This controversial technology is helping to find the escaped New Orleans inmates
The cameras were part of a network of around 5,000 operated around the city by the non-profit Project NOLA, 200 of which are outfitted with facial recognition technology. State police had shared information about the jailbreak with the organization.
The incident marks a win for the organization, whose camera network is believed to be unprecedented in the United States. The group is emblematic of a growing — albeit controversial — push to use facial recognition technology to help solve crimes.
'This is the exact reason why facial recognition technology is so critical,' New Orleans Police Superintendent Anne Kirkpatrick said during a press conference earlier this week.
But as adoption of the technology has grown, advocacy groups warn that it could undermine individual privacy. Even worse, inaccurate matches by facial recognition technology systems run by police departments elsewhere have led to false arrests in other cities.
In New Orleans, those concerns may be heightened by the fact that Project NOLA is independent from local law enforcement agencies — although it shares information with police — and therefore isn't necessarily subject to the same scrutiny or accountability.
'This is the stuff of authoritarian surveillance states, and has no place in American policing,' Nathan Freed Wessler, deputy director of ACLU's Speech, Privacy and Technology Project, said in a statement following a Washington Post report about the effort earlier this week.
But Project NOLA is a community endeavor, said Executive Director Bryan Lagarde, supported by the churches, schools, businesses and individual homeowners who he says allow the group to place cameras on their properties and can remove them at any time.
'This has been a community endeavor from the very beginning,' Lagarde told CNN. 'If we ever violate public trust, (the camera network) comes down instantly and effortlessly by the community that built it.'
Project NOLA was created in 2009 to be a 'force multiplier' for local law enforcement agencies, whose resources had been impacted by Hurricane Katrina, Lagarde said. Today, the non-profit also operates 5,000 cameras in other cities around the country.
Project NOLA takes images of wanted suspects from law enforcement 'be on the lookout' alerts and feeds them into its 'hot list' system. When its network of facial recognition cameras identifies a potential match, it sends a real-time alert to law enforcement.
That's what happened on Friday, when two of the escaped inmates walked in front of Project NOLA cameras mounted on local businesses in New Orleans' French Quarter. One was arrested shortly after. The other was tracked to a housing complex where Project NOLA does not have cameras but was arrested on Tuesday thanks in part to the information provided by Project NOLA about his likely location, according to the group.
Five escapees from the Friday jailbreak remain at large.
Project NOLA cameras were also used to investigate the New Orleans terror attack last New Year's Day that killed 14 people. Lagarde declined to provide the name of the third-party company that makes the facial recognition artificial intelligence model the group uses in its cameras.
As with many applications of AI, there is no federal regulation regarding whether and how AI can be used by local law enforcement. But a number of other cities have barred the use of facial recognition by government agencies, including police, over concerns about its efficacy and ethical implications.
Research has shown that the technology is less effective at correctly identifying women and people of color than white men, fueling worries that the tech's shortcomings could have an outsize impact on historically marginalized groups. Given the history of racial bias within some US police forces, 'Black and other people of color are at greater risk of misidentification,' when facial recognition is brought into the fold, Nicol Turner Lee and Caitlin Chin Rothman wrote in a 2022 Brookings report.
CNN has reached out to NOPD for comment regarding its relationship with Project NOLA. Kirkpatrick, the police superintendent, told the Washington Post earlier this week that her agency had launched a review of officers' use of alerts provided by Project NOLA, the accuracy of the information the group provides and how the partnership fits within city rules.
Lagarde said Project NOLA has aimed to be transparent with the New Orleans community about its work, including by partnering with locals to put up its cameras and posting about its work on social media.
'All of our data is on-network, which means it comes from our own network of cameras. Our cameras are on people's homes, business, churches, schools… The facial recognition is not being paid for by tax dollars. It is not accessible directly by law enforcement,' he said. 'So, you know, we are the gatekeepers. We check everything that goes into the system make sure it's valid.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
14 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
President Donald Trump's tax law could cause Medicare cuts if Congress doesn't act, CBO says
WASHINGTON — The federal budget deficits caused by President Donald Trump's tax and spending law could trigger automatic cuts to Medicare if Congress does not act, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office reported Friday. The CBO estimates that Medicare, the federal health insurance program for Americans over age 65, could potentially see as much as $491 billion from 2027 to 2034 if Congress does not act to mitigate a 2010 law that forces across-the-board cuts to many federal programs once legislation increases the federal deficit. The latest report from CBO showed how Trump's signature tax and spending law could put new pressure on federal programs that are bedrocks of the American social safety net. Trump and Republicans pledged not to cut Medicare as part of the legislation, but the estimated $3.4 trillion that the law adds to the federal deficit over the next decade means that many Medicare programs could still see cuts. In the past, Congress has always acted to mitigate cuts to Medicare and other programs, but it would take some bipartisan cooperation to do so. Democrats, who requested the analysis from CBO, jumped on the potential cuts. 'Republicans knew their tax breaks for billionaires would force over half a trillion dollars in Medicare cuts — and they did it anyway,' said Rep. Brendan F. Boyle, the top Democrat on the House Budget Committee, in a statement. 'American families simply cannot afford Donald Trump's attacks on Medicare, Medicaid, and Obamacare.' Hospitals in rural parts of the country are already grappling with cuts to Medicaid, which is available to people with low incomes, and cuts to Medicare could exacerbate their shortfalls. As Republicans muscled the bill through Congress and are now selling it to voters back home, they have been highly critical of how CBO has analyzed the bill. They have also argued that the tax cuts will spur economic growth and pointed to $50 billion in funding for rural hospitals that was included in the package.
The Hill
14 minutes ago
- The Hill
Treasury sets limits on remaining wind and solar tax credits
The Treasury Department issued guidance on Friday that narrows which wind and solar energy projects can receive the remaining tax credits that were largely eliminated under the Republicans 'big, beautiful bill.' The legislation passed by Republicans last month axes the credits for projects that don't begin producing electricity by 2028. However, it contains an exemption for projects that begin construction over the next year. Under the law, those projects would remain eligible for the subsidies even if they don't produce electricity under the specified time frame. The Trump administration's new guidance, however, sets further restrictions on which projects are considered having begun construction. It says that construction of these projects must be 'continuous.' It also defines 'having begun construction' as having done 'physical work of a significant nature.' This includes activities like manufacturing equipment and excavating land to begin placing equipment in it. But it excludes activities like only having done surveys, test drilling or excavation for purposes of altering the landscape. The guidance also says that even if the project meets those other requirements, it still must produce electricity by the end of the fourth calendar year after it begins construction. The renewable energy industry criticized the guidance, saying it would slow the buildup of low-carbon energy sources. 'This is yet another act of energy subtraction from the Trump administration that will further delay the buildout of affordable, reliable power. American families and businesses will pay more for electricity as a result of this action, and China will continue to outpace us in the race for electricity to power AI,' said Abigail Ross Hopper, president and CEO of the Solar Energy Industries Association, in a written statement. Climate advocates hurled similar criticisms. 'The Trump administration's new tax credit guidance represents yet another senseless attack on clean energy that will drive up electricity costs, make our energy grid less reliable, harm our economy and lead to more deaths and disease from harmful air pollution. The guidance places significant new obstacles on solar and wind projects,' said Vickie Patton, general counsel, Environmental Defense Fund, in a written statement. The maneuvers come after disagreements between more moderate and conservative Republicans over how rapidly to eliminate the credits. President Trump apparently told House Freedom Caucus members he would further restrict the tax credits if they supported his bill. After it passed, he issued an executive order telling the Treasury Department to take a strict approach to limit the tax incentives. Trump has also in recent weeks used other policies to go after renewables, including efforts to slow federal approvals of wind and solar projects. Even before it came out, Sens. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) and John Curtis (R-Utah), who are more supportive of renewables than many of their GOP colleagues, raised concerns about the Treasury guidance.
Politico
42 minutes ago
- Politico
Turkish Adams Donor Sentenced
With help from Amira McKee THE FINAL STRAW? Construction executive Erden Arkan must not have friends in the Trump administration like Mayor Eric Adams does. So while the Department of Justice moved to dismiss the mayor's case, the wheels of justice kept turning for Arkan. The Turkish-American co-owner of KSK Construction Group was given a light sentence of one year probation today in Manhattan federal court. He'll also pay a $9,500 fine and $18,000 in restitution after pleading guilty in January to giving 10 employees $1,250 each to donate to Adams' campaign. But even while accepting that he broke New York City campaign finance laws, Arkan's lawyer Jonathan Rosen presented him as a victim of 'an unprecedented act of prosecutorial discretion,' suggesting that federal prosecutors with the Southern District of New York wanted to salvage some sort of a win following the tumult and rounds of resignations over the dismissal of Adams' case. Rosen also suggested Arkan's case never should have been brought in federal court in the first place, arguing he was 'targeted… to serve some greater end in a bureaucratic power struggle over the Adams case.' While an official from the Turkish consulate helped coordinate Arkan's May 2021 fundraising event for Adams, Rosen said that Arkan 'never had any knowledge of foreign interference' alleged by federal prosecutors. He maintained that neither the Adams campaign nor the Turkish consulate knew about Arkan's straw donor scheme, which he'd cooked up himself. Judge Dale Ho dismissed the arguments. While he conceded 'it is true that there is some incongruency between the government's handling of Mr. Arkan's case and Mayor Adams' case,' he was firm that 'there is not a shred of evidence in the record' indicating that the prosecutors acted wrongly prosecuting Arkan. Another related case hasn't been resolved yet. Former Adams aide Mohamed Bahi pleaded guilty Tuesday to helping to organize a separate straw donor scheme for Adams' 2021 campaign. While Adams himself hasn't been accused of coordinating straw donations, the practice has been a serious problem for his campaign. Adams' old friend Dwayne Montgomery pleaded guilty last year along with other co-conspirators to giving Adams illegal donations, and THE CITY has reported on numerous examples of more apparent straw donations to Adams. Rep. Dan Goldman, a former federal prosecutor, told Playbook earlier this week that this wasn't an ideal outcome for Adams' case. 'As a prosecutor, I never liked when, ultimately, the only people held accountable for their crimes were the lower level people,' he said. 'But under the circumstances, when you've charged someone and there's a legitimate reason to charge that person, the right thing to do is to finish off the case.' — Jeff Coltin From the Capitol LET'S ALL GO TO THE (ASSEMBLY) LOBBY: New York moviegoers might soon have an easier time skipping the increasingly lengthy block of advertisements and trailers shown before the film starts, if a bill introduced this week becomes law. Assemblymember Clyde Vanel wants to require theaters to display the time a movie actually starts when promoting showings or selling tickets. His proposal comes as movies increasingly start as much as half an hour after the advertised time. 'For the consumer, this can have a real monetary and social impact,' he wrote in his memo accompanying the bill. 'Consumers not only may leave obligations earlier than they needed to in order to see the motion picture, but they may also consume their snacks purchased at the theater prior to the movie beginning.' 'There is no justification for deceiving consumers,' he wrote, especially since moviegoers 'cannot bring their own snacks to eat if they consumed their purchased snacks within the extremely long 30-minute preview period.' The bill would not apply to broadcasts of the Assembly session — where starting within half an hour of the scheduled time would be a major improvement. — Bill Mahoney FROM THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL NO 'SHOOK ONES': Queens Borough President Donovan Richards pledged today to help turn out Black voters for Zohran Mamdani in November, evoking both Martin Luther King Jr. and Mobb Deep in his enthusiastic endorsement. The Democratic mayoral nominee's policies — including a rent freeze and free and fast buses — are common sense, not socialism, Richards said in the borough that he and Mamdani both call home. Richmond Hill, Queens was the last stop of Mamdani's 'Five Boroughs Against Trump' tour. 'Count me in as a democratic socialist if it means that everyday New Yorkers will be able to afford this city,' Richards said, adding that civil rights icon King 'was called a socialist and communist as well' and referencing hip-hoppers Mobb Deep by boasting that there are no 'shook ones' in the borough, a reference to the group's hit song. Richards had previewed his endorsement of Mamdani a day earlier. One of Mamdani's biggest weak spots electorally has been politically moderate Black voters in areas like southeast Queens. And while he now has Richards as a surrogate, Queens Democratic Party leader Rep. Greg Meeks has yet to endorse him. (A Meeks spokesperson did not respond today to a query on whether the House member plans to meet with Mamdani.) Mamdani's support in the primary was stronger in parts of the city that are heavily gentrified. Southeast Queens includes neighborhoods that have resisted being priced out. Mamdani acknowledged the critical balance between creating homes for new residents without pushing out longer-term residents. 'One of the many things I appreciate about the borough president is how he has been able to chart a course of building more housing (though) not at the expense of displacing those who already live there,' he said. — Emily Ngo SEX WORK DEBATE: Andrew Cuomo went on the offensive today over Mamdani's past support for state legislation that would decriminalize sex work in New York. The former governor said in a statement that he spent years fighting iterations of the bill over concerns it would lead to an increase in sex trafficking and exploitation of vulnerable New Yorkers. 'Mark my words: This is the real world and if passed, this legislation will open the floodgates,' Cuomo said in the statement. 'Mamdani may not remember the bad old days of New York City, where Times Square was seedy and crime infested and New Yorkers knew which neighborhoods to avoid at all costs. We do, and no one should be eager to return to that era.' Cuomo's stance was backed by Sonia Ossorio, executive director at National Organization for Women New York City. Ossorio has previously criticized Mamdani's position on decriminalization. 'Full decriminalization doesn't protect vulnerable people — it expands a market that thrives on exploitation, human trafficking, and crime in our neighborhoods,' she said in a statement. Mamdani twice co-sponsored a bill that would decriminalize sex work and clear past arrest records related to prostitution while still allowing law enforcement to go after trafficking operations. Campaign spokesperson Dora Pekec declined to say whether Mamdani still supports the concept and whether he would advocate for the legislation from City Hall if elected. But she noted that the Democratic nominee has pledged additional resources to assist victims of prostitution and sex trafficking. 'While Andrew Cuomo is only interested in 'governing' behind a phone screen, Zohran is committed to genuine public safety, including combatting sex trafficking,' Pekec said in a statement that referenced a new department Mamdani plans to create. 'His Department of Community Safety will invest $40 million towards victims services including for programs like Safe Horizon, for which funding has been cut in past budgets.' The issue of whether to decriminalize sex work has been the subject of heated debate over the years. Organizations like DecrimNY, a coalition of sex workers and various organizations aligned with the decriminalization movement, argue the changes would make sex workers safer by allowing them to report violence or unsafe working conditions to authorities without fear of arrest while delivering more autonomy to consenting adults. — Joe Anuta IN THE COURTS CANNABIS REGULATORS SUED AGAIN: A dozen cannabis dispensary licensees are suing the state over a flip-flop on the cannabis agency's interpretation of the state's 2021 legalization law. 'The consequences are staggering. Petitioners' investments, often more than a million dollars, are now at risk' the petition reads. 'Their livelihoods are being threatened.' The petitioners are licensed under the Conditional Adult-use Retail Dispensary (CAURD) and Social and Economic Equity (SEE) licensing programs, which prioritize entrepreneurs with past cannabis convictions, women and minorities. The legal challenge seeks to block regulators from enforcing a new interpretation of school distance requirements in the state's cannabis legalization law, which would force licensees out of their dispensary locations that had been previously approved by the agency. Agency about-face: Earlier this month, the Office of Cannabis Management notified more than 100 licensees that their dispensary locations could be impacted due to the agency's misinterpretation of state law. The licensees are asking the court to annul the agency's new interpretation of the law, declare their locations compliant and block the state from taking any enforcement actions against them over the school distance requirement. A spokesperson for the OCM said that the office does not comment on pending litigation. The agency is proposing a legislative fix that would allow licensees to remain in their locations, but emphasized on its website that passing such legislation 'is not a guarantee.' The state is also creating an $15 million applicant relief fund for up to $250,000 per applicant to help find new locations. — Mona Zhang IN OTHER NEWS —26 FED PLAZA: As fewer immigrants show up for their court hearings, arrests at 26 Federal Plaza's immigration courthouses are nearing a standstill. (THE CITY) — GOV. CLEMENCY: Hochul pardoned a Laotian immigrant Friday to stop his deportation. (The New York Times) — CUT THE CHECK: Progressive Democrats in the New York Legislature are decrying Hochul's $2 billion rebate program as fiscally irresponsible amid looming federal cuts. (Gothamist) Missed this morning's New York Playbook? We forgive you. Read it here.
