Judge throws out murder charge against Michigan officer who struck a fleeing man with unmarked SUV
There was no evidence that state police Det. Sgt. Brian Keely "did no more than what was necessary and proper" to catch a man wanted for various crimes, U.S. District Judge Hala Jarbou said Wednesday.
Samuel Sterling, 25, died after he was pinned against a wall at a Burger King in Kentwood in April 2024. At that time, Keely was part of a U.S. Marshal Service group that tries to catch fugitives in western Michigan.
"Sterling was actively attempting to evade arrest, leading multiple officers on an extended chase in a populated area," the judge said. "Because Keely and the other officers reasonably believed Sterling was armed, they had good reason to believe that Sterling posed a significant threat to the safety of officers and the public."
Sterling was on foot. Keely made a reasonable decision to try to block him from entering the Burger King, even if the officer's actions were risky, Jarbou said.
The judge said it is "well settled" that a state can't prosecute a federal officer if the officer acted properly. Keely was charged with second-degree murder.
Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel said the decision was "nothing short of a miscarriage of justice."
Keely's attorneys said Sterling, who had past convictions, made things worse by running. There were six warrants out for his arrest, including an allegation of assault against his father and probation violations, the judge said.
"This ruling not only vindicates our client but also sends a strong message in support of those who serve with honor and integrity," Keely's lawyers said in a written statement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Firefighters in race to save Oregon's tallest tree after it ignites
Oregon firefighters are working to save one of the tallest non-redwood trees in the world after it caught fire last week. The coastal Douglas fir, believed to be about 450 years old and which stands 325 ft tall, was still burning east of Coquille on Tuesday, according to Megan Harper, public affairs specialist at the Bureau of Land Management. The Coos Forest Protective Association, a non-profit that provides wildland fire protection for several counties in Oregon, had received a call about the fire on Saturday. Harper said there's still a spot about 280 ft up the tree that's 'still hot and it's still showing some smoke'. 'That's the area of focus right now to see if we can get that that spot cooled down because of the thick bark,' she said. Related: Wildfire smoke far more dangerous to health than thought, say scientists The blaze was burning from the top of the tree down into its trunk on Monday, according to an update from the non-profit, and helicopter crews managed to douse flames in the canopy. On Tuesday, crews remained on 'observation mode' to see if the helicopter work was successful or not. 'They are holding off on any more helicopter drops today, just to see what the fire does,' Harper said. 'There are helicopters available to respond if they do start to see more fire developing.' Fire officials will not send climbing crews into the Doerner fir, according to the non-profit's update on Facebook, amid safety concerns. 'Fallout from the treetop makes it unsafe for crews to engage directly under the tree, so firefighters are working to identify additional ways to reach and extinguish the fire,' reads the statement from Monday. Firefighters have set up a containment line and sprinklers to prevent the flames from spreading near the ground. The cause of the fire remains under investigation, and investigators with the Bureau of Land Management are on scene. 'Visitors should be aware that the area will be closed to public use at this time due to active fire and firefighting efforts,' the Coos Forest Protective Association said. Harper said the tree's height makes it the first target for lightning strikes or anything falling from the sky. She said the tree also has a lot of dried moss and bark built up over the summer amid the heat and lack of rain. 'That material is all flammable,' Harper said. 'It's an older tree, it has a lot of pitch that's coming out of it, that sticky, sugary substance that has the potential to be pretty flammable.' Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
6th Republican-led state sends National Guard troops to DC
The number of National Guard troops in Washington, D.C., increased again on Tuesday as a sixth Republican-led state sent some of its soldiers to the nation's capital as part of the president's activation to fight what he claims is rising crime in the city. Tennessee sent 160 troops to the nation's capital on Tuesday, bringing the total number of troops ordered to the city to 2,021. About 900 members, which include members of the military police, have actually mobilized as of Tuesday afternoon and many of those members are unarmed. Aside from members of the D.C. National Guard, five other states previously sent their military members to serve in Trump's mobilization: Louisiana, Ohio, South Carolina, West Virginia and Mississippi. Guard troops are now helping law enforcement at 10 Metro stations, in addition to keeping a small presence along the National Mall, according to officials in charge of the operation, which they are now calling "D.C. Safe and Beautiful Task Force." MORE: Sen. Van Hollen says an armed National Guard in DC would be 'troubling' Stations include L'Enfant Plaza, Gallery Place, Metro Center and Union Station. Officials previously said Guard personnel are not arresting people, only helping to detain individuals briefly if necessary before handing them off to law enforcement. White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt announced later in the day there have been a total of 465 arrests since Trump launched federal law enforcement in Washington on Aug. 7. There were 52 arrests Monday night, according to Leavitt. Information about potential charges from those arrests has not been revealed. "Four more homeless encampments were also removed during yesterday's reporting period. To date, a total of 48 homeless encampments have been cleared in Washington, D.C., by multi-agency teams," she added. When asked by a reporter how long residents in the city should expect the National Guard to remain deployed in the district, Levitt said that they don't have a "timeline" to share. ABC News' Anne Flaherty contributed to this report.
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Body of 'Fun-Loving' 5-Year-Old Was Found Beaten in Dumpster, as Disturbing Video Emerges from Night of Killing
Elyjah Hearn's body was found in a dumpster in Panorama City, Calif. on July 12 NEED TO KNOW The body of 5-year-old Elyjah Hearn was found beaten to death in a dumpster on July 12 Elyjah's mother's boyfriend, Brycson Malik Gaddis, is accused of murdering the boy, prosecutors say Gaddis has reportedly pleaded not guilty A Los Angeles man is charged with murder after the body of his girlfriend's 5-year-old son was found in what prosecutors have described as a "commercial parking lot dumpster." The Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office charged Brycson Malik Gaddis with one count of murder and assault on a child causing death. Gaddis is accused of beating the child to death in an apartment in Panorama City on July 11, according to the D.A.'s office. 'This is truly a heartbreaking and horrific case, and our deepest sympathies go out to the young victim's family,' District Attorney Nathan J. Hochman said in a statement. 'We are committed to seeking justice and will ensure this defendant is held responsible for his actions.' The child was identified as Elyjah Hearn in a GoFundMe. KABC obtained disturbing surveillance video from the night of the alleged murder that appears to show a man walking with a woman while holding something wrapped in a blanket on the street where Elyjah's body was found the following outlet reported that Gaddis appeared in court on Aug. 18, and pleaded not guilty to the charges. The boy's mother, KABC reported, was questioned by police but was subsequently released. "Elyjah was a joyful, fun-loving child who brought light into every room he entered. He adored his family and was deeply loved in return," the GoFundMe organizer wrote. "His laughter, energy, and innocent spirit touched everyone who knew him. His life was cut short far too soon, and our hearts are broken beyond words." Read the original article on People
