CAS stays AIFF decision to crown Churchill as I-League champions on application from Inter Kashi
In an order passed 'on request for provisional measures', Elizabeth Steiner, the Deputy President of the Appeals Arbitration Division of the CAS, also barred the AIFF from conducting any medal ceremony till the case is decided.
The AIFF, on April 18, belatedly announced Churchill Brothers as the I-League champions after the its Appeals Committee ruled against second-placed Inter Kashi, who had then knocked the doors of the world's highest sports tribunal based in Switzerland.
New Delhi, Apr 27 (PTI) The drama surrounding this season's I-League title continued as the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) on Sunday stayed the decision of the All India Football Federation (AIFF) to declare Churchill Brothers of Goa as the champions on an application filed by Inter Kashi.
'The decision rendered by the Appeal Committee of All India Football Federation rendered on 18 April 2025 is stayed,' Elizabeth Steiner said in an 'ex parte' order.
'The All India Football Federation is ordered not to declare the winner of the I-League 2024/2025 or organise a medal ceremony for the I-League 2024-25 until the present arbitration has been concluded,' said the Austrian jurist.
In 'ex parte' order, the proceeding or action involves only one party without notice to the other. These orders are in place only until further hearings can be held.
The CAS granted the respondents, including the AIFF and Churchill Brothers 'a time limit to file a full reply to the application for provisional measures until 29 April 2025.' 'The costs of the present Order shall be determined in the final award or in any other final disposition of this arbitration,' the order said.
Churchill Brothers had finished provisionally on top of the table with 40 points after the final round on April 6. But, their title and Indian Super League promotion were subject to the outcome of Inter Kashi's disputed points from their January 13 match against Namdhari SC, which the latter had won 2-0.
The AIFF Disciplinary Committee had awarded a 3-0 forfeit win and three points to Inter Kashi after ruling that Namdhari fielded an 'ineligible player'.
That decision would have taken Inter Kashi to 42 points, enough to clinch the title. However, the AIFF Appeals Committee later put the Disciplinary Committee order 'inoperative and in abeyance' pending a final hearing.
After a delayed process, including a postponed April 12 hearing due to Namdhari's counsel citing 'sickness', the AIFF's Appeals Committee on April 18 set aside the Disciplinary Committee's order and ruled in favour of Churchill.
On the basis of its Appeal Committee ruling, the AIFF had declared Churchill Brothers as I-League champions.
Inter Kashi had, however, released a statement signalling their intent to escalate the matter to CAS.
'The conclusion of the hearing, and with it, the exhaustion of all internal dispute resolution processes, enables Inter Kashi to approach the CAS for a truly free and fair hearing of the matter.
'Inter Kashi will keep no stone unturned to secure justice, and any celebration in the interim may ultimately prove to be premature in nature,' the club had said in a statement. PTI PDS PDS AH AH
This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
3 hours ago
- First Post
India vs Hong Kong Live Streaming: How to watch 2027 AFC Asian Cup Qualifiers match?
India will face Hong Kong in a crucial AFC Asian Cup 2027 Qualifiers match on 10 June at Kai Tak Stadium. Both teams are still seeking their first win in Group C. Find out head-to-head stats, live streaming details, and full squads. read more India and Hong Kong are still looking for their first win in Group C. Image: AIFF The Indian football team will play an important match against Hong Kong in the AFC Asian Cup 2027 qualifiers. The game will take place on Tuesday, 10 June at the Kai Tak Stadium in Hong Kong. , which was an international friendly. So, the Blue Tigers will be looking to make a strong comeback in this game. This match is a big one in Group C because India and Hong Kong are the top-ranked teams in the group. But neither of them have won a game yet. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD India, who are ranked 127th in the FIFA rankings, had a draw with Bangladesh in their first match in March. Hong Kong, ranked 153rd, also drew their first game against Singapore. More from Football India vs Hong Kong: Head-to-head record When looking at the overall head-to-head record, India have the upper hand with 9 wins from 24 matches. Hong Kong have won eight times, and there have been seven draws between the two teams. Their most recent meeting came in Kolkata in the AFC Asian Cup Qualifiers in 2022, which India won 4-0. Where to watch live streaming of India vs Hong Kong AFC Asian Cup 2027 Qualifiers match? Fans in India can watch the India vs Hong Kong 2027 AFC Asian Cup Qualifiers match live via the FanCode app and website. Where to watch live broadcast of India vs Hong Kong AFC Asian Cup 2027 Qualifiers match**?** The live broadcast of India vs Hong Kong 2027 AFC Asian Cup Qualifiers match will be available on Star Sports Network (Star Sports 3 TV channel). India vs Hong Kong squads India's squad: Vishal Kaith, Gurmeet Singh Chahal, Amrinder Singh, Naorem Roshan Singh, Rahul Bheke, Konsham Chinglensana Singh, Anwar Ali, Thangjam Boris Singh, Sandesh Jhingan, Asish Rai, Tekcham Abhishek Singh, Suresh Singh Wangjam, Naorem Mahesh Singh, Ayush Dev Chhetri, Udanta Singh Kumam, Lalengmawia Ralte, Liston Colaco, Ashique Kuruniyan, Brandon Fernandes, Nikhil Prabhu, Sunil Chhetri, Edmund Lalrindika, Manvir Singh, Suhail Ahmad Bhat, Lallianzuala Chhangte
Time of India
15 hours ago
- Time of India
Patchy India confront Hong Kong's ‘naturalised' force
Panaji: Manolo Marquez has been in-charge of the national team for seven games since last year, and his only win was against lowly-ranked Maldives where, by the coach's own admission, his team 'didn't play a good game. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now ' There have been disappointing results, including last week's 2-0 loss against Thailand, but given some encouraging performances – draws against Vietnam away, Malaysia at home, – Manolo believes India can get a favourable result against Hong Kong in the Asian Cup 2027 final round qualifier at the newly-constructed Kai Tak Stadium, a 50,000-capacity venue that will host its first football match. 'We are not very worried about the scores in friendlies,' Manolo told reporters on Monday. 'What's important is that our focus is on the important game.' Given their patchy form, India will find it challenging. But having dropped points against Bangladesh in the opening round, they now must win against Hong Kong to have their noses in front as only the group toppers qualify for the continental showpiece in Saudi Arabia. 'The environment in the team is good. Obviously, in all teams across the world, the environment is better when you are winning games constantly. But the environment, the relationship between the players, regardless of the results, is very good. It's true that we have won just one game against Maldives, but the team is also difficult to beat. We are preparing some things for the future,' said Manolo. Nobody knows about Indian football's future but the present certainly looks bleak. Spread over 18 months and 16 matches, India have won just two. The three trophies that India won at home in 2023 and the away win against Kuwait in the World Cup qualifiers seem like ancient history. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now No wonder the AIFF is concerned. The federation has told coach Manolo that the players will get a bonus of $50,000 (approx. Rs 43 lakh) if they win against Hong Kong, the first such reward in over 20 years when a promise of Rs 1 lakh to each member of the team was made, if they could beat mighty Japan in the World Cup qualifiers. On paper, India should get the job done against a team who are ranked 153, 26 slots behind. The head-to-head record is marginally better too with nine wins to Hong Kong's eight in 24 meetings. When the two teams last met in Kolkata, the hosts scripted a comfortable 4-0 victory. Plenty though has changed since then. Hong Kong has started fielding naturalised players, making the team stronger, as evident from the first-half lead that they took against in a friendly last month. The only goal for the hosts in that 1-3 loss came from the boots of Juninho, a naturalised Brazilian. Other foreign-born players include Everton Camargo, Stefan Pereira and Dudu. 'If I am the Hong Kong coach, maybe I would do the same,' said Manolo. 'The problem is the rule. If I have my father or mother or someone very close from the country, I can understand. But there are countries that just select players if they play in the league. For me, it's not fair.' Ashley Westwood won't mind. A familiar name in Indian football having coached several teams, including most-famously Bengaluru FC, the former Manchester United trainee took over Hong Kong in 2024 after leaving his previous post with Afghanistan. He started badly, a solitary goal loss against Liechtenstein, but then bounced back with seven straight wins, their longest winning streak in almost 40 years. Since Westwood took charge, Hong Kong have lost just one of their last 10 matches. But there have been concerning draws, most notably the stalemate against Nepal last week, a result that will provide India with some hope.
Hindustan Times
15 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Hong Kong could be Marquez's last match as India coach
Kolkata: Manolo Marquez will hope to keep India on track for an unprecedented third successive Asian Cup finals berth when they face hosts Hong Kong in Tuesday's qualifier, which could be his last match as head coach. A win would be the ideal way to end his short India stint but for that Marquez's men will have to do what no Indian team has since 1957 – win in Hong Kong. All four teams in Group C, from where only the winners will qualify to the 2027 Asian Cup, have one point following 0-0 draws. The All India Football Federation (AIFF) has announced a bonus of $50,000 should India win at the stadium in Kai Tak Sports Park which will be inaugurated with this match. The last time the teams met in 2022, India won 4-0 in Kolkata. Appointed last August, Marquez continued as FC Goa and India head coach till May 31. From June 1 to May 31, 2026, Marquez is on contract only as India coach but has said he would not like to continue, according to officials at AIFF, Goa Football Association and FC Goa. The officials requested anonymity given the sensitive nature of the issue. Having won the Super Cup with them, Marquez is likely to continue as FC Goa coach. HT had reported this in its edition on May 6, 2025. India have won only one of their seven matches under Marquez, four of them including the qualifier against Bangladesh ending in draws. To prepare for the Hong Kong tie, India played Thailand last week and lost 0-2. Marquez, 56, did not want to make much of that saying on Monday that 'coaches are not worried about scores in friendly games'. India have trained nearly three weeks for this match. 'Our preparations have been much better this time, if we compare with the previous FIFA windows where you practically don't have too much time,' said Marquez, who won the Indian Super League cup with Hyderabad FC in 2021-22. In defence, Anwar Ali has recovered from fever leaving only Subhasish Bose unavailable due to injury. Under Ashley Westwood, the former Bengaluru FC, Punjab FC and ATK coach, Hong Kong prepared for this match with a 1-3 defeat against Manchester United and a 0-0 draw against Nepal. Hong Kong drew 0-0 against Singapore in their first match of the qualifying campaign. Unlike India, they have naturalised players born in Brazil, Spain and Japan.
