Critics say firm hired to review Community Living BC includes founding architect of the Crown corporation
In the wake of a coroner's inquest into the death of a woman with Down syndrome, the province has ordered what it calls an 'independent review' of Community Living BC's home-sharing program.
At the time of her death from starvation in 2018, 54-year-old Florence Girard weighed just 54 pounds.
A court later convicted her provincially funded caregiver Astrid Dahl of failing to provide the necessities of life.
Girard's death sparked a series of changes to the home-sharing program.
'I'm still hearing concerns from families,' said Sheila Malcolmson, the Minister of Social Development and Poverty Reduction, which oversees CLBC. 'The review that I've established is looking at how home sharing is operating right now in 2025 and whether the changes CLBC made since 2018 are having the impact we hoped.'
The government has hired Tamar Consultancy to conduct the review.
The firm has a limited footprint online, but Malcolmson confirms Tim Stainton is one of its principals.
Stainton is a professor emeritus in the School of Social Work at the University of British Columbia.
'His credentials are beyond reproach, quite frankly. I believe that the professor was around in that group before 2005 that actually helped to create CLBC,' said CLBC board chair Shane Simpson.
Stainton was part of the provincial Board of the Interim Authority for CLBC, which the province struck in 2002 to lay the groundwork for CLBC.
Not only is he one of the original architects of the Crown corporation he has just been hired to review – he has also conducted research at UBC sponsored directly by CLBC.
Reached by email, Stainton referred questions about his role in the review to the Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction.
Simpson also has history with the agency that predates his time on its board.
When Girard starved to death in 2018, Simpson was an MLA and the government minister responsible for CLBC.
Down Syndrome BC president Tamara Taggart is skeptical the latest review, which is set to cost taxpayers $75,000, will yield much in the way of fresh ideas.
She told CTV News she would rather see the province focus on implementing each of the 15 jury recommendations that came out of the coroner's inquest into Girard's death.
The Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction expects the results of the latest review sometime in the fall.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
29 minutes ago
- National Post
Michael Taube: Of course globally focused Carney hasn't opened his constituency office yet
Mark Carney has been Canada's Prime Minister for slightly over 100 days. Yet, he still hasn't done the one thing his predecessors did in short order: open a constituency office. Article content MPs of different parties often don't have constituency offices for short periods of time. The reasons are usually straightforward and completely understandable, including moving locations and hiring new staff members. The matter is typically resolved quickly. Article content Article content Article content This hasn't been the case with Carney in his riding of Nepean. Article content Article content An Aug. 12 column in the Ottawa Citizen focused on a local constituent, John Van de Brook, and his concerns about a rat infestation occurring in Barrhaven. He had apparently already reached out to his municipal councillor, and decided to contact Carney to ensure that all bases were covered. According to Bruce Deachman, 'it wasn't so many months ago that his then-MP, Chandra Arya, helped solve a problem that Van de Brook's wife was having with her permanent resident card. Who knows, he figured, maybe Carney could help with this?' Article content When Van de Brook tried to look up Carney's constituency office, he discovered that it didn't exist. 'I was disappointed,' he told Deachman, 'he should have one.' Two other local residents, Elaine and Lyndsay, also expressed their disappointment that Carney had no local presence in Nepean. 'You might see something on Facebook telling you to contact your MP,' the latter said in part. 'When I see that, my first thought is that, technically, we have an MP, but we have nowhere to contact an MP. And, because of the role of our MP, it doesn't feel like there's someone representing our riding.' Article content Article content Is this a party-based issue or delay? Doesn't seem like it. Two newly-elected Liberal MPs in the area, Giovanna Mingarelli and Bruce Fanjoy, reportedly have their constituency offices up and running. Article content Article content Deachman contacted the PMO about this matter. While he recognized that Carney is 'the prime minister and has more important things to worry about,' he also correctly pointed out 'constituency offices aren't simply a quaint tradition or something going out of style.' What did the PMO reportedly tell him? 'We'll have more to share on that shortly. Be in touch.' Article content While the history of constituency offices doesn't date back to the time of Confederation, the current configuration has existed since the 1960s and 1970s. Will Stos, the editor of Canadian Parliamentary Review, wrote in the Winter 2024 issue that they were established 'as a response to frustrations with bureaucracy and as necessary infrastructure for parliamentarians who did not have access to private office space.' Stos also pointed out 'the main motive behind all this work is undoubtedly to be of service to constituents. Some politicians may do this work with utter selflessness and have no ulterior motives. But, it's easy to see how a well-served potential voter could benefit a parliamentarian who is planning to run again at the next general election. Whether this constituent actively offers positive word-of-mouth promotion that bolsters the parliamentarian's standing in the community or silently reflects on the value of this personalised help when next at the ballot box, effective constituency work likely contributes, in part, to the well-established 'incumbency bonus' at the polls.' Article content Having volunteered for a few summers in then-Progressive Conservative MP Barbara McDougall's constituency office in St. Paul's (now Toronto-St. Paul's), I can confirm the value and importance of having this link between politicians and local residents in place. The former will be able to build personal relationships with individual constituents and neighbourhood businesses – and, in some cases, establish political relationships that lead to votes and financial donations. The latter will hopefully feel represented in the riding and know they can contact their local politician or staff members if they need help with an issue. It won't always result in a perfect conclusion, but it's an important lifeline that exists in politics and society — and must continue to exist in spite of the shift from personal to online forms of communication. Article content All politics is local, as the old saying goes. Carney, who thinks more on a global level, doesn't seem to recognize this. Article content Article content Yes, most prime ministers don't spend much time in their constituency offices because they don't have a lot of time to spare. Carney would be no different in this respect. At the same time, it's the role of his constituency assistants, or paid staff, to field all phone calls, emails, texts and physical visits from constituents who don't have set appointments. That's what they're hired to do. And while safety and security issues are more pressing concerns in this day and age, the prime minister's protective detail, which operates under the PCMP's umbrella, provides 24/7 security for Carney. Article content There's no excuse for Carney not to have a constituency office in Nepean after 100 days as PM. It makes him look like an out-of-touch elite who can't be bothered to speak to the common people and has no interest in their day-to-day issues, concerns and problems. Which has been an often-cited criticism of this prime minister since his first day on the job. Article content
CBC
37 minutes ago
- CBC
The Orca winner of The Search for B.C.'s Best Symbol
The winner of B.C.'s Best Symbol is revealed Started 13 minutes ago Live Social Sharing It's black, white, and the best symbol of British Columbia. The orca has emerged victorious in The Search for B.C.'s Best Symbol, defeating 63 other challengers in a friendly summer-long competition by CBC News to determine what iconic thing in this province best represents us. After five weeks and 500,000 votes, the orca defeated the totem pole in the final by a comfortable 64-36 per cent margin to win the unofficial and unscientific crown. It came after a semifinal win against B.C.'s official tree (the Western Red Cedar), a quarterfinal win against the official mammal (the spirit bear), and a round of 16 victory over the official bird (the Steller's jay). "They're an indicator of the health of the entire province," said Lauren Laturnus, an Environmental Science masters student who has spent her last four summers on Saturna Island monitoring the whales as they pass through the Salish Sea. "It reflects the interconnectedness of the entire province and they rely on the salmon from B.C.'s rivers and streams, which then rely on the forests." In other words, the orca — strong, beautiful, communal and connected to nature — fully earned its title as the province's best symbol. How orcas became such a big symbol of British Columbia 18 days ago From 'something to be feared' to B.C.'s best symbol It's indicative of a remarkable turn in public opinion in B.C. towards orcas, an apex predator that is typically highly social and has deep family bonds. While to the Nuu-chah-nulth First Nations, orcas are the guardians of the sea, and for the Tsleil-Waututh people, the whales are a source of spiritual power and teachings, to many settlers they were seen as competitors for B.C.'s salmon population. The whales were labelled "criminals" in newspaper headlines, and there was even talk of using machine guns to hunt them down. "They were seen as an animal that was quite terrifying and something to be feared," said Andrew Trites, director of the University of B.C.'s Marine Mammal Research Unit. "Even the name they were given, killer whales, that should be a red flag right there," he said. But after many orcas were put in captivity in the 1960s — including the famous Moby Doll, captured off the coast of Saturna and placed in the Vancouver Aquarium — public perception swiftly changed. "The public as well as scientists started to think about orcas not just as indistinguishable black and white predators with scary-looking teeth ... but actually as individuals with their own personalities, their own connections to other whales and even potentially to us," said Jason Colby, a University of Victoria historian and author of Orca: How We Came to Know and Love the Ocean's Greatest Predator. Southern B.C. orca numbers dropping B.C.'s love of orcas has led to them becoming the mascot for the Vancouver Canucks (Fin) and the 1994 Victoria Commonwealth Games (Klee Wyck). They're also available for purchase as stuffed animals or paintings in shops across the province. But the love has also led to an environmental movement to fight for their survival. While many transient and northern resident orcas spend much of their time in B.C. waterways, the group arguably most associated with B.C. — the southern resident orcas — number just 73 left. Pollution of the waterways and decreases in the salmon population have been blamed as culprits, and in recent decades several orcas have died just months after being born. This year, Laturnus says they haven't made it to Saturna Island, even though they would traditionally be seen by the early summer. "It is a bit worrying because this is their traditional habitat and their summer foraging home," she said. A contested connection to our environment is part of the B.C. story. But so too is beauty and grace, social and family bonds, and a love of oceans and fish.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Chestermere Lake water quality advisory no longer in place: AHS
Alberta Health Services (AHS) has lifted a water quality advisory for Chestermere Lake's Cove Beach. The advisory was issued on Aug. 8 after 'elevated levels' of fecal bacteria were found in the water. People were asked not to swim or wade in the Cove Beach area until further notice. On Friday, AHS issued an update saying fecal bacteria levels had 'returned to an acceptable level.' 'As always, visitors and residents are reminded to never drink or cook with untreated water directly from any lake or reservoir, at any time,' AHS said.
