Why Torness nuclear power plant is not all it's cracked up to be
Torness and Hunterston B are both Advanced Gas-cooled Reactors (AGRs) which opened in 1976 and 1989 respectively. There were an estimated 586 cracks across the two Hunterston B reactors when it was eventually forced to close in January 2022. There are a similar number of cracks in just one of the two reactors at Torness, with cracks also starting to appear in the other reactor. Cracking in the graphite core of these reactors is a problem because graphite debris could build up in the fuel channels comprising the operator's ability to keep the fuel cool and misshapen bricks could make inserting the control rods difficult. In a worst-case either of these could lead to a meltdown.
The late John Large, a nuclear engineering consultant, explained that cracks also cast doubt on the safety of these reactors in the event of an emergency like an earthquake. A cracked and deteriorating core has lost its residual strength. If the core is wobbled by a small earthquake the core could become misaligned, and the fuel modules could get stuck in the core. Then the fuel temperature would get raised and could undergo a melt. If the radioactivity gets into the gas stream and the reactor is venting because it's over pressurised then you have a release the radioactive gas into the atmosphere and you have dispersion and a contamination problem.
Pete Roche (Image: NQ) Clearly, it's time for the ageing Torness reactors to be closed. Keeping them open any longer would be gambling with public safety.
We also have to bear in mind that there is a significant design difference at Torness, compared with Hunterston, which could make the cracking problem worse. The Torness reactors have seal rings between the graphite bricks that make up the reactor core. The Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR) says there could be 'a systematic failure' of the seal rings after cracking.
In January 2020, ONR brought forward the date when it expected to start seeing cracks appearing at Torness by six years but the closure date was only brought forward by two years from 2030 to 2028. Logically, we might have expected Torness to close in 2024. Then, in January 2024, in a bizarre switch, EDF changed its mind, and reverted to a 2030 closure date 'subject to plant inspections and regulatory approvals'.
READ MORE on the Future of Torness series:
Torness was only ever expected to operate for 30 or at most 35 years, so it is now past its sell by date. With cracks appearing in both reactors the precautionary principle dictates that it is time to shut up shop.
Jobs at Torness won't disappear immediately when the station closes. It took over three years to empty Hunterston B of fuel. After that it will take almost a century to dismantle the buildings, decommission the reactors and eradicate the radiation from the land and buildings, in fact, when Hunterston B transfers its ownership from EDF to the Nuclear Decommissioning Authority (NDA) next April, the Scottish Parliament has been told the NDA will probably need to recruit more staff to help with the decommissioning work.
As far as building new reactors at Torness, or anywhere else in Scotland, whether large or small, is concerned, that would be the last thing Scotland needs. It is perfectly feasible to supply 100% of Scotland's energy (not just electricity) from renewable sources.
Future of Torness logo (Image: NQ) In fact, a recent study by renowned energy modelling academics at the LUT University in Finland, showed that not only is a 100% renewable energy mix feasible for the whole UK but it would save well over £100 billion in achieving net zero by 2050, compared to the UK Government's current strategy.
What we need to balance variable renewables and reduce payments for turning off renewables is not always on 24/7 nuclear reactors, but more energy storage and flexibility in electricity demand. Nuclear power is too slow, too inflexible and too expensive to play a role in cutting carbon emissions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
14 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Austrian Airlines jet issues squawk 7700 code and diverts to Glasgow
The plane issued a distress call - referred to as a 'Squawk 7700 code' as it flew over Scotland before diverting to Glasgow. It had been scheduled to fly to JFK airport in the US. Glasgow airport (Image: NQ) READ MORE: The jet was met by medics on arrival, and touched down safely. A spokesperson for Glasgow airport said that a passenger had taken unwell during the flight, prompting the diversion. The plane was scheduled to resume its journey once the passenger was removed for treatment.
The National
21 hours ago
- The National
Scottish activists mark 80 years since atomic bombings
A vigil, organised by the Glasgow branch of the Scottish Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament (CND), was held at the opening of the "Peace Garden" in the city's Botanic Gardens on Wednesday morning. Campaigners held banners reading "Peace", "Hiroshima 6 Aug 1945 Never Again" and "Scotland: Safer without nuclear weapons", while a group of singers from Protest in Harmony sang a number of songs calling for the abolition of nuclear weapons. (Image: NQ) (Image: NQ) (Image: NQ) The Peace Garden, which is located near the entrance of the Botanics, was opened to the public with a ribbon-cutting ceremony attended by Glasgow Lord Provost Jacqueline McLaren and Katsutoshi Takeda, the consul general of Japan, based in the Edinburgh embassy. It features the sapling of a Gingko tree – planted by Takeda and McLaren – which was raised from the seed of a tree which survived the Hiroshima bombing. Glasgow Lord Provost Jacqueline McLaren and Katsutoshi Takeda, the consul general of Japan (Image: NQ) The United States dropped nuclear bombs on Hiroshima and Nagaski on August 6 and 9 in 1945, leading to the end of World War Two with Japan's surrender. The bombs killed more than 200,000 people, with the Hiroshima bomb killing more than 140,000 people, including 38,000 children. Speaking to The National, Glasgow CND chair Jean Anderson said that while "the world is in a terrible state", projects such as the new Peace Garden "give people hope and something positive to do". READ MORE: Otter cubs rescued from side of 'very busy road' by quick thinking festival goer Anderson said that while the group hoped the project will educate people about the bombings, it will also teach people "that violence and hatred is not the greatest way to solve a problem, that real adults discuss things and they work out a better way of doing things". Lynn Jamieson, Scottish CND chair, commented: "I'm here to remember all of the victims and the survivors of Hiroshima, and the one wish that the survivors have is for nuclear weapons to be banned so that this never happens again. I'm here to carry their message forward." (Image: Scottish CND) Also among those in attendance was Patrick Harvie, Scottish Greens co-leader and MSP for Glasgow. Speaking to The National, Harvie said: "I grew up near Faslane, very aware of the threat and the nightmare of nuclear warfare. "Anything that we can do that not only commemorates what happened in the past, but reminds us that this is still a threat in the here and now and that we collectively – all of us in Scotland, throughout the UK, Europe and the world – need to take responsibility if we want to prevent such atrocities happening again. "It's lovely to have an event like this on our own doorstep, and I hope that there are similar events right around communities across Scotland." READ MORE: Ian Blackford to give shock return in Kate Forbes seat 'careful consideration' Scottish CND organised a number of other vigils across Scotland to commemorate the 80th anniversary of the atomic bombings, in Edinburgh, Aberdeen, Paisley, Stirling and Ayrshire. There are countries which are armed with nuclear weapons: The UK, the US, Russia, France, China, India, Pakistan, Israel and North Korea. Israel has not officially confirmed or denied that it is in possession of nuclear weapons, but it is widely acknowledged that it has the capability to produce and deploy them. The UK's nuclear weapons are held in Scotland, at the HMND Clyde Faslane naval base in Helensburgh. Commemorating the 80th anniversary of the atomic bombings, the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (ICAN) called for immediate action to eliminate nuclear weapons. Melissa Parke, ICAN executive director, attended a memorial event in Hiroshima alongside survivors – or hibakusha, as they are known in Japan – who have been involved in campaigning against nuclear weapons. Following the service, Parke said: "It is not possible to come to Hiroshima and attend these solemn commemorations without being moved as well as convinced of the urgent need for nuclear weapons to be eliminated. "The hibakusha, who were awarded last year's Nobel Peace Prize for their tenacious campaigning for the elimination of nuclear weapons deserve to see their work vindicated and to witness the end of these inhumane, indiscriminate weapons of total destruction in their lifetime." Parke added: "That means the nine nuclear-armed countries, most of which were represented here today, must heed their call to join the UN Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons and get rid of their arsenals.'
South Wales Argus
2 days ago
- South Wales Argus
Residents evacuated from homes as active bombs discovered in Penarth
Residents and businesses near Plassey Street were asked to leave the area earlier today around 1pm. A cordon was quickly put in place and now specialist 'armed' bomb disposal police are on the streets keeping residents safe. A police statement reads: 'We were called just before 1.30pm today with a report of unexploded ordnance having been found in a garden in Plassey Street Penarth. 'As a precaution there is a cordon in place and around 50 homes within the cordon are being evacuated, again as a precautionary measure while the devices are examined and made safe.' Police on Plassey Street where active bombs have been discovered (Image: NQ) Other affected streets include Glebe Street, and Salop Street. The bombs themselves are believed to be World War Two bombs that were discovered in a residential garden. On our scene reporter was informed that the bombs were discovered between Salop Street and Glebe Street after groundworks were carried out in a local garden. An excavator supposedly dug up the bombs near a garden close to local business Penarth Nails. Police on Glebe Street where active bombs have been discovered (Image: NQ) Police on the scene have confirmed a two-hour cordon is in place, but this could last up to four hours. A specialist team from Kent is travelling to the area to deactivate the bombs that will most likely be taken to a 'grassy area.' Residents remain outside currently as police work to make the area safe. Police on Glebe Street where active bombs have been discovered (Image: The Bike Shop Penarth) In the UK, the most commonly discovered World War II bombs are unexploded German bombs, often referred to as UXBs (Unexploded Bombs). These are typically remnants from the Blitz and other bombing raids carried out by the Luftwaffe between 1940 and 1945. Police on Glebe Street where active bombs have been discovered (Image: NQ) During this time Penarth's busy docks and strategic proximity to Cardiff's docks and steelworks made it a recurring target of German air raids from 1941 through 1945 In March 1941, over 150 high explosive bombs, and more than 5,000 incendiaries fell on Penarth devastating buildings including All Saints' Church, Holy Nativity, and houses on Clive Place, Glebe Street, Salop Street. For more information click here.
