EU's green fuel mandate costly, not helping environment: Global aviation body Iata
SINGAPORE - The International Air Transport Association (Iata) on July 16 stepped up criticism of the European Union's sustainable aviation fuel mandate as a costly initiative that is not helping the environment as regional supplies there remain low.
'The idea that you're buying sustainable fuel and then transporting it to use in Europe isn't the right way to do it, because you're clearly increasing the carbon footprint of that fuel as a result of the transportation costs,' Iata's director-general Willie Walsh said at a media roundtable in Singapore.
Iata estimated in June that production of SAF, which is considered
a low-carbon replacement for traditional jet fuel, is expected to reach two million tonnes, or 0.7 per cent of airlines' fuel consumption, in 2025.
'Mandating the use of a product that isn't available doesn't lead to any environmental benefit,' Mr Walsh said, adding that fuel companies that have an obligation to produce SAF are also increasing the cost of traditional jet fuel.
By Iata's assessment, he said 'the cost that they're charging is way in excess of the actual cost of the limited supplies of sustainable fuel'.
'The EU in effect has facilitated monopoly suppliers to increase prices with no environmental benefit,' said Mr Walsh, adding that the region needs to re-evaluate its SAF targets.
Under the ReFuelEU Aviation requirement, airlines need to have a 6 per cent SAF blend in their jet fuel usage by 2030. The EU is offering some subsidies for SAF purchases by airlines, Reuters reported in June.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore Acute psychiatry services to be expanded across all healthcare clusters: MOH
Singapore July BTO launch to have over 4,600 balance flats, 2 BTO projects with under than 3-year wait
Singapore Baby died after mum took abortion pills and gave birth in toilet; coroner records an open verdict
Singapore Alleged Toa Payoh cat killer and abuser handed new charge of torturing sixth cat
Business Tycoon Robert Kuok's daughter Kuok Hui Kwong appointed CEO of Shangri-La Asia
Life S'pore travel agency Beyond Expeditions criticised for planning, safety issues
Singapore 'Kpods broke our marriage, shattered our children': Woman on husband's vape addiction
Singapore Asia-Pacific will need over 230k new pilots, 250k aircraft maintenance technicians by 2042: ICAO chief
On the supply front, at least five SAF projects in Asia, outside of China, have started up or are earmarked to start production in 2025, targeting exports regionally and to Europe. Singapore is among key exporters of the green fuel to the EU.
Mr Walsh also questioned the use of palm oil as a means to produce sustainable fuel.
'I think that you could argue there is sustainable palm oil and there is palm oil that wouldn't be considered sustainable, and I think in some parts of the world there it's too black and white,' Mr Walsh said.
We need to have a much more 'nuanced approach' to the usage of palm oil as a feedstock and 'much more detailed assessment of the sustainability of the feedstock', he added. REUTERS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
a day ago
- Business Times
Oil steadies as mixed US economic and tariff news offset new Russia sanctions
[NEW YORK] Crude oil futures were little changed on Friday on mixed US economic and tariff news and worries about oil supplies following the European Union's latest sanctions against Russia for its war in Ukraine. Brent crude futures fell 24 cents, or 0.3 per cent, to settle at US$69.28 a barrel, while US West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude futures fell 20 cents, or 0.3 per cent, to end at US$67.34. That put both crude benchmarks down about 2 per cent for the week. In the United States, single-family homebuilding dropped to an 11-month low in June as high mortgage rates and economic uncertainty hampered home purchases, suggesting residential investment contracted again in the second quarter. In another report, however, US consumer sentiment improved in July, while inflation expectations continued to decline. Lower inflation should make it easier for the US Federal Reserve to reduce interest rates, which could cut consumers' borrowing costs and boost economic growth and oil demand. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Separately, US President Donald Trump is pushing for a minimum tariff of 15 per cent to 20 per cent in any deal with the European Union, the Financial Times reported on Friday, adding that the administration is now looking at a reciprocal tariff rate that exceeds 10 per cent, even if a deal is reached. 'Currently envisioned reciprocal tariffs, coupled with announced sectoral levies, could push the U.S. effective tariff rate above 25 per cent, surpassing 1930s peaks ... In coming months, the tariffs should increasingly be manifest in inflation,' analysts at US bank Citigroup's Citi Research said in a note. Rising inflation can raise prices for consumers and weaken economic growth and oil demand. EU sanctions In Europe, the EU reached an agreement on an 18th sanctions package against Russia over its war in Ukraine, which includes measures aimed at dealing further blows to Russia's oil and energy industries. 'New sanctions on Russian oil from the US and Europe this week were met by a muted market reaction,' analysts at Capital Economics said in a note. 'This is a reflection of investors doubting President Trump will follow through with his threats, and a belief that new European sanctions will be no more effective than previous attempts.' The EU will also no longer import any petroleum products made from Russian crude, though the ban will not apply to imports from Norway, Britain, the US, Canada and Switzerland, EU diplomats said. EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas also said on X that the EU has designated the largest Rosneft oil refinery in India as part of the measures. India is the biggest importer of Russian crude while Turkey is the third-biggest, Kpler data shows. 'This shows the market fears the loss of diesel supply into Europe, as India had been a source of barrels,' said Rystad Energy's vice-president of oil markets, Janiv Shah. In other news, US oil major Chevron closed its US$55 billion acquisition of US energy firm Hess on Friday after winning a landmark legal battle against larger US oil major rival Exxon Mobil to gain access to the largest oil discovery in decades off Guyana. REUTERS
CNA
a day ago
- CNA
EU, UK tighten pressure on Russia with new oil sanctions and banking curbs
BRUSSELS: The European Union and Britain announced fresh sanctions on Friday (Jul 18) targeting Russia's oil revenue, banking sector and military capacity, aiming to intensify pressure on Moscow to end its war in Ukraine. The move includes slashing the price cap on Russian oil exports, blacklisting additional vessels from Russia's so-called shadow fleet, and expanding restrictions on financial transactions and dual-use exports. It marks the EU's 18th package of sanctions since Russia launched its full-scale invasion in 2022. EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas said the message to Moscow was 'clear' — that Europe would 'not back down' in its support for Ukraine. 'The EU will keep raising the pressure until Russia ends its war,' she said. UK JOINS PRICE CAP PUSH British Foreign Secretary David Lammy said London was joining the EU in tightening the oil price cap, describing the step as 'striking at the heart of the Russian energy sector.' 'As Putin continues to stall on serious peace talks, we will not stand by,' he said. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky praised the new sanctions as 'essential and timely.' The oil price cap, originally introduced by the G7 in 2022, is designed to reduce Russia's export revenues by preventing shipping and insurance firms from servicing oil sold above a fixed threshold. The cap will now be lowered to 15 percent below global market prices, or roughly US$47.60 per barrel, according to EU officials. The limit can be adjusted as global oil prices fluctuate. DIVISIONS OVER ENFORCEMENT The updated price cap comes despite a lack of support from US President Donald Trump, who has yet to sign on to the revised limit. EU officials acknowledged that the effectiveness of the measure would be diminished without Washington's cooperation. They expressed hope that other G7 nations, including Canada and Japan, would align with the new approach. SHADOW FLEET, PIPELINES, REFINERIES TARGETED The latest EU package also blacklists more than 100 vessels from Russia's so-called 'shadow fleet' — older tankers allegedly used to bypass oil sanctions. New restrictions aim to prevent the reopening of the defunct Nord Stream 1 and 2 gas pipelines in the Baltic Sea. Sanctions will also target a Russian-owned oil refinery operating in India and two Chinese banks, as the EU cracks down on Moscow's efforts to sustain trade ties outside the West. Additional bans were imposed on transactions with more Russian banks and on exports of dual-use goods that could support military operations in Ukraine. SLOVAKIA DROPS OPPOSITION The package was approved after Slovakia dropped its weeks-long opposition following talks with Brussels over energy guarantees. Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico, a Kremlin-friendly leader, said he received 'guarantees' from EU officials about long-term gas prices. TRUMP THREATENS SECONDARY TARIFFS The sanctions came days after Trump issued an ultimatum to Russia, threatening 'massive secondary tariffs' on buyers of Russian energy if Moscow does not halt its military campaign within 50 days. Trump's warning marked a sharp turn from his earlier push to reset relations with the Kremlin, with administration officials suggesting the president had grown increasingly frustrated with Putin's lack of movement toward a ceasefire. WESTERN PRESSURE GROWS Western officials admit that sanctions have yet to cripple Russia's economy, but they argue key indicators such as inflation and interest rates are worsening. French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot described the latest sanctions as 'unprecedented,' adding that 'together with the United States, we will force Vladimir Putin into a ceasefire.' The Kremlin said it would try to 'minimise' the impact of the new measures and warned they would backfire.
Straits Times
2 days ago
- Straits Times
Germany's Merz casts doubt on Ukraine EU entry by 2034
BERLIN - German Chancellor Friedrich Merz on Friday cast doubt on the possibility of Ukraine joining the European Union by 2034, saying accession was unlikely to come at a point affecting the bloc's medium-term finance plans, which run to 2034. "For us, the absolute top priority is, first and foremost, to do everything possible to end this war," Merz said on Friday after a meeting with Romanian President Nicușor Dan in Berlin. "Then we'll talk about the reconstruction of Ukraine... but that's going to take a number of years ... It will probably not even affect the EU's current medium-term financial outlook," the chancellor said. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said in Kyiv in February that Ukraine could join the EU before 2030 if the country continues reforms at the current speed and quality. EU leaders have also said accession to the EU would be the most important security guarantee for the future of Ukraine. REUTERS
