. Her mother had told her she needed to 'wake up' and stop tolerating her husband's abusive behaviour. 'I have to think of my own health and the kids. He needs to stop his pity party.' Judge Aylmer, telling the woman he agreed with her, granted her a protection order. In another case, a weeping woman with a baby got a protection order against the child's father. He 'gets very angry out of nowhere', 'never stops' and she has spent two months asking him to leave her apartment, she said. He had a 'meltdown' some days earlier when she took the baby from him before he had finished changing her nappy. The baby was hiccupping and she took her up because she feared the infant was about to vomit, she said. He 'gritted' his teeth, called her 'disgusting' and put his finger in her face. 'The look on his face, I got really scared.' She had permitted him to live with her for periods and he kicked her out on some occasions, she said. 'I slept in a hotel when I was nine months pregnant because he would not give me a break.' They had gone to therapy but he had not taken agreed actions to address his issues, she said. 'I have no problem him having a relationship with his daughter but our relationship is over. I can't be with him.' A woman with a baby and toddler got an interim barring order against her partner. She said he physically abused her previously and recently forced his way out of their home after pushing her away from the door when she confronted him about a suspected affair. He grabbed her arm, leaving her with bruises, and when she sought to stop him leaving, drove his car towards her, scaring her, she said. He has not returned home and had told a social worker he did not intend to, she said. A distraught mother who told the judge she is in fear and has 'lost everything' as a result of her adult daughter's drug addiction got a protection order against her. Her daughter, aged in her thirties, told her 'one side of my brain is telling me to stab and slice you and the other side is saying 'that's your Mammy''. Her daughter had been in a violent relationship and has children, all of whom are being cared for by other family members. 'God help any other family going through this.' She paid €3,000 to drug dealers for her daughter's debts and her daughter constantly pesters her for money, especially at night. 'She is getting worse and worse, the drugs have her destroyed, she'll be at it again tonight, I can't bear it.' After she spent almost €500 getting her daughter into a treatment unit, she was thrown out due to excess drugs in her system, she said. Another treatment appointment was fixed for later this year. 'It's destroying me, all we're doing is ringing places trying to get her help and we're getting nowhere.' When the judge said drugs are a 'demon' and many are in the same position, the woman agreed. 'I can see the little kids being destroyed, they are little 'gofers' for them.' She grew up in a large family, none got involved in drugs, she never drank and 'worked hard all my life to put food on the table'. Many people she grew up with were dead from drugs. In another case, the judge granted a fresh protection order to a woman who said gardaí found a meat cleaver, which she did not know was there, in a box in her home after her ex-partner had threatened to 'chop me up'. He had been diagnosed with a serious mental illness and accused her of having listening devices in the house, she said. She previously got a protection order against him but gardaí could not locate him to serve it. She last saw him in May and did not know where he was.
