Stab victim ‘gave grief' to murder-accused's friend over £20 debt, trial told
The defendant, of Station Road, Stanley, Derbyshire, pleaded guilty to possessing a bladed article in a public place but denies murder.
Marcus Coleman, a friend of Hartle's who was 'feet away' from the attack, went with two other friends and the defendant to buy cannabis from Mr Smedley that evening.
Mr Coleman, who was 17 at the time but is now 18, denied that there was animosity between him and Mr Smedley because of an incident months earlier.
Peter Joyce KC, defending Hartle, cross-examined Mr Coleman, who gave evidence from behind a screen at Derby Crown Court on Thursday, and said: 'Noah had been causing you… some grief about a £20 debt of cannabis a little while before.'
The witness replied: 'It was a separate incident that happened months prior, it had nothing to do with this incident.'
Mr Joyce said: 'I suggest it was on this night you saw Charlie for the first time in four months, that's when you told him about the problem with Noah.
'You told him that Noah was giving you grief. Noah had really annoyed you, irritated you, hacked you off.'
Mr Coleman said it was 'not really a problem'.
Mr Joyce said: 'There was no need at all for four of you to go and meet Noah was there? Unless there was a second purpose that required all four of you to go, namely to give him a bit of a slapping.
'For the next four hours the three of you are together at your home aren't you? The three of you instead spent between nine o'clock and one o'clock… doing a number of things. One, smoking weed. Two, talking about what had happened and, I suggest, agreeing your stories.'
Mr Coleman replied: 'No sir.'
Mr Joyce asked: 'Did you decide you would not say the three of you had a grudge against Noah?'
The witness said no.
Mr Coleman said: 'We weren't really talking about anything sir, we were shocked. We were trying to distract ourselves with the cannabis and I think I was on my PS5 at the time, trying to distract myself from the situation.'
When asked why he left the scene with his friends after Hartle ran away instead of helping Mr Smedley, Mr Coleman said he was 'scared' and added: 'I still regret it to this day.'
Mr Joyce said: 'You ran away from Noah in the opposite direction and you took a roundabout route to get away so you would not be seen.
'I'm going to suggest that the reason for all of that was that all four of you – you three and Charlie – had agreed earlier that Noah was to be given a bit of a slapping.'
Mr Coleman replied: 'No, not true sir.'
The trial continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
a day ago
- Powys County Times
Newtown's Stafford Jones hit woman in Aberystwyth bar
A Newtown man has been jailed for almost two years for a forearm or elbow smash on a woman in a nightclub that left her out cold and needing stitches. Stafford Jones, of Lon Maesycoed, Newtown, appeared before Swansea Crown Court on Friday (July 18). The 30-year-old had previously admitted one count of unlawful wounding which occurred in Aberystwyth on July 14, 2023. David Singh, prosecuting, said the incident, which was captured on CCTV, happened at Bar 46 just after midnight. The footage showed Emily Renshaw, the victim, gesticulating with the defendant. She was then seen to push Jones - who reacted by hitting her with what the court heard was "either an elbow or forearm". The complainant immediately fell to the floor and lost consciousness. She suffered a laceration to her lip which required stiches, and bruising to her eye and facial area. The defendant was arrested in Liverpool on August 13, 2023. In police interview, Jones claimed that the victim had approached her in a bar "shouting abuse". He said he'd never seen her before, but that she was "aggressive and irate". The defendant said that he had then left with a friend and gone to Bar 46 in Bridge Street - but said that the victim followed him between bars and approached him again, threatening to "get my cousin on you". He claimed that she pushed him, and that he reacted as shown in the CCTV footage. "I understand my actions were excessive, and I am remorseful for them," he said. The defendant has 14 previous convictions for 18 offences, the court was told - including previous offences of violent disorder and battery. Defending, Alycia Carpanini, said Jones had expressed remorse and regret over the incident, admitting that he had been an "idiot". She added that he was determined to be a "better role model" for his two children. Judge Huw Rees sentenced Jones to 22 months imprisonment.
Glasgow Times
2 days ago
- Glasgow Times
Boy who stabbed pupil to death tells jury why he took ‘scary' knife to school
The teenager told a court on Friday he did not want to go to school on the morning he killed Harvey Willgoose, also 15, because 'I thought I was going to get hurt that day'. The defendant was giving evidence for a third day at Sheffield Crown Court, where he is on trial for murdering Harvey during the lunch break at All Saints Catholic High School in the city on February 3. Harvey Willgoose was stabbed during a lunch break at All Saints Catholic High School (Jacob King/PA) He told the court he 'ordered' the knife because 'it was a scary-looking knife and, if I pulled it out, somebody wouldn't try to pull out theirs'. Gul Nawaz Hussain KC, defending, asked the boy: 'We know you took a knife to school with you that morning, why?' The defendant replied: 'In case anyone tried to pull a knife out on me or try to hurt me.' Mr Hussain said: 'Did you want to start any trouble that day?' The boy said: 'No.' And Mr Hussain asked him: 'Did you want to hurt anyone that day?' The boy replied: 'No.' The barrister read a Snapchat message Harvey sent to the defendant before school that day, which said: 'Is it beef I what', which the boy said he read as meaning: 'Is it beef or what?' Mr Hussain said: 'Did you want beef with Harvey?' The boy said: 'No.' The defendant explained to the jury of eight women and four men how he met Harvey after arriving at school on February 3 and Harvey said to him: 'Is it beef between me and you?' He said he asked Harvey why he thought he had 'beef' with him but Harvey just asked him about his injured hand. The boy said they then started joking about boxing and started sparring in the corridor. The defendant said Harvey was laughing and he told the jury: 'I was thinking it was alright between me and him.' The boy said they parted with a handshake, but bumped into each later in the morning and Harvey said to him: 'Watch where you are f****** going,' in an angry way. The defendant said he tapped Harvey on the arm and Harvey said: 'Don't touch me. I'll actually juck (corr) you up.' The boy said: 'In Sheffield, juck means stab.' He said Harvey was 'angry in his face and said it quite angrily', telling the jury: 'I felt confused because we shook hands this morning.' The defendant then described an incident in a lesson he had with Harvey just before the lunch break. He said Harvey bumped into him and said: 'I'll smash you all over.' The boy said he backed off but said to Harvey: 'Do it then.' He said Harvey told him: 'I'll batter you. Let's take it outside.' The defendant has told the trial how he had no problems with Harvey until an incident five days before the fatal stabbing, which led to the school going into lockdown. The defendant has admitted manslaughter but denies murder (Jacob King/PA) According to prosecutors, two members of staff physically intervened in a dispute between two other students and the defendant had to be restrained as he tried to get involved. The jury has been told it was the defendant's claim that one boy had a knife that led the school to go into lockdown, although the police who responded never found a weapon. The defendant said he was off school for the next two days because he was so concerned for his safety. The jury has heard Harvey was not involved in the altercation but joined in a Snapchat group exchange over the following weekend. The defendant described how these exchanges left him feeling even more scared but his father made him go to school on the Monday morning – February 3. He said: 'I got a bad feeling about going to school that day. 'I felt like something was going to happen.' The jury has been shown CCTV footage of Harvey being stabbed in a courtyard at All Saints later that day. The court has heard that the defendant, who cannot be named, has admitted manslaughter but denies murder. He has also admitted possession of a knife on school premises. Addressing the jury last week, Mr Hussain said: '(The defendant) did not set out to kill or seriously hurt anyone. 'The defence say (the defendant's) actions that day were the end result of a long period of bullying, poor treatment and violence, things that built one upon another until he lost control and did tragically what we've all seen.' The defendant will continue giving evidence on Monday.
Powys County Times
2 days ago
- Powys County Times
Boy who stabbed pupil to death tells jury why he took ‘scary' knife to school
A 15-year-old boy who stabbed a fellow pupil to death has told a jury he took a 'scary-looking knife' to school that day 'in case anyone tried to pull a knife out on me or try to hurt me'. The teenager told a court on Friday he did not want to go to school on the morning he killed Harvey Willgoose, also 15, because 'I thought I was going to get hurt that day'. The defendant was giving evidence for a third day at Sheffield Crown Court, where he is on trial for murdering Harvey during the lunch break at All Saints Catholic High School in the city on February 3. He told the court he 'ordered' the knife because 'it was a scary-looking knife and, if I pulled it out, somebody wouldn't try to pull out theirs'. Gul Nawaz Hussain KC, defending, asked the boy: 'We know you took a knife to school with you that morning, why?' The defendant replied: 'In case anyone tried to pull a knife out on me or try to hurt me.' Mr Hussain said: 'Did you want to start any trouble that day?' The boy said: 'No.' And Mr Hussain asked him: 'Did you want to hurt anyone that day?' The boy replied: 'No.' The barrister read a Snapchat message Harvey sent to the defendant before school that day, which said: 'Is it beef I what', which the boy said he read as meaning: 'Is it beef or what?' Mr Hussain said: 'Did you want beef with Harvey?' The boy said: 'No.' The defendant explained to the jury of eight women and four men how he met Harvey after arriving at school on February 3 and Harvey said to him: 'Is it beef between me and you?' He said he asked Harvey why he thought he had 'beef' with him but Harvey just asked him about his injured hand. The boy said they then started joking about boxing and started sparring in the corridor. The defendant said Harvey was laughing and he told the jury: 'I was thinking it was alright between me and him.' The boy said they parted with a handshake, but bumped into each later in the morning and Harvey said to him: 'Watch where you are f****** going,' in an angry way. The defendant said he tapped Harvey on the arm and Harvey said: 'Don't touch me. I'll actually juck (corr) you up.' The boy said: 'In Sheffield, juck means stab.' He said Harvey was 'angry in his face and said it quite angrily', telling the jury: 'I felt confused because we shook hands this morning.' The defendant then described an incident in a lesson he had with Harvey just before the lunch break. He said Harvey bumped into him and said: 'I'll smash you all over.' The boy said he backed off but said to Harvey: 'Do it then.' He said Harvey told him: 'I'll batter you. Let's take it outside.' The defendant has told the trial how he had no problems with Harvey until an incident five days before the fatal stabbing, which led to the school going into lockdown. According to prosecutors, two members of staff physically intervened in a dispute between two other students and the defendant had to be restrained as he tried to get involved. The jury has been told it was the defendant's claim that one boy had a knife that led the school to go into lockdown, although the police who responded never found a weapon. The defendant said he was off school for the next two days because he was so concerned for his safety. The jury has heard Harvey was not involved in the altercation but joined in a Snapchat group exchange over the following weekend. The defendant described how these exchanges left him feeling even more scared but his father made him go to school on the Monday morning – February 3. He said: 'I got a bad feeling about going to school that day. 'I felt like something was going to happen.' The jury has been shown CCTV footage of Harvey being stabbed in a courtyard at All Saints later that day. The court has heard that the defendant, who cannot be named, has admitted manslaughter but denies murder. He has also admitted possession of a knife on school premises. Addressing the jury last week, Mr Hussain said: '(The defendant) did not set out to kill or seriously hurt anyone. 'The defence say (the defendant's) actions that day were the end result of a long period of bullying, poor treatment and violence, things that built one upon another until he lost control and did tragically what we've all seen.'
