S$52K rental for Tampines clinic: Ong Ye Kung ‘dismayed,' Ho Ching defends winning bidder
Since then, the story has unfolded further, with the company that won the rental bid explaining its side, telling CNA the high price it pays for rent will not be passed on to its patients by way of higher fees for consultations and medications.
Andrew Chim, the co-owner of I-Health Medical Holdings, was quoted in a Jun 4 (Wednesday) report as saying that 'Rent is not commensurate with (consultation) fee. I can assure you that the total bill for different cases will be in range for other heartland clinics.'
Later that day, Health Minister Ong Ye Kung weighed in on the issue, writing in a Facebook post that he was 'dismayed' by the rental bid, which is equivalent to S$1,000 per square meter. See also Malaysia-born swimming champ jailed 8 weeks for defaulting on NS
'This must translate to higher cost of healthcare one way or another and negate the effort of Ministry of Health, Singapore (MOH) to try to keep the cost of primary healthcare affordable,' he wrote, adding, 'More importantly, higher rental bids do not necessarily translate to the best healthcare that the community needs.'
He emphasised the growing importance of GPs in Singapore's ageing society, highlighting their vital role in fostering the necessary trust between doctors and patients, as the latter are guided toward better health outcomes.
'He or she is the vital link to connect patients to acute hospital care, preventive community care, and social prescriptions,' he wrote.
Mr Ong added that in May, the Health Ministry and the Housing Development Board (HDB) launched a Price-Quality evaluation Model (PQM) at Bartley Beacon. In this new approach, the quality of care accounts for 70% of the tender evaluation, while rental makes up the remaining 30%. Although the Tampines clinic had been awarded before the new PQM, he said that it will become the norm for when tendering GP clinics in HDB heartlands.
On Thursday morning, however, the winning bid for the S$52,000 clinic at Tampines appeared to be defended by Ho Ching, the former CEO of Temasek.
In a Facebook post, Madam Ho, the wife of Senior Minister Lee Hsien Loong, wrote that the company that won the bid is 'not a newbie' as it has won and lost bids in the past and has three other existing clinics.
'These are folks who have experience and know the operating costs,' she added, explaining that the company had assessed its bid as a long-term investment, building its clientele with families in a new estate that would remain loyal through the years.
'They even studied how many BTOs (build-to-orders) are coming up and what other developments are coming up before they bidded. They are not going into an established area where families already have existing old family GPs that they trust and go to as their family doctor,' wrote Mdm Ho, adding, 'They expect to break even by about 18 months.' /TISG
Read also: Singaporeans shocked by S$52K/month rental for Tampines clinic
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
4 hours ago
- CNA
More opt for mid- to long-term car leasing options, citing affordability and convenience
Some car rental firms are seeing more Singapore drivers opting for mid- to long-term leasing options over buying cars. They say their customers find these options more affordable and convenient as they don't need to be tied down by a 10-year Certificate of Entitlement, which can cost over S$100,000 upfront. Drivers also do not have to deal with the car's maintenance.
CNA
5 hours ago
- CNA
No plans to 'fully liberalise' cross-border ride hailing, but app bookings for licensed taxis being considered: LTA
SINGAPORE: There are no plans to fully liberalise cross-border point-to-point transport via ride-hail services, the Land Transport Authority said on Sunday (Aug 3). However, the authority added that it is considering the use of ride-hailing apps to book cross-border trips on licensed taxis and increasing the number of boarding and alighting points in Singapore and Malaysia. LTA noted recent Malaysian media reports suggesting that Singapore is looking to introduce cross-border on-demand ride services, and said it wanted to clarify the current arrangements and ongoing discussions. Singapore and Malaysian officials met to discuss cross-border service arrangements on Aug 1, with the issue of allowing cross-border e-hailing to ferry passengers raised during discussions. LTA, however, said that no decision was made on the issue. 'While we are open to ideas to improve the cross-border commuting experience, we would like to clarify that LTA has no plan to fully liberalise cross-border point-to-point transport via ride-hail services,' said the authority. The Malay Mail reported on Sunday morning that Johor and Singapore have proposed introducing a cross-border e-hailing service as an alternative mode of transport for commuters. Johor Chief Minister Onn Hafiz Ghazi was quoted as saying the proposal was among various matters discussed during his meeting with Singapore's Acting Transport Minister Jeffrey Siow. The chief minister also said that the proposed service would offer more flexible on-demand transport options for the public, as well as ease congestion. LTA said in its clarification that there is an existing reciprocal cross-border taxi scheme in place that allows a licensed fleet of up to 200 taxis from each side to ferry passengers between Singapore and Johor Bahru. These cross-border taxis are currently permitted to pick up and drop off passengers only at a single designated point in the other's country - Larkin Sentral in Johor Bahru for Singapore taxis and Ban San Street Terminal in Singapore for Malaysian taxis. LTA said the existing quota of the cross-border taxi scheme is not fully utilised. "In view of commuter demand for more convenient cross-border travel, we will encourage full take up of the quota of licensed taxis,' said LTA. 'We are also considering increasing the number of boarding and alighting points in each other's country, and to use ride-hailing apps to book cross-border trips on licensed taxis.' LTA said that in any adjustment to the cross-border point-to-point transport regime, its key priorities are to better meet commuter demand while safeguarding the interests of Singapore's taxi and private hire drivers. 'As cross-border taxi scheme is a reciprocal arrangement, any change will require agreement from both governments,' it added. BUS OPERATIONS At the meeting, LTA said the Malaysian authorities also requested Singapore's cross-border buses to start their operations from Johor Bahru at 4am. LTA said it is assessing whether the operating times of these services can be adjusted to help address bus crowding in the early mornings. 'A key consideration is that the first buses should match the starting time of our local bus and MRT services when they arrive in Singapore. LTA is exploring with cross-border bus operators the possibility of bringing forward the bus start times slightly, as well as engaging private bus operators on their interest to operate earlier services at higher fares.' Public bus operations SBS Transit and SMRT told CNA that they are engaging their captains regarding the request. Currently, the earliest public bus across the border on weekdays begins at 5am. SBS Transit said it has to consider the availability of its resources while SMRT said it aims to ensure its services meet commuter needs while maintaining operational sustainability. The safety of commuters and the well-being of bus captains remain the top priorities, added SMRT.
Straits Times
5 hours ago
- Straits Times
Singapore must stay socially progressive while conserving its cultures: Tharman
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox President Tharman Shanmugaratnam speaking at an event to launch the Encyclopedia of Singapore Tamils on Aug 2. SINGAPORE – Singapore must continue to be a place where cultures can be preserved, including that of its many sub-ethnic groups. At the same time, it must also remain socially progressive, where discrimination in any form is not tolerated, said President Tharman Shanmugaratnam. At an Aug 2 event to launch the Encyclopaedia of Singapore Tamils (EST) , Mr Tharman said the story of the city-state's Tamil community is, in many ways, that of Singapore itself – one of resilience, multicultural integration and also deep social transformation over the country's 60 years of independence. The EST is an online resource that documents the history and contributions of the Tamil community here over the past 200 years, and is a collaboration between the Centre for Singapore Tamil Culture (CSTC) and the National Library Board (NLB). The President noted that in Singapore's early years, migrants from southern India naturally brought with them their caste traditions and practices. As a result, segregation in their social interactions, jobs and living arrangements closely resembled those in their places of origin. For instance, the encyclopaedia records how almost all Indian enclaves here had designated Adi-Dravida zones for those lowest in the caste hierarchy, such as the area between Jalan Besar and Rochor Canal. While attitudes towards caste started to change in the 1930s and 1940s due to reformist movements such as the Tamil Reform Association and the Japanese Occupation, the most profound changes came after Singapore gained independence, said Mr Tharman. A national education system promoted meritocracy regardless of social background, public housing brought people of all communities together, and a growing economy provided opportunities for all, he noted. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore No plans to fully liberalise cross-border ride-hailing services between S'pore and Johor: LTA Singapore LTA, Singapore bus operators reviewing Malaysia's request to start services from JB at 4am World Trump is winning his trade war, but Americans will pay the price Singapore President Tharman meets migrant workers who saved driver of car that fell into sinkhole Opinion The charm – and drawbacks – of living in a time warp in Singapore Singapore Now flying solo, Acres CEO Kalaivanan Balakrishnan presses ahead with wildlife rescue efforts Life KPop Demon Hunters to get sequels, expanded universe to include musical, live-action remake The result was a dilution of caste traditions and better appreciation for inclusivity. But there are still remnants of caste practices among those who have been higher up in the traditional social hierarchy, and a renewed influx of such practices among new immigrants, said Mr Tharman. More also needs to be done to help those who have faced disadvantages passed down through generations, from the time their forefathers arrived here as coolies and indentured labourers, he added. 'As much as we have done away with the most regressive social practices, we have to keep working at this... even as we conserve the core of our cultures, Singapore must remain a socially progressive place, where discrimination of all forms is not tolerated, and inclusivity becomes part of all our lives,' said Mr Tharman. 'It is what makes us as Tamil Singaporeans, and as Indian Singaporeans, distinctive among Indian communities globally.' At the event, CSTC chief executive Arun Mahizhnan said the encyclopaedia addresses a longstanding lack of a comprehensive historical record of Singapore's Tamil community. It currently contains more than 350 entries, covering a range of topics that includes historical events, arts, community organisations, journalism, education, politics and personalities. Being online means it will be accessible to a broad audience both in Singapore and abroad, added Mr Mahizhnan, who is also EST's chief editor. 'Besides preserving our history, it can also inspire younger generations to appreciate and connect with their heritage.' EST deputy editor Sivanantham Neelakandan said the encyclopaedia is meant to be a living document that will continue to grow and 'serve as a lasting testament for generations to come'. The encyclopaedia, published in conjunction with SG60 and NLB's 30th anniversary, can be accessed both in Tamil and English. In his speech, Mr Tharman paid tribute to the generations of Tamils who contributed to Singapore society in areas such as education, women's rights, politics, medicine, law, sports and the arts. He also spotlighted the Tamil community's influence on the city-state's culinary landscape, such as how mee goreng (spicy fried noodles) was created and popularised by the Muslim Chulias of Madras. 'As we celebrate SG60, may this be a reminder of each of our communities' contributions, from the labourers who led the most difficult of lives to the civil servants, educationists, professionals and entrepreneurs, each contributing to making this nation that we treasure,' he said. The event was attended by almost 600 guests, including Minister for Digital Development and Information Josephine Teo and Minister of State for Culture, Community and Youth and Minister of State for Manpower Dinesh Vasu Dash. Following the launch, a roving exhibition will tour four venues across Singapore from August 2025 to February 2026, showcasing key aspects of Singapore's Tamil heritage through interactive panels and displays. The exhibition will highlight lesser-known facts about Tamil publishing, postage stamps, schools and signages.
