US appeals court rules for Sorkin's 'Mockingbird' play in copyright dispute
Upholding a trial judge's order, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit said that, opens new tab after Lee reclaimed her rights to the 1990 adaptation from the Dramatic Publishing Company, the company lost its right to block Atticus LLC's "non-first-class" performances of the 2018 version.
Attorneys for the companies did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the decision.
Lee wrote "To Kill a Mockingbird," her classic Southern novel about Scout Finch and her honorable attorney father Atticus, in 1960. She granted Dramatic the right to develop a stage adaptation of the book in 1969. Their contract said that Dramatic's version would be "the only one the amateur acting rights of which [Lee] will permit to be leased and/or licensed."
Lee terminated the contract and reclaimed her rights under U.S. copyright law in 2011. She gave producer Scott Rudin's company the right to produce what became the Sorkin adaptation in 2015. That company later assigned its rights to Atticus LLC.
Sorkin's adaptation was first staged in 2018 after Rudin's company resolved a separate lawsuit from Lee's estate alleging that the play deviated too far from Lee's novel.
An arbitrator found in 2019 during a previous dispute between Atticus and Dramatic that the latter maintained its exclusive right to "non-first-class" theater performances of "To Kill a Mockingbird" despite Lee's termination. Atticus filed a lawsuit in New York challenging the arbitrator's ruling, and a federal judge ruled for Atticus in 2023.
The 2nd Circuit agreed with the lower court on Tuesday that Dramatic did not have the right to block Atticus from allowing amateur performances of Sorkin's play following Lee's termination of Dramatic's contract.
The case is Atticus LLC v. Dramatic Publishing Co, U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit, No. 23-1226.
For Atticus: Wook Hwang of Sheppard Mullin Richter & Hampton
For Dramatic: Willy Jay of Goodwin Procter
Read more:
Harper Lee estate sues Broadway's 'To Kill a Mockingbird' play
Broadway's 'To Kill a Mockingbird' may be scrapped in legal flap
Broadway's 'Mockingbird' play to go ahead after dispute settled
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time Out
6 hours ago
- Time Out
Brookfield Place is hosting a free Tennis Open this month, and you can register to play today
Brookfield Place is serving up summer fun with a side of tennis. The downtown hub has once again transformed its scenic Waterfront Plaza into a pop-up center court for the 10th annual Brookfield Place Open, in partnership with the Tennis Channel. And yes, it's completely free to play. Whether you're an aspiring Federer or just want to volley with friends at golden hour, registration for open-court play opened today, August 7. Reserve your slot fast—each half-hour session allows 2–4 players, and space tends to go quickly. Walk-ups are welcome, but only if slots haven't already been snagged. One court will be available for casual play, and racquets and tennis balls are provided (though BYOR—bring your own racquet—is strongly encouraged due to limited gear). All players must sign a waiver at check-in and minors will need a guardian present. Miss your time slot by more than five minutes? Your spot goes back into the wild. Beyond the baseline, Brookfield Place is turning summer into a lifestyle. Post-match, swing by the Tartinery Shack for their exclusive Honey Dew Cooler, a refreshing U.S. Open -inspired cocktail made with fresh honeydew juice, mint, lime and soda water. Or, if you're feeling fancy, head to Sixpoint Brewery for a Peach Melon Ball Spritz (Southern Tier vodka, melon liqueur, and brut Champagne—need we say more?). The Brookfield Place Open 2025 runs through the end of August as part of the complex's seasonal slate of events, designed to lure locals and officegoers out of their air-conditioned caves and into the summer sun. Alongside the tennis, expect happy hours, al fresco bites and waterfront views made for golden-hour Instagramming. So whether you're practicing your backhand or just want an excuse to sip cocktails by the Hudson, Brookfield Place is the spot to play, chill and soak up peak NYC summer.
Leader Live
8 hours ago
- Leader Live
Danny Dyer says Bafta win was ‘very emotional moment after 35 years in the game'
The former EastEnders star, 48, won the male performance in a comedy award for his role playing Lee in the Sky Max series Mr Bigstuff. Dyer told the PA news agency: 'I would like to think that I could maybe inspire some people that feel that they don't stand a chance, being from a working class background, that you can, if you're committed and you have belief in yourself and ambition, that you can certainly be and do whatever you want to do, whatever you want to achieve in life. 'I think me maybe winning that Bafta was a moment of going, 'Oh, OK, you know what? Anyone can do it.' 'I'm not knocking what I've done, or my achievements or my hard work I've put in, but I do think that it's quite an elite thing, that Bafta thing. 'I think that to give me my flowers after 35 years in the game was a very emotional moment for me and I hope it's inspired a lot of other young kids coming through to just keep at it. Keep at it and never give up.' Speaking about a lack of working class people in the TV and film industry, Dyer said: 'I don't know why it's changed so much. It's a real shame. We need to do something about it.' Dyer also said 'there's room for another series' of Mr Bigstuff, which follows brothers Lee and Glen, played by Ryan Sampson, who are look for their estranged father in series two, after finding out he is alive. 'The character Lee is quite relevant at the moment, in the sense of, the whole masculinity thing, what's going on at the moment with men, and what's true masculinity and what's toxic masculinity,' said Dyer. He added: 'Lee is quite lovable, and he's got no filter, and he does stand up for what's right… it's a funny little layer to Lee.' A post shared by Deliveroo (@deliveroo) Dyer has had a busy past year or so, having starred in Disney+ series Rivals and as the protagonist in Nick Love's comedy-drama Marching Powder. Reflecting on life in the limelight, he said: 'It's really odd to think of what people's perceptions are of me. I don't know what that is. I think I represent different things to different people. 'I think, living in this world of social media, which is really quite destructive and not very nice, it doesn't breed happiness, and people commenting on stuff… I feel like places like Facebook, you might get a lot of hate, obviously Twatter or Twitter, or whatever the f*** it's called, just an awful place to go. 'Instagram's a bit kinder. Only really dabble with Instagram. So for me, there's reality, which is the real world, and then there's the online world, which I feel is a load of bollocks. 'I can walk the streets and no one will give me no f****** aggravation, I get nothing but love. If I was to just look at, say Twitter (now called X), then I would never leave my house.' Dyer is the new star of a Deliveroo advert in which he proclaims to be a 'tosser', asking viewers to join him in eating salads as well as vegetables and other fresh produce.
Western Telegraph
8 hours ago
- Western Telegraph
Oasis Wembley Stadium: Man named after falling to death
Lee Claydon was pronounced dead at the scene after attending the concert on Saturday (August 2). Witnesses described the 'horrendous' scenes after the man reportedly fell from a balcony during the band's long-anticipated reunion tour. His family have since named Lee - a 'loving family man' - as the victim. In a GoFundMe set up by his brother Aaron, it reads: 'Our family has been turned upside down and are struggling to deal with this devastation and unexpected loss.' It said: 'Lee was a loving family man who was a role model to his son Harry and was loved so much by all of his family. 'Lee would have done anything for any of us and he was taken from us far too soon and we will miss him very much. 'Lee loved all outdoor activities, one of his favourite hobbies was fishing. 'He also loved music and his guitar. He also really enjoyed going to watch and support the boys and his nephew at their football games.' According to the fundraiser, he has left behind his son, dad, partner, brothers, sisters, nephews and niece. It is hoped the GoFundMe can help his partner financially and emotionally as they are 'going through any family's worst nightmare.' The fall happened during the latest in a run of stadium shows for the band's sell-out Live '25 reunion tour – their first since splitting in 2009. Recommended reading: A spokesperson for Wembley Stadium said: 'On Saturday (August 2), Wembley Stadium medics, the London Ambulance Service and the police attended to a concert-goer who was found with injuries consistent with a fall. 'Despite their efforts, the fan very sadly died. Our thoughts go out to his family, who have been informed and are being supported by specially trained police officers. 'The police have asked anyone who witnessed the incident to contact them.'
