EU-sponsored report says Russian economy is weaker than official data indicates
'The fiscal stimulus of the war economy has kept the economy afloat in the short term, but the reliance on opaque financing, distortionary resource allocation, and shrinking fiscal buffers makes it unsustainable in the long term. Contrary to Kremlin narratives, time is not on Russia's side,' it said.
The EU has imposed 16 packages of sanctions on Russia since the start of the war in Ukraine in February 2022, targeting Moscow's main sources of revenue – oil, gas and coal exports. Other Western powers, including the United States, Canada, Britain and Japan also imposed sanctions.
Keen to show Western sanctions are pointless, Russia says its gross domestic product grew 4.3pc in 2024 after 3.6pc expansion in 2023.
But Torbjorn Becker, who presented the SITE report to EU finance ministers, said Russian GDP numbers could not be trusted because Moscow was most likely strongly understating inflation which affected real GDP calculations.
'Russia claims inflation is 9-10pc. Why would they then have a policy rate of 21pc at the central bank? Which regular central bank would have a policy rate that's basically 11.50 percentage points higher than the inflation rate? If any of our central banks were doing something like that, they would be out of their job the next day,' Mr Becker told reporters.
'That's a very clear indication that inflation may not actually be the right number. If you understate inflation, you will then overstate real GDP numbers,' he said.
He also pointed to Russia's budget constraints caused by falling revenues from oil, gas and coal and rising military spending. Since the start of its invasion of Ukraine and despite its massive war effort, Russia has been reporting a budget deficit of 2pc of GDP every year.
'Fiscal numbers in Russia don't really correspond to what we think they are putting into the war effort,' Mr Becker said.
He said much of the financing of the war machine was going through the banking system. 'So if you add that to the fiscal numbers, their fiscal deficits would be ballpark twice as high as what they have shown in the official statistics,' he said. This, in turn, was building up financial risks in the banking system, Mr Becker said, because banks were reporting high credit growth.
ADVERTISEMENT
'These are all indicators that we usually look at when we want to predict the banking crisis,' he said.
European Economic Commissioner Valdis Dombrovskis said the European Commission agreed with the SITE report.
'Their analysis highlights the unreliability of Russian statistics, and how the Russian economy is not performing as well as its official statistics suggest,' Mr Dombrovskis told reporters after the EU ministers' meeting.
'The Commission broadly agrees with this analysis and the overall increasing fragility of the Russian economy. This underlines the importance of the international community's ongoing efforts to limit the Kremlin's capacity to continue its war of aggression against Ukraine,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Trump RULES OUT US troops patrolling Ukraine to police peace deal as he reveals role America would play when war is over
DONALD Trump today ruled out American troops patrolling Ukraine — but said he was looking at air cover for European boots on the ground. The US President publicly confirmed that Britain, France and Germany had committed manpower to police any deal with Russia but insisted his forces would play a back-seat role underwriting the peace. 7 Donald Trump has ruled out US troops patrolling Ukraine to police the peace deal with Russia Credit: The Mega Agency 7 Zelensky won concessions from Trump after turning up for a White House summit in a suit Credit: AFP 7 The White House did not deny claims Putin had suggested Moscow as a venue for face to face talks with Zelensky Credit: Reuters His comments came as the White House confirmed Mr Trump's team was negotiating a one-on-one showdown between Volodymyr Zelensky and Vladimir Putin. But dashing Ukraine ambitions, Mr Trump warned the country 'is not going to be a part of Nato'. He said instead: 'We've got the European nations, and they'll front-load it. When it comes to security, the Europeans are willing to put people on the ground. 'We're willing to help them with things — especially, probably, talk about by air, because there's nobody who has the kind of stuff we have. I don't think it's going to be a problem.' READ MORE ON UKRAINE FLAMINGO FIRE Ukraine fires 'Flamingo' missile that can strike Moscow for the first time The White House released a remarkable series of behind the scenes photographs of world leaders, including PM Sir Keir Starmer, negotiating plans for the so-called Coalition of the Willing of 30 nations signed up to protect Ukraine. Mr Trump was snapped showing them a collection of MAGA caps, while, hours after the meeting a new portrait of the President, unsmiling and striding between lines of US flags was also unveiled. The candid snaps of Monday's summit also showed leaders studying a map of Ukraine in the Oval Office as they discussed Ukraine ceding territory to bring about an end to the war with Russia. It was claimed the leaders used the talks to convince Mr Trump to take a stand against Putin demands for Kyiv to turn over all of its Donbas region — comparing it to the US losing his beloved Florida. And it was reported by the Wall Street Journal that they talked the President into supporting Ukraine keeping heavily fortified parts of the eastern region by describing it as a 'bastion against the Huns'. Speaking about the chances of a deal, Mr Trump said: 'I think Putin is tired of it. I think they're all tired of it. Trump caught on hot mic during Zelensky summit revealing whether he thinks peace in Ukraine can happen 'But you never know. We're going to find out about President Putin in the next couple of weeks. 'It's possible he does not want to make a deal.' He added: 'I hope that President Putin will be good, and if he is not, it is going to be a rough situation and I hope President Zelensky is going to show flexibility as well.' The Sun told how Mr Zelensky won concessions from Mr Trump after turning up for a White House summit in a suit — as opposed to the combat fatigues he wore when they rowed six months ago. The White House did not deny claims Putin had suggested Moscow as a venue for face-to-face talks with Mr Zelensky. But the Kremlin would not publicly confirm they had even agreed to sit down with the Ukrainians. Russian Foreign minister Sergei Lavrov said Moscow was 'not rejecting any forms of work, neither bilateral nor trilateral' but said any talks would have to be 'prepared extremely carefully'. He did suggest that they were open to meeting the Ukraine leader if it was prepared with the 'utmost thoroughness'. Mr Zelensky has reportedly rebuffed the offer from Putin to hold the meeting in Moscow. However, Mr Trump's press secretary Karoline Leavitt insisted Putin was signed up for a meeting — and that the US was actively involved in the organisation of it. Geneva was being talked up as a more suitable location for the showdown. Switzerland, which remained neutral during both World Wars, has promised immunity to the Russian despot despite an International Criminal Court warrant out for his arrest. No knee bending is critical By Harry Cole AS the dust settles on that extraordinary White House gathering, what's left beyond some of the most astonishing pictures of world leaders in living memory? For Donald Trump's blowhard critics, even trying to seek an end to the bloody war is a new low, but that does not do the significance of Monday's meeting justice. The President pledged to continue to underwrite the safety of Ukraine with American might, in a huge U-turn on his campaign vows to withdraw from the world stage. Large swathes of his Maga base are going to hate that, but as British Ambassador Peter Mandelson said last night, Trump is a 'President with an appetite for risk that is enviable'. On territory — Ukraine is going to lose parts of the Donbas. Let's not sugarcoat it. For all the talk about 'not redrawing borders by force', that's exactly what is going to happen. Russia keeps 70 per cent of a region it's already flattened. But — and this is critical — Trump did not bend the knee to Moscow's Mad Vlad demand for the entire Donbas. He stated publicly negotiations must mirror current front lines. That matters. This isn't over. Not by a long shot. But here's the bottom line: if this ends with US planes patrolling the skies over Europe and Russia is forced to scale back its ambitions, that is not a win for Putin. And for Ukraine — beaten, bloodied, but still standing — it could be a far better deal than the disaster many feared. Although it is a signatory to the court, the Alpine nation said it could get around its obligations to handcuff Putin because of Geneva's role as the UN's European HQ. Swiss Foreign Minister Ignazio Cassis said: 'We have always signalled our willingness, but it naturally depends on the will of the major powers.' Both France and Italy have signalled their enthusiasm for Geneva as a host country. Sir Keir Starmer chaired a virtual call of the pro-Ukraine Coalition of the Willing countries from Scotland, where he is on holiday. Britain, France and Germany are all prepared to deploy peacekeeping troops in Ukraine in the event of a deal to end the war. A No10 spokesman said: 'The PM began by reflecting on the constructive meeting, saying it was clear there was a real sense of unity and shared goal of securing a just and lasting peace for Ukraine.' At one awkward moment the PM was forced to tell other world leaders to 'mute themselves' so he could speak. 7 Sir Keir Starmer chaired a virtual call of the pro-Ukraine Coalition of the Willing countries from Scotland Credit: AFP 7 European leaders continued to lavish praise on Mr Trump Credit: X 7 War in Ukraine is still ongoing after Russia's invasion on 24 February, 2022 Credit: Getty Meanwhile, despite the solidarity with President Zelensky, the Ukraine leader was told he would have to show 'flexibility' in negotiations — even if some supporters back home want him to refuse to budge. British ambassador to Washington Lord Mandelson said: 'He may go back to Kyiv and find he doesn't have the political support for the flexibility that he's got to show in order to help bring this to an end. 'So we've got to continue making sure that what Zelensky can take back is cast-iron assurance, so that if he does show flexibility, Ukraine can be safe.' European leaders continued to lavish praise on Mr Trump, with Emmanuel Macron saying his 'unpredictability' was a handy trait. The France President said: 'I think we have changed President Trump since he arrived in power in January. We rose up, united as Europeans, and he took it into account. He also brought a fundamental asset in dealing with Russia — his unpredictability.' PREZ'S HEAVEN BID DONALD Trump has said he believes it will help pave his way into heaven if he can find an end to the war between Russia and Ukraine. The US President told the Fox & Friends chat show yesterday: 'I want to end it. You know, we're not losing American lives, we're not losing American soldiers. 'We're losing Russia and Ukrainian, mostly soldiers. Some people, as missiles hit wrong spots or get lobbed into cities. But if I can save 7,000 people a week from being killed, I think that's pretty — I want to try to get to heaven if possible. 'I'm hearing I'm not doing well. I hear I'm really at the bottom of the totem pole. But if I can get to heaven, this will be one of the reasons.' DON'S HAT TRICK 7 Trump flaunts his collection of MAGA memorabilia to Zelensky and Macron Credit: x DONALD Trump shows Volodymyr Zelensky and Emmanuel Macron the real feather in his cap — a shelf full of MAGA memorabilia. The US President was seen with a red 'Four More Years' hat in the White House with the Ukraine and France leaders after the peace talks on Monday. Trump previously flaunted the collection to Azerbaijan's President Ilham Aliyev last week.
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Major cheese company confirms closure of Irish manufacturing plant in Laois as 132 jobs under threat
The confirmed closure of the manufacturing plant is set to occur in the second half of 2026 WORK WOES Major cheese company confirms closure of Irish manufacturing plant in Laois as 132 jobs under threat A MAJOR cheese company has confirmed their plans to close a manufacturing plant in Portlaoise in the second half of next year. The US cheese company Leprino Foods has announced its closure plans for the manufacturing plant in Co Laois, which currently employs around 132 Irish employees. The firm, which produces mozzarella and string cheese, said the "difficult" decision was taken after a "comprehensive evaluation" of all possible options to improve the financial and operational performance of the Portlaoise plant. Some 132 staff work at the Laois site. The confirmed closure of the manufacturing plant is set to occur in the second half of 2026. In a statement, Chief Executive of Leprino Europe Paul Vernon said: "Despite considerable efforts, the level of sustainable improvement needed could not be achieved. "Closing the site will help ensure that Leprino can remain competitive while optimising its manufacturing footprint to continue meeting the evolving needs of customers. 'We understand the impact this announcement will have on our colleagues, their families, and the local community. 'We want to express our sincere gratitude to the talented team at Portlaoise. This decision does not lessen the value of their hard work or contributions.' Leprino said it will provide enhanced redundancy packages as well as career transition assistance to employees. It is also understood the current production in Portlaoise will be transitioned to other European sites in Magheralin in Northern Ireland and Llangefni in Wales. They added: "The company will provide enhanced redundancy packages, career transition assistance, and regular updates to ensure transparency at every stage." 'CONTINUE TO EXPLORE OPPORTUNITIES' "In parallel to the above we will continue to explore opportunities for the site with any potentially interested third parties." Leprino has only been in operation in Portlaoise since 2020. It started as a family-owned company in Denver, Colorado, in 1950 when Mike Leprino Sr started making mozzarella cheese for his family's corner grocery shop. Leprino is now one of the largest producers of mozzarella cheese in the world, and also supplies lactose, whey protein, micellar casein, and sweet whey. It employs more than 5,500 people globally and has global sales in 80 countries.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on Ireland's economic position: not as good as it looks
The decision by The Economist magazine to exclude Ireland from its annual ranking of the world's richest countries is not the first time comparisons of this kind have sidelined the State's economy, Even official EU statistics now sometimes leave out Ireland, particularly when looking at trends in trade. And private sector analysts often exclude Ireland when looking at Europe-wide indicators. Should we be upset? Not really. The problem, as the Economist puts it, is that Ireland's economic data is 'polluted by tax arbitrage.' Multinationals organise their tax affairs to declare as much profit as possible in Ireland, helped by accountants who are , as the magazine said , 'as versed in the arts of surreal creativity as James Joyce.' Ireland argues, with some justification, that these companies have ' substance' here – in other words they employ people and produce goods or services from Ireland. However, the extent of the profit declared here is well in excess of what would be justified by this activity. And so, on a range of estimates, as much as half of Ireland's corporate tax take may be 'windfall' – not directly related to activity here – and our Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is very significantly inflated. Does this matter? It complicates analysis of Ireland's economy and more meaningful assessments now use other modified aggregates. Had the Economist included Ireland in its list of GDP per head, it would have been somewhere in the top half dozen countries. A more realistic measure would put Ireland in the middle of the European pack. READ MORE Unfortunately, Ireland's out-of-kilter data has created another problem. It has put the State in the spotlight internationally, including in the White House, where there has been focus on Ireland's trade surplus with the US, due almost entirely to pharma exports. The Irish GDP and trade figures may not reflect the scale of real activity here, but they do show major pharma production in Ireland for the US market and the impact of the associated aggressive tax planning. In that way, Ireland's mangled figures do still tell a real story.
