Arch Manning, Texas top preseason poll Top 25 with huge expectations
I just have one question about that: Are we sure?
Pull the name off the jersey. Forget about the maturity, the presumed intangibles, the osmosis of a lifetime spent in proximity to two uncles who did some pretty good things on the football field. What do we really see?
We see a player who has thrown a mere 95 passes in two seasons on campus, a player who didn't play a meaningful snap against a good team last season outside of some situation-specific quarterback run packages. We also see a quarterback who was apparently not a viable option for Sarkisian in the second half of last season, even when it was clear that starter Quinn Ewers was not 100 percent healthy and dragging down the potential of Texas' offense.
Maybe it's not fair to read into that. Coaches are notoriously weird about quarterbacks, hypersensitive to locker room dynamics and public perception if they even acknowledge the possibility of a change. If Sarkisian's loyalty to Ewers wavered even an inch, it would have unleashed a cacophony of noise around the Texas program that might have been worse than watching his quarterback throw six interceptions over the final five games.
That said, if Manning wasn't ready to give Texas a better chance to win a national title last year when the deck was stacked in the Longhorns' favor everywhere else on their roster, isn't it fair to be a little skeptical that he's going to be ready now?
Most folks, it seems, are not skeptical. Manning begins the 2025 season as the betting favorite to win the Heisman Trophy at some prominent sports books. Texas was the far-and-away choice among SEC media members to win the league in their preseason poll, with Manning being named to the all-conference third team. And in perhaps the most outrageous bout of Arch Madness we've seen yet, ESPN/SEC Network commentator Paul Finebaum predicted he would be "the best college quarterback we have seen since Tim Tebow entered the scene in 2006."
Mind you, since Tebow's Heisman run in 2007, we've seen Cam Newton, Johnny Manziel, Jameis Winston, Marcus Mariota, Lamar Jackson, Baker Mayfield, Joe Burrow, Caleb Williams and Jayden Daniels come through college football. If Manning is even in the top half of that group, then yes, Texas will probably be this year's national champion.
But can't we just slow down a little bit given, you know, the lack of on-field evidence that Manning deserves this level of expectation?
A year ago, Manning in fact did get his chance to start for Texas when Ewers strained his oblique muscle in the middle of their third game against Texas-San Antonio. Manning remained at the controls for the next two home games against Louisiana-Monroe and Mississippi State and was largely good. Not transcendently great, but good.
Then Ewers return from injury, and that was pretty much Manning's season for all intents and purposes. Two full games and a little more than half of a third, all against bad opponents. And that was with the best and most experienced offensive line in college football protecting him. It's not a critique of Manning whatsoever to say we didn't learn much about what he's capable of.
Sarkisian talks about Manning in far more measured tones. He understands what the two-year buildup of hype has created and the potential for narratives to turn quickly if his quarterback plays poorly in the opener against No. 2 Ohio State. He also knows that turning over four starters on the offensive line is a wildcard that will probably make things incrementally more challenging for his inexperienced quarterback.
"He's a great guy. He's a great teammate," Sarkisian said last month at SEC Media Days. "He's got an unbelievable work ethic. And I think, if he stays true to himself, that's going to help him navigate these waters as they present themselves. We've got to do a great job of supporting him around him, as coaches, as players, and ultimately, I think he's prepared for the moment. But now it's just time for him to go do it and enjoy doing it quite frankly."
Notice that's quite a bit different than how Sarkisian spoke the same day about "the deepest and most talented defense that we've had" or the receiving corps that "we're really excited about."
Maybe that's just Sarkisian intentionally lowering the temperature, with the full understanding that his fan base has been frothing to watch Manning finally take his place in Texas history. Or maybe there's a tiny part of him that's skeptical his quarterback can live up to the trail of hosannas laid in front of him based more on name and reputation than on-field accomplishment.
One way or another, after more than half a decade of hearing about the next-in-line to the Manning quarterback dynasty, we won't have to wait long for an answer.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
8 hours ago
- Reuters
Yankees turn to Carlos Rodon in bid to avert sweep by Rangers
August 6 - The Texas Rangers will vie for a sweep of the slumping New York Yankees when the teams square off on Wednesday afternoon in the finale of a three-game series in Arlington, Texas. The Yankees will send left-hander Carlos Rodon (11-7, 3.34 ERA) to the mound, and Texas will counter with rookie right-hander Jack Leiter (7-6, 4.10). New York star outfielder Aaron Judge returned to the lineup Tuesday after being on the 10-day injured list with a flexor strain in his right elbow. He batted third as the designated hitter and went 0-for-3 with two strikeouts in the Yankees' 2-0 loss. New York manager Aaron Boone was happy to have the slugger back in the lineup. "It's Aaron Judge -- we know what he means to our lineup, to the guys in the room," Boone said. "So to get him back, we're certainly excited about that. "He's been pretty upbeat about the progress he's made -- so far, so good." Texas has won three of its past four games while the Yankees have dropped five straight. Rodon allowed four runs and a season-high five walks in 4 2/3 innings in his most recent appearance, a no-decision against the Miami Marlins on Friday. He was handed a 6-0 lead and didn't allow a hit until the fifth inning, but the Yankees lost 13-12. "It kind of starts with me not getting through the fifth," Rodon said. "I had a good little run going, and then I got real inconsistent, spraying balls. Just not good enough. Five walks, 107 pitches to get 13 outs is pretty unacceptable." Rodon also had nine strikeouts in the start, his most since recording 10 twice in the month of May. He is 2-2 over his past five starts, allowing 18 runs over 28 combined innings as his ERA has increased from 2.95 to 3.34. Rodon is 3-1 with a 3.17 ERA in eight career starts against the Rangers, with those appearances covering 48 1/3 innings. One of the wins came on May 22, when Rodon posted six scoreless innings, allowing two hits and two walks while striking out eight. Leiter also settled for a no-decision Friday in his most recent start. He allowed two runs on three hits and three walks with seven strikeouts over 4 1/3 innings in his team's 4-3 loss to the Seattle Mariners. "I felt really good," Leiter said. "Physically, felt really good all day. The last thing you want to do is walk a few guys. I think the bright side is that could've gone south." The no-decision snapped a streak of three consecutive victories and four games with either a win or a loss. Leiter took a loss in his only career appearance against the Yankees, yielding five runs on seven hits with two strikeouts over five innings last September. While New York got Judge back on the field Tuesday, the Rangers still are waiting for first baseman Jake Burger to return from the injured list. Burger has been rehabbing a quad sprain that's kept him out since July 12 and had penciled in this weekend's home series against Philadelphia to return to the team. Instead, he began a minor league rehab stint on Tuesday. --Field Level Media
The Herald Scotland
14 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
College football preseason poll full of quarterback ineperience
Unless, apparently, you're a blue blood program. So while you stare at the first US LBM Coaches Poll of the 2025 college football season, don't ignore the glaring reality staring back. Five of the top eight teams have first-time starters at the most important position on the field. "The quarterback is critical to everything you do," Texas coach Steve Sarkisian said. "There's no getting around it." It is here where we introduced Texas, Ohio State, Georgia, Notre Dame, and Alabama. All among the top 10 in the Coaches Poll, and all preseason favorites to reach the College Football Playoff -- and possibly much more. All with first-time, full-time starters. If you think the CFP selection committee has problems ranking teams, the 67 coaches shouldn't get pass on criticism, either. There's a whole lot of funky in the first Coaches Poll, beginning at the top with teams ranked on reputation. Not their critical quarterback component. The quarterbacks at those five blue bloods - teams with a combined 119-23 record over the last two seasons - have combined to throw 262 career passes. Arch Manning of Texas has never started an SEC road game, and his only SEC start came last season against tomato can Mississippi State. Gunner Stockton of Georgia has never started an SEC game. CJ Carr of Notre Dame, Julian Sayin of Ohio State and Ty Simpson of Alabama have never started a game. Think about this: college football coaches have essentially told you they believe in a group of quarterbacks who, on average, have 50 career throws each. Maybe this isn't the layup everyone thinks it is. Maybe we're on the verge of a wild ride through the 2025 season, where the unknown unfolds into the unthinkable. Especially considering there's much more to this quarterback story than just first-time, full-time starters. Texas is preseason No.1 for the first time in school history, more hype baggage (and expectations) for Manning to carry before the first snap of the season. After back-to-back national titles in 2021-22, Georgia missed the CFP in 2023 and last year sustained an ugly loss in the quarterfinals -- and suddenly looks vulnerable. Ohio State is completely rebuilt on both sides of the ball (only nine starters return), and all Sayin has to do is defend a national title. And beat Michigan for the first time since 2019. Simpson begins his fourth season at Alabama, a program that owned the four-team CFP under former coach Nick Saban -- but couldn't make the first 12-team field in 2024. Simpson is merely carrying that weight, OK? ARCH MADNESS: Manning rumor madness with Nick Saban and Cleveland Browns GOOD FIGHT: Deion Sanders is stepping up in biggest battle of career Then there's Carr, a talented redshirt freshman who was given the keys to a championship-level team after Irish coach Marcus Freeman declined to add an experienced quarterback from the transfer portal -- and go all-in with the unknown. "I feel like the experience from last year is invaluable," Stockton said. That "experience" consisted of the second half of the SEC championship game victory over Texas, and the CFP quarterfinal loss to Notre Dame. Manning's experience is a home game against the worst team in the SEC, and a home game against lightweight Louisiana-Monroe. Simpson's most extended time on the field was two years ago in a tight win over South Florida, when he replaced starter Tyler Buchner and was essentially the best of two bad options. Carr and Sayin will take their first legitimate college football snaps in the season opener, both in monster non-conference games. Notre Dame plays at Miami, and Ohio State plays host to Texas. "You want command of the offense," said Ohio State coach Ryan Day, who insists Sayin is still competing with junior Lincoln Kienholz - who has also never started a game - for the starting job. "When you stand in there as a quarterback, you want everyone to believe in you. You want them to follow your command." That's all it takes? This will be a cakewalk. Matt Hayes is the senior national college football writer for USA TODAY Sports Network. Follow him on X at @MattHayesCFB.
The Herald Scotland
14 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Texas, Arch Manning are No. 1. How Steve Sarkisian rebuild Longhorns
This is a first: Texas had never been ranked No. 1 in the preseason in the history of the Coaches Poll, which debuted in the 1950 season. "This is a new year, new faces, new team, and obviously expectations are high for our program," coach Steve Sarkisian said at SEC media days. "I'm not naive to that. I don't put my head in the sand, and expectations are very high." The preseason ranking can be seen as the latest source of validation for the program constructed by Sarkisian, now entering his fifth season. Helped by an NIL-driven landscape of personnel management that has been a boon for many deep-pocketed programs, Texas looks on paper to be nearly flawless. Given their ability even in the deep SEC to simply out-talent most teams on the upcoming schedule, the Longhorns' quest to go wire-to-wire atop the Coaches Poll could come down to how they manage intense hype that has coalesced around one all-or-nothing goal: to deliver a national championship. "I do think we have a very hungry football team, one that is talented," Sarkisian said. "I think this is a championship roster. Now we've got to play like a championship team, but I do think it's a championship roster." How Texas got to No. 1 Before climbing to the top of the preseason poll, Texas had to experience the lowest point in modern program history. The team Sarkisian inherited for the 2021 season was fresh off four bowl wins in as many years, a program first since winning five in a row from 2004-08. But the Longhorns had struggled in former coach Tom Herman's final two years, failing to build on a 10-win 2018 season capped by a Sugar Bowl defeat of Georgia. Texas opened the Sarkisian era with a non-conference win against Louisiana-Lafayette and then won two in a row to start Big 12 play, rising to No. 23 nationally heading into the Red River Rivalry against Oklahoma. That 55-48 loss was the first of six in a row, the program's longest such streak since 1956, and included a miserable 57-56 overtime defeat to Kansas - the Jayhawks' lone conference win and one of just two wins overall on the season. Steady progress ensued beginning in 2022, an eight-win finish highlighted by a 49-0 rout of the Sooners and five losses by a combined 25 points. The 2023 Longhorns won the Big 12 in the program's final year of membership before losing 37-31 to Washington in the College Football Playoff national semifinals at the Sugar Bowl. Last year's team nearly took the SEC by storm, losing only twice to Georgia - the second in overtime of the conference championship game - and then beating Clemson and Arizona State in the expanded 12-team playoff before losing a close game to eventual national champion Ohio State in the Cotton Bowl. "I mean, it was a tough loss, but that was the last season," said junior linebacker Anthony Hill. "We have a whole new team. We want to go out there and be 1-0 next year. That's all we'll focus on is just being 1-0, and we'll handle everything else when the time comes." The program has undergone a clear shift in mentality, embracing the "all gas, no brakes" mindset instilled by Sarkisian and his staff. But the primary factor behind this recent resurgence is simpler: Texas has procured an eye-popping talent level through traditional recruiting and the transfer portal, buoyed by a willingness to spend millions to compile the best roster money can buy. Arch Manning leads loaded Texas roster Though it's impossible to pinpoint the exact total spent on talent acquisition, the 2025 Texas roster is expected to cost between $35 and $40 million, the Houston Chronicle reported in the spring. The crown jewel of this roster is Manning, who enters his first year as the starter after throwing for 939 yards and accounting for a combined 13 touchdowns in the backup role to Quinn Ewers as a redshirt freshman. Manning is part of four consecutive signing classes ranked among the top five nationally by the major recruiting services. The No. 1-ranked class inked in this winter included four five-star and 14 four-star recruits, with eight signees ranked among 247Sports' top 85 prospects overall. Another 11 players joined the program through the transfer portal, with as many as five projected to start. "We have a bunch of good players and follow his lead," Manning said of Sarkisian. "This is a big-time conference. It's tough each week. But I think we've done a pretty good job. I'm hoping to carry that forward." To some degree, every program in the Power Four is trying to lean on NIL and the portal to build a deeper roster that layers traditional recruiting and player development with more established players acquired as transfers. The Longhorns' NIL offerings have joined the program's inherent advantages - members of an elite conference, one of the nation's strongest brands, competitive in the championship race - to turn Texas back into a trendy destination for the top prospects out of high school or the portal. "We're trying to build a roster that is one that can withstand the test of time," said Sarkisian. "We never wanted to come here and be a one-year-wonder team and then the next year be not very good. So we're trying to be sustainable for a long period of time. I think that that's what good programs do." No player embodies the program's enviable collection of NFL-ready talent more than Manning, who chose Texas because of his close relationship with Sarkisian and the chance to carve out his own reputation away from the shadows cast by his family's quarterback legacy. Like few before him - maybe his uncle, Peyton, and former Heisman Trophy-winning quarterbacks such as Tim Tebow - Manning will be watched, monitored and scrutinized at a level unmatched by any other active player in the Bowl Subdivision, his every performance held against the obscenely high standard set by his name, location and obvious physical gifts. "I take football pretty seriously," Manning said. "Other than that, just a regular guy." Handling hype and expectations A steady stream of factors have combined to make this the most highly anticipated season of Texas football in decades - a statement in itself given the annual hype around the program - and raised the boom-or-bust stakes to the point where anything less than an SEC crown and multiple playoff wins could be seen as a disappointment. One is the Longhorns' back-to-back playoff berths, with both years ending with the offense having opportunities in the red zone and in range of delivering an appearance in the championship game. (Fixing ongoing red-zone issues is a "huge emphasis of ours" this offseason, Sarkisian said.) The second is the wealth of depth and experience on the roster. While not necessarily represented in previous starting experience at Texas, which brings back only nine starters from last season, the run of top-ranked signing and portal classes in a row have created a conveyer-belt type of depth-chart substitution where rising stars such as sophomore edge rusher Colin Simmons (nine sacks in 2024) are poised to transition from key reserve roles into the starting lineup. And the third is Manning. If he plays well and the Longhorns win the SEC, Manning will be fodder for talk-show debate centered on the possibility that he enters the NFL draft after one season as the starter; if Texas struggles, the redshirt sophomore could easily become the scapegoat. There's no question the Longhorns are deserving of the hype. But what will decide this season is how Texas manages these intense expectations against a schedule that opens with a rematch at No. 2 Ohio State, features road trips to Florida and Georgia, includes the annual neutral-site matchup with Oklahoma and ends with the first matchup against Texas A&M at DKR-Texas Memorial Stadium since 2010. "But I also say we're the University of Texas, and the standard is the standard here, and that's competing for championships year in and year out," said Sarkisian. "It didn't matter when we were in the previous conference. It didn't matter now that we're in the SEC. It is what it is."
