Whanganui's Aramoho pedestrian bridge avoids closure as funding sought for replacement
The Chronicle reported last April that tenders for a new bridge were far above the $2 million budget, meaning the project was not eligible for NZ Transport Agency Waka Kotahi's (NZTA) low-cost, low-risk (LCLR) funding.
A report from Allingham in November 2024 said the cost had risen to $4.5m.
He told the Chronicle this week the council was still working to secure funding from NZTA, through a present value end of life (PVEoL) application.
The cost of the project had been cut back 'to the bones', with an estimated cost of $3m.
'Basically, by removing all peripheral works and getting it down to just the bridge, we'll have a better shot at funding,' Allingham said.
'We need to be ready to act as soon as we're allowed to.'
He said if funding was not secured before or as part of NZTA's National Land Transport Programme for 2027-2030, 'tough decisions' would have to be made, including possible closure or the council paying for the whole project itself.
He said the PVEoL process was more complicated than applying for LCLR cash.
'You're looking at the whole history of the bridge, what the cost of maintenance has been, what the cost of the new bridge is and what the savings are against the cost of the maintenance.'
The bridge had barriers to stop motorbikes from travelling across, but he was looking at getting them removed, he said.
'They obstruct mobility scooters and I'd like it to be used by as many people as possible.
'We want to do our best for everybody and it has to be everybody. Ensuring the disabled community has access to our bridges and footpaths is as much a priority as tanker trucks, forestry and everybody else.
'Fingers crossed, people won't run motorbikes over it. If they do, we can put a camera there and identify them.'
The main railway bridge, owned by KiwiRail, was built in the 1870s, with the clip-on pedestrian section added in 1961.
In 2023, the Chronicle reported the bridge had an estimated 126,600 users a year.
Mike Tweed is a multimedia journalist at the Whanganui Chronicle. Since starting in March 2020, he has dabbled in everything from sport to music. At present his focus is local government, primarily the Whanganui District Council.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Spinoff
7 hours ago
- The Spinoff
Ōtaki to Levin cost blowout shines a spotlight on NZ's infrastructure woes
With a budget that has more than doubled, the road has little hope of recouping costs through tolls, writes Catherine McGregor in today's extract from The Bulletin. One very expensive road The cost of the Ōtaki to north of Levin (O2NL) highway has ballooned to $2.1 billion, more than double the original 2020 estimate of $817 million, despite the fact that construction has yet to begin in earnest. Infrastructure minister Chris Bishop has laid the blame squarely on the previous government, claiming 'it was basically costed on the back of an envelope very quickly so Grant Robertson could announce projects at the start of election year'. In a bid to contain spiralling costs, NZTA proposed a series of pared-back design changes earlier this year, including replacing an interchange with a roundabout. But those proposals were strongly opposed by Horowhenua residents and, as 1News reported in June, ultimately scrapped. NZTA told BusinessDesk's Oliver Lewis (paywalled) that reconsenting the changes would have added more delays and costs than simply sticking to the original plan. Tolls won't bridge the funding gap To help recoup some of the cost, the government will impose tolls on the O2NL once it opens in 2029. But they're unlikely to make much of a dent in the final bill. The Infrastructure Commission recently told a select committee that for a toll road to pay for itself, it must cost no more than $32 million per kilometre, carry 40,000 vehicles a day, and cut travel time by 15 minutes. As Thomas Coughlan writes in the Herald (paywalled), O2NL fails on at least two counts: it will cost about $85m per km and is expected to carry more than 20,000 vehicles a day by the late 2030s. Currently, just three toll roads exist in New Zealand, all in the upper North Island. More are planned, including Penlink north of Auckland and Tauranga's Takitimu North Link, with O2NL joining that list. On Wednesday, the government announced a new digital road user charge system that should also enable the digital payment of tolls – but easier toll payments won't solve the core problem of projects that cost far more than they can return. Consensus under construction The O2NL cost blowout coincided with this week's Building Nations infrastructure conference, where politicians from both major parties repeated the familiar call for bipartisan planning on major builds. Infrastructure minister Chris Bishop says he wants 80 to 90% agreement on the long-term project pipeline. But as The Spinoff's Joel MacManus points out, high-minded talk of consensus tends to mask the cynical partisan reality. Bishop insists his concerns are about 'project selection and management', but, Joel notes, his definition of the 'right' projects tends to track closely with his party's own preferences. Labour has hardly done better: its handling of the cancelled iRex ferry project kept National in the dark about the extent of the cost blowout until after the election. 'The problem is that it is easy to say your opponents should be bipartisan in supporting your ideas,' Joel writes. 'It's harder to agree to support your opponents' ideas.' The Green roadblock The problem with the bipartisan-infrastructure dream isn't just opposing priorities, but also a deeper ideological divergence. As Richard Harman argues in the Herald (paywalled), any future Labour-led government is almost certain to include the Greens, a party that remains staunchly opposed to National's Roads of National Significance, including O2NL. The Greens believe that funding should be redirected toward rail and existing road upgrades, not carbon-intensive new highways. A recent Labour-Greens minority report on another expressway project argued that 'there is an urgent need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and New Zealand has a limited financial budget and a limited carbon budget'. According to Harman, this kind of objection 'transcends the purely practical and economic and veers off into ideological considerations', making lasting political consensus difficult to achieve. As long as infrastructure remains a proxy for deeper debates over climate, growth and spending priorities, bipartisan agreement may remain more aspiration than reality.
Scoop
21 hours ago
- Scoop
Contractor Being Finalised For Ashburton's Second Bridge
The likely contractor to build Ashburton's second bridge should be announced by September. NZTA is in the process of applying for consents and permits for the project, including developing plans to find and relocate up to 140 skinks in the area. The Government announced in December it would fund the 360-metre bridge, with construction expected to start in mid-2026, pending approvals. NZTA project director Lonnie Dalzell said there will be an announcement on the appointment of the 'Early Contractor Involvement' in the next few weeks. The contractor chosen for that role enters into a negotiation for the design and construction contract for the project - but if an agreement isn't reached, NZTA can go back to the market to find another contractor. Dalzell said NZTA is continuing to work through property acquisition, approvals and procurement, including the process to bring a construction contractor on board before the detailed designs are completed. 'This will allow the contractor to be involved in refining the details of the design, look at improved construction methods, understand the local opportunities and address any potential issues. 'We expect to complete this process later this month and to award a design and construct contract at the end of the year. 'We will have more clarity on project costings once we work through the detailed design process.' Once the design and construction tender is settled, it will finalise the price of the project, for both the NZTA-funded bridge and the council-funded road to the bridge on the Tinwald side of the river. A number of consents have been lodged or are in the process of being lodged, and in some cases, NZTA and the council are applying for the same consents. Where overarching applications are being lodged, they are seeking separate consents for the portions of the project specific to either NZTA or council. "So, in other words, it is not two consents sought for the same piece of work,' Dalzell said. 'A process is underway for consent applications to the regional council, with those applications due to be lodged later this month. This relates to NZTA's bridge and embankment construction, and the council's work on the connecting road and associated infrastructure.' An 'outline plan of works' will also be lodged with council, detailing how aspects of the project will be constructed, he said. Both parties have been granted archaeological authority for the project, a legal permit that ensures the protection of cultural and heritage sites during construction and how they will manage any potential archaeological finds. 'Last month, we applied for the necessary wildlife permit and have developed a Lizard Management Plan for DOC approval, which includes how we intend to rehome the lizards, including monitoring and pest control.' A lizard survey found 11 southern grass skinks, considered 'At Risk – Declining' in New Zealand, within the project boundary he said. 'It is expected that there are more, and we are preparing plans for finding and relocating up to 140 of these skinks during construction.' NZTA has also been working with Environment Canterbury to provide enhanced habitat for bird nesting ahead of the breeding season, particularly for the threatened, black-billed gull (tarāpuka), away from the project area and ahead of construction starting. Three existing, raised gravel islands in the river around the SH1 bridge have been identified as suitable habitat for nesting birds, and NZTA has started clearing the islands of vegetation and debris downstream of the bridge. NZTA staff will provide an update on the Ashburton Second Urban Bridge project at the council meeting on August 20. A public update on the project will take place on September 11 from 3:30-6:30pm at the Event Space at Te Whare Whakatere, Ashburton Library and Civic Centre. NZTA will run the information session for the public to come and see the plans and ask questions.
The Spinoff
a day ago
- The Spinoff
Cheaper petrol on its way under new system – but will drivers end up paying more?
While Chris Bishop calls it the biggest change to road funding in 50 years, details on how the new system will work remain scarce for now, writes Catherine McGregor in today's extract from The Bulletin. Major shift from fuel tax to pay-per-km The government has announced it will scrap fuel excise duty and move all vehicles to a system of road user charges (RUCs), in what transport minister Chris Bishop called 'the biggest change to how we fund our roading network in 50 years'. He said the surge in fuel-efficient, hybrid and full electric vehicles had eroded the longstanding connection between petrol consumption and kilometres driven. Under the new system, charges would be based on distance travelled, vehicle type, time and location. The timeline is still vague: Bishop expects legislation to pass in 2026, with the system 'open for business' by 2027. But a full transition date for light vehicles remains deliberately unannounced, with Bishop explaining the government is 'focused on getting the system right rather than rushing its rollout', reports the Herald's Jamie Ensor. Privatised and digitised Alongside the policy shift comes a sweeping modernisation of the road charging system. Gone will be the paper labels stuck to windscreens, replaced by a fully digital e-RUC system. The NZTA's dual role as both regulator and RUC retailer will be split, with private firms taking over the collection and administration of charges. The idea is that this will drive innovation and reduce compliance costs by allowing the market to offer high-tech solutions, such as integrations with in-car computers. 'Instead of expanding a clunky government system, we will reform the rules to allow the market to deliver innovative, user-friendly services for drivers,' Bishop said. Flexible payment options like monthly billing and post-pay models are being considered, and RUCs could be bundled with tolls and congestion charges in a single bill. As Luke Malpass writes this morning in The Post (paywalled), the new system is being designed with one eye firmly on a future where our most expensive roads are funded with tolls, and ease of payment will be key to getting people to use them. 'Roads have to be paid for somehow,' he notes. A pattern of reform The transport minister's announcement came as a surprise to many, but the move had been clearly signalled for years. National ran on eliminating fuel taxes and the policy was part of the National-Act coalition agreement. Last year the government scrapped the Auckland regional fuel tax and oversaw the imposition of RUCs on electric vehicles, ending a long-standing exemption. These earlier moves laid the groundwork for yesterday's grand shift. As the number of petrol hybrids on the roads climbs – from 12,000 in 2015 to 350,000 today – there's a growing mismatch between fuel tax contributions and actual road usage, Bishop said, adding that lower-income drivers of older cars are effectively subsidising wealthier owners of hybrids and EVs. The missing details While the move has been widely framed as a step toward fairness and future-proofing, many of the key details remain unresolved, writes Stuff's Michael Daly. One key question: how much drivers will pay. Bishop gave no indication as to how much the government is planning to charge different vehicle types under the new system. Currently, light diesel vehicles pay $76 per 1000km, but that figure may not translate directly to petrol vehicles. Owners of small, fuel-efficient cars could be forgiven for worrying they'll end up paying more under a RUC system, regardless of the weight class tiers. There are also concerns about the cost of privatising tax collection. 'The only people who will see any benefit from this scheme are the corporates who take their cut to gather the tax,' said Fleur Fitzsimons of the Public Service Association, whose members include NZTA employees. As the legislation progresses and the 2027 rollout approaches, the government will need to spell out what motorists are actually signing up for – and how much they'll be paying.
