‘Evict the Charleston Scroungers': row in Lewes over the Bloomsbury group's legacy
When the doors closed on two art shows in the Sussex town of Lewes last weekend, a record number of people had crossed the threshold of Southover House to look at works by Picasso and Grayson Perry.
For 18 months, the former council office building has housed a pop-up outpost of Charleston, the former home of key members of the Bloomsbury group, which is nearby in the village of Firle.
But despite its popularity over half-term, Lewes's new Charleston site is at risk. District councillors are to decide on Thursday whether to pull the plug or extend the lease on the site for another 25 years. A fresh lease would allow for a collaboration with three prestigious cultural institutions; the Victoria and Albert Museum, the National Portrait Gallery and the Tate.
While many who live in Lewes and the surrounding area at the foot of the South Downs hope that Charleston wins the day, members of a vociferous local campaign group are dismayed to see a council property given over to what one told the Observer he regards as an old-fashioned 'legacy', or establishment, arts organisation.
Other protesters have argued that the site should be given instead to the NHS, or to a youth organisation – or perhaps used to create much-needed housing.
A few angry fly posters have encouraged local people to rise up and 'Evict the Charleston Scroungers', urging the council to give health professionals the keys to Southover House, which they claim has 'inexplicably been given to a group of undeserving conceptual artists'.
Nathaniel Hepburn, Charleston's director, knows that some will be against a longer lease but said he hopes the district council will see the risk of ending the self-funded cultural project after 'an amazingly successful first 18 months'.
The leader of the Green-led Lewes district council, Zoe Nicholson, is a fan. 'It's done a fantastic amount, but one of the most important things to me is the amazing job they've done of exposing our young people to what the arts can be, especially when the government funding for this area has dropped away,' she said. 'As a small local authority, we would be doing something that really makes a difference, without any grant funding or national funding and yet with some great partnerships.'
Charleston, the historic home of painters Vanessa Bell and Duncan Grant, took over the 23,000 sq metre site when the district council offices moved to Newhaven.
Within a few months, at a cost of less than £1m – raised largely from local donations – it set up a venue that now attracts about 2,000 visitors a week and runs an educational partnership with the neighbouring further education college.
While it receives no public subsidy, almost half its visitors enter for free, or on concessionary tickets, due to a monthly 'pay what you can' scheme.
At the heart of the row is the popular image of the Bloomsbury group as an entitled cluster of indolent aesthetes. In fact, although largely well-born and London-raised, Grant, Bell and their frequent visitors, Roger Fry and Bell's sister, Virginia Woolf, had all turned their backs on respectable society and material comfort to pursue art, learning and their radical theories in peace.
Woolf was anti-authority and evangelised for public access to books and art, once writing: 'To admit authorities, however heavily furred and gowned, into our libraries and let them tell us how to read, what to read, what value to place upon what we read, is to destroy the spirit of freedom which is the breath of those sanctuaries.'
Nicholson said the factors being weighed in the renewal decision are the likely benefits to the town's economy and the work planned to make the site accessible to low-income families. 'We don't want to sell off our assets if we don't have to,' she added.
'If we can do something for the public good, we will try to protect it in perpetuity. I've heard people asking why this shouldn't be a place for our youth or perhaps new council houses. They are good questions, but we looked at converting it into housing – and we'd have to spend a lot to make it acceptable. Anyway, we are doing that in other places.'
A new health centre, she added, is also planned in the area.
Charleston, close to the home of Woolf and her husband, Leonard, was once a centre for discussion and creativity in the 1920s and 30s and is now the custodian of the Bloomsbury collection of art. Among its portraits is one of another regular guest, the philosopher and economist John Maynard Keynes, currently on loan to Sotheby's.
'When Keynes was conceiving what later became the Arts Council, he lived at Charleston and then at nearby Tilton,' said Hepburn. 'He was thinking of towns like Lewes when he wrote: 'Certainly, in every blitzed town in this country one hopes that the local authority will make provision for a central group of buildings for drama and music and art. There could be no better memorial of a war to save the freedom of the spirit of the individual.' Now, more than 80 years later, the new arts centre he dreamed of might be about to happen.'
A plan to develop the site as the National Bloomsbury Gallery, agreed with directors of the three national museums, would see large Bloomsbury group collections being taken out of London storage for display. Hepburn might well use Woolf's own words this week when he tries to persuade Lewes to secure a building he argues will bring treasure to their doorstep. 'Never pretend that the things you haven't got are not worth having,' Woolf wrote.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Exclusive: Sarah, Duchess of York: My ‘profound' trauma in childhood and public life
It is an extraordinarily frank series of revelations. But then Sarah, Duchess of York, has always had a willingness to wear her heart on her sleeve. Writing exclusively for The Telegraph, the Duchess describes 'the profound scars' of her childhood that 'led to feelings of unworthiness [that] contributed to an unhealthy attitude to food that often threatened to spiral into a full-scale eating disorder'. She writes, too, of being marked by 'tabloid headlines of the 1980s and 1990s' and more recent 'comments on social media (which I regard as a cesspit)'. Such was the extent of recent online vitriol, combined with a double cancer diagnosis, that she says her mind was forced 'to some dark places'. Coming to terms with all this, she says, was brought on by long discussions of post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) during a visit to a Swiss clinic. Her revelations, which you can read in full below, are a heart-rending reminder that this was a woman cruelly nicknamed the 'Duchess of Pork' and 'Fat Fergie' when she gained weight during her first pregnancy. Such language would never be tolerated today. It is with characteristic candour that she admits that her difficult childhood has had a much more profound effect on her adult life than she ever realised. Her description of how her mother's decision to leave the family when she was 12 for a new life in South America 'led to feelings of unworthiness' explains quite a lot of the Duchess's difficulties. As well as contributing to her 'unhealthy attitude to food', it perhaps also throws some light on why she has always tended to be so trusting of those who have shown her any attention. When her mother, Susan, abruptly abandoned her to live with an Argentinian polo player Hector Barrantes, Sarah was left to look after her father, Major Ron Ferguson, with her elder sister Jane, who later moved to Australia. Tragedy struck in 1998 when Susan Barrantes was killed in a car crash, aged 61. Coming just a year after the death of her beloved sister-in-law, Princess Diana, in a car crash – it left the Duchess completely bereft. She has previously blamed her fragile emotional state on her parents' marriage breakdown. In a 2018 TV interview with US show Modern Hero, she said: 'Suddenly she'd gone and she never came back and I never saw her again really. I built a huge wall to the real Sarah. And I believed it was because I was worthless. Why would you leave your child? You wouldn't.' Little wonder, then, that Sarah has always stuck by her ex-husband, Prince Andrew, with whom she still shares a home at Royal Lodge, Windsor, despite his own string of nightmare headlines. She was similarly unwaveringly loyal to her father following revelations he had frequented a London massage parlour, The Wigmore Club, in 1988. Father and daughter remained extremely close until Major Ferguson's death in 2003, aged 71. He had cancer during the last decade of his life, having been diagnosed with prostate cancer in 1996 as well as skin cancer. The Duchess had a similar 'double diagnosis' of breast cancer and skin cancer in 2023 and 2024 – which has also had an understandable impact on her mental health. As she writes: 'Most recently, I don't mind admitting that my mind went to some dark places – focusing on my own mortality – when I was diagnosed with first breast cancer and then skin cancer, which my father had when he died and also killed my best friend.' This is not the first time Sarah has admitted to seeking help for her internal struggles. Like Diana, she dabbled with psychics and, in 1992, was reported to have visited a 'mystic healer' called Madame Vasso. That was the year she suffered her most excruciating embarrassment, as tabloid headlines screamed 'Fergie Toe-Job' to accompany photographs of Texan multi-millionaire John Bryan sucking her toes while she sunbathed topless during a holiday in the south of France with her daughters Princesses Beatrice and Eugenie. To make matters even worse, Sarah was on holiday with the Royal family at Balmoral Castle when the gobsmacking images emerged. She had to walk into breakfast that morning as all the newspapers were laid out for the family – including the late Queen and Prince Philip – to see. Princess Diana summed up the mood in the Scottish Highlands with a message to journalist Richard Kay which simply read: 'The redhead's in trouble'. Quite how the Duchess, now 65, coped with that unedifying episode is anyone's guess. But the pain of being in the public eye didn't end there. The mother of two, who was married to Prince Andrew from 1986 to 1996, ended up being the subject of another tabloid exposé in 2010, when she was filmed by the News of the World offering Mazher Mahmood, an undercover reporter posing as an Indian businessman, access to Prince Andrew for £500,000. She later tried to sue Rupert Murdoch's News Group Newspapers for £45 million in lost earnings. If these high-profile incidents weren't hard enough, spendthrift Sarah also had a succession of debt problems – and courted controversy once again in 2011 when it emerged that convicted paedophile Jeffrey Epstein had helped her to avoid bankruptcy. She later admitted taking money from Epstein had been a 'gigantic error'. Such highs and lows have helped make her the most relatable of all the members of the Royal family. Lately, her willingness to confront the lows confirms a fragility that has endeared her to the masses; something that was illustrated by the cheers from the crowd when she arrived at Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's 2018 wedding. This latest admission once again serves as a reminder that the Royals are, at heart, just like the rest of us: real people who carry the emotional baggage of the journey they have been on. Mental health knows no boundaries by Sarah, Duchess of York As a mother, a public figure, and someone who has experienced the profound challenges of mental health, I have always believed in the power of openness, kindness and compassion. But being open about the struggles I have faced has not always been easy. I've always known there were issues I needed to address, stemming from my childhood and my time in the public eye. Then I was diagnosed with cancer, twice in the same year, something that would be challenging for anyone in terms of mental as well as physical health. I've always worked hard on my emotional wellbeing, so as well as exploring these issues, I was keen to understand how I could better use whatever platform I might have to advocate for more open discussion about mental health challenges and better policies in this area. I am particularly concerned about the crisis in mental health we are seeing in our young people. There are escalating rates of anxiety, depression and other wellbeing issues in the next generation. This crisis is driven by a combination of social, economic, and digital factors, compounded by the many challenges people face in accessing timely and effective support. All of this inspired my recent visit to Paracelsus Recovery in Zurich, which kindly hosted me as a guest. I am not embarrassed to reveal the clinic offered me a sanctuary, renowned as it is for its bespoke, cutting-edge treatment for those grappling with mental health and addiction issues – particularly those whose struggles are often hidden behind the facade of a public role. You may have heard of Paracelsus, named after the 16th-century Swiss physician and pioneer who went against the grain by declaring that those suffering from mental illness were not possessed by evil spirits but deserved humane treatment instead. The clinic that bears his name has proved successful because of two remarkable individuals: Dr Thilo Beck, the clinic's lead psychiatrist, and Jan Gerber, its chief executive and founder. Their insights into conditions such as complex post-traumatic stress disorder, adult attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and the need for mental health advocacy have left an indelible mark on me and made me determined to do more. Dr Beck, with his decades of experience and roles advising governments on health policy, and his determination to make his expertise available to all, doing extraordinary work with homeless people suffering from mental health and addiction problems, provided an understanding of complex PTSD and adult ADHD. He explained that these conditions often manifest in subtle ways, making them challenging to diagnose, especially in high-functioning individuals. I learnt that complex PTSD, resulting from prolonged exposure to trauma, can lead to an inability to control or regulate one's emotional responses, feelings of detachment and a pervasive sense of hopelessness. I wasn't there to be diagnosed, but we discussed my own childhood and the profound scars that were left when my mother left the family when I was 12 for a new life in South America. This certainly led to feelings of unworthiness and I'm sure contributed to an unhealthy attitude to food that often threatened to spiral into a full-scale eating disorder. Spending most of my life in the public eye has been a great privilege, but has also presented its own challenges. The tabloid headlines of the 1980s and 1990s and intrusions into private life have doubtless left a mark, as do comments on social media (which I regard as a cesspit). Most recently, I don't mind admitting that my mind went to some dark places – focusing on my own mortality – when I was diagnosed with first breast cancer and then skin cancer, which my father had when he died and also killed my best friend. A lot has been written about ADHD in recent years, and I've sometimes wondered whether there might be signs of it in me. Dr Beck explained how adult ADHD often presents as chronic disorganisation, impulsivity and difficulties in maintaining focus, which can be misinterpreted as character flaws rather than a neurological condition. However, individuals with ADHD often think outside the box, leading to innovative solutions and creative breakthroughs. Their ability to connect seemingly unrelated ideas can be a significant advantage in fields requiring originality. Despite being easily distracted, they also often have periods of what's called 'hyperfocus', where they can concentrate intensely on tasks that interest them. This can lead to high productivity and exceptional performance in areas such as research, writing and creative endeavours. So people with adult ADHD can often be immensely successful and powerful. What struck me most was Dr Beck's emphasis on the importance of individualised treatment plans when treating mental health conditions. Patients must undergo comprehensive assessments, including functional medicine and genetic tests, to understand the root causes of their symptoms. This holistic approach ensures that treatments are not just reactive but proactive, addressing both the mind and the body. Jan Gerber shared his insights into the societal stigma surrounding mental health. He noted that individuals in high-pressure or public roles often feel compelled to maintain a facade of perfection, leading to isolation and often untreated mental health issues. I could certainly identify with this. When you're in the public eye, there's a need to be the proverbial swan – gliding effortlessly on the surface, while paddling frantically beneath the water. One of the reasons I am writing this is because I agree with Jan that we need to promote open conversations about mental health and how we can improve access to mental healthcare across society for all. Only by addressing the stigma head-on can society move towards a more compassionate and understanding approach to mental health. He also introduced me to some cutting-edge therapies. One of the most innovative I witnessed was the Satori Chair. Today, there is increasing research to demonstrate that music and sounds can have a profound effect on our minds and body. This state-of-the-art device uses vibrational sound therapy designed to retrain the brain to relax, producing deep, lasting levels of relaxation, meditation and sleep. For me, its effects were remarkable. Another groundbreaking treatment I experienced is intermittent hypoxia-hyperoxia therapy (IHHT), a therapeutic approach that involves alternating cycles of hypoxia (low oxygen) and hyperoxia (high oxygen) to stimulate physiological responses in the body. Administered through controlled breathing sessions, there is emerging evidence that IHHT can enhance cellular function, improve cardiovascular health and support cognitive performance. It left me feeling energised and focused. Epigenetic and gut biology testing is also used, enabling targeted treatment via IVs, micronutrients and supplements and specially engineered diets to rebalance the biochemistry of the brain and body. What the visit taught me is that mental health knows no boundaries. It affects individuals across all walks of life, and it is imperative that we continue to break down the barriers of stigma and silence. As a society, we need to foster an environment where seeking help is seen as a strength, not a weakness. If you or someone you know is struggling, I encourage you to seek help. You are not alone, and there is no shame in taking the steps towards healing. Let us continue to support one another and work towards a future where mental health is treated with the care, respect and attention it deserves.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
My unexpected Pride icon: Jurassic Park's strutting, swaggering T rex is pure camp
'That's camp,' proclaimed my drag queen friend Vanity as we watched the T rex rip a tyre off a Jeep in the first Jurassic Park movie. It's 2012, 2am and we're in her bedroom playing our favourite Jurassic Park drinking game, where you swig every time you see a dinosaur. 'Is it, though?' I said, doubtfully, dipping a Walkers Sensation in some coleslaw. 'Course it is. All the gays love Jurassic Park. Don't be an idiot, Jones.' She pointedly slapped down the lid on the coleslaw as if that were the end of the matter. I thought about it a bit and ultimately agreed with her. I absolutely loved Jurassic Park. And so did just about every queer person I knew. Jurassic Park, in fact, made me feel proud. Prouder than seeing a load of 00s popstrels perform at Pride parades, prouder than drinking in the street in Soho, prouder even than M&S's Pride sandwich. Granted, my judgment was a little clouded from the drinking game. But still. I've since wondered if this was specific to my strange little bubble of pop-culture-obsessed London reprobates. But its surprisingly innuendo-ready quotes ('clever girl', 'hold on to your butts', 'dinosaur eats man, woman inherits the Earth') and unforgettable performances (human and raptor) are an enduring staple everywhere from drag brunches to bleary afterparties. London's historic queer venue the Royal Vauxhall Tavern held a Jurassic Park cabaret night in 2023 called 'Life Finds a Slay'. In San Francisco last year, the Brava theatre hosted 'Jurassic Drag', two Jurassic Park nights celebrating various drag legends ('they've survived a hostile world and trekked the Earth collectively for more than 170 years … which we all know in drag time is roughly 250 million'). Also last year, the Canadian podcaster and academic Hannah McGregor published a feminist-focused queer memoir, Clever Girl, billed as 'a smart and incisive exploration of everyone's favourite dinosaur movie and the female dinosaurs who embody what it means to be angry, monstrous and free'. (An honourable mention goes to the British gay couple and their dog who went viral in 2020 for recreating scenes from the films during lockdown.) It makes sense when you look at the first two movies. Their director, Steven Spielberg, has always had a propensity for the camper, more fun side of mild to moderate peril, flinging damsels into snake pits and children into shark-infested waters at the first chance he gets. He and the screenwriter David Koepp wield this impish inclination with gusto in Jurassic Park and Jurassic Park: The Lost World, whether it's a dilophosaurus wobbling her wattles or Julianne Moore gasping on glass over a gulch. Laura Dern is constantly in peril in the first movie – and for a lot of gay men, women in peril is a favourite genre – there is a stampede of psychosexual and misogynistic issues to dive into with that one. (Other notable women-in-peril franchises beloved of gay men include Scream, Buffy, Tomb Raider and, depending on Tyra Banks's mood, America's Next Top Model.) Also, if you are a millennial gay man, Jeff Goldblum's tanned, heaving bosom inside a liberally unbuttoned shirt was definitely at least part of your sexual awakening. A special mention should go to Bob Peck as park warden Robert Muldoon, who sported short-shorts that would make even Lara Croft raise one of her perfectly plucked eyebrows. (The later Jurassic World films are notably sanitised, safe and sexless in comparison – like smooth, scaly iPhones.) Really, though, if I stand up in the Jeep, take off my sunglasses and really look at it, the main reason I find pride in Jurassic Park is right there, rumbling and stomping in front of me: the dinosaurs. Dinosaurs are deeply camp – their fierce, confident assuredness followed by their fiery, dramatic downfall. Their strutting, swaggering gaits. It's very drag, with their relentless energy and fierce joie de vivre, not to mention their various ruffs and feathers and talons and shiny teeth. They just served. Some may say it's ridiculous to have an emotional affinity with 65m-year-old extinct reptiles, to which I say: why is it any more ridiculous than having an affinity with Strictly Come Dancing or Taylor Swift or raccoons? It's not. It's completely normal. Now, pass those night-vision goggles: we're going to Hampstead Heath.
Top Gear
an hour ago
- Top Gear
Question of the Week: which movie car do you dream of owning the most?
Question of the Week A Fast and Furious legend came and went for sale all too quickly last week, and that got us thinking… Skip 4 photos in the image carousel and continue reading Lead movie cars are cool when they're done right, and Han's Veilside 'Fortune' Mazda RX-7 from Tokyo Drift is one of the finest examples of this. That it hogged most of the attention in a movie packed with characterful metal - from Sean's RB26-swapped '67 Stang to Takashi's menacing 350Z - is telling of just how right its builders got it. Advertisement - Page continues below So you can imagine our frustration that one of the three original cars used in filming appeared for sale last week… before the listing ended on a whim. Chances are, someone saw the £345k price as a worthwhile investment. Shame, that. We were just about to hit 'post' on a bound-to-be-successful crowdfunding pitch... sniff. You might like Just look at it. That body kit completely transforms the RX-7's looks with new light signatures and a spate of bumper attachments. Chromed and dished five-spoke alloys sit at each corner, and the gorgeous silhouette is finished up in a 'House of Kolor Orange' and black livery. It was left completely stock, too, so the sequential twin-turbo, twin-rotor '13B' engine still put out 276bhp, got to 62mph in 5.3s and topped out at 155mph. No devilishly over-complicated internals here; just brutal Nineties simplicity that probably could be driven with a pair of Uwabakis on. Advertisement - Page continues below Sure, the bucket seats are slightly worn, but you will find an aftermarket sound system, a DVD screen on the passenger's side, and lots of carbon fibre along the dashboard and centre console. That R34-humbling NOS bottle is still perched between the seats, albeit probably empty after all these years. Still, very desirable. Anyway, that got us thinking: if you could pick one, and only one, which movie car do you dream of owning more than any other? Any movie, any era. Let us know below, and we'll round up our favourite answers at the end of the week. Go. Thank you for subscribing to our newsletter. Look out for your regular round-up of news, reviews and offers in your inbox. Get all the latest news, reviews and exclusives, direct to your inbox.
