logo
Editorial: Japan politicians must stop fueling anti-foreigner sentiment for electoral gains

Editorial: Japan politicians must stop fueling anti-foreigner sentiment for electoral gains

The Mainichi12-07-2025
When politicians continue to stoke public alarm toward foreigners, they risk spreading xenophobic sentiment throughout society.
For the July 20 House of Councillors race in Japan, multiple political parties have adopted campaign promises calling for stricter immigration policies and other measures targeting foreign residents. This is a development unseen in previous elections.
The ruling Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) has embraced the slogan "zero illegal immigrants," promising stronger crackdowns on unlawful employment and proposing that any social insurance or medical bill payment defaults by foreigners could count against them during residency screenings.
For its part, the opposition Democratic Party for the People (DPFP) cited national security concerns in support of tighter controls on foreign ownership of Japanese real estate. The party also proposed introducing new taxes to tackle speculative foreign investment, claiming that it's driving up domestic property prices.
One party particularly prominent in its anti-foreigner stance is Sanseito, which has declared an explicit "Japanese First" platform. The minor party claims that increasing numbers of foreign workers suppress wages for Japanese citizens and calls for restricting their entry. It has also advocated halting welfare benefits to foreign nationals and tightening the criteria for acquiring Japanese citizenship.
Weak basis for party platform pledges
The backdrop to this intensified political rhetoric is Japan's growing foreign resident population, which reached about 3.77 million at the end of last year -- a record high accounting for 3% of the total population. Political parties argue this has resulted in increased crime and friction with locals, raising public safety and security concerns.
On social media, statements claiming "foreigners are weakening public security," "foreigners exploit the medical care system during short stays" and "foreigners undeservedly receive welfare benefits" have been widely shared. Comments alleging foreigners receive preferential treatment have similarly proliferated online.
Even more alarming are recent hate speech incidents targeting Kurdish residents in Kawaguchi, Saitama Prefecture, and elsewhere. Without understanding individual cases and context, some netizens accuse Kurds of being "fake refugees" or troublemakers.
Political parties appear to be picking up and, by including countermeasures in their campaign promises, endorsing these claims. In reality, however, these assertions largely do not have a basis in fact.
According to official government statistics, the number of crimes committed by foreigners has remained relatively the same for about the past 15 years. And as of January this year, there were around 75,000 individuals residing illegally in Japan -- less than a quarter of the peak.
As for the National Health Insurance program, some surveys covering particular local municipalities have found lower contribution rates among foreign nationals. Even so, in proportion to overall medical expenses, those incurred by foreigners are extremely small.
And on welfare benefits, foreign recipients currently receive payments based on national government guidelines.
Foreign nationals in Japan remain inadequately protected by law, holding a precarious status. Even foreigners who duly pay taxes are excluded from political participation and voting rights.
Policies of inclusion are essential
With growing anxiety spreading among Japan's foreign-born communities, civil society groups assisting foreign nationals recently issued a joint emergency statement declaring: "Inciting xenophobic views fuels conflict with people of different nationalities and ethnicities, risking the breakdown of an inclusive society."
A representative of one of the groups behind the statement noted, "With wages stagnating despite higher prices, many people are struggling to make ends meet. Against this backdrop, foreigners are being used as scapegoats."
Such scapegoating rooted in discontent parallels the dynamics seen in European countries, and the United States under the administration of Donald Trump.
Facing continued population decline and aging demographics, Japan has expanded its intake of foreign workers to offset labor shortages. As a result, foreign nationals have already become essential contributors to Japanese society. Japan must now prioritize policies that help people with diverse values live as fellow members of society.
To fully participate in Japanese society, it's essential for foreign nationals to acquire the Japanese language, yet existing government support programs remain insufficient. Furthermore, working conditions that benefit everyone must be established.
It's also important to create opportunities for meaningful interaction between Japanese and non-Japanese residents to help foreign nationals better understand social norms and expectations.
In the 1990s, when Japan welcomed large numbers of Japanese descendants from Brazil and other countries, similar friction emerged in various communities. Yet in some areas, such as the Shizuoka Prefecture city of Hamamatsu and the Gunma Prefecture town of Oizumi, residents and local governments overcame initial barriers through sustained, creative efforts and eventually formed communities where people now support each other as neighbors.
Human rights must be universally respected regardless of nationality. Correcting misinformation and fake stories about foreign nationals is an essential responsibility of politicians and government leaders, contributing toward eliminating prejudice and discrimination within society.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Japanese Opposition Leader Noda Vows to Pursue Change of Govt

timean hour ago

Japanese Opposition Leader Noda Vows to Pursue Change of Govt

News from Japan Politics Jul 21, 2025 02:50 (JST) Tokyo, July 20 (Jiji Press)--Japanese opposition leader Yoshihiko Noda expressed an intention to pursue a change of government as Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba's ruling coalition is struggling to maintain its majority in the House of Councillors, the upper chamber of parliament, in Sunday's election. Some within Noda's Constitutional Democratic Party of Japan may push for an opposition-led coalition to replace the Ishiba administration. Noda regarded the Upper House election as an important step toward taking over the reins of government in the next election for the House of Representatives, the lower parliamentary chamber. He plans to ramp up his attack on the ruling coalition. "The prime minister should accept the no that the public said to him," Noda said on television Sunday, adding, "We need to consider how to create an alternative to the Ishiba administration." [Copyright The Jiji Press, Ltd.] Jiji Press

Ishiba May Come Under Pressure to Step Down

time3 hours ago

Ishiba May Come Under Pressure to Step Down

News from Japan Politics Jul 21, 2025 01:09 (JST) Tokyo, July 20 (Jiji Press)--Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba may come under pressure to step down if his ruling coalition falls far short of his goal in Sunday's election for the House of Councillors, the upper chamber of parliament. Ishiba declared his intention to stay in office even as the ruling bloc is struggling to maintain its Upper House majority in the election. "We must be aware of our responsibility to fulfill for the nation and our responsibility as a comparative first party. I will take charge of it," he said on television Sunday night. But the political landscape is becoming increasingly uncertain as moves to find a successor to Ishiba are already underway behind the scene within his ruling Liberal Democratic Party. The ruling coalition had to maintain its Upper House majority after it failed to secure a majority in the House of Representatives, the lower parliamentary chamber, in last year's election, an LDP official said. [Copyright The Jiji Press, Ltd.] Jiji Press

Performative ‘elections' expose a sad lack of vision
Performative ‘elections' expose a sad lack of vision

Japan Times

time3 hours ago

  • Japan Times

Performative ‘elections' expose a sad lack of vision

Under former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, the Liberal Democratic Party's leadership offered the Japanese people and the region the Free and Open Indo-Pacific Vision (FOIP), Abenomics to revive the nation's economy after nearly three decades of stagnation and 'proactive pacifism' as guiding ideas for Japanese citizens. While not completely successful in realizing these visions, they offer a stark contrast to Japan's Upper House elections. These performative 'elections' have again exposed a troubling void at the heart of the island nation's political culture: the absence of any compelling strategic vision for the country's future. While political parties jostle for position and trade barbs over peripheral issues, none have articulated a coherent blueprint for addressing Japan's serious and mounting structural challenges. This vacuum of imagination reflects not merely political timidity but a deeper cultural reluctance to embrace bold leadership, a tendency encapsulated in the Japanese proverb 'the nail that sticks up gets hammered down.' The policy platforms on display during the campaign were notable primarily for their smallness of ambition. The LDP recycled familiar promises about economic revitalization and security enhancements, offering incremental adjustments rather than transformative solutions. The Constitutional Democratic Party of Japan countered with equally uninspiring proposals for modest wage increases and tweaks to social programs. Even newer entrants like Reiwa Shinsengumi and Nippon Ishin no Kai failed to break free from this pattern of cautious incrementalism. What makes this lack of vision more concerning is the magnitude of challenges Japan faces. The nation confronts a demographic crisis, with a rapidly aging society and plummeting birthrate threatening economic vitality and social cohesion. Gender inequality remains entrenched, depriving the economy of talent and perpetuating outdated social structures. The employment system struggles to adapt to a dynamic global economy. Educational institutions remain rigid, hierarchical and are ill-equipped to foster the creativity and flexibility demanded by the 21st century. Rather than grappling seriously with these existential challenges with a concrete vision, political discourse has increasingly fixated on the comparatively minor issue of immigration. Parties across the spectrum have devoted outsized attention to illegal migrants, migrant crime and border control measures despite scant evidence that foreign nationals pose any significant threat to Japanese society. Foreign residents constitute less than 3% of Japan's population and crime rates among immigrants remain lower than those of the general population. This misdirection of political energy reveals both the poverty of strategic thinking and a troubling susceptibility to populist scapegoating. The rise of parties like Sanseito, which has gained traction with its populist, right-of-center platform, reflects growing voter dissatisfaction with establishment politics. Yet this phenomenon represents less a coherent alternative vision than a protest vote against the status quo. Like similar movements in Europe and the Americas, Sanseito channels frustration without offering substantive solutions. Its popularity signals not the emergence of new ideas but the bankruptcy of old ones. This political paralysis stems partly from institutional factors such as the factional nature of Japanese politics, the power of bureaucracy and the influence of special interests. But it also reflects deeper cultural dynamics. Japanese society has long valued consensus over conflict, harmony over disruption and collective cohesion over individual initiative. These values have many virtues, contributing to social stability and group solidarity. Yet they also create powerful disincentives for the kind of bold, visionary leadership required to navigate transformational change. The contrast with other major powers is instructive. Whatever one thinks of U.S. President Donald Trump's 'Make America Great Again' vision or Chinese leader Xi Jinping's 'China Dream,' these leaders have articulated clear, compelling narratives about their nations' destiny. Their visions may be flawed, divisive and unrealistic, but they provide a sense of direction and purpose that mobilizes political energy and shapes public discourse. Japanese politics offers no equivalent. There has been no overarching narrative about where the country should go or what it should become since Abe. This absence of vision has concrete consequences. Without a clear strategic direction, policy responses remain reactive and piecemeal. Demographic decline proceeds unchecked because no party dares propose the radical reforms to immigration policy, gender relations or work culture that are necessary to reverse it. Economic stagnation persists because structural reforms threaten entrenched interests. Educational ossification continues because innovation requires challenging established hierarchies. The irony is that Japan possesses tremendous assets that could underpin a compelling national vision. Its technological prowess, cultural creativity, social cohesion and democratic institutions provide a strong foundation for renewal. A political leader willing to articulate how these strengths could be mobilized to address contemporary challenges might find a receptive audience among voters hungry for change. Such a vision need not mimic the nationalist populism of Trump or the authoritarian ambitions of Xi. As Phillip Lipscy of the University of Toronto alludes to in his essay "Japan: the harbinger state," Japan could chart its own course, offering a model of inclusive prosperity, sustainable development and creative adaptation to demographic change. It could position itself as a laboratory for solutions to challenges such as aging societies, work-life balance and technological disruption that other developed nations will soon face. It could leverage its cultural soft power and technological capabilities to shape global conversations about the future of human society. Developing such a vision requires political courage and the willingness to stick out, that is, to risk being hammered down. It demands leaders who prioritize long-term national interests over short-term political calculations. It necessitates a political culture that rewards innovation rather than punishing it and one that values bold thinking alongside careful consensus-building. The alternative is continued drift and a slow-motion crisis. Japan's challenges will not resolve themselves through incremental adjustments or wishful thinking. Where is the spirit and vision of the Meiji restorers, those who rebuilt Japan from the ashes of war after World War II or Abe and his team, who offered FOIP, Abenomics and the leadership that drove Japan to lead the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership? A compelling vision with concrete and achievable objectives would contribute not only to Japan's sustainable prosperity but also to its global influence. In an era when nationalist and authoritarian visions are ascendant worldwide, Japan could offer an alternative model, one that combines economic dynamism with social cohesion, technological innovation with cultural continuity, global engagement with national identity. The nail that sticks up may get hammered down, but the alternative is a political culture of timid conformity that guarantees only decline. Japan needs leaders willing to take that risk, to articulate bold visions and pursue transformative change. Until such leaders emerge, its enormous potential will be unrealized and its future increasingly uncertain. Stephen R. Nagy is a professor of politics and international studies at the International Christian University in Tokyo and concurrently a visiting fellow for the Hungarian Institute for International Affairs and the Japan Institute for International Affairs.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store