Breakingviews - UK's deregulation drive fosters wrong type of risk
Reeves's latest bundle of policy proposals – dubbed the Leeds Reforms after the British city where she unveiled them – follows a similar speech last year at the Mansion House dinner, the preferred forum for the chancellor to flaunt her pro-finance credentials. On Tuesday evening she told, opens new tab City grandees that regulation was a 'boot on the neck' of growth, and talked up a range of measures to cut red tape on the financial sector, which accounts for 9% of UK economic activity.
Many of the planned reforms are sensible. Watchdogs like the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Bank of England's Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) will face, opens new tab clear deadlines on how quickly to approve new firms and senior managers. Separately, banks may be allowed to alert customers to the fact that money in their cash accounts could be earning higher returns in the stock market, a practice stamped out after the 2008 crisis. Reeves is also considering, opens new tab further changes to tax-free savings accounts, which could in theory include nudging more people into equities.
The common thread is that Britain's weighty edifice of rules and regulations has left too much money sitting on the sidelines, harming both savers and the competitiveness of UK capital markets. It's a broadly correct diagnosis. A recent Aberdeen report found, opens new tab that Brits had the smallest percentage of their wealth in equities and mutual funds among the Group of Seven wealthy countries.
Other elements of Reeves's reform push, however, could create the wrong type of risk. She touted bank supervisors' decision to raise the balance sheet threshold beyond which lenders must issue loss-absorbing debt to protect depositors to 40 billion pounds ($54 billion), from 25 billion pounds. That's odd since the failure of U.S. lender Silicon Valley Bank in 2023 arguably demonstrated the dangers of not having such a buffer.
Supervisors are also extending the implementation deadlines for other global bank-capital tweaks and will report back to Reeves on broader levels of equity among lenders. She wants to ensure that the overall framework strikes the 'optimal balance to deliver resilience, growth and competitiveness'.
It's welcome that Reeves recognises Britain's financial sector competes for international business, rather than just existing to funnel capital to UK startups and small businesses. Nevertheless, her deregulatory drive could be dangerous. The surest way to protect economic growth is to make sure systemic banks don't get into trouble. A robust and stable financial system allows credit to keep flowing as the rest of the economy waxes and wanes. Meanwhile, the 42-million-pound fine the FCA slapped on Barclays on Wednesday is a reminder that money laundering controls can be worryingly lax, even at the largest UK banks. Cutting red tape is one thing, but tearing pages out of the bank-regulation rulebook risks going too far.
Follow Liam Proud on Bluesky, opens new tab and LinkedIn, opens new tab.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
M&S to make huge change by launching first-of-its-kind store perfect for holiday goers and it opens in just HOURS
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) M&S is making a huge change by opening a first-of-its-kind store that is perfect for Brits jetting off on their summer holidays. The home of Percy Pig will open its first ever airside store at Heathrow Airport on Monday, July 21. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 1 A mock image shows how the new M&S store will be laid out It means jet setters will be able to stock up on iconic M&S food after going through security. From tomorrow, holiday goers will be able to pick up sandwiches and sweets from its new branch at Gate A, located within Terminal 5 of the busy airport. Later this week a second store will open at Gate B, which will sell gifts such as its popular biscuit tins as well as prepackaged food. Alex Freudmann, managing director at M&S Food said: "This launch builds on the success of our well-established landside airport stores across the UK and allows us to serve customers even closer to their departure gates. "Whether travellers are looking for breakfast, lunch or dinner, or a British gift to take home, we're aiming to bring some M&S magic to their journey through Heathrow.' The high street stalwart already has seven branches across popular UK airports, including Luton and Manchester. But this is the first time flyers can get their hands on its products after passing through security and waiting to board the plane. It is not the first time in recent months that M&S has spruced up its store estate. Last Autumn it opened its first ever standalone clothes store in London's Battersea Power Station. The new store features a curated selection of women's and men's clothing, focusing on premium lines and beauty products. Shoppers race to M&S as one of their best selling items which is a mum-essential viral are scanning for just 63 PENCE Earlier this year, the brand also said it would open six Foodhalls across London and revamp nearly a dozen sites after committing £90million to the investment. It builds on the previous £30million investment made last year, and the extra £50million investment in stores across the Northwest of England. The brand-new Foodhalls will open their doors in Covent Garden, Leytonstone, Clapham Common, Putney, New Malden and Fulham Broadway. They will be completed "over the next few years, pending planning permisison", according to M&S. What else is new at M&S Elsewhere, M&S said it would dish out treats to millions of customers as a thank you following its cyber attack. Over 1.8 million customers will receive birthday gifts this month, and those who missed out in May and June will also be rewarded. Eager customers will be able to choose between one of two of M&S' bestselling food products. These could include Percy Pigs or a Swiss Truffle Assortment Box, a Bouquet of Flowers or bottle of Prosecco, a punnet of Grapes or a packet of Outrageously Chocolatey Round Biscuits. Sparks birthday treats were among the casualties of the cyber attack for those who had a birthday over the spring and early summer. It comes after M&S is picking up the pieces from a vicious cyber attack which occurred in April and cost the firm £300million in lost profits. For weeks the beloved retailer was unable to process online orders and store shelves were left bare. Last week, three teenagers and a woman were arrested in the UK as part of an investigation into attacks, which also targeted Co-op and Harrods. They have since been released on bail.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Are we willing to drop cash Isas and take more risks with our money?
Savers are missing out on financial rewards because the benefits of investing in stocks and shares are being drowned out by risk warnings, the chancellor week Rachel Reeves said savers would be sent details of investment opportunities if they have money in low-interest accounts. And she won't completely rule out cutting the annual tax-free allowance of cash Individual Savings Accounts (Isas) to push people into stocks and shares Isas instead. But what are her chances of making the UK a nation of investors, rather than risk-averse savers?Experts say women are investing less than men, and have warned the chancellor that some of her ideas could backfire and put off potential new investors. 'Pink websites won't work' Cash savings accounts are steady and safe. The amount of interest varies between account providers, but it is clear how much the returns will be. They are popular when putting money aside for emergencies, or for holidays, a wedding or a contrast, the value of investments in stocks and shares can go up and down, but with risk can come reward. Long-term investments can be lucrative, not only for individuals, but for the economy as a Suter, director of personal finance at investment platform AJ Bell, says Reeves and the finance sector should start by making investing more attractive to written reports on the Isa gender gap, she argues that, for too long, advertising about investing has been designed by men. Lisa Caplan, director at investment company Charles Stanley, agrees. "It's not about making your website pink. It's about using less jargon, competitive language, and masculine imagery," she says."When clients who are women feel seen and understood, they will be more willing to trust their money to an adviser or even an investment platform. I think this is beginning to change." Jema Arnold is an investor, and works for UK shareholders' association ShareSoc. She wants investing to be part of general, honest conversation among friends, not private and hidden. "I go to a book club. I want investing to be like that," she is joined in a London cafe by Laura Colucci, who is in her 40s, and Wendy Lanham, who is 71. All three are divorcees, who were forced to think about their relationships with money when their marriages Arnold was with an investment banker for 17 years. "In many ways I was a traditional housewife," she says. Her now ex-wife had managed that side of the finances."I'd switched off that part of my brain when raising a daughter. That was a mistake. I felt foolish. I had to switch it back on again fairly quickly."Mrs Colucci was the same. "There were investments in my name," she says. "It was a huge learning curve in one year, when I had to take control."Mrs Lanham put her money into savings accounts. Only later did she consider moving some into that was a path that all three initially found difficult to join."People froze up and looked awkward when I talked about investing," says Mrs Arnold. Male domination Mrs Lanham says she joined a group which met to talk about investing. The membership was entirely male. "I bought myself a book called Investing for Idiots, went to a conference, and treated it like adult education," she says. "I did not know anything, but hung in there, and the organisation changed."Now, the trio are members of SIGnet – a network of investor groups that meet in different parts of the UK, or online. It is not-for-profit and covers different areas of interest. It has lots of female they say the chancellor will have little hope of getting more people to invest without initially improving their understanding, especially if they are trying it for the first time."There's no point telling people to go and run a marathon when they've never run before," says Mrs Colucci. Reeves told financial services and business bosses in her Mansion House speech this week that the "negative" narrative around savers investing money in stocks and shares needed to change."For too long, we have presented investment in too negative a light, quick to warn people of the risks without giving proper weight to the benefits," she announced new adverts, reminiscent of the "Tell Sid" campaign of the 1980s, which encouraged people to invest in the newly privatised British messages will also be sent by banks to people who have money in low-interest Suter, from AJ Bell, says this needs to go beyond a "token effort"."If it can get widespread coverage and enthusiasm, then it could make a difference," she says. Isa debate Carol Knight, chief executive of the Investing and Saving Alliance, says Reeves' ambition will be judged a success if more women, more people from ethnic minorities, and more people outside of London become investors. But Anna Bowes, savings expert at the Private Office, says the chancellor risks her plan backfiring by encouraging people to invest now when markets are jittery due to global uncertainty. That could lead to short-term losses."This needs to be done very carefully or it could put off a generation of investors."And she stresses that forcing people to consider a stocks and shares Isa by reducing the amount that could be put tax-free into a cash Isa would be a huge mistake. Reeves has stepped back from immediately cutting the tax-free limit on cash Isas, following a backlash from banks and building she is still keen to shift some of the £300bn in these accounts to being invested in the UK and its companies, despite "differing views on the right approach".Any changes would have an impact on millions of people. Isas are incredibly popular - about 42% of UK adults have at least and shares Isas are less popular but more money is held in them overall - around £431bn, compared to £294bn in cash with Isas are more likely to be older, with estimates suggesting about half of pensioners have one. And while more women have Isas overall, more men have the investment option, with women more likely to stick to the safety of investment companies that sell stocks and shares Isas back a change, while banks and building societies who dominate the cash Isa market are against debate is likely to pick up again as the chancellor's autumn Budget gets closer.
Times
an hour ago
- Times
Reeves is right, but she is walking a tightrope — with our money
The chancellor, Rachel Reeves, wants us all to take more risks with our money. That much was clear as she delivered her Mansion House speech on Tuesday. The government is on a mission to get more savers investing in the stock market. Reeves is planning an advertising campaign to help explain the benefits of investing — rather than highlighting the risks — and from April the Financial Conduct Authority, the City regulator, will offer 'targeted support' that will allow banks to alert customers to specific investment opportunities. 'For too long, we have presented investment in too negative a light, quick to warn of the risks without giving proper weight to the benefits,' Reeves said. But she didn't stop there. The chancellor also wants to roll back regulatory rules, not just for investment products (risk warnings will be tempered) but also for mortgages (so that it will be easier to borrow more). Encouraging more people to invest; offering bigger loans to hopeful first-time buyers; and forcing pension funds to invest in the UK. It's all part of the government's masterplan for growing the economy. And for much of this she's right. It is true that UK savers are not keen on investing in the same way as our American counterparts. This can be seen clearly in how we use Isas, with two thirds of accounts held in cash rather than stocks and shares. According to a YouGov survey, 55 per cent of the public were unwilling to invest in stocks and shares. Most of us need to invest more and stop our love affair with cash. There is a belief that investing is akin to gambling — not helped by the stringent 'your investment can go down as well as up' warning displayed on every money billboard, piece of paperwork and website. Savers so often forget that leaving your money in cash isn't risk-free, especially in a high-inflation environment. More savers need to become investors. But let's not forget why those regulatory rules were introduced in the first place. Are we now heading back to the hazy days of 2008 when you could get a loan for more than a property was even worth? Light regulations, then a crash, then tighter regulations: it's the same old merry-go-round, with seemingly no lessons learnt from the last ride. • How to get a nation of savers investing And again, as is so often the case, politicians are ignoring that this is our money, not theirs, that they are playing with. The right choices need to be promoted. So much could go wrong if the wrong advice is given or unsuitable products are pushed. Investing in high-risk vehicles such as the long-term asset fund that invests in private markets and infrastructure assets could open the door to a potential mis-selling scandal. Yet the plan is for savers to be able to do this through their Isas. For most beginner investors, the best way to dip a toe into the market is typically by investing in a standard tracker fund. Not only will your assets be diversified (as you invest in often hundreds or even thousands of different companies to spread your risk), you will also keep charges low. Banks, which will offer this new targeted support, typically only have a limited number of investment products on offer and while that often includes a tracker, they tend to be more pricey than the industry average. • The cheap and easy way to invest (without the risk) As for mortgage lending, as I've written before, there's a fine line between responding to the needs of borrowers and putting them in a difficult position if rates were to take another turn or property prices were to fall. It could be a risky business — but then, never being able to get on the property ladder could be the greatest risk of all. Risk can pay off, but we're walking a tightrope. It's all about getting the balance right.@JohannaMNoble
