Yankees manager Aaron Boone is ripped for appalling decision as his AL team loses All-Star Game in historic tiebreaker
After putting on a furious six-run comeback to tie the game, the American League manager completely whiffed on his selections for the first ever 'swing-off' in All-Star Game history.
The AL was down 6-0 going into the seventh inning, but put on four runs in the top of the seventh.
Then, a miraculous two-run ninth inning extended the game and then forced a 'swing-off' for the first time ever. Rules of the swing-off allowed each manager to pick three hitters to take three swings to try and hit the most home runs.
National League manager Dave Roberts, who also leads the Los Angeles Dodgers, sent up Miami's Kyle Stowers, Philadelphia's Kyle Schwarber, and New York Mets star Pete Alonso.
Boone fell flat. While the selection of Home Run Derby participant Brent Rooker of the Athletics made sense, his other two choices were Seattle's Randy Arozarena and Tampa Bay's Jonathan Aranda.
After going down 6-0 by the seventh inning, the AL put up a comeback to tie the game after nine innings. A new rule had the ASG end by a Home Run Derby between three players.
Arozarena is 31st in baseball for home runs with 17. Aranda has only hit 11 homers - putting him in a tie for 101st.
Rooker took an early lead with two blasts, while Stowers hit only one. Arozarena stepped up and only sent one hit over the wall with his three swings.
Next, Schwarber stepped up and hit all three swings for home runs to take a 4-3 lead for the NL.
Hope rested on the shoulders of Aranda, who needed to hit at least one more home run to extend the proceedings further. Two home runs would force Alonso's hand even further.
Instead, Alonso never came up to bat. Aranda took three swings and missed on all three of them as the NL won the All-Star Game.
When the dust settled, Boone was roasted on social media for his mind-boggling decision making.
It was only made worse when ESPN's Jesse Rogers reported that Alonso told journalists that participants in the swing-off 'are pre-determined by the managers before the game even starts'.
Before the swing-off even happened, sports writer Bill Simmons joked, 'The AL is gonna get killed in the All-Star Game, then Aaron Boone is gonna tell reporters he liked how his guys looked out there - every AL fan gets to be a Yankee fan tonight.'
The first ever home run swing off at the All-Star Game was absolute CINEMA 🍿 pic.twitter.com/pNYqhO0Hwy
— FOX Sports: MLB (@MLBONFOX) July 16, 2025
The AL took an early lead when Brent Rooker (L) out-swung Kyle Stowers (R)
The AL's final batter was Jonathan Aranda, who has only hit eleven home runs on the season and is 101st in all of baseball. Aranda didn't hit a single home run and the NL won the game.
Well, the AL didn't get killed per se. But, the Aaron Boone Experience was in full effect and fans pilloried him on social media.
'I'm not even a Yankees fan but I want Aaron Boone fired,' wrote one user on X.
Another joked, 'Aaron Boone has been my manager for 7 innings and now I know why Yankee fans are always so grumpy.
'MLB invented those swing-off rules 45 minutes ago and Aaron Boone still found a way to have a managerial disasterclass. God bless him,' a third user said.
'This mf Aaron Boone deadass put Jonathan Aranda in the homerun derby with the All Star Game on the line,' a different post read.
Another user posted, 'Leave it to Aaron Boone to make the wrong decisions even in a meaningless game.'
Schwarber's heroics led to him being named the MVP for the All-Star Game.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
28 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Max Holloway spoils Dustin Poirier's retirement sendoff with decision win
The trilogy fight between Max Holloway and Dustin Poirier may not have been a microcosm of their first two encounters, but it delivered an electrifying final 15 seconds when Holloway and the retiring Poirier traded blows in Round 5. The result was a victory for lightweight Holloway by unanimous decision on the three judges' cards -- 48-47, 49-46, 49-46 -- at UFC 318 in New Orleans on Saturday night. Advertisement Holloway (27-8 MMA) was classy in victory against Poirier, as he had lost the first two fights of the series before returning the favor in Louisiana native Poirier's last MMA bout. "The baddest man alive, bro," said Holloway, 33. "Give it up for Dustin Poirier." A first-round knockdown from the Hawaiian set the tone early as Holloway nearly finished Poirier (30-10) but his 36-year-old opponent persevered. By Round 4, Poirier had little energy left but admitted post-fight that he was impressed that the former featherweight champion Holloway's striking was still as sharp as ever. According to the final stats on the broadcast, Holloway outlanded Poirier 113-99 in significant head strikes. Advertisement "I thought he was going to be in here cracking a little bit harder, which he was," Poirier said of Holloway. "This guy is tough to deal with when he's in front of you. He's slick. He's crafty. He's fast. He's the (BMF) champ. I got nothing but respect for Max, man. He's one of the good guys." Holloway made his first defense of the "BMF" title a successful one since winning it last April at UFC 300. It is unclear what direction the belt takes, as it is not associated with a division and has been used infrequently since November 2019 Paulo Costa of Brazil got back in the win column with a unanimous decision over Roman Kopylov, utilizing his boxing to sweep the cards 30-27, 30-27, 29-28. Costa (15-4) remains in the middleweight title picture, while Kopylov (14-4) had won his last two fights. The next two fights also saw another string of decisions with welterweight Daniel Rodriguez outlasting Kevin Holland despite a late rally from Holland nearly finishing him in Round 3 with strikes. The cards read 29-28, 29-28, 29-28, as Holland (28-14) was another betting favorite at the expense of Rodriguez (20-5). Advertisement Patricio Pitbull earned his first UFC victory with a win by unanimous decision over featherweight Dan Ige by identical 29-28 scores. Pitbull's wrestling was too much for Ige, who entered the fight having lost two of his last three fights. Pitbull (37-8) last fought in April at UFC 314, where Ige (19-10) earned a win on the same card. UFC 318's pay-per-view got underway with lightweight Michael Johnson earning a unanimous decision in an upset of Daniel Zellhuber. The 39-year-old Johnson (24-19) was a significant underdog entering the fight but won the cards with matching 29-28 scores. A second-round knockdown swung the fight in Johnson's favor, as Zellhuber (15-3) now has lost back-to-back outings.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Phillies will again look to big boppers in finale vs. Angels
July 20 - Kyle Schwarber and Bryce Harper are giving the Los Angeles Angels all they can handle this weekend. The Philadelphia Phillies hope for another powerful performance from their left-handed sluggers on Sunday when they conclude their three-game home series with the Angels. Schwarber has homered in each of the first two games of the series, including a go-ahead grand slam in Saturday's 9-5 victory. His impressive week also included MVP honors at Tuesday's All-Star Game after he swatted homers on all three of his swings during the tie-breaking home run derby. Meanwhile, Harper homered twice in Friday's series opener -- a 6-5 win by Los Angeles -- and delivered another blast in Saturday's win. He is 5-for-8 with four runs scored in the series. The power surge by Schwarber and Harper has certainly been a welcomed sight for a Phillies team that has struggled to hit home runs (outside of Schwarber) for much of the season. "It's just the way this game goes," Schwarber said after the win. "You want to be able to feel like you're going to be able to score runs in different ways." Philadelphia needs its power hitters to produce more than ever with third baseman Alec Bohm -- the team's typical clean-up hitter -- on the injured list with a rib fracture. "It could be three weeks. It could be four weeks," manager Rob Thomson said. "It could be less than that. I hate putting timelines on anything." The Angels have enjoyed some home run fun of their own in the first two games of the series. Taylor Ward has gone deep in both contests, as has Jo Adell. In total, the visitors have cranked out six home runs -- three in each game. Instead, Saturday's culprit was the Los Angeles bullpen. Angels relievers gave up seven runs in three innings pitched. But Los Angeles interim manager Ray Montgomery isn't losing any confidence in his relievers. "They're young. They're still battling through it," he said. "They haven't figured out who they are yet entirely. So we're going to continue putting them in situations like that and look for the best spots -- and, hopefully, they make the pitches they need to make." The Angels will aim to rebound behind right-hander Jose Soriano (6-7, 3.90 ERA), who will be starting against the Phillies for the first time. He faced Philadelphia once as a reliever in 2023 and allowed a two-run triple to Trea Turner during a brief stint on the mound. Soriano's last start came July 13 against the Arizona Diamondbacks. He gave up five runs, but only one earned, in five innings in a 5-1 defeat. Ranger Suarez (7-3, 2.15) will get the ball for Philadelphia after a solid first half in which he gave up three runs or fewer in each of his last 12 starts. Most recently, the lefty allowed three runs in 6 2/3 innings in a 4-2 loss to the San Diego Padres on July 11. Suarez, who has never previously faced the Angels, was at peace with not getting selected for the National League All-Star team. "Obviously it's what you want -- you want to go to the All-Star Game. But I'd rather have some rest right now," he said prior to the break. "I think it's what's best for us, for the team and it's a long second half that we're going to have. So, I want to remain as healthy and as fresh as I can." --Field Level Media
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Flawless Scottie Scheffler leads at The Open but Rory McIlroy threat remains
Relentless Scottie Scheffler kept his head as others around him were losing theirs, but while his main rivals fell away, the spectre of Rory McIlroy loomed in the distance. However, the Northern Irishman's six-shot deficit may be too far back even for someone who completed the career Grand Slam at the Masters earlier this year, considering the quality of his quarry. Advertisement McIlroy's description of Scheffler as 'inevitable' summed up the situation perfectly, as while the American was not as spectacular as he was on Friday in assuming the lead, his progress to a 67 and a four-shot advantage was serene. Matt Fitzpatrick, who began the day one behind, briefly drew level after an eagle at the second but he was never able to edge himself in front, and every time he slipped up he was punished by his playing partner, either by moving another shot away or saving an unlikely par. McIlroy, six groups ahead, rode the wave of home support hyped by three birdies in his first four holes, and while his momentum stalled it was reignited by a monster 56-foot eagle putt – his longest of the week – at the 12th which produced the loudest roar of the tournament. It was important as he had bogeyed the previous hole in a bizarre incident when his shot from the rough dislodged a previously buried ball. Advertisement But it was a stroke of good luck at the 15th which brought his final birdie of the day as, coming out hot from the rough, it bounced against the flagstick and dropped four feet from the hole. Rory McIlroy sank three birdies in his opening four holes on Saturday (Mike Egerton/PA) McIlroy mania reached its peak at the 17th. With his burnt orange shirt appearing red on television screens, the sight of him marching out of the packed gallery surrounded by thousands of fans was reminiscent of Tiger Woods. The crowd were so ramped they went wild as he pitched 33 feet past the hole, offering little chance of birdie, but they believed – as they will continue to do on Sunday. The Masters champion, however, is a little more realistic. Advertisement 'Scottie Scheffler, he is inevitable. Even when he doesn't have his best stuff he has become a compete player,' said McIlroy. 'It's going to be tough to catch him tomorrow if he keeps playing the way he does, but if I can get out tomorrow with a similar start to today and get the crowd going, hopefully he feels that behind me – and you never know.' England's Matt Fitzpatrick is also in contention (Peter Byrne/PA) Scheffler looks unshakeable, though. Already with a three-shot lead, he birdied the difficult Calamity Corner 16th for the third successive day and the gap was looking as big as the chasm in front of the par three. China's ultra-consistent Haotong Li is his closest challenger, with Fitzpatrick dropping back to nine under – where he started the round – having reached 11 under. Advertisement Scheffler reeled off six straight pars but still did not lose his overnight lead before a back-to-back eagle and birdie represented a gear shift. His back nine included eight pars, and the kind of nerveless saves which have made him one of the most successful and consistent golfers of the last three years – closing out victory the last 10 times he has held the outright 54-hole leads. 'A lot of it is staying patient. I know what I need to do tomorrow and it is a matter of going out and doing it,' said Scheffler, whose three majors wins have all come leading after the third round. 'I'm not thinking about winning The Open when I go to sleep tonight.' Advertisement Englishman Tyrrell Hatton got himself to nine under but a bogey at the 16th halted his progress, while slightly further down the leaderboard 52-year-old compatriot Lee Westwood had a round of two halves, going out in 40 before an Open record-equalling 29 for the back nine. 'It was a good back nine, wasn't it? I'd have taken 29 on the back nine stood on the 10th tee,' he said. Defending champion Xander Schauffele, who started the day two under having been in danger of missing the cut until a birdie run on his Friday back nine, played the three par-fives in five under with two eagles on the back nine after a birdie at the second. His 66 moved him to seven under but the two-time major winner accepts he is too far back. 'It would have to be a perfect storm situation, it doesn't look like any of those boys up front are letting up,' he said.
