logo
Planned burn during 2023 Shuswap wildfires could have turned deadly: report

Planned burn during 2023 Shuswap wildfires could have turned deadly: report

Global News07-05-2025

British Columbia's worker protection agency says a planned burn by the province's wildfire service during the devastating 2023 fire season could have killed or injured multiple firefighters who became 'trapped by extreme fire behaviour' that cut off their escape.
Inspection reports by WorkSafeBC say the BC Wildfire Service didn't adequately ensure safety during the burn in the Shuswap region on Aug. 17 that year, and a group of trapped Brazilian firefighters had to retreat to a 'safe zone.'
2:22
B.C. wildfires: Frustrations over the Bush Creek fire battle
WorkSafeBC says they had to burn off fuel around their truck and spend the night because of low visibility, smoke, fire activity and falling trees.
Story continues below advertisement
They were picked up the next day by another crew that 'cut their way into the site.'
'Other crews reportedly had to navigate off-road and around a burning pile of logging debris when the fire overcame the escape route causing damage to some trucks and causing one truck to nearly roll over in the process,' one of the reports says.
A report dated Aug. 1, 2024, was obtained by The Canadian Press, while two other reports dated Aug. 30 and Dec. 6 were later provided by WorkSafeBC in response to inquiries.
The Forests Ministry has previously said the planned ignition took place along a 10-kilometre stretch of power lines with the goal of reducing fuels in the path of an advancing wildfire, which went on to destroy dozens of homes.
The Aug. 1 WorkSafeBC report says that after fire activity increased and compromised the escape route, the trapped Brazilian firefighters sheltered in an open area below power transmission lines, where they parked their truck.
2:18
Re-building of homes, lives underway one year after destructive North Shuswap wildfire
'The planning and execution of this ignition operation was not adequate to ensure worker safety and workers were put at risk as a result,' it concludes.
Story continues below advertisement
The employer did not provide adequate information, instruction, training or supervision for the crews involved, the report says, and the incident 'could have resulted in multiple serious injuries or fatalities of workers.'
It adds that 'workers did not exercise their right to refuse unsafe work,' and the employer is responsible for ensuring workers are aware of their right.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
In response to a request for comment, the Forests Ministry said its priority is always the safety of the public and fire responders.
The BC Wildfire Service has been in compliance with the order from WorkSafeBC as of Dec. 6, 2024, after taking steps to update processes and procedures for planned ignitions, the ministry said in a statement.
The WorkSafeBC report from that date confirms the service had complied with its order, but notes the agency had determined there were grounds for imposing an administrative penalty over the 'near miss' incident.
In an email on Tuesday, the agency said it is 'now considering appropriate enforcement action' related to the planned ignition operation.
The agency noted its inspection reports are not posted publicly, but they are available upon request following review and redaction for privacy reasons.
5:35
Documentary on Bush Creek Fire
At the time of the planned ignition on Aug. 17, two wildfires — the Lower East Adams Lake and Bush Creek blazes — had been steadily moving toward the northern shore of Shuswap Lake after they started about five weeks earlier.
Story continues below advertisement
Whipped up by high winds the next day, the fires went on to destroy more than 170 properties and damage dozens more in the Shuswap area. The Skwlax te Secwepemculecw First Nation lost more than 80 structures.
B.C.'s Forest Practices Board was also investigating the province's response to the same wildfires after receiving a complaint from a local resident.
Jim Cooperman told The Canadian Press in 2023 that he filed the complaint alleging 'gross negligence' by the BC Wildfire Service in conducting the burn just beyond power lines about two kilometres from his home in Lee Creek.
Cooperman said he was convinced it was the planned ignition, not the wildfires themselves, that raced down the slope on Aug. 18.
He said the power lines meant to act as a fire break were surrounded by dead brush and instead became a 'conduit' for the flames.
2:34
'It's like driving through a war zone,' fire evacuees return home in the North Shuswap.
The fire would eventually stop about 15 metres from the back of his home on the property where Cooperman has lived since 1969.
Story continues below advertisement
Cooperman said it's his understanding that the report from the Forest Practices Board's investigation is still being finalized.
In an email on Tuesday, he said the WorkSafeBC report 'confirms the concerns' of many in the area, that the wildfire service was irresponsible and unethical in conducting the ignition 'just prior to a major windstorm.'
The community is still 'reeling' from the destructive firestorm, he said, adding it caused 'severe' economic and emotional stress for local residents.
'Since the fire we have been seeking accountability from the B.C. government,' Cooperman said. 'This report strengthens our case.'
The Aug. 1 WorkSafeBC report says interviews with workers involved in the burn revealed a 'lack of planning contributed the entrapment incident.'
1:05
B.C. wildfires: More properties evacuated from Sorrento
The BC Wildfire Service's own analysis report following the incident mentions there was 'no consideration towards ground resource co-ordination' as part of the planning process for the ignition, the inspection report says.
Story continues below advertisement
It says ground crews were given 'limited verbal instructions but were not given a briefing prior to this ignition operation.'
The report says such an 'advanced' operation would have required an ignition specialist to be present, but no one involved held that designation.
It also says the BC Wildfire Service's 'facilitated learning analysis' following the incident referenced workers being given verbal instructions, 'but there was not time for a planning session on the ground.'
The Forests Ministry has said the planned ignition was complete within roughly two hours.
'The purpose of (the burn) was not to contain the wildfire but reduce its intensity and provide a greater chance of survival to any structures in its projected path,' it said in response to a previous request for comment.
2:52
Officials report 131 structures lost in B.C.'s Shuswap from Bush Creek East wildfire
'While we know the extreme conditions on the day resulted in significant structure loss, we know the planned ignition saved structures in Lee Creek.'
Story continues below advertisement
A bulletin posted by the Columbia Shuswap Regional District at 8:30 p.m. on the day of the planned ignition said the operation was successful.
The aerial ignition of about 26 square kilometres was conducted 'along the power line in the North Shuswap … creating a significant guard line,' it said.
Cooperman said his daughter called at about 12:15 p.m. the following day to say she could see flames in the hills above nearby Scotch Creek.
He had packed up and left by 1:15 p.m., about an hour before the district issued an evacuation order for the Lee Creek and Scotch Creek areas.
'Our home place is now just ashes and burnt sticks. It's very difficult for us,' Cooperman said in an interview in the fall of 2023.
A few days after the firestorm, the director of operations for the BC Wildfire Service defended the planned ignition, saying sustained high winds that changed the course of the fire were responsible for much of the damage.
'I want to be perfectly clear: that planned ignition saved hundreds of homes and properties along the north Shuswap,' Cliff Chapman told media.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Iconic Toronto church marks 1 year since fire ripped through its walls
Iconic Toronto church marks 1 year since fire ripped through its walls

Global News

time10 hours ago

  • Global News

Iconic Toronto church marks 1 year since fire ripped through its walls

A year ago, Toronto firefighters responded to the four-alarm fire on Gladstone Avenue that left St. Anne's Anglican Church in ruins. Extensive damage to the national historic site in Toronto's Little Portugal extended well beyond the walls – many paintings were damaged or destroyed, including early works by Group of Seven members. Now, the team at Toronto Art Restoration is working to revitalize some of those pieces. 'It's like restoring a piece of their story, a piece of their history, a piece of their memory in a way,' said Toronto Art Restoration Director Alicia Coutts. It's a slow process – the art pieces include three murals: Christ in the Garden, The Tempest and Healing of the Palsied Man. Coutts said these works are an example of Canadian classical art, integrating the evolution of Canadian cultural history into sacred spaces. Story continues below advertisement 'There was definitely some loss, I mean there are some parts of this canvas that are completely charred,' Coutts said. 'But, for the most part, you can see a lot of the imagery still and a lot of the colours — even some of the original gold leaf that was on it, I was able to maintain.' Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Coutts said she managed to take massive amounts of soot off the surface of the works, as well as a burnt layer on some areas. 'It took quite some time, but I've gotten through all of the cleaning of the murals, ' she said. View image in full screen After restoration work was completed. Toronto Art Restoration View image in full screen Before restoration work was done. Toronto Art Restoration The next stage of her work will be visual reintegration — but how much of each piece should be recreated? Story continues below advertisement That's a decision she plans to bring to the church and community. 'Should we be remembering this part of history?' asked Coutts. 'Is there a middle ground in between completely doing full visual re-integration and getting it seamlessly blended in with the original paint, or do we — you know — sometimes what we do is use muted colours.' The original church remains boarded up as discussions about the rebuild continue. The congregation has been meeting at the Parish Hall on Dufferin Street in the meantime. The cause of the fire remains unknown. The investigation by the Office of the Fire Marshal is ongoing.

Torontonians will soon be able to spot strawberry moon
Torontonians will soon be able to spot strawberry moon

Global News

time12 hours ago

  • Global News

Torontonians will soon be able to spot strawberry moon

Torontonians, get ready to look up. The full moon in June, called the 'Strawberry Moon,' will light up the sky on Wednesday, June 11. Arguably one of the most beautiful moons of the year, it marks the start of early summer. This celestial moon will rise in the southeast shortly after sunset and move low across the southern sky, setting in the southwest around dawn. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Despite its name, the moon won't look red or pink, but rather large and golden. 'Strawberry' comes from Native American traditions. June is the time when wild strawberries ripen in parts of Canada and the United States. Indigenous Peoples used this moon as a signal to start gathering the fruit. This year's phenomenon will reach peak illumination at 3:44 a.m. EDT on June 11, according to If the skies are clear, the best time to view the moon from Toronto and the GTA will be at 10 p.m. on June 10. Story continues below advertisement Other names for the strawberry moon include berries ripen moon, green corn moon and blooming moon, according to almanac. This full moon comes just before the summer solstice, which falls on June 20 this year. About every 20 years, the full moon and the solstice happen on the same day. The next full moon after this one will be the full buck moon, which will rise on July 10.

Saskatchewan celebrates Eid Al-Adha
Saskatchewan celebrates Eid Al-Adha

Global News

time3 days ago

  • Global News

Saskatchewan celebrates Eid Al-Adha

See more sharing options Send this page to someone via email Share this item on Twitter Share this item via WhatsApp Share this item on Facebook Eid Al-Adha is a annual celebration for Muslims around the world to remember a prophet's story from the Holy Book Quran on Friday. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Thousands of Muslims in Saskatchewan came out to listen to the morning Eid sermon which was followed by a short prayer. Muslims typically celebrate Eid by sharing food, donating to the less fortunate and spending time with family and friends. More details can be found in the video above.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store