PA Speaker rejects disqualification references
The Speaker dismissed disqualification references against 26 opposition members. In a detailed six-page written order, the Speaker clarified that the question of disqualifying an elected member cannot arise without a judicial decision. He emphasized that disqualifying a public representative is tantamount to silencing the voice of the people.
In his ruling, Speaker Malik Muhammad Ahmad Khan stated that references should not be used as a tool for political vendetta. He criticized verdicts like the Panama case, stating that such decisions harm democracy and undermine political stability.
He further stressed that differing opinions should be heard rather than suppressed, as criticism and dialogue are fundamental to a democratic system.
The Speaker condemned protest behaviour within the Assembly but clarified that such incidents do not justify a member's disqualification. He urged political parties to focus on improving the legislative process and playing a constructive role rather than creating obstacles.
On this occasion, the Speaker also proposed the formation of a 'Charter of Assemblies,' aimed at strengthening and bringing transparency to the parliamentary system. He advised political parties to prioritize public issues and avoid unnecessary conflicts.
The Speaker's decision is being hailed in political circles as a balanced and democratic move, expected to reinforce parliamentary traditions.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
18 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Speaker puts brakes on PTI MPAs disqualification move
Listen to article Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Muhammad Ahmad Khan apparently put the matter of PTI disqualifications to rest on Saturday by ruling the disqualification applications against 26 suspended lawmakers as non-maintainable, but by passing the buck to the judiciary and election tribunal. The sword of litigation still dangles over the suspended lawmakers, with the speaker making it clear that while his doors were not closed, the petitioners must first knock on the right ones, by securing a declaration from a court of competent jurisdiction before revisiting his office. In a move seen as a political de-escalation, the speaker has dismissed the applications filed against 26 suspended opposition lawmakers, following a successful round of talks between the treasury and opposition benches. A six-page ruling signed by the speaker outlines the rationale for rejecting the four separate applications, which sought to disqualify the PTI-affiliated MPAs over their disorderly and abusive conduct during the budget session. The move to dismiss the applications gained momentum after recent behind-the-scenes negotiations between government and opposition leaders bore fruit. According to sources, the reinstatement of the suspended MPAs is now expected soon. It is noteworthy that Speaker Khan had earlier suspended the 26 PTI lawmakers under Rule 210(3) of the Rules of Procedure of the Provincial Assembly of the Punjab, 1997, following their disruption of Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz's speech on June 27. In his detailed ruling, Speaker Khan noted: "Though serious legal and constitutional violations, including constitutional oath, have been alleged by the applicants, these violations first need to be established in a court or tribunal of competent jurisdiction before I could decide whether a question of qualification has arisen in terms of Article 63(2) of the Constitution and refer the question to the Election Commission of Pakistan." "The people are the source of all power, and through their vote, they confer trust — not to be undone without the gravest reasons. To disqualify a representative is not merely to silence a voice — it is to disenfranchise people. For an elected House is not only a chamber of laws; it is the echo of the people's will. That voice must not be silenced," he added. The speaker ruled that references to past cases, such as the Panama Papers and other disqualification jurisprudence under Articles 199 and 184(3) of the Constitution, were not valid in the current context. Such petitions, he noted, could undermine freedom of speech in the House and nullify the opposition's presence. Article 19 protects robust debate — even if abrasive — subject to reasonable legal restrictions. "These restrictions are found in our Rules, not in threats of permanent disqualification. Let the welfare of the people be the supreme law, the Assembly must remain a forum where dissent is voiced, not extinguished," the ruling stated. Speaker Khan stressed that the welfare of the electorate is best preserved when the House handles internal disorder itself, without disenfranchising voters' chosen representatives. He also expressed concern about many members' lack of familiarity with assembly rules, legislative processes, and the effective use of standing committees. He called for targeted training to uphold parliamentary supremacy and democratic accountability. "As elected representatives, we must legislate responsibly, put an end to political victimisation, and work together to uphold the supremacy of the people's Assembly and protect our democracy. Political parties are, after all, the true guardians of democracy and the responsibility to uphold the democratic functioning of the House lies with all of them collectively," the speaker added. He called for inter-party dialogue reminiscent of the Charter of Democracy to ensure the Assembly functions effectively as a space for public interest and genuine debate. Referring to political theory, Khan noted: "Modern societies are built upon dialogue; as Jürgen Habermas wrote, 'The public sphere is that realm of our social life in which something approaching public opinion can be formed,' underscoring that free, inclusive and reasoned discourse within parliaments forms the bedrock of democratic communities. Safeguarding this vital exchange of ideas is indispensable for our collective democratic future." In a strong critique of constitutional clauses historically used to undermine democracy, Speaker Khan declared: "As Speaker and a political worker, I firmly oppose anti-democratic constitutional provisions. This includes the infamous Article 58(2)(b), and Articles 62 and 63, all imposed by authoritarian dictators, notably General Zia-ul-Haq. These Articles have historically been weaponised to unjustly target elected politicians. We must end this vicious cycle; the Panama Case cannot become another tool like Article 58(2)(b). Otherwise, we succumb to Nietzschean nihilism, believing time is a flat circle and we are condemned to repeat mistakes." He asserted that misuse of these Articles undermines the constitutional right to political association and representation under Article 17. Disqualifying elected representatives on allegations or technicalities violates the presumption of innocence, disenfranchises voters and erodes the legitimacy of parliament. "The disqualification of elected representatives has deep roots in Pakistan's history. Early examples are the Public Representative Offices Disqualification Act 1949, and Elective Bodies Disqualification Order (EBDO) 1959. These 'backdoor tools' have consistently served non-democratic elements," the speaker stated. He criticised political parties for occasionally abetting such practices, citing the Panama "show trial" as an example of judicial overreach that continues to affect the political landscape through undemocratic means. "This destructive chain must be broken," Speaker Khan emphasised. "The very fact that the Constitution has been exploited this way means such challenging questions can be, and have been raised." He called upon the federal parliament to remove such dictatorial remnants from the Constitution to reclaim democratic values. Concluding his remarks, Speaker Khan affirmed: "During my tenure as Speaker, I will work to uphold parliamentary rule and the principles of representative constitutional democracy, as envisioned by our great Islamic Republic's founding fathers."
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
Flood-hit areas: CM reaches Chakwal to take stock of situation
LAHORE: Chief Minister Punjab Maryam Nawaz Sharif herself reached Chakwal to conduct a comprehensive aerial survey of the flood-affected areas of Takiya Shah Murad, Amirpur Mangan Lallani and Dhidwal. She also conducted aerial survey of Dumman Bridge connecting Chakwal to Jhelum, and directed the relevant authorities to complete the construction and rehabilitation of the Bridge soon. She visited flood-affected houses, roads and bridges, and inspected the construction and rehabilitation of affected roads in the area. The Chief Minister observed the drainage process of flood water. She visited Deputy Commissioner Office Chakwal, and announced financial assistance of Rs5 million for those who died due to roof collapse during rains, and the next of kin of the four people who died due to landslides in Chakwal during rains will be given financial assistance of Rs1 million each. On her directions, members of Punjab Assembly (MPAs) and the Deputy Commissioner will go to the houses of the affected people and immediately give them cheques of the financial aid announced. Maryam Nawaz directed to fully reactivate Civil Defense Force across the province, besides ensuring their latest training to increase the capacity of Civil Defense Force volunteers. She directed the authorities concerned to get mud houses vacated before the start of next spell of rain. She also directed them to provide relief camps or government buildings to families living in mud houses. She directed to open Dumman Bridge for traffic as soon as possible, besides taking necessary measures to repair and restore the bridge linking Chakwal to Jhelum at the earliest. The Chief Minister directed the relevant authorities to complete construction and repair of other 6 bridges and roads in Chakwal as soon as possible. She directed C&W to immediately construct and repair the road from Balksar to Chakwal at Tehwa Bahadur, besides making necessary arrangements before the start of next rain spell. She also directed them to present a survey report on small dam in Chakwal, and said, 'No one has control over natural disasters, life and death are in the hands of Almighty.' She added, 'Deaths occurred due to drowning, roof collapse, and electrocution etc, but the response of government institutions is commendable.' She highlighted, 'Deputy Commissioners should be present in the field until late at night. Keeping in view the current flood situation, full preparations should be made for the next year.' The CM added, 'I have taken a moment-by-moment report of each city from administration during rains. I have also sought a report on damage to buildings and crops that collapsed during flood waves.' She underscored, 'Thank God, no death occurred due to negligence of administrative institutions in the entire Punjab.' The Chief Minister was briefed by Deputy Commissioner Chakwal Sarah Hayat on steps taken during and after the flood. She said, 'Chakwal is normal, though more than 400mm of rain fell.' She added, 'Flow of water in Chowasidan Shah Drain was 4 times more than usual. 6 areas, 6 roads and 4 bridges of Chakwal district were affected by the flood.' She highlighted, 'Desilting of all rivers and drains, and necessary equipment were made functional before the rains.' Deputy Commissioner Chakwal briefed her about desilting, survey of dangerous buildings and flood mock exercises. She said, 'People were immediately rescued in Chakwal during the rains and shifted to safer places.' She noted, 'In the historic and record spell of rains, the police and administration rescued 223 people, Rescue 1122 rescued 57, and 27 people were rescued by helicopter.' Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz Sharif was briefed about law & order situation in the area by DPO Chakwal. He said, 'Law & order situation in Chakwal is improving and crime is decreasing.' He added, 'There has been a 30 to 40% reduction in incidents of theft and robbery. She congratulated Commissioner Rawalpindi and Deputy Commissioner Chakwal Sarah Hayat, and DPO Ahmed Mohiuddin. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
Tarar, Naqvi discuss important issues
ISLAMABAD: Federal Minister for Information and Broadcasting Attaullah Tarar and Federal Minister for Interior Mohsin Naqvi held a meeting to discuss matters of mutual interest, the overall law and order situation, and the constructive role of the media in national discourse. During the meeting, both ministers agreed on adopting a coordinated strategy to strengthen the state narrative, maintain public confidence, and counter misinformation on social media platforms. 'The integrity of the country, dignity of national institutions, and social harmony must be protected at all costs. No negative propaganda against these will be tolerated,' said Minister Tarar. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
