Michigan court ends effort to sue Oxford school staff over 2021 mass shooting
The Michigan Supreme Court on Wednesday dismissed appeals by families of students killed or wounded at Oxford High School in 2021, ending efforts to hold employees partly responsible for the mass shooting.
Under Michigan law, immunity is a high hurdle to overcome in lawsuits against a government body, including public school staff. Lawyers typically have to show that gross negligence occurred.
The court, in a two-sentence order, said it would not step into the litigation. The decision means a 3-0 Court of Appeals decision in favor of school employees will stand.
A lawyer for the families said he would speak at an afternoon news conference.
The appeals court in September said there was no evidence that Oxford staff were the 'proximate cause' of the tragedy, noting it was 15-year-old Ethan Crumbley who 'made the definite and premeditated decision' to take a gun to school, kill four students and wound seven other people.
Before the shooting, he sketched images of a gun, a bullet and a wounded man on a math paper, accompanied by despondent phrases. His parents were quickly called to a meeting at school but declined to take him home.
No one — parents or staff — checked the boy's backpack for a gun, though an administrator joked that it was heavy.
Crumbley, now 19, is serving a life prison sentence. His parents, James and Jennifer Crumbley, are each serving 10-year sentences for involuntary manslaughter. Prosecutors said they had ignored his mental health needs, bought him a gun as a gift and then failed to safely secure it.
___
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
25 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
ICE chief's brutal takedown after Democratic mayor compares his agents to neo-Nazis
The acting director of Immigration and Customs Enforcement attacked high-profile Democrats for 'putting my people in danger' after they criticized how agents do their jobs - with one liberal mayor comparing ICE officers to a neo-Nazi group. Todd M. Lyons took specific aim at Boston Mayor Michelle Wu and New York Congressman Hakeem Jeffries in a recorded statement. Wu had previously commented about how ICE agents and the white supremacist group Nationalist Social Club-131 both wear masks. 'I don't know of any police department that routinely wears masks. We know that there are other groups who routinely wear masks. NSC-131 routinely wears masks,' the progressive mayor told reporters this week. The Nationalist Social Club-131, better known as NSC-131, is a neo-Nazi group based in the New England area that claims to have chapters in France, Hungary and Germany, according to the Anti-Defamation League. Last week, Wu described ICE agents as a 'secret police' force that has 'snatched' illegal immigrants off the streets of Boston. Lyons said the rhetoric of Wu and other Democrats is dangerous to ICE agents in the field, some of whom have been doxxed by communities facing immigration raids. 'Politicians need to stop putting my people in danger. I'm not asking them to stop. I'm demanding that they stop,' he said in his video message. 'Here's what I have to say to Boston Mayor Michelle Wu, Congressman Hakeem Jeffries, and anyone else stirring up outrage about ICE does,' Lyons said. 'These are real people with real families that you're hurting with your ridiculous rhetoric and inflammatory comments.' Jeffries, the House Minority Leader, said Tuesday during a press conference that ICE agents concealing their identities with masks is a futile exercise. 'Every single ICE agent who is engaged in this aggressive overreach and are trying to hide their identities from the American people will be unsuccessful in doing that,' he said. 'This is America. This is not the Soviet Union. We're not behind the Iron Curtain. This is not the 1930s. And every single one of them, no matter what it takes, no matter how long it takes, will of course be identified. That, in fact, is the law,' Jeffries added. Federal regulations stipulate that any US official making an immigration-related arrest must identify themselves as an immigration enforcement officer. There is nothing in federal code requiring them to share their name with suspects, nor are there any rules about face coverings. A May 23 joint letter penned by Democratic Senators Mark Warner and Tim Kaine accused the Trump administration of allowing ICE agents to wear masks when arresting 'nonviolent individuals without a prior criminal history.' In the letter addressed to Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, Border Czar Tom Homan and Lyons, the Democratic senators said the practice of ICE agents covering their faces used to be 'reserved for undercover or sensitive operations.' 'We remain deeply concerned that ICE's lack of transparency will lead the public to intercede in enforcement efforts, escalating an already tense interaction, and risking an entirely avoidable violent situation,' the letter read. 'Increased use of face coverings and lack of prompt and clear identification by ICE officers and agents in public is also having unintended consequences. Criminals are taking advantage of ICE's anonymity and impersonating law enforcement officers and ICE agents,' the senators claimed. A May 23 joint letter penned by Democratic Senators Mark Warner and Tim Kaine accused the Trump administration of allowing ICE agents to wear masks when arresting 'nonviolent individuals without a prior criminal history' Lyons, who has been leading ICE on an acting basis since March 9, has an explanation for why his agents have been covering their faces since Trump took office. At a Monday press conference in Boston, he talked at length about how people leaked the personal information of ICE agents conducting a raid in Los Angeles, leading to death threats against them. 'People are out there taking photos of the names, their faces and posting them online with death threats to their families and themselves,' he said. He described a joint operation between ICE and the Secret Service where they arrested a person who was 'going online, taking [ICE agents'] photos, posting their families, their kid's Instagram, their kids' Facebooks and targeting them.' 'So let me ask, is that the issue here, that we're just upset about the masks? Or is anyone upset with the fact that ICE officers' families were labeled terrorists,' he said while holding back tears. Senator Marsha Blackburn, a Tennessee Republican, introduced a bill Wednesday that would make it a crime to dox federal law enforcement officials. The bill would impose a maximum criminal penalty of five years in prison for anyone convicted.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Watch: Family of raccoons rescued from wood-burning stove
Body cam shows the adorable moment police in Golden, Colorado, rescued a family of raccoons from a wood-burning stove. The Jefferson County Sheriff's Office posted the video to Facebook. On May 19, Animal Control officers responded to a call that a raccoon and her kits had moved into a homeowner's stove. The mother reportedly fled up the chimney when officers arrived. In the video, the babies are carefully scooped up and brought to a bush outside of the home, where they can be reunited with their mother. The kits were reported to be healthy and safe.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
JD Vance says Elon Musk's attack against Trump is a ‘huge mistake'
JD Vance said Elon Musk was making a 'huge mistake' going after Donald Trump in a storm of bitter and inflammatory social media posts after a falling-out between the two men. But the vice-president, in an interview released on Friday after the very public blowup between the world's richest person and arguably the world's most powerful, also tried to downplay Musk's blistering attacks as an 'emotional guy' who got frustrated. 'I hope that eventually Elon comes back into the fold. Maybe that's not possible now because he's gone so nuclear,' Vance said. Vance's comments come as other Republicans in recent days have urged the two men, who months ago were close allies spending significant time together, to mend fences. Musk's torrent of social media posts attacking Trump came as the president portrayed him as disgruntled and 'CRAZY' and threatened to cut the government contracts held by his businesses. Musk, who runs electric vehicle maker Tesla, internet company Starlink and rocket company SpaceX, lambasted Trump's centerpiece tax cuts and spending bill but also suggested the president should be impeached and claimed without evidence that the government was concealing information about Trump's association with infamous pedophile Jeffrey Epstein. 'Look, it happens to everybody,' Vance said in the interview. 'I've flown off the handle way worse than Elon Musk did in the last 24 hours.' Vance made the comments in an interview with 'manosphere' comedian Theo Von, who last month joked about snorting drugs off a mixed-race baby and the sexuality of men in the US navy when he opened for Trump at a military base in Qatar. The vice-president told Von that as Musk for days was calling on social media for Congress to kill Trump's 'big, beautiful bill', the president was 'getting a little frustrated, feeling like some of the criticisms were unfair coming from Elon, but I think has been very restrained because the president doesn't think that he needs to be in a blood feud with Elon Musk'. 'I actually think if Elon chilled out a little bit, everything would be fine,' he added. Musk appeared by Saturday morning to have deleted his posts about Epstein. The interview was taped on Thursday as Musk's posts were unfurling on X, the social media network the billionaire owns. During the interview, Von showed the vice-president Musk's claim that Trump's administration hasn't released all the records related to sex abuser Jeffrey Epstein because Trump is mentioned in them. Vance responded to that, saying: 'Absolutely not. Donald Trump didn't do anything wrong with Jeffrey Epstein.' 'This stuff is just not helpful,' Vance said in response to another post shared by Musk calling for Trump to be impeached and replaced with Vance. 'It's totally insane. The president is doing a good job.' Vance called Musk an 'incredible entrepreneur', and said that Musk's 'department of government efficiency', which sought to cut government spending and laid off or pushed out thousands of workers, was 'really good'. The vice-president also defended the bill that has drawn Musk's ire, and said its central goal was not to cut spending but to extend the 2017 tax cuts approved in Trump's first term. The bill would slash spending but also leave about 10.9 million more people without health insurance and increase debt by $2.4tn over the decade, according to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. Musk has warned that the bill will increase the federal debt and called it a 'disgusting abomination'. 'It's a good bill,' Vance said. 'It's not a perfect bill.' He also said it was ridiculous for some House Republicans who voted for the bill but later objected to some parts and claim they hadn't had time to read it. Vance said the text had been available for weeks and said: 'The idea that people haven't had an opportunity to actually read it is ridiculous.' Elsewhere in the interview, Vance laughed as Von cracked jokes about famed abolitionist Frederick Douglass's sexuality. 'We're gonna talk to the Smithsonian about putting up an exhibit on that,' Vance joked. 'And Theo Von, you can be the narrator for this new understanding of the history of Frederick Douglass.' The podcaster also asked the vice-president if he 'got high' on election night to celebrate Trump's victory. Vance laughed and joked that he wouldn't admit it if he did. 'I did not get high,' he then said. 'I did have a fair amount to drink that night.' The interview was taped in Nashville at a restaurant owned by musician Kid Rock, a Trump ally.
