Nurse called transgender doctor ‘weirdo' and ‘it', tribunal told
She was placed on special leave after Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment, and cited concerns about 'patient care'.
Ms Peggie has lodged a claim against NHS Fife and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act 2010, including sexual harassment; harassment related to a protected belief; indirect discrimination; and victimisation.
Lindsey Nicoll, an emergency nurse practitioner who became friends with Ms Peggie in 2010 and began holidaying with her in 2017, said the veteran nurse would use racial slurs and posted jokes about floods in Pakistan which killed 3,000 people into a 'Benidorm group chat' in 2017.
Ms Nicoll said that in 2024 the pair were at an airport when Ms Peggie allegedly saw a group of women wearing burkas and appeared 'disgusted', the tribunal heard.
The witness said that after the trip she removed herself from the group chat and explained she 'wouldn't be spending time in Sandie's company'.
Ms Nicoll alleged that at a lunch on September 4 2023, Ms Peggie referred to Dr Upton as 'it' and 'weirdo', the tribunal heard.
Ms Nicoll said: 'I can distinctively remember her saying 'weirdo' at lunch.'
She said that in February 2024 her ex-friend had posted in a group chat 'well it appears official, Sandie Peggie vs Beth Upton', and that Ms Peggie had inadvertently messaged someone in error 'asking for photos of that weirdo', the tribunal heard.
Asked about a message sent by Ms Peggie which read 'can you post a picture of that weirdo', Ms Nicoll said: 'I obviously didn't realise the weirdo she was referring to was Beth.'
She said that Dr Upton was mentioned at the lunch 'immediately', the tribunal heard.
The witness said: 'She started talking about a doctor who had been working in A&E about three or four weeks, she was really angry about the doctor being there, referring to the doctor as 'weirdo'; 'it'; 'him'.
'I remember someone saying 'why can't you live and let live?' She seemed full of anger and hate about this doctor who she had only just met.'
During cross-examination by Ms Peggie's lawyer, Naomi Cunningham, the witness agreed she was aware of allegations Dr Upton had 'caused chaos' in a previous job including allegedly complaining about being misgendered by dementia patients and admitted patient confidentiality could have been breached in the group chat, the tribunal heard.
Ms Cunningham said: 'Do you agree your regulator places some stress on confidentiality, so sharing patient details, chatting about patients by name on a chat like this would be breach of regulations?'
Ms Nicoll said: 'Yes, it would.'
The witness provided 10 jokes shared by Ms Peggie regarding flooding in Pakistan, branding them 'racist', but admitted posting a laughing emoji when Ms Peggie posted saying 'Sorry folks if that makes me racist', the tribunal heard.
Ms Nicoll said she may have 'enabled' Ms Peggie and that it was 'likely' she had behaved as alleged towards Dr Upton, describing her as 'rude' and 'bigoted', the court heard.
Other users of the group chat posted jokes including about the adult baby diaper loving community, the tribunal heard.
Ms Cunningham said: 'Do you disagree you were the only member of the Benidorm group who disagrees with Sandie's stance?'
The witness said: 'My reason for feeling the way I do is to do with Sandie's views and how she likely behaved to the doctor. I accept everyone has got different views about being in a changing room with a transgender person.'
The witness denied she was 'hostile' to Ms Peggie but added: 'It's something I certainly felt strongly about and felt I needed to do.'
Messages written by Ms Nicoll were shared, including: 'She's a fanny who is going to end up with a massive payout, I hope she's struck off', and 'if anyone was to ask for statement about Sandie's character I would do it. She should be struck off, I hope she is', the tribunal heard.
Ms Cunningham said she was 'attempting to end Sandie's career', but the witness said she felt there was no place for 'bigotry' in nursing.
The witness said: 'I've watched her stare in disgust at people walking through an airport in burkas, I've heard her calling a transgender woman a weirdo, and I don't think it's acceptable, no.'
She added: 'I think it's important for people to understand Sandie's character, the bigoted racism that Sandie is all for. I don't think there is a place for it in nursing. I think we should be showing people compassion and empathy, and respect, and I don't think Sandie does that.'
Ms Peggie will be recalled at the hearing on Tuesday for further questions.
The tribunal continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
3 hours ago
- Times
Trans doctor Beth Upton lamented lack of guidelines on changing rooms
The transgender doctor at the centre of a landmark tribunal over women-only spaces lamented the lack of clear guidelines about access to female changing rooms, documents have shown. Dr Beth Upton said NHS Fife potentially missed an opportunity to intervene before the incident involving the doctor and the nurse Sandie Peggie in a female changing room at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife, on Christmas Eve 2023. Peggie has taken the health board and Upton to an employment tribunal claiming she faced discrimination and harassment as a result of being forced to share female changing rooms with the doctor, who is biologically male but identifies as female. Sandie Peggie told Upton that the doctor had no right to be in the women's changing rooms at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife IAIN MASTERTON/ALAMY Peggie confronted Upton in the women's changing rooms at the hospital's A&E department, telling Upton she believed the doctor had no right to be there.
The Sun
9 hours ago
- The Sun
Woman, 25, complaining of bloating and pain told stomach ‘turned to clay' after 4 months of suffering common condition
A WOMAN was left with a stomach "like clay" after suffering from a common condition for four months. Medics who examined the 25-year-old after she turned up at A&E with intense pain and bloating"left indents" on her stomach while pressing on it. 5 5 The unnamed patient said she'd been struggling to poop for four whole months and had a history of constipation. A CT scan laid bare the extent of the problem, showing her gastrointestinal tract was packed with months worth of stool. Faecal impaction – where poo builds up in the last part of the large intestine – is a long-term complication of constipation. Upon examination, doctors found the lower part of her stomach 'felt like clay', and found they could 'leave indents' in her abdomen when pressing on it due to the huge stool blockage. The scan also found she had a 15cm-diameter redundant sigmoid colon – an abnormally long colon that folds and twists within the abdominal cavity, and can cause constipation. The colon was stretched out and had a large amount of stool in it. The woman opted to have manual disimpaction – a procedure where hardened stool is manually broken up and removed under anaesthesia – which had to be repeated multiple times. Medics who oversaw her care wrote in the journal Cureus: "At the distal sigmoid colon, the endoscopist could not advance the colonoscope because of a lack of visibility as the stool was tough, and no amount of softening with lavage could move the stool. "Also, the practitioner could not reach that area manually, so the procedure had to be stopped." The doctor noted her colon was 'markedly dilated' and the stool 'resembled dense/moist clay'. 5 stretches to ease bloating, gas and constipation after a flight Following the procedure, the woman was given a pure liquid diet to help clear out her colon. She also had to have a packet of the laxative Miralax a day, as well as as a gallon of the colon-clearing substance GoLYTELY. Throughout her stay, she was able to poop 21 times. By the time she was discharged, she had dropped nearly 10lbs in weight - from 128.9lbs to 119lbs. 5 5 5 The patient – who is believed to have been treated in the US – had a history of chronic constipation, going back to when she was first toilet trained as a young child. She had previously had treatment for the condition, including weekly enemas and daily stool softeners, as well as attending hospital for manual removal under anaesthesia. As she noticed her constipation improving, the woman had stopped taking Miralax medication recommended by doctors – which saw the condition return with a vengeance. By the time she came to the emergency room, she had been experiencing pain for several weeks, and was not responding to over-the-counter medications, laxatives or enemas. Symptoms of constipation and when to get help You are likely constipated if: You have not had a poo at least three times during the last week or you're pooing less often than usual The poo is unusually large or small and is dry, hard or lumpy You are straining or in pain when you have a poo You feel like you haven't fully emptied your bowels You may also have a stomach ache and feel bloated or sick. If your constipation and bloating is really disrupting your day-to-day life, then it might be time to seek further help. 'I would advise seeking medical help if you experience severe and/or persistent symptoms that don't improve with lifestyle changes,' nutritionist Sophie Trotman says. This can include: Eating a healthy balanced diet and include fruits that contain sorbitol such as apples, apricots, grapes and raisins, raspberries and strawberries Drinking plenty of water and other fluids and avoid alcohol Gradually increasing the fibre in your diet Adding some wheat bran, oats or linseed to your diet Not delaying if you feel the need to poo and having a regular toilet routine to give yourself plenty of time to poo Trying a daily walk or run to help you poo more regularly 'If constipation or bloating is accompanied by severe pain, unexplained weight loss, blood in your stool, or if you're unable to pass gas or stool at all, it's important to consult with a doctor as soon as possible," Sophie adds. Plus, if you've had a sudden change in bowel habits, it is also important to consult with a doctor. This can include having softer poo, diarrhoea or constipation that is not usual for you, or needing to poop more or less often than you are used to. While she couldn't poop, she experienced "occasional involuntary leakage of watery stool every few weeks". This is a common symptom of faecal impaction. After discharge, she was scheduled to follow up with the Gastroenterology department, but failed to do so. Constipation refers to finding it hard to poo, producing hard, lumpy stools and having to strain to do so. It's very common and can affect anyone at any age. Eating too little fibre, not drinking enough water and not moving about are common culprits of constipation - as is ignoring the urge to poop. But stress and anxiety or taking certain medicines can also have an impact on your bowels. You should see a GP about constipation if it affects you regularly and treatment like lifestyle changes and laxatives doesn't seem to ease it.
Times
a day ago
- Times
Trans doctor in nurse row lamented lack of guidelines on changing rooms
The transgender doctor at the centre of a landmark tribunal over women-only spaces lamented the lack of clear guidelines about access to female changing rooms, documents have shown. Dr Beth Upton said NHS Fife potentially missed an opportunity to intervene before the incident involving the doctor and the nurse Sandie Peggie in a female changing room at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife, on Christmas Eve 2023. Peggie has taken the health board and Upton to an employment tribunal claiming she faced discrimination and harassment as a result of being forced to share female changing rooms with the doctor, who is biologically male but identifies as female. Peggie confronted Upton in the women's changing rooms at the hospital's A&E department, telling Upton she believed the doctor had no right to be there. Upton lodged a formal complaint with the board, claiming to have been subjected to a transphobic 'hate incident', which led to Peggie being suspended for several months. Peggie is now suing the health board and Dr Upton for alleged sexual harassment, belief discrimination, and victimisation under the Equality Act 2010. A previously unpublished document among hundreds included in an evidence bundle for the tribunal reveals Upton raised the absence of a clear transgender policy at the internal Fife Health and Social Care Partnership disciplinary hearing into Peggie's conduct. • Janice Turner: Class snobbery is at heart of NHS gender war The HR representative Melanie Jorgensen asked Upton at the conduct hearing in June if there had been a missed opportunity for intervention by NHS Fife before the changing-room incident. The notes of the meeting state Upton said this was 'difficult to answer' and adds the doctor 'feels potentially there was a missed opportunity'. Upton told the hearing it was 'clear the organisation do not have a policy'. The notes continue: 'Beth Upton advised that she understands the legal side of things, but also feels a lot of this would have been easier if there had been a policy document that would have confirmed what to do in this situation.' Upton's comments come after the pivotal Supreme Court judgment in April that ruled women are defined by biological sex under equalities law. Trina Budge, director of For Women Scotland who brought the legal challenge to the Supreme Court, said: 'There absolutely should be a policy and it's unacceptable that they continue without one. 'This should have been dealt with as a priority after the Supreme Court judgment. 'The policy should have made it clear that men such as Dr Upton are not allowed in female changing rooms. 'It's just creating more disasters and more tribunals for the NHS — not just NHS Fife but throughout Scotland.' Fiona McAnena, director of campaigns for the human-rights charity Sex Matters, which advocates for clarity about biological sex in law and life, said: 'This shows the risks of changing policy on the fly in response to one trans-identifying person's request. • Sandie Peggie blames her upbringing for use of racial slurs 'A sign on a door saying 'Male' or 'Female' is already a statement of policy — that the space is for one sex only, in compliance with workplace regulations. 'That is what most people will understand the sign to mean. Employers are not free to choose a different meaning of 'single-sex', or a different interpretation of laws and statutory regulations. Every employer needs to follow the law as it stands.' A spokeswoman for NHS Fife previously said: 'Throughout the course of the employment tribunal, NHS Fife has been clear that it will not comment on individuals or evidence while legal proceedings are ongoing. 'We remain respectful of the legal process and the role of the tribunal in considering all evidence presented.' A Scottish government spokesman said: 'It would be inappropriate to comment further while judicial proceedings in an employment tribunal are ongoing.'
