How would Mandela tackle SA's problems today if he were in Ramaphosa's shoes?
As Nelson Mandela's birthday approaches, I find that without any conscious bidding my mind has embarked on a thought experiment: If Mandela were in Cyril Ramaphosa's shoes now, if he were president of South Africa facing a truly shocking crisis in the criminal justice system, what would he do?
It's a silly experiment, I know, both because he isn't here, and because people, especially unusual people like Nelson Mandela, tend to surprise you.
But I can't help it, and it is partly Ramaphosa's fault. He is forever invoking Mandela's name, forever claiming to channel his spirit. Mandela, he says ad nauseum, was the world's great consensus builder; his ship would not sail until all had consented to board.
This could not be further from the truth. Mandela was a patrician leader, at times even a draconian leader, who steamrolled dissent when he thought it necessary. And he led at a time when it was necessary. During the transition to democracy, he ended the armed struggle in the face of fierce opposition from across the democratic movement. He abandoned nationalisation when the trade union movement and South African Communist Party screamed that he had sold out. He went into these battles fiercely. He was rude, arrogant, insulting. He interrupted people when they were speaking. He was a hard man who played a hard game; he'd been like that all his life.
I would hazard a guess that in the midst of the crisis Ramaphosa is facing, Mandela's most patrician qualities would have come out. He'd be firing people. He'd be insulting them in public speeches. He would put on that forbidding face of his, his lips in a downturned grimace.
Would it have worked? He managed to drag a volatile movement through a nightmarishly difficult transition to democracy. Could he have dragged it out of the quagmire of criminalisation and violence it finds itself in now? Who knows? What's left of the African National Congress may be too far gone for that. What he would not do, I am sure, is tepidly announce yet another commission of inquiry. DM
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
3 hours ago
- The South African
Roland Schoeman accuses Cyril Ramaphosa's ANC of looting 'a trillion rand' in scathing tweet
South African Olympic gold medallist Roland Schoeman has ignited a storm of political controversy, this time accusing President Cyril Ramaphosa and the ruling African National Congress (ANC) of looting 'over a trillion rand' – a claim that drew mixed reactions from South Africans across the political spectrum. The 45-year-old swimming icon, who won gold at the 2004 Olympics in Athens in the 4x100m freestyle relay and has since become a prominent online political commentator, took to social media following Ramaphosa's latest address to Parliament, writing on X (formerly Twitter): 'Imagine where the country would be if you and your party didn't steal over a trillion rand.' The post, which quickly gained traction, triggered a polarising response – some users applauded his bluntness, while others condemned his remarks as simplistic, racially charged, or disconnected from South Africa's broader social and economic realities. While many users on social media agreed with Schoeman's anti-corruption message, others challenged his narrative, pointing out issues of historic inequality, white privilege, and deep-rooted systemic dysfunction that go beyond a single administration. @hopeinbetween replied: 'If they can stop pleasing whiteness, we could be in an even better and stronger position as a country!' @Vincent62343509 added: 'They allowed population growth to spiral with poor border control… compared to our economic growth, that's unsustainable.' Others were more scathing: @HumanOpinion1 wrote: 'Imagine trying to sell 'progress' after looting a trillion rand. That's like bragging about patching one pothole after burning down the whole highway.' The comment section revealed that, while frustration over corruption is shared across racial and political lines, Schoeman's tone and framing drew accusations of bias and oversimplification. Over the years, the swimmer-turned-commentator has regularly spoken out on issues including farm murders, racial identity politics, and EFF leader Julius Malema, once applauding the UK's decision to reject Malema's visa application. His use of terms like 'civilised nations' and support for greater US influence in South African affairs has also raised eyebrows, with some accusing him of promoting neocolonial sentiment. The Presidency has not responded directly to Schoeman's post, although the ANC has in the past dismissed similar public accusations as 'uninformed and populist'. Ramaphosa himself has consistently defended his administration's anti-corruption efforts, pointing to the Zondo Commission, reforms at SARS, and crackdowns on public sector fraud. Political analysts say Schoeman's remarks underscore a growing culture of online populism, where celebrities and influencers can shape national debate – often without accountability. 'Roland taps into a very real frustration many South Africans feel,' said political analyst Thami Ndlovu. 'But attributing all of South Africa's challenges to theft alone ignores the layers of complexity in our economy and society.' Others argue that voices like Schoeman's – while provocative – are reflective of a leadership vacuum and widespread disillusionment with post-apartheid governance. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
IOL News
5 hours ago
- IOL News
Exploring Nelson Mandela's legacy: Insights from the 8th annual lecture in India
Nelson Mandela Image: File / Independent Newspapers Speakers were at a loss for words on how to describe Nelson Mandela to future generations during the Nelson Mandela 8th Annual Lecture, held in India, on Friday. The lecture was organised by the India International Centre, South African High Commission and the Working Group on Alternative Strategies. The Nelson Mandela International Day 2025 was celebrated under the theme: It's still in our hands to combat poverty and inequity. Sedula Mamabolo, Counsellor at the South African High Commission in New Delhi, said the theme is a call to action that reminds us that Mandela's legacy is not confined to history. 'It is a living challenge to each one of us. Mandela was not only a statesman but a symbol of ethical resistance. A man who taught us that reconciliation is not weakness but wisdom,' Mamabolo stated. Suhas Borker, Convener of the Working Group on Alternative Strategies, said Mandela was a role model for people in India because he was rooted in his actions, character, and impact. Borker said that Mandela's humility and service-oriented leadership inspired ethical governance 'His perseverance inspires us to face adversity with strength. He was committed to racial equality and justice in his leadership role in dismantling institutionalised racism. He prioritised unity over revenge, establishing the Truth and Reconciliation Commission to heal the nation's wounds,' Borker said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Next Stay Close ✕ Anand Grover, senior advocate at the Supreme Court of India and human rights activist addressed how Mandela viewed violence and whether it was justifiable ethically by the oppressed people of South Africa. 'In India, we've had a rich history of how violence has been used and treated, whether it is justified, ethical, or otherwise. Mandela, being a pragmatic politician, used nonviolence as a tactic, not a principle. He was always conscious of what would happen after they succeeded and that is very important because it did not involve loss of life,' Grover said. Speaking of Mandela's imprisonment and the things he had to endure, Grover said: 'I want to know whether Indian politicians would ever think of doing it. He was asked to clean the old-style toilets. He was asked to clean the bucket of another prisoner. I challenge you, not one politician in India will do it, whichever party, because of our caste system. It's a sad reflection but that is the greatness of Mandela,' he said. Cedric Crowley, acting High Commissioner for the South African Embassy in India, said that after the adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, we are now moving backwards. "The promises of the Sustainable Development Goals, which were a promissory note that no one shall be left behind, that governments will make every effort to ensure that poverty is eradicated, at least half, that there will be health care, that the population, the climate will be taken care of. "We are reversing those advances we made. What we have decided to do is to increase our defense spending to prepare for war instead of fighting the war against poverty and inequality. Mandela, today, would have been very disappointed to live in this period in this time where people are oppressed and robbed of their inalienable right to dignity and development," he added. Crowley said that Mohandas Gandhi came to South Africa suffering the same consequences of discriminatory laws, and that propelled him to become an activist. He said Gandhi created a political party and his theories on Satyagraha were developed. "When he returned to India, our country contributed to your independence because he successfully engaged in liberating India from British colonial oppression. So I think we've contributed to India in some small measure because of that experience of injustice," Crowley said. Crowley said he could not answer a student on how do we ensure that there are more Mandela's in this world and what characteristics should one exhibit, have and possess to become great like him. "I think if we try to develop theoretical frameworks of understanding Mandela, we will be at a loss because he is too complex. He is too layered as an individual. But there's one thing I think that could explain it, potentially and that is that Mandela loved deeply," he lamented.
eNCA
20 hours ago
- eNCA
Rejecting rhetoric and tokenism, and embracing transformative thinking
Dear Colleagues, Partners, and fellow South Africans, 'As Mandela Day Approaches – Let us reject rhetoric and tokenism, and embrace transformative thinking echoed in Random Acts of Kindness and Deliberate Acts of Restoration.' As we approach 18 July 2025, let us pause—not merely to commemorate, but to reflect with integrity and purpose. This is not the time for soothing rhetoric or symbolic gestures that serve only as temporary pain relief for our nation's deeper wounds. Our people deserve more than ceremonial empathy. They deserve bold action rooted in justice, courage, and dignity. The legacy we inherit was paved by sacrifice, not convenience. It was not built for comfort, but carved through blood, resilience, and the unwavering dream of a liberated, dignified, and equal South Africa. Truth be told, Tata Madiba never lived for applause. He didn't crave glory and was never fixated on his name being used to celebrate a single day. What made him extraordinary was his unwavering insistence that others must thrive. He lived together with the other departed struggle heroes for something far greater: a country united in its commitment to dignity, justice, and the Constitution. And if we are conscious, that mission remains unfinished. Yes, we honour the legacy, but let us do so with courageous leadership, a long-term vision, and real, measurable change—not with rehearsed speeches or symbolic gestures. It must become a national habit of giving, building, and transforming beyond our own needs. And that's where our perspective must shift. It should call each of us as citizens, leaders, and institutions to act in ways that honour the Constitution, not in speech, but in deeds. Among us are the Madibas, who may never be known, whose names will never appear in headlines-yet they serve, they sacrifice, and they build quietly. They are educators, nurses, caregivers, municipal workers, professionals in the built environment, economists, scientists, transport drivers, bakers, cleaners, mortuary workers, police officers, court workers, community leaders, job creators, entertainers, news anchors, recyclers and ordinary citizens who rise with selfless purpose every day. Let us salute them because Mandela's legacy lives not in statues, but in the quiet strength of those who continue to build despite the odds. To those who may no longer believe in Mandela Day, for whatever reason, I urge you: still participate. Not for symbolism or performance, but because selfless giving and sacrifice still matter. Even one act of deliberate kindness can restore faith, dignity, and hope. This is not a day of branding; it is a day of becoming better neighbours, more ethical leaders, and more conscious builders of the nation. The real question is not what we will do for 67 minutes, But what will we do with the 364 days that follow? Because the soul of Mandela Day lies not in what we give away for a moment, but in what we build, protect, and transform for generations to come. In that spirit, we must be careful not to reduce this day to ribbons, branded t-shirts, or food parcels. These are appreciated, but we must not confuse temporary relief with long-term transformation. It is easy to perform well. It is harder to build well. Yet, that is precisely what our country needs: systems, institutions, and leadership that outlive applause. Let us take on this challenge moving forward: to use our platforms and resources to restore dignity where it has been denied. We must drive transformation that is structural, not merely symbolic. Our leadership must be defined not only by strategy, but by conscience. We do not lead for compliance; we lead for meaningful, generational impact. This calls for asking the difficult questions: Are we building generational capacity, or simply ticking off compliance boxes that soothe our conscience but make no lasting change? Are our interventions enabling dignity and self-reliance, or are we creating dependency under the guise of goodwill? Because if Mandela Day means anything, it must mean this: Leadership without moral imagination is not leadership at all. It is administration without vision, authority without purpose, and influence without integrity.'. Today, I challenge each of us, whether in government, business, education, or civil society, to step beyond words and symbolism. Let us commit to actions that restore dignity, open doors, and build lasting opportunities. Let us hold ourselves accountable not only on Mandela Day, but in the decisions we make every day thereafter. 'Decolonization is not only a long-standing political and epistemological movement aimed at liberation and freedom for those people who experienced colonialism and who are today…' — Sabelo J. Ndlovu-Gatsheni Together, let us safeguard what we fought so hard for. This legacy is not guaranteed. It is fragile, and it is urgent. It must be preserved, protected, and passed on to future generations. Let us honour the legacy by carrying forward the mission. Let us lead with courage. Act with conscience. Live the Constitution in practice, not just in theory.
