Nation's Report Card spurs calls for change as reading and math scores circle the drain
The Nation's Report Card is sparking calls to action as dismal scores on reading and math show students across the country have failed to recover from the pandemic.
The National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) data released Wednesday showed reading scores have fallen even further for fourth and eighth graders than in 2022, while math scores show only slight progress for fourth graders, but still not enough to catch up to pre-pandemic numbers.
'These results are both heartbreaking and tragic,' said Alicia Levi, president and CEO of Reading is Fundamental. 'We need to take action […] We are calling on, leaders from all sectors, public and private, to join us in this fight.'
Increasing investment, preparing educators with new ways to teach subjects and acknowledging students are moving up grades without the fundamentals are all crucial for fixing the problems, according to experts.
Reading took the biggest hit, with the percentage of eighth graders able to read at NAEP's basic line the lowest in the assessment's history.
The news is even worse for the lowest-performing students: Those in just the 10 th and 25 th percentiles for both fourth and eighth grade had the lowest scores since NAEP's first reading assessment in 1992.
Brandon Cardet-Hernandez, president of Mrs. Wordsmith, a group that seeks to improve children's literacy outcomes, called it 'a state of emergency.'
'We know that 70 percent of incarcerated people read below fourth grade level. We know that literacy is deeply tied to our economic opportunities and our health outcomes. So, particularly coming out of $190 billion in ESSER funds, it's a tough day to hear that we have not made progress and actually lost ground in our reading proficiency across the country,' Cardet-Hernandez said.
Seeking to combat the problem, numerous school districts and states in recent years have required educators to switch how they teach reading to a method called the 'science of reading.'
Previously, those educators used the 'balanced literacy' method, which focused on teaching students how to read using cues or context in the text. The science of reading instead focuses on ensuring students understand phonics when learning to read.
Whether NAEP's flagging scores are an indictment of the method cannot yet be determined, according to experts.
New York City, which holds the largest public school district in the country, switched to the science of reading in 2023, only giving one academic year with the concept before students were assessed by NAEP.
'It's way too soon to have expected to see the trickle down from state level policy initiatives being implemented and then actually enacted at the school level in ways that would support faster development on the part of a student,' said Karyn Lewis, director of the Center for School and Student Progress at NWEA, an education research group.
'I think in education we are often way too reactionary and want to pull back before we have full evidence about whether a policy or an initiative is working,' Lewis added.
Math had somewhat better luck, though the scores are little cause for celebration.
Fourth graders had a two-point gain in math but were still unable to overcome the five-point drop that was seen in the subject when the pandemic began. Eighth graders had no significant changes in their math scores.
Math has been assisted by extra federal dollars going towards tutors and after-school programs, and critics say that type of energy was not put into reading.
'We're not making the investment,' Levi said. 'I see today that there is such public and private sector investment in STEM — the idea that science and math and technology are the future and that we need to double, triple, quadruple our investment — and you are seeing the results of that is reading has been left behind.'
Experts say reading is also just a harder subject to help play catch up on when students fall behind and how teachers are trained for this problem needs to change.
'We know that math is made of more discrete skills that are probably much easier to target for intervention,' Lewis said. 'You can identify, for instance, that a student is struggling with long division, and then you know the specific steps to intervene there and get them caught up with that specific skill set. In contrast, reading is cumulative.'
Adult literacy has also fallen, according to numbers released last month.
The National Center for Education Statistics, part of the Department of Education, released data in December showing 28 percent of adults in the U.S. are ranked at the lowest levels of literacy, compared to 19 percent in 2017.
As students' progress through the grades, reading goes from a subject that is taught to a subject that is assumed. After grade three, they are expected to be expanding their knowledge through reading in new subjects, and educators are not expected to teach how to read the material.
'I think we are seeing the effects of the fact that early elementary students, early elementary teachers, they're the most well-prepared to teach those foundational skills,' said Lewis. 'And we've got students leaving those early elementary grades missing some of those foundational skills due to the school disruptions, and they're coming into the classroom of more advanced teachers who may not be prepared to support those foundational reading gaps.'
'I think we're seeing a mismatch between the needs of students and the preparation of our teacher workforce,' she added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
2 days ago
- Newsweek
Gen Z Parents Not Reading to Children Alarms Experts
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Literacy rates are declining, screen time is increasing, and experts are sounding the alarm on the death of parents reading to their children. Though it is critical for their cognitive development, there has been a significant drop in parents, particularly those from younger generations such as Gen Z, reading to their children, and fewer are doing so for pleasure. As the alarm sounds on what could be a burgeoning literacy crisis, Newsweek spoke to the experts to find out more. Reading Time Down, Screen Time Up Recent research and data have shown there is a clear pattern among young children and the media that they are consuming: reading is on the decline, and screen time is on the up. Photo-illustration by Newsweek/Getty/Canva On average, children aged 8 to 12 spend between four and six hours watching and using screens each day, and teenagers can spend up to nine hours on screens, according to the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. Screen Time and Children In 1984, the first year that data is available for, 35 percent of 13-year-olds reported that they were reading for fun "almost everyday." By 2023, this figure had dropped to 14 percent, as per the NAEP. NAEP Long-Term Trends: Student Experiences A recent survey from HarperCollins UK found that there is a pronounced disinterest in reading aloud for younger parents. Less than half of parents of children up to 13 years old describe reading aloud to kids as being "fun," for them; and 29 percent of children aged 5 to 13 think that reading is more "a subject to learn," than "a fun thing to do." Only 32 percent of 5- to 10-year-olds will frequently choose to read from enjoyment, which is down from 55 percent back in 2012. Literacy rates in the U.S. appear to be decreasing, dropping nearly 10 points since 2017. In December, data released by the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) showed that 28 percent of adults in the U.S. ranked at the lowest levels of literacy, compared to 19 percent in 2017 Why Is It Important To Read to Children? "There are so many advantages to reading together with your child," Hugh Rabagliati, a psychology professor at the University of Edinburgh in Scotland, told Newsweek. "Books help kids to learn new concepts and ideas; they encourage kids to engage in discussion; and they prepare kids for reading, through attending to wordplay and vocabulary." Carmel Houston-Price, professor of language and cognitive development at the University of Reading in England, told Newsweek over email: "For young children, it's 'book-sharing' rather than 'reading' that best supports their development, as 'sharing' implies that the child and parent are not just reading the printed pages but are actively engaging with the book and each other; turning the pages, repeating the lines, talking about the pictures, relating the story to the child's own experiences. "Babies and toddlers often show interest in looking at books before their first birthday, particularly books with textures, flaps or rhymes that catch their attention, precisely because these types of books allow the type of exploration and interaction with the adult that is beneficial to children's learning," Houston-Price said. She added: "Book-sharing also supports children's early language development, both in terms of the vocabulary used in the book and children's skill in answering questions and telling stories." Stock photo: A person reads at the Rice University Library on April 26, 2022 in Houston, Texas. Stock photo: A person reads at the Rice University Library on April 26, 2022 in Houston, Maryanne Wolf, the director of the Center for Dyslexia, Diverse Learners, and Social Justice and professor-in-residence at the University of California, told Newsweek over email: "Few realize the multiple linguistic, cognitive, social-emotional, and neurological contributions made by the simple act of reading daily to one's young child---beginning from the first moments they can sit upon a lap. "Not only does the baby begin to associate reading with the emotions of love and protection, the language and cognitive circuits of the young brain are learning the sounds (phonemes) of their language, the meanings of first words, the slow appreciation of what books convey," Wolf added. What Is the Impact of Not Reading to Children? Not reading to children, then, will see a loss of these benefits. Houston-Price said that, without the opportunity to share books with parents, all these benefits are "likely to be lost." Wolf, meanwhile, said: "The loss of this opportunity by parents will ineluctably affect the acquisition of reading by their children in ways and the delight we want every child to experience when learning to read." Stock photo: A student in the library reads a book on February 2, 2022 in New York City. Stock photo: A student in the library reads a book on February 2, 2022 in New York B. Neuman, professor of Childhood Education and Literacy Development at the Steinhardt School of Culture, Education and Human Development, told Newsweek that, in settings where families aren't reading aloud, and books aren't present, "more often than not, children do not experience lots of things." "The scholarly culture that surrounds them early on, helping them establish a reading habit, less ability to attend to a storybook reading in school contexts, a limited understanding of the purpose of reading—joy, information, imagination," Neuman said. "Given what we know about early learning impacting on children's later development," Houston-Price said, "we should be giving young children the very best start in life, which includes opportunities to share books." How Can Reading Be Reintegrated Into Daily Routines? So, what should parents be doing to help reintegrate reading? Neuman said, "Parents should limit children's use of digital media," and should "consider a routine of reading to children regularly." Other tips for parents include carrying "books with them wherever they go," as well as "spending time reading themselves," which, in turn, provides a "good model of reading enjoyment to children." And technology isn't necessarily the enemy here. Rabagliati told Newsweek: "There are also some great technological solutions, like screen-free Yoto Players. These provide some of the same benefits of reading aloud, but don't require the parents to become a human audiobook." Houston-Price said that parents should make sure there are "age-appropriate books around the house that children can access." She added: "Regular visits to a local library might help to ensure there is variety on offer, but remember that young children enjoy repetition much more than adults do, so be prepared to read the same book over and over again. "Look at a book for just a few minutes at a time with very young children, or for as long as they are keen to," Houston-Price said, adding: "There's no need to read a book cover to cover or to read every line." She also noted: "Many children enjoy the routine of a story at bedtime, so perhaps let your child choose a book and take a few minutes to have a cuddle and a read before bed."
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
My music students will play at CMA Fest. More kids need this opportunity
I was 11 years old when I first played with a brass band on a big stage outside my home city of New Orleans. I can still remember the thrill of hearing our jazzy, rhythmic sound meet the roar of applause from an appreciative audience. This weekend, 62 adolescents and early teens from the Tremé and surrounding neighborhoods of New Orleans will, like me, get their chance to perform away from home at the CMA Fest here in Nashville. It's a big deal. These kids, part of the Marching Crusaders band program, come from low-income communities and under-resourced schools. Our afterschool program gives them the opportunity to learn the foundations of music, join a marching band, and perform live — while also getting academic tutoring, hot meals, and the chance to forge connections with their peers and the adults who care about them. I started the program in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, which left our city bereft of so much — including music education. Our marching bands, a mainstay of our schools and a highlight of community events, were struggling. Fast forward two decades and the tradition is as popular as ever, particularly in high schools. More: Can music education boost grades, attendance? A new case study suggests it might Our program enrolls both elementary and middle school students and aims to get them ready for high school and college band opportunities, and — for those with the dream — life as professional musicians. But there are plenty of other reasons to provide wraparound services and music programs to students nationwide. Too many families who need aftercare programs don't have access to them. And music education isn't reaching many kids from low-income backgrounds who would benefit from the training and the support services that organizations like ours provide. We designed the Marching Crusaders program for students ages 9-14, because it's a formative time in a child's life when they can use help beyond what's available in the traditional school day. Risk taking increases, and mental health challenges are up. The Nation's Report Card shows middle schoolers are experiencing major academic declines and having difficulty making up lost ground related to the pandemic. Learning music helps children develop discipline and has been linked to positive academic outcomes. Our program also offers daily tutoring and celebrates the Crusaders' academic progress on a weekly basis when our staff distributes prizes, provided by our generous partners, to top academic achievers. I really enjoy having the kids run over to pass me their report card and get a photo of us showcasing their accomplishments. I always try to learn from others, and there are nonprofits in Music City worthy of attention and public support. I'm impressed with the work of W.O. Smith Music School, which provides low-income students with high-quality music instruction; the Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum's Words & Music program, focused on songwriting; and Notes for Notes, which provides youth access to instruments and recording studios, to name just a few. More: Inside the nonprofit studio that lets Nashville kids make music for free. 'When you walk in here you're an artist' And. of course, there's the CMA Foundation, which invests the proceeds from CMA Fest into music education programs, including the one I lead. But there's no question kids need more, and perhaps we should all be looking for ways to provide it. The Marching Crusaders program serves around 200 kids, but we have a waitlist that garners hundreds of applications within days of opening, even if we only have 20 slots to fill. It hurts to have to turn kids away every year. Especially at this moment of economic uncertainty and proposed education funding cuts, communities can strengthen music education. That can happen when nationally known artists, like those who call Nashville home, use their voice for good, or when communities find a way to expand and fund in-school and out-of-school music education. Helping can also mean letting young artists take the stage during events like CMA Fest — even when those kids look and sound a little different from other performers. More: Country stars share how music teachers changed their lives. Top moments from CMA Foundation awards It's also so valuable to mentor kids and provide space for them to practice and play. I got my start learning drums in the childhood home of famed jazz musician Trombone Shorty. His mom, Lois Nelson Andrews, had a big heart and open door for budding musicians. Later, trumpeter Milton Batiste put me on the stage with the Olympia Brass Band. Today, I'm just paying it forward. The Crusader Marching Band is the largest of several programs that fall under our nonprofit, The Roots of Music. The others include an in-school kindergarten and elementary program and a high school audio engineering and production program. I believe children are the roots of music. We must nourish and take care of our roots. We'll all be better off for it. Derrick Tabb is the founder and Executive Director of The Roots of Music nonprofit. An acclaimed musician, he plays the snare drum with the Grammy-award winning Rebirth Brass Band. This article originally appeared on Nashville Tennessean: Nashville CMA Fest is a great lesson, chance for children | Opinion
Yahoo
6 days ago
- Yahoo
Trump DOJ targets California after Trans runner's title wins spark outcry
The post Trump DOJ targets California after Trans runner's title wins spark outcry appeared first on ClutchPoints. The Trump administration is ramping up pressure on California following a transgender teenager's victory in two state track titles. Sixteen-year-old AB Hernandez placed first at the California high school championships, drawing national attention and sparking a sharp rebuke from federal officials, per CBSNews. Days later, the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division, led by Harmeet Dhillon, issued a letter accusing the California Interscholastic Federation (CIF) of violating the Constitution. The CIF's bylaw allows students to compete in alignment with their gender identity, regardless of the gender listed on official records. Dhillon's letter, sent to all California public school districts, demanded they abandon the policy and certify compliance by June 9. According to Dhillon, the CIF's approach amounts to 'unconstitutional sex discrimination,' citing the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. Her letter specifically warned that knowingly limiting athletic opportunities for female athletes based on sex could result in legal consequences. Though Hernandez wasn't named in the letter, she became a flashpoint the next morning when President Trump posted on Truth Social that California would face 'large scale fines.' The California Interscholastic Federation had recently adopted a pilot program for the championship meet that expanded eligibility for female athletes. That program enabled Hernandez to compete and share the podium with two other runners in one of her title events. The pilot rule applied only to events in which she participated. Amid the growing uproar, Hernandez appears unfazed. In an interview with Capital & Main, she addressed the backlash directly. 'I'm still a child,' she said. 'You're an adult, and for you to act like a child shows how you are as a person.' Meanwhile, acting U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli announced that the Central District of California has launched an investigation into CIF's policy. This adds another layer of federal scrutiny to an already tense situation, as political lines deepen over trans inclusion in high school athletics. With Trump reigniting the culture war over transgender athletes, California's school system now faces pressure—not just from vocal critics, but from the federal government itself.
