OF COURSE ‘restorative justice' in schools doesn't work — and now the proof is in
Gee, who would've thunk it?
Actually, the study — by the Manhattan Institute — confirms what we've long known about then-Mayor Bill de Blasio's push for 'restorative justice' in the name of racial equity: It was always doomed to fail.
Restorative justice calls for schools to provide students and staff the opportunity to talk through conflicts instead of punishing kids with meaningful measures like suspensions.
Yet the data shows that, despite an outlay of $100 million since it became the prevailing practice, incidents requiring the NYPD's school safety division more than doubled — from 1,200 in the first quarter of 2016 to 4,120 in the first quarter of 2025.
The report also found that putting troubled students in 'meditation rooms' instead of suspending or kicking them out of class doesn't solve any problems, as violent incidents continued to rise and absenteeism jumped 35%.
The study cites several instances of students not being punished or held accountable for deplorable behavior and violent acts.
Though students at Origins High School who had subjected a Jewish teacher to Nazi salutes and threats were sent to a 'meditation room,' the harassment did not stop.
This spring, an 8-year-old stabbed a staff member with a pencil and threatened classmates at Staten Island's PS 8. Parents derided the school's response — a meditation room and calls home — as entirely inadequate.
A Center for Court Innovation in Brooklyn found no statistically significant benefits in schools that implemented restorative-justice practices compared to those that used a traditional disciplinary approach.
The Department of Education claims suspensions have plummeted 48% over the past 10 years, resulting in 'keeping more children in class and engaged.'
Duh: If your policy is to suspend fewer kids, as restorative-justice calls for, it's no shock that fewer kids get suspended.
Even Schools Chancellor Melissa Aviles-Ramos admits the approach isn't cutting it: 'The work is far from done,' she conceded Wednesday. Yet she vowed, 'It's not leaving New York City public schools.'
That's unforgivable: The study's bottom line clearly found restorative justice fuels disorder, a lack of accountability and possibly an increase in chronic absenteeism.
The disruptions that prevent well-behaved kids from learning alone should be enough to ditch this policy, not to mention the violence and absenteeism that comes from it.
Mayor Eric Adams, as a former cop, should know that kids who don't pay meaningful consequences for misbehavior will simply continue misbehaving.
Some good news: An April 2025 executive order from Donald Trump puts the kibosh on using race as a factor in discipline, which may help push schools to return to traditional responses to misconduct and a restoration of order in classrooms.
But until New York City's policy changes, the chaos will continue — and learning will suffer.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
an hour ago
- Los Angeles Times
Neo-Nazi group leader sentenced to 20 years in prison for planned Maryland power grid attack
BALTIMORE — The founder of a Florida-based neo-Nazi group has been sentenced to 20 years in federal prison for conspiring with his girlfriend to plan an attack on Maryland's power grid in furtherance of their shared racist beliefs. Brandon Russell, 30, was convicted by a jury earlier this year. Prosecutors presented evidence detailing his longstanding affiliation with white supremacist causes and his recent efforts to organize 'sniper attacks' on electrical substations around Baltimore. During a sentencing hearing Thursday afternoon in federal court in Baltimore, U.S. District Judge James Bredar excoriated the defendant for his reprehensible views, saying Russell was clearly the brains behind the operation, which sought to precipitate societal collapse by targeting the energy infrastructure of a majority-Black city. In the aftermath of the planned attacks, Russell and his co-defendant, Sarah Beth Clendaniel, intended to 'create their own bizarre utopia populated by people who only look and think like they do,' Bredar said. 'Well, that's not how it works,' the judge continued. 'The law doesn't permit that. We don't change course in this country via violent overthrow.' Bredar imposed the maximum sentence allowed for Russell's conviction of conspiracy to damage an energy facility. The judge also ordered a lifetime of supervised release, including close monitoring of Russell's electronic devices. Bredar previously sentenced Clendaniel to 18 years behind bars after she pleaded guilty to her role in the plot. He said Russell should receive a longer sentence because he was more culpable and contributed the 'intellectual horsepower' that propelled the plot closer to fruition. The two were arrested in February 2023 — before their plans were executed. Russell's attorney, Ian Goldstein, has argued that Clendaniel posed a greater threat because she was taking steps to obtain a firearm and shoot up electrical substations. Meanwhile, Russell was living in Florida with absolutely no plans to travel to Maryland, according to his attorney. 'For Mr. Russell, everything was talk,' Goldstein told the court. He also pointed to Russell's supportive family. Court papers filed ahead of sentencing included a letter from his mother, who said she believes he's been trying to fill the void left by a largely absent father. She said some challenges arose with her son after she moved them back to the Bahamas, where she has relatives. 'Brandon Russell is an educated young man who has served this country's military,' his attorney wrote, connecting his descent into Nazism with longstanding mental health challenges. 'His family relationships speak volumes of the person he can be.' The judge wasn't persuaded, but he noted Russell's 'somewhat complicated psychosocial history' and recommended mental health treatment during his time in prison. Russell declined to address the judge directly. He appeared in court wearing maroon prison attire and showed no obvious signs of emotion during the hearing. Several years ago, Russell co-founded the neo-Nazi group Atomwaffen Division, which is German for 'atomic weapon.' This wasn't his first run-in with law enforcement. In 2017, police responded to a 2017 double homicide at a Tampa apartment building and found Russell outside crying, dressed in military fatigues. One of his roommates had killed the other two, officials said. During a search of the house, police found a stash of highly explosive materials and a cache of neo-Nazi signs, posters, books and flags. Russell pleaded guilty to possession of an unregistered destructive device and improper storage of explosives. Skene writes for the Associated Press.
San Francisco Chronicle
an hour ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Gavin Newsom urges UCLA not to strike a deal with Trump
Gov. Gavin Newsom urged UCLA Thursday not to capitulate to President Donald Trump's demands in order to claw what university leaders say is $584 million in federal research funding the administration has suspended or threatened because it says the campus has mishandled allegations of antisemitism on campus. UC President James Milliken said Wednesday the university system has agreed to talks with the administration over the allegations against UCLA. The Department of Justice announced on July 29 that it had determined the university violated Jewish students' rights by failing to adequately respond 'to complaints of severe, pervasive, and objectively offensive harassment.' But Newsom, who serves as a member of the UC Board of Regents, urged the nation's top public university system not to capitulate to Trump's demands like several Ivy League schools recently have. 'We're not Brown, we're not Columbia, and I'm not going to be governor if we act like that, period full stop. I will fight like hell to make sure that doesn't happen. There's principles, there's right and wrong, and we'll do the right thing. And what President Trump is doing is wrong, and everybody knows it.' The Trump administration has blocked more than $5 billion in funding from at least eight universities: Harvard ($2.3 billion), Columbia ($400 million), Duke ($108 million), Northwestern ($790 million), Cornell ($1 billion), Brown ($510 million), the University of Pennsylvania ($175 million) and UCLA ($300 million). Dozens more have been similarly threatened. Several law firms, meanwhile, have pledged nearly $1 billion in pro bono legal work to causes favored by Trump to avoid being penalized for doing work or representing clients the White House opposes. Newsom declined to say whether he has been involved in the UC's conversations about negotiating with Trump. 'They'll do the right thing, I have the confidence,' Newsom said. And I'll do everything in my power to encourage them to do the right thing and not to become another law firm that bends on their knees, another company that sells their soul, or another institution that takes a shortcut, takes the easy wrong versus the hard right.'
2 hours ago
Neo-Nazi group leader sentenced to 20 years in prison for planned Maryland power grid attack
BALTIMORE -- The founder of a Florida-based neo-Nazi group has been sentenced to 20 years in federal prison for conspiring with his girlfriend to plan an attack on Maryland's power grid in furtherance of their shared racist beliefs. Brandon Russell, 30, was convicted by a jury earlier this year. Prosecutors presented evidence detailing his longstanding affiliation with white supremacist causes and his recent efforts to organize 'sniper attacks' on electrical substations around Baltimore. During a sentencing hearing Thursday afternoon in federal court in Baltimore, U.S. District Judge James Bredar excoriated the defendant for his reprehensible views, saying Russell was clearly the brains behind the operation, which sought to precipitate societal collapse by targeting the energy infrastructure of a majority-Black city. In the aftermath of the planned attacks, Russell and his co-defendant, Sarah Beth Clendaniel, intended to 'create their own bizarre utopia populated by people who only look and think like they do,' Bredar said. 'Well, that's not how it works,' the judge continued. 'The law doesn't permit that. We don't change course in this country via violent overthrow.' Bredar imposed the maximum sentence allowed for Russell's conviction of conspiracy to damage an energy facility. The judge also ordered a lifetime of supervised release, including close monitoring of Russell's electronic devices. Bredar previously sentenced Clendaniel to 18 years behind bars after she pleaded guilty to her role in the plot. He said Russell should receive a longer sentence because he was more culpable and contributed the 'intellectual horsepower' that propelled the plot closer to fruition. The two were arrested in February 2023 — before their plans were executed. Russell's attorney, Ian Goldstein, has argued that Clendaniel posed a greater threat because she was taking steps to obtain a firearm and shoot up electrical substations. Meanwhile, Russell was living in Florida with absolutely no plans to travel to Maryland, according to his attorney. 'For Mr. Russell, everything was talk,' Goldstein told the court. He also pointed to Russell's supportive family. Court papers filed ahead of sentencing included a letter from his mother, who said she believes he's been trying to fill the void left by a largely absent father. She said some challenges arose with her son after she moved them back to the Bahamas, where she has relatives. 'Brandon Russell is an educated young man who has served this country's military,' his attorney wrote, connecting his descent into Naziism with longstanding mental health challenges. 'His family relationships speak volumes of the person he can be.' The judge wasn't persuaded, but he noted Russell's 'somewhat complicated psycho-social history' and recommended mental health treatment during his time in prison. Russell declined to address the judge directly. He appeared in court wearing maroon prison attire and showed no obvious signs of emotion during the hearing. Several years ago, Russell co-founded the neo-Nazi group Atomwaffen Division, which is German for 'atomic weapon.' This wasn't his first run-in with law enforcement. In 2017, police responded to a 2017 double homicide at a Tampa apartment building and found Russell outside crying, dressed in military fatigues. One of his roommates had killed the other two, officials said. During a search of the house, police found a stash of highly explosive materials and a cache of neo-Nazi signs, posters, books and flags. Russell pleaded guilty to possession of an unregistered destructive device and improper storage of explosives.
