Letters to Editor: water, Al Jazeera, Ardern
Recent opposition to the Waitaki District Council's preferred Water Well Done proposal is probably a reflection of the general lack of trust in the council rather than misinformation.
Take the Proposed District Plan. This now legally enforceable plan allows that certain people are allowed to access private properties to cut, dig and build without the landowner's permission within the new wahi tupuna overlays. Conversely the same landowners can be required to consult with and pay whatever fee iwi deem appropriate in addition to council's own consenting requirements.
The consulting process was haphazard and ultimately ignored the concerns of affected landowners. To their credit, councillors John McCone, Guy Percival and Brent Cowles opposed the plan which to the detriment of the Waitaki District community was approved in December.
One councillor even stated that people affected by the PDP can now "share the same feelings of loss and disempowerment and identity ... caused by the Kemp Purchase of 1848". Our community deserves much better representation than being held liable for what happened over 175 years ago.
Mark Hay
Oamaru In-house backed
I am tired of reading Ben Bell's accusations that Waitaki's decision to nix a joint water company with Gore, Clutha and Central Otago is the "misinformed" decision of only 161 submitters in our public consultation.
Out of 300 submitters in the consultation, 85% favoured another option instead of the tie-up with those three districts. Only 15% supported Southern Water Done Well. Sentiment throughout the district was strongly in favour of keeping water in-house.
Faced with an election in three months, the Waitaki councillors suddenly realised that public sentiment was so strong that it had to be respected. That's why the vote was 9-2 for continued in-house operation.
The Gore councillors are wrong to claim that government required them to approve Southern Water Done Well. There are 19 councils nationwide which have chosen in-house. Minister Simon Watts may be trying to bully councils, but this hasn't scared the stronger councils in the past, nor will it in the future.
Mike Sweeney
Oamaru No, it's dire
Dire wolves, mammoths, moa ... .why? Any effort to bring these back from the dead, at this stage is ridiculous, what you get is nothing like the original. What you get is a Claytons version.
As has been shown, the dire wolves are only that in name. They are nothing like the originals, simply a white wolf with a few shredded DNA strands that amount to nothing.
If there was going to be money sunk into these sorts of folly projects I would much prefer it be spent on saving our current flora and fauna
Graham Bulman
Dunedin Higher huts
Re the tragic death of Wednesday Davis on Mt Ruapehu (ODT 14.7.25). This is very sad indeed and the circumstances appear to be particularly distressing for the family, and they have my full sympathy.
I note however that the Whangaehu has been repeatedly reported as the "highest alpine hut in New Zealand". This is not the case by a significant margin. Whangaehu hut is at an altitude of 2080m while Empress Hut (at the top of the Hooker Glacier at Aoraki/Mt Cook) is at an altitude of 2472m, Plateau Hut (also on Aoraki/Mt Cook) is at 2200m, Centennial Hut (on the Franz Josef Glacier) is at 2400m.
Stating that Whangaehu is the highest hut in New Zealand puts an erroneous perspective on the story.
Derek Chinn
Queenstown Overwhelming news and the bare essentials I watch the Al Jazeera news channel. Their news coverage can be difficult to watch. Images can be overwhelming and leave you questioning why some events on this planet are allowed to continue. The only thing on television at the moment that can put a smile on your face is an advertisement. It shows a naked skier, beautiful snow views and the background music is Age of Innocence by Enigma. It is very peaceful and you have to smile.
Lorraine Adams
Oamaru Enduring legacy
I was horrified to read Neville McLay's letter (ODT 14.7.25). Can it really be true that the stadium will only last another 35 years, especially when you think that most old villas were built between 1890 and 1910.
Many will have been renovated in the past 35 years when the houses were already nearly 100 years old.
So the stadium is only to last about a quarter as long as the average old villa?
George Livingstone
Roslyn Boo Sir Ian
It is so very sad to see all the knives pointed in direction of Dame Jacinda Ardern, the latest poison from Sir Ian Taylor. The combined threats and personal attacks made on her mainly through the cowardly medium of social media disgusted me.
Dame Jacinda succeeded in saving many lives when the country faced a relentless and deadly Covid virus. She was applauded and recognised upon the world stage. The mosque massacre and Christchurch earthquakes, she resolutely and bravely faced up to with utmost dignity sincerity and compassion.
Clive McNeill
North East Valley Bravo Sir Ian
"Better late than never" as the saying goes. Recent comments ridiculing and criticising Sir Ian Taylor about his about-face opinion of Jacinda Ardern just goes to show that changing one's mind and an admission of being wrong, is frowned upon and not appreciated by many. I, however applaud his honesty and bravery in publicly admitting his previous error in judgement.
Joyce Yee-Murdoch
Cromwell Boo Sir Ian
I was disappointed by Sir Ian Taylor's article on Jacinda. It read like a lovesick virgin teenager's lament on finding the object of their adoration had feet of plasticene and a far-from-saintly past.
Most politicians who get the top job, with some exceptions, and Jacinda was no exception, do the best they can with the hand they are dealt. And with impeccable timing she quit when she realised she was no longer the solution but part of the problem. We don't need to look far in the contemporary world to find exceptions who did neither. So we should be grateful.
I am absolutely delighted that Jacinda has found things to do and a means of earning a crust, after leaving us Kiwi ingrates for what she must see as greener and safer pastures.
I suggest Sir Ian plants his sour grapes in our great Central soil where they can turn to fine wine, and saves his rocks for his own rockery rather than use them as ammunition.
Morley Williams
Cromwell
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsroom
2 hours ago
- Newsroom
Luxon's failed attempt at empathy
Opinion: During her time as Prime Minister, Dame Jacinda Ardern won international plaudits for her response to the Christchurch Mosque attacks and the Covid-19 pandemic. She was widely regarded as an empathetic political leader who understood and respected the nature of modern society and who genuinely sought to bridge divisions through dialogue and constructive engagement. However, the decline in her support over her last couple of years in office as her government struggled with the post-pandemic recovery showed that, though a generally positive attribute, political empathy in the absence of policy achievement is not enough to maintain public support.
The Spinoff
2 days ago
- The Spinoff
What we saw at Whānau Mārama New Zealand International Film Festival: week one
A Palme d'Or winner, the Jacinda Ardern documentary, cage fighting in Kaikohe and more – reviewed. It Was Just an Accident The Civic was buzzing on opening night of the New Zealand International Film Festival and few films could've justified the packed house like It Was Just an Accident. Hailed by festival director Paolo Bertolin as the first truly deserving Palme d'Or winner in years, the Iranian drama delivers a taut and affecting meditation on justice, memory, and the price of survival. When a group of former political prisoners encounter the man who once tortured them, the film becomes a quiet reckoning – not just with the past, but with the uncertain line between forgiveness and vengeance. Director Jafar Panahi, long a master of subversive Iranian cinema, handles the material with precision and grace. The cinematography is luminous, but never distracts from the film's emotional core, which is often laced with unexpected moments of humour – the kind that briefly disarms before plunging deeper. Though rooted in Iran's political landscape, It Was Just an Accident speaks to universal dilemmas of power and reconciliation. It's a film of rare weight and restraint – one that lingers long after the credits roll. / Liam Rātana Prime Minister I assume no other film festival film has started 30 minutes late because a protest outside and beefed up security meant a very slow entry into the Civic for 2,400 viewers. A documentary about Jacinda Ardern, even two years after she's resigned as prime minister and left the country, will do that. Once it got started, my heart sank – an opening shot both 'observational' but clearly orchestrated of Ardern dropping Neve to the school bus in Chicago before strolling peacefully to Harvard. Would this be a long wellness ad for working at Harvard? Thankfully, it quickly jumped back to 2017, with Ardern about to become Labour leader. There's familiar footage of press conferences and newslines intersected with genuinely enthralling snippets of Ardern's phone calls at the time with the Alexander Turnbull Oral History Project, which are not supposed to be released until after Ardern's death. They're incredibly candid – more candid even than Ardern was in her own book – and give the film that extra emotional weight. It's very hard to properly review a film that covers events most New Zealanders experienced, through one very powerful person's perspective. But if I watched something like this about any other world leader, that had this much access and candour, I would love it. Clarke Gayford has a cinematography credit as the person who filmed a lot of the more intimate moments (Ardern drafting her resignation press release in bed; stressfully reading updates on the mosque shootings). If I left with one impression it's that I can't believe she didn't break up with him through all of that. / Madeleine Chapman Fiume o Morte! The footnotes of history often make the best documentary subjects, and this is very much the case for this documentary by Igor Bezinović, who trains a lens on his hometown, Rijeka in Croatia, and the 18-month period when it was ruled by a proto-fascist Italian aristocrat, army general (and poet!) Gabriele D'Annunzio, and called Fiume. Bezinović's enlisting of the citizens to reenact historical events is a genius format; doing more than just humanising and placing the history in a present context, each brings their own memories, cultural identity and role in the community to the character. D'Annunzio, fuelled by hubris and cocaine, is played by numerous bald men, including a dustman and someone in a punk band. Taking over the city was farcical (though not without very real pain and loss of life) and there's a level of absurdism to the retelling – his loyal, strapping foot soldiers must know how to fight and jump over things but also dance and sing – and it all happens as modern life goes on around it. It's a darkly funny film – there were lots of laughs to be heard at The Academy – and though hyper specific to a region of complex cultures and identities, the broader story is one of the shifting identities of a city, how pasts and presents that often coexist in one place, what we decide to forget and how we chose to remember. See it if you can. / Emma Gleason Kaikohe Blood and Fire Yes this is about an MMA club in a small Far North town — a simple premise on paper — but what Simon Ogsten's documentary really delivers is a gut-punch about the community men crave and where they go to find it. We see the members of Team Alpha find a sense of brotherhood and support alongside the physical rewards (and risks) of the sport, the outsized role the club plays in Kaikohe, we get a sense of where they came from and what hole this fills for them. Ogsten captures the violence, of course, but also the desire for it. At the start of the film, one subject explains how he loves a war and wants a 'wild, mongrel fight', a shocking declaration for some viewers, but one that comes from a deep place and a long, expansive history of martial culture. What that looks like now, how we satisfy such desires and the place they're given in society, puts the sport in context. Contemporarily, violence is both frowned upon and rewarded, depending on where and who's doing it. MMA is booming, in the big leagues and small towns like Kaikohe. After watching this I 'got it', that primal why and modern need, and it makes you think. / Emma Gleason Dreams (Sex Love) A bit of a risky choice from me, knowing nothing about the trilogy(!) of films from Norwegian director Dag Johan Haugerud. Dreams is the final release (after Sex and Love, also showing at the festival) and follows 17-year-old Johanne as she falls head over heels in love with one of her teachers. She writes evocatively of her feelings and interactions with the teacher and eventually shows her writing to her mother and poet grandmother, who debate the ethics of the situation as well as the quality of her writing. Haugerud's greatest achievement in Dreams is accurately, and without condescension, conveying the brutality of a first love and the sense that nothing else in the world is more important or more painful. We view Johanne's relationship with her teacher first through her infatuated lens, then through her guardians' protective lens, then through a subjective, analytical lens as her teacher responds. As is often the case in life, there are no clear villains or heroes, just women of different generations trying to navigate a teenager's powerful crush. Despite a heavy use of voiceover (which is not my preferred narrative technique) I found myself engrossed in Johanne's emotional processing and maturation. Near the start of the film, Johanne describes wanting to tell her teacher how she feels. She's terrified that her teacher will either get mad or, even worse, 'laugh condescendingly, like when a child says something adorable'. It's a relatable and brutal feeling, made all the more ironic throughout the rest of the film as viewers around us laughed at her romantic despair over and over. May we all never forget the agony of a first love. / Madeleine Chapman The Ballad of Wallis Island I turned up to The Ballad of Wallis Island 15 minutes late and stressed to high heaven, scurrying into a seat in the back row as Tim Key was giving a sopping wet Tom Basden a tour of his big old house on what I knew from reading the blurb to be a remote Welsh island. Within literal seconds a smile had involuntarily spread across my face and not a minute had passed before I was full-on chuckling along with the rest of the Civic crowd, which I think tells you everything you really need to know about this film. Story wise, Key plays Charles, a lonely widower and 2x Lotto winner who basically Parent Traps his favourite folk duo, McGwyer Mortimer (Basden and Carey Mulligan), into reuniting to play a one-off gig for him on the island, unwittingly forcing them to confront the pasts they've been simultaneously stuck in and running from. A huge part of this movie's appeal lies in the chemistry: Key and Basden have been friends and comedic collaborators for years (Wallis Island started life as a short film they made together in 2007), and Mulligan slots into the dynamic seamlessly.
Otago Daily Times
6 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Major rates increase forecast for district
It was a case of more bad news for Waitaki ratepayers this week, with suggestions big rates rises could be coming sooner and more often than first thought, as the district tries to fund a financially sustainable in-house water services unit. There was also bad news for those who might be elected to Waitaki District Council in the October elections. As part of the government's Local Water Done Well reforms, councils throughout New Zealand must submit a Water Services Delivery Plan (WSDP) to the Department of Internal Affairs by September 3. The Waitaki District Council last month voted that would be done through an in-house business unit, rejecting three other options including a joint council-controlled organisation (CCO) with the Central Otago, Clutha and Gore district councils. On Tuesday, it held a second weekly workshop to refine a draft plan to be put to Internal Affairs for initial feedback this week. Following the first workshop, councillors heard a rates rise of 25.61% in the 2028 LTP year would be needed to fund the in-house plan (it might also rise to about 30% if depreciation of water assets was included in the WSDP). This week, the council's chief financial officer Amanda Nicholls told the meeting if depreciation was included the 2028 rates rise would need to be 42.55%, with another "significant" increase needed in 2035. However, Mayor Gary Kircher suggested including the depreciation earlier than 2028. Doing so would ease the needed rates rise but bring it forward, Ms Nicholls said. Mr Kircher said he did not think there was a choice. It would mean a 25% rates increase for next year, followed by a 30% hike the following year. He recognised that also meant leaving it to the new council (following the local body elections in October) to redo the long-term plan and try to reduce the rates rise by cutting capital projects. "There's a lot of stuff that council has to do between now and agreeing on that annual plan to cut costs elsewhere," Mr Kircher said. The existing long-term plan was put together under the understanding that the council would adopt a joint CCO water services model, as it had previously said that was its preferred choice of model.
