Tory ex-ministers defend record after PM demands ‘answers' over Afghan data leak
Ex-veterans minister Johnny Mercer claimed he had 'receipts' regarding the former Conservative administration's actions in relation to Kabul but said it was 'absurd' to accuse him of failing grasp the scale of crisis.
Johnny Mercer claimed he had 'receipts' relating to the previous government's handling of Afghanistan (Andrew Matthews/PA)
'I know who is covering their tracks, and who has the courage to be honest,' he said. 'I would caution those who might attempt to rewrite history.'
Thousands of people are being relocated to the UK as part of an £850 million scheme set up after the leak, which was kept secret as the result of a superinjunction imposed in 2023 which was only lifted on Tuesday.
At Prime Minister's Questions, Sir Keir insisted there would be scrutiny, which the Conservatives should welcome.
'Ministers who served under the party opposite have serious questions to answer about how this was ever allowed to happen,' he told MPs.
Former prime minister Liz Truss, who was foreign secretary at the time of the breach in February 2022, but a backbencher when the superinjunction was sought, said she was 'shocked' by the 'cover-up'.
She said the revelations pointed to a 'huge betrayal of public trust' and 'those responsible in both governments and the bureaucracy need to be held to account'.
Mr Mercer said: 'I've spilt my own blood fighting for a better Afghanistan, lost friends, fought to get operators out of the country and away from the Taliban, and visited hundreds of resettled families and hotels in the UK under direct commission from the previous prime minister after the schemes were dangerously failing.
'Others were with me in this process and we have all the receipts.'
Shadow justice secretary Mr Jenrick said he had 'strongly opposed plans the plans to bring over 24,000 Afghan nationals' during 'internal government discussions in the short period before my resignation' in December 2023.
'I first learned of the data leak and plan to resettle people after the superinjunction was in place,' he said. 'Parliamentary privilege is not unlimited; I was bound by the Official Secrets Act.'
Mr Jenrick said the secret scheme had been 'a complete disaster' and that the previous government 'made serious mistakes' but that 'thousands more (Afghan people) have come since Labour came to power.'
'Contrary to what some have suggested, the Afghan individuals I helped came on the Arap (Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy) scheme and had nothing to do with the subsequent ARR scheme caused by the data leak,' he added.
Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle has said the 'episode' raises 'significant constitutional issues'.
Earlier on Wednesday, Downing Street declined to say what questions former ministers should face but said Sir Keir was 'angry' about the breach.
Sir Keir's press secretary said: 'The Prime Minister is angry at such a terrible breach that had such grave consequences being allowed to happen.
'Which is why it's clear that there are questions that need to be answered by Conservative ministers who, in their own words, have talked about the ineptitude of the Conservative government at the time.'
She also pointed to comments from Mr Mercer, who described the handling of the breach as 'farcical' and 'the most hapless display of incompetence by successive ministers and officials that I saw in my time in government'.
The Commons Defence Committee will be setting out plans for an inquiry straight after the parliamentary recess in September.
Chair, @TanDhesi has responded to the Secretary of State's statement on Afghanistan.
— Defence Committee (@CommonsDefence) July 16, 2025
Committee chairman Tan Dhesi said: 'These shocking events now deserve proper, thorough parliamentary scrutiny to ensure that lessons are learned.
'I have consulted my cross-party colleagues on the Defence Committee and we all agree that this is work we intend to lead.'
Tory former defence secretary Sir Ben Wallace said he makes 'no apology' for applying for the initial injunction and insisted it was 'not a cover-up' but was motivated by the need to protect people in Afghanistan whose safety was at risk.
A dataset of 18,714 who applied for Arap was released in February 2022 by a defence official who emailed a file outside authorised government systems.
The Ministry of Defence only became aware of the blunder when excerpts from the dataset were posted anonymously on a Facebook group in August 2023, and a superinjunction was granted at the High Court in an attempt to prevent the Taliban from finding out about the leak.
Then defence secretary Sir Ben said he had applied for a four-month standard injunction shortly before leaving office but, on September 1 2023, when Grant Shapps took the role, the government was given a superinjunction.
Former defence secretary Sir Ben Wallace (Ben Birchall/PA)
Sir Ben said he did now know why the superinjunction was granted 'but nevertheless, I think the point here is I took a decision that the most important priority was to protect those people who could have been or were exposed by this data leak in Afghanistan, living amongst the Taliban who had no regard for their safety, or indeed potentially could torture them or murder them', he told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.
He also defended his actions in an article in the Daily Telegraph newspaper.
'I make no apology for applying to the court for an injunction at the time. It was not, as some are childishly trying to claim, a cover-up,' he said.
The leak led to the creation of a secret Afghan relocation scheme – the Afghanistan Response Route – in April 2024.
The scheme is understood to have cost about £400 million so far, with a projected final cost of about £850 million.
A total of about 6,900 people are expected to be relocated by the end of the scheme.
The key facts on the Afghan Resettlement data incident that took place in 2022, and the action we are taking to support those impacted.
Defence Minister @LukePollard explains 👇 pic.twitter.com/DY3SbBSmgp
— Ministry of Defence 🇬🇧 (@DefenceHQ) July 16, 2025
The official responsible for the email error was moved to a new role but not sacked.
Defence Secretary John Healey said he was not going to 'lead a witch hunt after a defence official'.
'This is much bigger than the mistake of an individual,' he told the BBC.
The superinjunction was in place for almost two years, covering Labour and Conservative governments.
Kemi Badenoch has apologised on behalf of the Conservatives for the leak.
'On behalf of the government and on behalf of the British people, yes, because somebody made a terrible mistake and names were put out there … and we are sorry for that,' she told LBC.
Between 80,000 and 100,000 people, including the estimated number of family members of the Arap applicants, were affected by the breach and could be at risk of harassment, torture or death if the Taliban obtained their data, judges said in June 2024.
However, an independent review, commissioned by the Government in January 2025, concluded last month that the dataset is 'unlikely to significantly shift Taliban understanding of individuals who may be of interest to them'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE 'I'm embarrassed to be from here!' Fed up locals in once-bustling town blast endless boarded up shops and drug addicts as they claim 'Labour does not care about us'
Llanelli in west Wales, just ten miles from Swansea, was once a bustling market town. Steeped in history, it was built in part by the money made from the Stepney clan, a distinguished local family who invented the tyres fitted on all London taxis just a century ago. But the Llanelli of today couldn't be more different. Rather than a buzzing town with crowds of shoppers and cafes and restaurants bursting with visitors, empty units and betting shops line the streets while rubbish piles up in doorways. Some locals now even confess they're too scared to look around the few remaining stores because of drug addicts dropping needles and shouting at passers-by. Ed Davies, 31, a former business owner told MailOnline: 'Why would you come here? I'm embarrassed to say I'm from Llanelli.' Frustrated with the lack of improvements from the local Labour-run council, Llanelli residents have decided to turn to Nigel Farage 's Reform Party. Earlier this month Labour admitted Reform is a 'serious threat' in Wales after a poll found the party on track to win elections next year and nowhere is the swing more obvious than Llanelli. More In Common research for Sky News put support for Farage on 28 per cent, ahead of Plaid Cymru on 26 per cent. Labour was in third on 23 per cent, while the Tories and Lib Dems were trailing on 10 per cent and 7 per cent respectively. In the 2024 general election Reform lost out by just 1,500 votes and have now come back with a vengeance to win over the local council. Residents told MailOnline they hoped that Reform could offer the change and rejuvenation Llanelli needs and hoped that Nigel Farage's policies could rid the town of its drug problem and improve the rundown centre. Locals explained that with the crumbling shop parades, the community spirit has all but gone and drug addicts have made it such an unwelcome place they're too scared to venture in to the shopping centre. One retired nurse and grandmother, who wished to remain anonymous, said her granddaughter is so scared to come in to town she has to be accompanied. The 73-year-old added that the drug problem in the centre is so bad that she and her family worry about getting high off the smoke. She said: 'My granddaughter won't walk through on her own anymore, she says you can get high of the drugs being smoked. I have to bring her in if she wants to get her nails done or anything. 'The druggies hang around in the centre and it's horrible. It's really bad.' The worried former nurse added that she knows the council are trying with new business spaces but unfortunately it's not enough to turn the tide. She added: 'Compared to what it was - they're trying and building new flats with business spaces underneath but there's no footfall. It's a sad state of affairs.' And her thoughts were echoed by retiree Arwyn Owens, 75, who explained that the increase in drug use and the run down centre had led him to turn his back on Labour. He said: 'I've lived here all my life and it used to be thriving but now all we've got are charity shops. We've got no big shops anymore just banks and empty shops and betting shops. 'Right next to the Boots it's just drug addicts wandering around and people are afraid to go in to town now. 'I don't know what needs to be done but something. I've voted Labour all my life but never again. The council used to be run by Labour, we had Labour for 20 years but they've done nothing. Aled Williams, 34, (pictured) said the only places still busy are the banks or the Specsavers where he works and he understands why no one wants to come to the town 'I think we need someone new who's for the community rather than voting for the council, we need to be prioritised.' Gary James, 42, was in agreement and said the entire town had 'gone downhill'. He told MailOnline that he remembered when Llanelli very busy but now there were no new businesses which had left the town drained of community spirit. Stepney Street, Llanelli's main shopping artery named after the once rich and powerful local Stepney family was full of boarded up shops punctuated by for sale signs. On the corner, right next to the street sign lauding a family which had once brought such prosperity to the area was the local job centre which had streams of addicts walking in and out in a daze. The local post office was boarded up and even the charity shops were closing their doors. Rows of empty retail units looked long abandoned and walking in to the market felt like walking back into a ghost town. Big brands like Tesco, Marks & Spencers, Argos and Iceland have all moved out and residents say they understand why no one wants to visit. Aled Williams, 34, said the only places still busy are the banks or the Specsavers where he works. He said: 'It's not what it was. There used to be a Woolworths, and M&S, a big tesco and there was a slow decline but then it became quite drastic and I understand why people don't want to come here.' And while the lack of businesses was dispiriting, some had not lost hope in rejuvenation and Mr James said that he believed Reform could make a real difference. 'I think Reform will change things,' he said, 'The Labour council just don't care about you. 'I want things to go back to the way they were before.' Former chocolate shop owner Mr Davies, put the town's changing political opinion down to failing business and drug addicts and said Llanelli had been getting more dilapidated for years. He said: 'I think it got worse when I was growing up but it's been 20 years of nothingness. 'There's no footfall here, there's just empty units which looks so much worse.' Daniel Philitonga, 16, and his mother Gina agreed with Mr Davies. The college student, who moved to the town with his family in 2014 said there was simply nothing to do which lead people to just 'hang around'. Daniel said: 'There's nothing for us to do - I never come in to town and my friends don't either.' Ms Philitonga added that she wouldn't let her 12-year-old daughter out in town on her own and would be worried about her safety. Shadows of Llanelli's thriving past can be found all over but remain sad reminders about how far it has fallen in to disrepair. An art deco-style theatre which opened in 1938 as Wales's first multiplex and is one of just 14 of the original Odeon cinemas left in existence in Britain. But crumbling, with weeds sprouting from the gutters and boarded up windows, the historic building seems unlikely to open up again despite having been bought in 2014 by William Ratti, a former international records boss for £130,000. Even the local shopping centre was so empty the upstairs floor had been shut off and signs read 'Exciting new shop coming soon' but the dusty shut up interior told a different story. Mr Davies added that drug addiction was also a serious problem in the town. He said: 'The addicts make a mess too and there loads of them and drugs and stuff. It's horrible. There's a real problem with cannabis being grown in empty shops. 'Why would you come here to visit - I'm embarrassed to say I'm from Llanelli.' In fact Llanelli has such as problem with drugs that earlier this year the town was part of a wider sting operation in west Wales. In May Pllumb Krosi, 34, was arrested after police found a 'large-scale cannabis farm' across three floors of a disused retail space in Llanelli town centre, according to Carmarthenshire News. While in February 1 50 cannabis plants totalling £113,000 were found in a property in the town. Local Fabian Cela was charged with production of cannabis but pleaded not guilty. The concern around drug use was a fear many of the locals had with Shauna Towend, 27, describing seeing broken needles in the local parks. There's broken glass, needles, swearing,' she said, 'all while the kids are around, it's all the addicts. 'We can't even go to the park or walk though because of all the shouting and swearing, it's just a horrible atmosphere.' A local Llanelli resident, who gave her name as Andrea, 61, said that the Labour council weren't tackling the problem of drug users in the right way and said instead of dealing with the issues, they'd just removed benches which had previously acted as a meeting point. She told MailOnline: 'They've taken away the benches because of the druggies so now there's nowhere to sit down. You can't avoid them now, they're everywhere.' The mother-of-one added that it's turning people away and now instead of people coming in to enjoy an afternoon of shopping, locals keep their visits short. A former bank in an impressive Victorian building to let but with some serious work needed it doesn't appear to be an attractive investment property Another boarded up uni with weeds growing where the sign sued to hang and a vandalised entryway 'People just come come in for 5-10 minutes instead of shopping for hours because there's nowhere to shop and nowhere to sit, it's all so run down and the shops are burnt out from fires. One such example was a former Bright House shop which had been burnt through and was boarded up and fenced off. Police have not provided an official explanation as to the cause but locals said it was part of a wider pattern of cannabis farms being burnt to the ground and it wasn't the first to have happened. Andrea added the only things in the town centre are 'banks, charity shops and vape shops or betting places', but added that even 'they're all closing down because the rents are too expensive'. One former bank, previously housed in an impressive Victorian building was up for rent but with weeds growing out of the historic stonework it didn't appear to be an attractive prospect. Grandmother Erma, 81, added that she remembers being able to leave her children outside to play while she shopped in the indoor market but couldn't imagine doing that now. She explained: 'It used to be bustling and the traffic was two way. There was a butchers and big shops and you could leave the children outside but now it's only busy three times a year for events and there's no shopping. 'I'm ashamed to say where we live - it's full of drug addicts, they've taken over.' The pair said they weren't convinced anything would change soon but agreed that Labour had let them down. But not everyone was convinced by Reform and Toby Jeffries, a 16-year-old college student said he didn't think Farage's new party was the answer although he conceded Llanelli was far from an ideal place to grow up. He said: 'It used to be more thriving with the Sunday markets but now it's like something out of Soviet Russia. People don't shop here anymore they just go to Trostre (Retail Park). 'The town is full of rubbish, there's nothing to do and it's really anti-social.' Despite all the frustrations there are reportedly plans to develop the almost-empty shopping centre in a luxury cinema, restaurant, music venue and function room worth £2million but residents are sceptical and will 'believe it when we see it'.
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Lord Prescott statue refusal is 'terribly disappointing', says Hull MP
A Labour MP has said it is "terribly disappointing" that plans for a memorial statue in Hull to honour the late Lord John Prescott has been refused by the city Turner, Lord Prescott's successor in the Hull East seat, said he will sign a petition by Hull's Labour councillors that demands the Lib Dem-controlled council reverse their former deputy prime minister, deputy Labour leader, and member of the House of Lords died on 20 November last for a memorial statue in the city were rejected at a meeting on Thursday, following concerns about funding. Councillor Julia Conner raised the motion for the statue, but the plans were rejected after a 26-26 tied vote. Lord Mayor Cheryl Payne cast the deciding said: "The money was going to be a tiny amount of money from the leader's fund, probably £1,000 would have done it. The rest of the money would have come in from donations and good will gestures and charitable giving from members of the public."He added: "I've got businesses who are prepared to put fairly substantial amounts of money in because they think to have a tribute to John Prescott is worth having in this city."John was a legend, always banging the drum for Hull."Council leader Mike Ross had voted against the motion and said such a statue would cost "upward of £150,000". He had questioned whether the public would feel it was "right to spend taxpayers' money on this proposal".Listen to highlights from Hull and East Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, watch the latest episode of Look North or tell us about a story you think we should be covering here. Download the BBC News app from the App Store for iPhone and iPad or Google Play for Android devices
.png%3Ftrim%3D0%2C0%2C0%2C0%26width%3D1200%26height%3D800%26crop%3D1200%3A800&w=3840&q=100)
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
Chaos and fear as Afghans exposed in huge data breach left in limbo by UK
When the email from the Ministry of Defence dropped into his inbox, Qargha's heart leapt. After an agonising four-year wait, he hoped that this would finally be confirmation that he could escape the threat of the Taliban and be brought to safety in the UK. Instead, it was news that the government had exposed his personal information – and kept him in the dark about it for nearly two years. Already in fear for his life, he will now take extra precautions even when going for a walk or shopping. He is one of around 18,700 Afghans whose names and contact details were exposed in the catastrophic data leak, which happened when an MoD official emailed a secret database to trusted contacts in February 2022. The blunder, which has resulted in some 16,000 Afghans affected by the breach being relocated to Britain as part of a covert operation, was discovered after someone posted parts of the database online in August 2023. News of the breach prompted the government to use an unprecedented superinjunction to keep the breach a secret in an attempt to block further spread of the information, meaning that even those affected could not be told. Ministers had argued that 100,000 people's lives were at risk of Taliban reprisals if news of the data breach got out, but a government-commissioned review later concluded that being identified on the dataset was unlikely to constitute sole grounds for targeting. Just before the gagging order was finally lifted on Tuesday, the MoD scrambled to email tens of thousands of Afghans, warning them their data was compromised. Desperate for news that MoD caseworkers had finally made a decision on his case, Qargha, a former member of the Afghan security forces who is still in Afghanistan, thought the email would finally confirm his eligibility approval. But he was shocked when he discovered the truth. He told The Independent: ' I am very concerned about the leak of my personal information and I understood more about it from Afghan International TV as well. They said this leak will put many lives at risk. 'My day-to-day life will be harder now. I am living in a safe house and I know that today or tomorrow, if I need to go to the hospital or seek help for anything, I will have to be more cautious now. I am putting restrictions on myself – being more cautious about going shopping, going for a walk, going to the park or going for a haircut'. The former soldier applied for sanctuary in the UK in 2021, but he was rejected along with many members of former Afghan specialist units in the summer of 2023. During that time, one UK special forces liaison officer oversaw the blanket rejection of 1,585 such applications. Qargha is waiting on a review of that decision, and the years of limbo are taking their toll as his agonising wait continues. 'My old home has already been raided twice. It is impacting me mentally, having to wait for so long. Everyone knows us and the work we did against the Taliban before the takeover, so my life is hard, stress level is up, everything is up,' he said. One former member of the Afghan special forces unit, ATF444, who served alongside the British yet left behind after the withdrawal, is also still waiting for a review of his application for help. Akthar said that after he received the two alert emails from the MoD, he had 'a lot of questions'. 'I don't understand, this is not a third-world country. This is the UK, where access to technology is high. How have they managed to leak this information?', he told The Independent. 'We are already at risk and they have put us at more risk. There are lots of questions but what can we do about it - nothing. 'Whatever caution we were taking before, we should triple that caution. At this moment, the fear is like hell. 'My moving around has become restricted a lot. Before, if I was taking 50 per cent precaution for my safety, I need to make sure I'm doing it 100 per cent,' he added. Last week, Taliban members began doing door-to-door raids of the district he was in, so he jumped in a car with a friend and drove for 12 hours to a different province, he said. He also needs to try to work to get money to support members of his family. 'It's making me desperate,' he said, adding: 'My family has not done anything to anybody and they don't deserve to die'. Another former member of the Afghan security forces said his 'stress changed to depression' on receiving the bright red warning message, alerting him that his information had been breached. 'My stress level is very high, all I can do is wait for my application to be processed,' he said. The Independent revealed on Wednesday that hundreds of Afghan special forces soldiers had had their details leaked in the MoD breach. Some 18,500 people affected by the leak have been brought to the UK or are on their way, while 5,400 have received approval letters but still need to be evacuated. Ministers have said that, while the MoD's resettlement scheme (Arap) has been closed to new applicants, existing cases will still be processed. But no time frame for the evacuations has been given, leaving those affected in limbo. An MoD spokesperson said: 'We will not comment on individual cases. 'This Government is fully committed to delivering on the pledge made by Parliament to those in Afghanistan who are eligible to relocate and resettle. 'We aim to see through our commitment to those eligible under the ARP to its completion by the end of the parliament. Eligible Afghans and their families will continue to arrive in the UK for the foreseeable future.'
