Look at increasing Scottish Government borrowing limits, MPs tell UK Government
Currently, the Government is limited to borrowing £600 million for day-to-day spending and £450 million for capital projects.
But in a report from the Scottish Affairs Committee at Westminster on the fiscal arrangements north of the border, MPs pushed for the limits to be increased.
The report said: 'At present, the Scottish Government's limited borrowing powers constrain its ability to manage fiscal shocks, as it is only able to borrow for resource purposes to cover forecast errors.
'Capital borrowing limits are currently linked to, and grow in line with, inflation, which may not necessarily be the highest metric of growth.'
It added: 'We agree with the Secretary of State that borrowing limits should be linked to the measure which offers the Scottish Government the highest level of flexibility but, crucially, we note that which metric delivers this remains undetermined.
'The UK Government should therefore publish a transparent analysis of what borrowing limits would look like based on the different metrics advised in the evidence for this inquiry.
'At the next fiscal framework review, we encourage the UK Government to consider reforming the Scottish Government's capital borrowing powers, by automatically coupling borrowing to the metric which offers the highest limit.'
The report comes at the end of an inquiry by the committee which sought to gauge the effectiveness of the Barnett Formula – the measure which dictates the level of funding the UK Government sends to Scotland every year.
The MPs found the measure was 'fit for purpose', although it is 'imperfect'.
The committee also rejected calls for the formula to shift and provide funding to Scotland based on need.
Scotland, the report said, already receives more funding per head than any other country in the UK and a change in the framework could see funding cut.
In written evidence to the committee, Scottish Finance Secretary Shona Robison reiterated the Scottish Government's support for full fiscal autonomy – an arrangement which would see powers over tax and spending devolved.
But the committee dismissed such a move as not being a 'realistic prospect'.
'Fundamental questions remain about how full fiscal autonomy would work in practice, and whether it would be operable within the constraints of the UK's current devolution settlement,' the report said.
'Practicality aside, we do not believe that a compelling case has been made that such a change would automatically result in Scotland receiving a higher level of funding.'
Ms Robison declined an invitation to appear before the committee, leading the MPs to say 'do not see how we can consider this a serious proposition, and we remain to be convinced that this proposal is desirable in principle, let alone workable in practice'.
Responding to the report, Ms Robison said: 'This report rightly recognises that Scotland's finances remain largely dictated by the UK Government's spending decisions, irrespective of the impact on Scottish public services.
'That has meant Scotland has been left with a shortfall of £400 million to pay for the Chancellor's national insurance increase, and saw Scotland short-changed by more than a billion pounds over the next three years at the recent spending review.
'The decisions we have taken to ask higher earners to pay a little bit more – while most income tax payers pay less than in the rest of the UK – mean that we can support vital public services and provide free tuition, prescriptions and the Scottish child payment to help tackle child poverty.'
Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said: 'The spending review provided the Scottish Government with an extra £9.1 billion, giving them a record settlement.
'People will expect that to deliver better outcomes for Scots – lower NHS waiting lists and better attainment in our schools.
'Spending per head in Scotland is around 20% higher than the rest of the UK thanks to the Barnett formula. This report confirms that it appears to be the position of the Scottish Government to scrap that formula that delivers higher funding – they should explain why they want less money for public services in Scotland.
'Their plans for full fiscal autonomy would mean a £12 billion cut in public spending for Scotland.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
an hour ago
- The National
I was at the national Palestine protest in Edinburgh. Here's what happened
This protest came at a time when activists across the UK calling out the genocide in Gaza are having to censor their own language, clothing, and signs, or risk arrest. "What about my watermelon earrings?" one activist asked me when I arrived. Another pointed to their socks that were in support of Palestine. According to campaign group Defend Our Juries, more than 150 arrests have been made at demonstrations across the UK. READ MORE: RECAP: Activists defy Labour with illegal pro-Palestine T-shirts in Edinburgh In Scotland, Sean Clerkin, 64, was arrested and has been charged under the Terrorism Act, after he displayed a placard stating "Genocide in Palestine, Time to Take Action". A 55-year-old man was also charged in Glasgow last week under suspicion of terror offences for wearing a T-shirt allegedly showing support for Palestine Action. Both of those actions took place in Edinburgh on Saturday, but no arrests were made despite police in attendance at two different protests. 'We are not here to support Palestine Action, we are here against genocide', Mick Napier, from the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign, told the crowd outside St Giles who were embarking on their route to first the UK Government offices at Queen Elizabeth House, and then to Bute House, the official residence of the first minister of Scotland. "Genocide in Palestine, Time to Take Action" was chanted several times throughout the day. Protesters held banners which read "we will not be silenced" and "[[UK Government]] is corrupt". Journalist Lesley Riddoch, former SNP MP Tommy Sheppard, Alba leader Kenny MacAskill, and leaders from the Gaza Genocide Emergency Committee (GGEC) led the march. Outside the [[UK Government]] offices, Sheppard called for his colleagues in the Scottish Government to "think again" about Scottish Enterprise funding going to Israeli-linked arms companies. Sheppard said: "To my colleagues in the Scottish Government, it is time to think again about the fact that Scottish Enterprise has a relationship with these [arms manufacturing] companies. "That needs to be ended. It cannot be justified by saying, 'oh, none of the money goes to produce arms, it's a completely different part of the company, nothing to do with arms exports'. "Do you remember in the 1970s and 1980s when we fought against apartheid and we campaigned to boycott Barclays? No one said 'let's boycott Barclays but make an exemption when they're funding community projects locally'. Tommy Sheppard (Image: Laura Pollock) "No, the whole point of boycotting and taking action against the company is to make sure that they understand that their actions in one part of the world have consequences for everything else they do elsewhere. "That is that is how we apply leverage and that is what we must do as well." He later told me the shift in Israel's assault with their plans for a concentration camp in Gaza is the key reason the stance by the Scottish Government must reviewed. READ MORE: Garbage join growing artist coalition against pro-Palestine censorship "They [the Scottish Government] have to stop being scared when the other side are trying to demonise us and trying to make us worry that we're going to arrested for turning up," Sheppard said. Riddoch took to the microphone next and was visibly emotional when sharing her anger at arrests made following the proscription of Palestine Action. "We can remember situations in the past like this and thought this would never happen again, when people are wondering if the police will arrest someone for wearing a t-shirt," she said. "So the point is, as everybody here has said, this is a genocide, as everyone is saying here together, Palestine needs action and we will all go together on that one." Lesley Riddoch (Image: Laura Pollock) She later spoke directly to officers in the crowd, adding: "Now I'm appealing to the police. I know it's tough. You are moral citizens as well. "Do we look like terrorists?" Later, MacAskill spoke outside Bute House: "Many countries have had the courage that the UK are only going to face in terms of a conviction at The Hague in some day to come. "Take a bow South Africa, Spain, Ireland." He continued: "We do wish to see the hostages returned, but it's nothing to do with them. Kenny MacAskill (Image: Laura Pollock) "Netanyahu's war is about the obliteration of Gaza and the colonization of Palestine and the removal of its people. "That's what it is. That's why we have to speak out." Doha Abu Amer, a Palestinian woman who has family in Gaza, Colin Brown from the Fire Brigades Union Scotland, and Billy Hendry, an ex-Royal Marine, all spoke as well. There were several chants calling out both Keir Starmer and John Swinney, telling them "you can't hide" - many by children. "She is driving a lot of things," one of the mothers told me of her 11-year-old daughter, "even at school, she was trying to do a bake sale for Palestine. I have to catch up with what she is wanting to do. Our kids today are so aware of what is going on. "You cannot push children to do something if they don't believe in it in their hearts." When activists put on t-shirts that others have been arrested for, the crowd cheered and I looked towards Police Scotland officers in the crowd. One liaison officer took a picture of them, and the pair spoke to each other, but no action was taken. "Strength in numbers," Riddoch later questioned on social media after everyone made it home. READ MORE: Uniformed police pulled from Glasgow Pride over 'impartiality' concerns Deputy assistant commissioner Ade Adelekan, who leads the policing operation in Westminster where more than 100 activists have been arrested over the last two weeks, warned on Friday that those expressing support for Palestine Action 'will likely be committing an offence and will very likely be arrested'. He added: 'I would urge those people to consider the seriousness of being arrested under the Terrorism Act and the very real long-term implications – from travel, to employment, to finances – that such an arrest is likely to have for their future.' After the march, Riddoch told me: "A lot of people in my family were saying 'if you get lifted for a terrorism charge, you'll never be able to go anywhere with your passport again'. "This is the kind of stuff they're doing to just drive complete fear of saying: this is a genocide."
Business News Wales
2 hours ago
- Business News Wales
Cardiff University to Share in £54m Global Talent Fund to Attract Top Researchers
Cardiff University is set to share in a £54 million fund to attract top researchers to the UK. It is one of 12 leading universities and research institutions which will deliver the Global Talent Fund. It is designed to attract a total of 60-80 top researchers – both lead researchers and their teams – to the UK, working in the eight high priority sectors named in the UK Government's Industrial Strategy, such as life sciences and digital technologies. The UK Government says that each of the selected institutions has a track record of recruiting and supporting top international R&D talent, as well as securing international competitive research funding to the UK. They are empowered to develop their own approaches and plans to spend their share of the Global Talent Fund to attract research talent from the around the globe in their choice of Industrial Strategy areas, including covering visa and relocation costs for researchers and their family members. Cardiff University's Vice-Chancellor Professor Wendy Larner said: 'We are delighted to have secured this funding to help us attract the world's best minds to Cardiff and Wales. 'It is a clear endorsement of our standing and place in the UK research community and sends a clear message that we are well-positioned to attract global talent. It will enable us to support more of the world's leading academics in Wales – helping to further boost our research capacity and global reputation in key research areas.' The institutions selected to deliver the Global Talent Fund are: University of Bath Queen's University Belfast University of Birmingham University of Cambridge Cardiff University Imperial College London John Innes Centre MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology University of Oxford University of Southampton University of Strathclyde University of Warwick Science Minister Lord Vallance said: 'Genius is not bound by geography. But the UK is one of the few places blessed with the infrastructure, skills base, world-class institutions and international ties needed to incubate brilliant ideas, and turn them into new medicines that save lives, new products that make our lives easier, and even entirely new jobs and industries. Bringing these innovations to life, here in Britain, will be critical to delivering this Government's Plan for Change. 'My message to the bold and the brave who are advancing new ideas, wherever they are, is: our doors are open to you. We want to work with you, support you, and give you a home where you can make your ideas a reality we all benefit from.' The Global Talent Fund is administered by UKRI and is part of over £115 million funding dedicated to attracting scientific and research talent to the UK. In addition to this fund, two fellowships have been launched aimed at bringing groundbreaking AI research teams to UK organisations and labs: the £25 million Turing AI 'Global' Fellowships, as well as a UK-based expansion of the Encode: AI for Science Fellowship. Alongside this, two new fast-track research grant routes have been announced by the National Academies – including £30 million from the Royal Society for a Faraday Discovery Fellowship accelerated international route, part-funded by their £250 million DSIT endowment. The Royal Academy of Engineering has announced a similar fast track international route, as part of its £150 million Green Future Fellowships endowment from DSIT – this funding will ensure the UK competes for the best global talent in science and research. Researchers looking to relocate to the UK can also benefit from the Choose Europe scheme, thanks to the UK's association to Horizon Europe. All will be supported by the Global Talent Taskforce. Launched as part of the Industrial Strategy, the taskforce will report directly to the Prime Minister and Chancellor, and support researchers, scientists and engineers as well as top-tier investors, entrepreneurs and managerial talent to bring their skills to Britain. Work to cultivate top AI research talent in the UK is further bolstered through the Spärck AI scholarships, which will provide full funding for master's degrees at nine leading UK universities specialising in artificial intelligence and STEM subjects. These scholarships will open for applications in Spring 2026. Postgraduate research will also be supported broadly, with £500 million UKRI funding supporting students at 45 higher education institutions to study projects in biological, engineering and physical, and natural and environmental sciences. The IMF estimates that breakthroughs in AI alone could boost productivity by as much as 1.5 percentage points a year, which could be worth up to an average £47 billion to the UK each year over a decade. Other technologies could be gamechangers too: quantum computing could add over £11 billion to the UK's GDP by 2045, while engineering biology could drive anywhere between £1.6-£3.1 trillion in global impact by 2040. Professor Christopher Smith, International Champion at UK Research and Innovation (UKRI), said: 'Global challenges from climate change to energy security, food systems to antimicrobial resistance do not respect borders, and neither should the research and innovation required to address them. Time and again, international collaboration has driven transformative breakthroughs: from the discovery of the Higgs boson at CERN, to the global effort to decode the complex wheat genome, enabling the development of high-yield, climate-resilient crops that support food security worldwide. The impact of global partnerships is clear. 'The Global Talent Fund is a vital part of UKRI's mission to support an open, dynamic, and diverse research and innovation system. By supporting our brilliant research institutions to attract outstanding individuals from across the world and foster collaboration between nations, we are strengthening the UK's position at the heart of the global knowledge economy. This fund aligns with our enduring commitment to international engagement, and to working together to shape a better future for all.'
STV News
2 hours ago
- STV News
Thousands march through Edinburgh for pro-Palestinian campaign
Thousands of pro-Palestinian demonstrators braved rain to march through Edinburgh on Saturday, as part of a national campaign. One veteran activist said the recent move to proscribe Palestine Action under anti-terror laws had not deterred people from showing their support to the wider movement. A large group gathered outside St Giles' Cathedral in the early afternoon before marching down the Royal Mile, chanting while waving flags and banners. The march stopped in front of the UK Government headquarters at Queen Elizabeth House, where speeches were given outside the building, before heading on to Bute House – the First Minister's official residence. Other demonstrations took place in Manchester, Bristol, Truro and London – calling for the ban on Palestine Action to be reversed. While there were dozens of arrests at the other events, Police Scotland said no arrests had been made in relation to the march in Edinburgh. Mick Napier, founding member of the Scottish Palestinian Solidarity Campaign, said there was a large turnout in the Scottish capital because of outrage over Israel's plan for a 'humanitarian city' in Rafah. PA Media Speaking as the march set off down the Royal Mile, he told the PA news agency: 'It's large, it's bigger than we've had for a very long time and it's entirely due to the building of the Israeli concentration camp in Rafah. 'They've called it a humanitarian city but people are utterly horrified, cumulatively, by what's happened during 22 months of genocide.' He said the ban on Palestine Action was 'absurd' and police had been on a hair trigger, arresting people for placards and banners which contain the words Palestine and action. Mr Napier said the ban had not deterred people from supporting the wider pro-Palestinian movement, saying: 'I think people are enraged. 'I look back to previous campaigns against the war in Vietnam, when that issue became fused with the issue of free speech it rose to a higher level.' Earlier this week, three women were arrested under the Terrorism Act after a van was driven into the external fence of the Leonardo UK factory in Edinburgh. The group Shut Down Leonardo claimed it was making components for F-35 fighter jets but the defence company says it does not directly supply equipment to Israel. Asked if such actions worked against the pro-Palestinian movement, Mr Napier said: 'I think in the past it may have put some people off, not any more.' Other activists at the march condemned the move to ban Palestine Action. Jane Ferrell, who travelled from Fife, said: 'It's Palestine Action one day, what's it going to be in the end? 'Trade unionism, the Labour Party activists, who knows?' Former MP Tommy Sheppard spoke to the crowd outside Queen Elizabeth house, saying: 'Today in the Middle East a genocide is being prosecuted in real time and we are watching it on television play by play.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
