Starmer's fury over Afghan data breach as he warns Tories ‘have questions to answer'
The prime minister said the leak should never have happened and that Tory ministers have 'serious questions to answer', a day after an unprecedented superinjunction was lifted.
Ben Wallace, who was defence secretary at the time the draconian legal order was granted, earlier said he took full responsibility for the leak, which happened when an MoD official released a spreadsheet containing the names of 18,000 Afghans "in error".
But questions have been raised over why no one has been fired over the breach, which put the lives of those with links to UK forces in danger of reprisals from the Taliban, amid calls for further investigation.
It comes as the chair of a powerful Commons committee has written to the Information Commissioner, applying pressure for a rethink on its decision not to investigate the breach, which cost the taxpayer billions in relocating thousands of affected Afghans to the UK.
At the start of a tense Prime Minister's Questions, Sir Keir expressed his anger, telling MPs: "We warned in opposition about Conservative management of this policy and yesterday, the defence secretary set out the full extent of the failings that we inherited: a major data breach, a super injunction, a secret route that has already cost hundreds of millions of pounds.
"Ministers who served under the party opposite have serious questions to answer about how this was ever allowed to happen."
He suggested the Conservatives should "welcome" scrutiny from the Commons Defence Committee, which has vowed to investigate.
In a dramatic intervention just hours later, right-wing former home secretary Suella Braverman revealed that there were splits in the Tory government over how to deal with the breach and said she had opposed the superinjunction and the new secret route set up to bring those affected to the UK.
In a scathing statement, Ms Braverman condemned the former Tory government, then led by Rishi Sunak, in which she played a major role before she was sacked by the former prime minister.
She said: 'There is much more that needs to be said about the conduct of the MoD, both ministers and officials, and the House of Commons is the right place to do so. I hope we have the opportunity soon.
'What has happened is outrageous and must never happen again. We must therefore be very clear about what that was and how it happened.
'The cover-up was wrong, the super injunction was wrong, and the failure to stop unwanted mass immigration has been unforgivable. So, I am sorry: the Conservative government failed you and its leaders let you down. It wasn't good enough then. It's not good enough now.'
Mr Sunak, ex-defence secretary Grant Shapps and former armed forces minister James Heappey, who oversaw the cover-up, have all been contacted for comment, but none have broken cover and have all remained silent on the breach.
Amid calls for further investigation into the breach, Defence Secretary John Healey said that 'accountability starts now' after admitting that he was uncomfortable with the way that the information had been covered up for three years.
The Commons Defence Committee confirmed it would launch its own inquiry, and Dame Chi Onwurah, chair of the Commons committee for science innovation and technology, is writing to the Information Commissioner pushing for an investigation.
The Information Commissioner has so far declined to hold its own probe, despite previously issuing a fine of £305,000 for a much smaller MoD data breach.
Dame Chi told The Independent: 'A leak of this magnitude is, of course, extremely worrying and the fact that it happened in the Ministry of Defence brings the additional dimension of security concerns. The Defence Select Committee Office (ICO) will be undertaking a full inquiry, in the meantime I will be writing to the Information Commissioner to ask for more details on his office's role in this case.'
Jon Baines, a senior data protection specialist at Mishcon de Reya, expressed bafflement at the commissioner's attitude to the breach.
He said: 'I have not seen such unanimous bafflement from the data protection commentariat at the ICO's lack of apparent interest.
'There is a potential argument that there is no point in a big fine against the MoD when it would punish the public purse.
'Enforcement is not just about fines. The information commissioner has the power to lay a report before parliament. I have been banging on for years about the issue of hidden data in spreadsheets, and if I were the commissioner, I would be thinking about how I can raise the issue.
'A report before parliament would give them publicity, raise the issue and seize parliament.'
The ICO has not responded to The Independent 's request for comment.
Meanwhile, a member of the defence select committee has warned against naming and shaming the individual responsible for the breach and said the committee should instead look at a failure of government.
Confirming the committee would launch an inquiry, its chair, Labour MP Tan Dhesi, told BBC Radio 4's The World at One Programme: "We want to get to the bottom of what has happened on behalf of parliament, which has been sidelined for too long on this issue.'
"Ultimately, I think the fact there has been no parliamentary scrutiny, that nobody's been held to account on this, is just not on at all."
Leyton and Wanstead Labour MP Calvin Bailey, who was a key figure in organising flights out of Kabul when allied forces went into a chaotic retreat as the Taliban swept to power in 2021, called for 'proper scrutiny' on the matter.
He said: 'We need to go back and give proper scrutiny to everything, not just the data breach, the whole culture management and oversight of the operation, of the extraction recovery, the foreign policy and the military engagement and involvement.
'We will probably find that people were working under duress and pressure, because there were too few people to deal with the crisis.'
He also warned that the defence committee was 'best placed to do the necessary work' as a full public inquiry 'would take too long and be too expensive'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
12 minutes ago
- Telegraph
The Palestine Action protests reveal Britain's spiritual sickness
Palestine Action's campaign against Israel recalls the famed elevator scene from Mad Men. Sore at being sidelined in a pitch meeting, ambitious and impatient advertising executive Michael Ginsberg confronts his boss, Don Draper, and pouts: 'I feel bad for you.' Draper, icier than the rocks in his Old Fashioned, replies: 'I don't think about you at all.' It's doubtful if Israel will think at all about crowds taking to Britain's streets to demand the unbanning of proscribed terror organisation Palestine Action. Reports of some protesters chanting 'f*** your Jewish state' are unlikely to give anyone in Jerusalem much pause. Such scenes will be regarded as a matter of private grief not to be intruded on. For all that Palestine Action's criminal campaign of thuggery and intimidation is directed at the state of Israel, and specifically its ability to defend itself, it's not Israel that needs to worry about Saturday's events. Israel can take care of itself, but can the UK? Because these protests portend nothing good for Britain. Recall that Palestine Action is not merely anti-Israel. This is an organisation that openly, proudly targets British companies for vandalism and destruction. That uses criminal conduct to terrorise British business owners into changing their commercial relationships. An organisation whose activists have breached a British military base and damaged RAF planes. And not insignificant numbers of Britons have assembled in UK cities in solidarity with that organisation. This is not a well country. The last time we found ourselves in this level of economic decline and political dysfunction, in the 1970s, we were called the Sick Man of Europe. But this is a different kind of sickness. It's a spiritual sickness, a new British disease. Chants of 'f*** your Jewish state' will have been alarming for British Jews, who have been forced to watch in horror as their country, including and perhaps especially its educated middle classes, have been radicalised by events in the Middle East since October 7, 2023. From Parliament to the press, churches to the universities, the BBC to the NGOs, Britain has become fixated on the war in Gaza, to the exclusion of other, deadlier conflicts. And in a way that is detached from all reason, so that even the sketchiest Hamas propaganda is accepted at face value. It is not simply that Britons are troubled by the human suffering in Gaza – a very real and very grave situation – but that the public square has become thoroughly Palestinianised in a short space of time. All other foreign conflicts, and even some domestic matters, have been pushed aside. Gaza is the new unifying issue of British politics. That reflects trends that have been in train for some time now. The UK political class is so thoroughly in sway to the political culture of American progressivism that, after Black Lives Matter and 'trans women are women', it was inevitable that they would embrace the historically illiterate Civil Rights frame for the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The mass immigration of foreign-born Muslims is also making obsessive hatred of Jews and Israel a fact of mainstream political discourse in Britain. Given the decline of the UK and the modish self-loathing promoted in classrooms, lecture halls, on television and in museums, it should not surprise us that there is some level of sympathy out there for an organisation that vandalises RAF planes, those symbols and guarantors of British self-determination and sovereignty. It's not just Israel's defensive capability that is under attack. Nothing Palestine Action or its acolytes do will change reality on the ground in Gaza or alter the strategic aims of the Israeli government. Israel draws strength not only from its military but from the national self-confidence of its people. In Britain, they take to the streets in the name of foreign nations and imported hatreds.
Times
12 minutes ago
- Times
Keir Starmer needs his authority back. Can a Blairite veteran help?
F or a fortnight after Sir Keir Starmer's U-turn on disability benefits, the cabinet pondered what, if anything, he would do to shore up his political authority. On Wednesday came the surprising, if underwhelming, response when he suspended four rebellious MPs, most of them little known to the public. Privately, however, Starmer is planning to go further than most expect, first with a summer recess shake-up of the Downing Street operation. It can be revealed that he intends to start with the appointment of Tim Allan, who is on a final shortlist to become permanent secretary for communications, a new civil service role giving him influence across all government departments, and is Starmer's preferred candidate. Allan is a former No 10 director of communications who served in the Blair government and remains close to Alastair Campbell and Pat McFadden. But he is best known within political circles for founding Portland, the lobbying company closely linked to New Labour. Its clients have historically included the governments of Kazakhstan, Russia and Qatar, for whom it set up anonymous blogs attacking critics of its World Cup bid. Campbell remains on its payroll as a 'senior adviser'.
The Sun
12 minutes ago
- The Sun
Bombshell poll reveals MOST Brits think crime is out of control & don't trust cops or govt to keep them safe
CRIME is out of control, according to the majority of people quizzed in a survey. The damning poll, published today, lays bare a shocking lack of confidence in the Government and police to keep us safe. 5 5 The bombshell survey reveals Reform UK boss Nigel Farage is more trusted than the PM or Tory leader Kemi Badenoch on every single question about tackling crime. Voters think sky-high immigration and failure to integrate those coming here are fuelling the crimewave. The shocking findings will spark alarm in Sir Keir Starmer's team, which is under massive pressure to get a grip on law and order. Britain has been plagued by gangs of criminals on bikes snatching mobile phones, brazenly shoplifting, and stealing jewellery and watches. 'Lawless country' Earlier this month, 24-year-old Blue Stevens was stabbed to death in London as he tried to stop robbers taking his Rolex wristwatch. The Survation poll, for Friderichs Advisory Partners, found 49 per cent of people thought Britain was 'becoming a lawless country'. Just 35 per cent of the 2,000 adults quizzed disagreed. Meanwhile, 56 per cent said they believed that crime had risen over the past five years. Voters were asked about nine different crimes and whether they thought they were 'out of control'. Shockingly, a majority answered yes to all nine crimes. Inside UK's crime capital where residents fear for lives and lay out razor wire to stop thieves These were: violent crime, knife crime, burglary, theft, drugs, vandalism, cybercrime, sex offences and gangs. Some 74 per cent said knife crime was 'out of control' and 60 per cent said the same of violent crime. For theft it was 70 per cent, for drug-related crimes 69 per cent, and for burglary 55 per cent. Asked what caused the crimewave, immigration came out top, with 22 per cent blaming the migrant crisis. Next came 'economic inequality' at 20 per cent, then ' lenient sentencing ' at 17 per cent. Worryingly for the PM, the survey also revealed that people have lost faith in the state when it comes to maintaining law and order. Some 52 per cent do not think Starmer can fix things, saying that Labour was performing 'poorly' on tackling crime. 5 Similarly, some 57 per cent said they are 'not confident' the Government can tackle crime. Farage was seen as more trusted than Starmer or Badenoch when it came to fighting crime. Asked which political leader they trust most to maintain law and order, 27 per cent replied Farage. Starmer was next on 21 per cent and Badenoch was third on just 14 per cent. STABBER'S 59 CRIMES A CRIMINAL convicted of 59 offences was jailed for just 33 months after plunging a blade into the neck of a customer in a pharmacy. Alexander Davidson, 38, walked up to the man waiting for his prescription and stabbed him in a desperate craze for heroin and crack cocaine. Liverpool crown court heard he had previously assaulted someone with a dart and stabbed his father during a row over a mobile phone. The thug's 34 previous convictions date back to 2003 — including a suspended prison sentence for unlawful wounding in 2013, a 30-month stretch for assault causing actual bodily harm and five years for drug trafficking offences in 2007. Sentencing him, Recorder William Beardmore said: 'You could have easily severed the carotid artery or jugular vein. 'That would have killed him, and you would have been facing an allegation of murder. You should regard yourself as exceptionally lucky.' Farage also came up trumps on tackling migrant offenders. Some 37 per cent thought Farage was more likely to deport foreign criminals, while 17 per cent backed Starmer and 11 per cent Badenoch. Quizzed on which political leader they trusted to make Britain safer, Farage was again top on 29 per cent, Starmer second on 20 per cent, and Badenoch last again on 12 per cent. Worryingly, the poll also found that trust in the police's ability to catch criminals was at rock bottom. 5 5 One in five said they or a member of their family had been a victim of crime in the past year. But of these, 18 per cent did not bother to call the police because they had no faith they would catch the criminals or take the crimes seriously. The Labour Government made tackling crime one of its top five priorities when it was elected last year. 'Lenient sentencing' But police chiefs have furiously accused the Government of failing to fund forces properly. A row exploded earlier this year when Chancellor Rachel Reeves agreed to hand police another £2billion a year. Top cops had been publicly demanding more, and the National Police Chief Council said the failure to stump up cash threw Labour's promises to hire another 13,000 neighbourhood officers into doubt. LABOUR IS FAILING COUNTRY By Nigel Farage, Reform Leader THIS new polling confirms what many of us already knew — Britain has become a lawless country. It lays bare the lack of faith the British people have in Labour to make our streets and communities safe. And it's not hard to understand the reasons why. Total crime is now 50 per cent higher than it was in the 1990s. Police no longer investigate or attend shoplifting or theft. Violent repeat offenders are released early and two-tier policing has completely eroded trust. People feel that Keir Starmer is not tough on crime and he goes easy on the criminals. As for Conservatives, they have broken Britain and their own brand is broken, too. They are no longer the party of law and order. The decline that we see today began during their 14 failed years in office. Successive Tory governments cut thousands of police officers but oversaw an explosion in the population. It is clear to me that they should be in hiding for the damage they have done and must simply never be forgiven. Reform UK will fix broken Britain and restore law and order in our country. The British people deserve nothing less. This is a topic you'll be hearing a lot more about from us over the next few days and weeks. Career criminals will be put on notice. This is a national emergency and, after years of complacency by the other parties, it's clear that lawless Britain needs Reform.
