Mother and baby home victim says Executive should 'hang their heads in shame' over new proposals
More than 14,000 pregnant women and girls passed through the secretive institutions, with many found to have been mistreated, held against their will and forced to give up children for adoption.
A bill to establish an inquiry into mother and baby homes, Magdalene Laundries and Workhouses - and an associated redress scheme - passed its first stage in the Stormont Assembly on Monday.The proposals are expected to cost around £80 million.
Adele Johnston who was born in a home and later sent to one when she was a pregnant teenager says those affected haven't been listened to and the Department needs to go back to the drawing board.Speaking of her experience in the homes she said: "It was very demeaning and demoralizing.
"We were made to work, we were made to feel that we were unworthy, unfit, that we weren't fit to look after a child and that, the best place for a child was to be adopted."
She had high hopes for Stormont proposals to deal with this dark period of our past, but feels let down after a meeting with the First and Deputy First Ministers on Monday.
"We didn't expect all that we asked, but we did not expect it to be so brutal and it was brutal.
"We were corralled into one meeting and we were dealt one body blow after another.
"And we feel very badly let down by the First Minister, the Deputy First Minister and the TEO.
"Actually, they need to hang their heads in shame for what they done yesterday."Concerns have been expressed that 'huge swathes' of potential applicants to a long awaited redress scheme are set to be excluded.They were run by the Catholic Church, religious orders, some Protestant denominations as well as the State, with some in operation until 1995.First Minister Michelle O'Neill said they hope the legislation 'demonstrates our sincere commitment to respecting and fulfilling the wishes of those who for many decades have suffered and been silenced'.The Executive Bill is to establish a statutory public inquiry and a statutory redress scheme at an estimated cost of £80 million, which includes almost £60 million in initial redress payments to cover about 6,600 claims.Each eligible claimant is to receive a payment of £10,000, and a £2,000 payment will be made to each eligible family member on behalf of a loved one who has died since September 29, 2011.A further Individually Assessed Payment (IAP) for the specific harm suffered by an individual is to follow the public inquiry.The ministers also met with survivors of the institutions on Monday.However some who attended the meeting expressed concern over those who are excluded by the proposals.The legal firm KRW Law, which represents many of the victims and survivors, described 'huge disquiet over the prospective exclusion of many survivors'.They said the cut-off for posthumous claims for deceased birth mothers and children of 2011 'cuts out a huge swathe of prospective applicants', while victims of work houses appear to be excluded, and the 'blanket removal' of foster care home survivors.There is also concern around the limit on the sum proposed by way of interim payment with no allowance for inflation.Solicitor Aine Rice, of KRW's historic abuse team, said they reject the current proposals as 'unfit for purpose'.She said: 'So much work has been put in by many people to get to this stage only for it to be undone in one fell swoop.'There's an insensitivity underpinning all of this which makes it galling.'We reject the current proposals as unfit for purpose. More, much more, needs done to address the imbalance in play here. We need to see a complete U-turn by the time we reach the next stage of the Bill, but time is running out fast.'We are told that many are thinking of leaving the consultation forum and threatening protest.'Institution survivor Marie Arbuckle said the latest proposals are a 'kick in the teeth for many survivors'.She added: 'It seems to me that the Government hasn't listened to us properly at all.'Why do a consultation in the first place if the wishes and hopes of survivors aren't taken on board?'I don't think lessons have been learned from what happened in the south of Ireland.'The understandable drive to save money has simply gone too far, and all at the expense of the wishes of victims.'We have lost all confidence in the process we worked so hard on for the last three years.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
Changed needed with Guernsey's revenue service
The current revenue service is "a difficult place for people to work", Guernsey's new chief executive of the States has Smillie said the service in charge of personal income tax was "clearly not performing well" or where the states would "like it to be at the moment".The department has been criticised for its lack of public trust and IT issues causing delayed tax returns being processed. Smillie said the staff, which were "on the frontline", worked hard "in the circumstances that they find themselves in". He said: "We need to equip those people to make sure they've got the right tools to do the job and they will do a cracking job. "They've got some great ideas, some brilliant initiatives and I'm absolutely sure if we empower them and give them the opportunity to change things and help themselves we'll see a dramatic improvement." Mr Smillie said although morale was "low", staff members were "optimistic" with the plans going into the said: "They really care about the service they provide, there's absolute acknowledgement it's not where it needs to be and they have lots of ideas."In terms of the systems that we have, the technology that we've deployed, it's just not working in a way that they need in order to provide a good service."The chief executive said change would take time and that it had to happen "from the bottom, up".He said: "The thing I'm really pleased about is we've got a group of people that are kind of really, really up for that and that's the kind of case study I'd like to create within the public services. "We've got a very good, difficult situation that we wouldn't necessarily want to be in but the advantage we've got to take from that is when we start to demonstrate change, it will be an example we continue to use to others."
The Guardian
a day ago
- The Guardian
Trump administration orders release of Epstein court documents amid mounting pressure
Update: Date: 2025-07-19T07:55:16.000Z Title: Trump administration orders release of Epstein court documents Content: The US Department of Justice asked a federal court on Friday to unseal grand jury transcripts in Jeffrey Epstein's case at the direction of Donald Trump amid a firestorm over the administration's handling of records related to the wealthy financier. The move – coming a day after a Wall Street Journal story put a spotlight on Trump's relationship with Epstein – seeks to contain a growing controversy that has engulfed the administration since it announced that it would not be releasing more government files from Epstein's sex trafficking case. Todd Blanche, the US deputy attorney general, filed motions urging the court to unseal the Epstein transcripts as well as those in the case against British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell, who was convicted of luring teenage girls to be sexually abused by Epstein. Epstein killed himself in 2019 shortly after his arrest while awaiting trial. The justice department's announcement that it would not be making public any more Epstein files enraged parts of Trump's base in part because members of his own administration had hyped the expected release and stoked conspiracies around the well-connected financier. Trump's demand to release the grand jury transcripts came after the Wall Street Journal reported Thursday on a sexually suggestive letter that the newspaper says bore Trump's name and was included in a 2003 album for Epstein's 50th birthday. The letter bearing Trump's name includes text framed by the outline of what appears to be a hand-drawn naked woman and ends with, 'Happy Birthday – and may every day be another wonderful secret,' according to the newspaper. The outlet described the contents of the letter but did not publish a photo showing it entirely. Trump denied writing the letter, calling it 'false, malicious, and defamatory' and promised to sue. Trump said he spoke to both to the paper's owner, Rupert Murdoch, and its top editor, Emma Tucker, and told them the letter was 'fake'. In other developments: Attorney general Pam Bondi called the case 'a matter of public concern' in a formal request asking a federal judge to unseal grand jury transcripts from the 2019 investigation into Epstein, the late sex offender and longtime associate of Donald Trump. Dick Durbin, the senior Democrat on the senate judiciary committee wrote to Bondi to ask about the work of the 1,000 FBI personnel who reviewed approximately 100,000 Epstein-related records in March. 'My office was told that these personnel were instructed to 'flag' any records in which President Trump was mentioned', Durbin wrote. 'What happened to the records mentioning President Trump once they were flagged?' he asked. Tulsi Gabbard, the director of national intelligence, has called for Barack Obama and former senior US national security officials to be prosecuted after accusing them of a 'treasonous conspiracy' intended to show that Trump's 2016 presidential election win was due to Russian interference. The Trump administration has decided to destroy $9.7m worth of contraceptives rather than send them abroad to women in need. A state department spokesperson confirmed that the decision had been made – a move that will cost US taxpayers $167,000. Marco Rubio, the secretary of state barred Brazilian supreme court justice Alexandre de Moraes from the United States in retaliation for the prosecution of Jair Bolsonaro, the former president of Brazil who has been charged for his role in allegedly leading an attempted coup following his loss in the 2022 election. Democrats are condemning CBS for its decision to cancel The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, noting the news comes a few days after its host criticized the network's parent company, Paramount, for settling a $16m lawsuit with Donald Trump. Senator Adam Schiff, a California Democrat who appeared as a guest on Colbert's show on Thursday night, later wrote on social media: 'If Paramount and CBS ended the Late Show for political reasons, the public deserves to know. And deserves better.'
BreakingNews.ie
2 days ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Christian patriarchs in rare visit to Gaza after deadly Israeli strike on church
Top church leaders have visited Gaza a day after its only Catholic church was struck by an Israeli shell. The attack killed three people and wounded 10, including a priest who had developed a close friendship with the late Pope Francis. Advertisement The strike drew condemnation from the Pope and US President Donald Trump, and prompted a statement of regret from Israel, which said it was a mistake. Since ending a ceasefire in March, Israel has regularly launched far deadlier strikes across Gaza against what it says are Hamas militants, frequently killing women and children. Strikes killed 18 people overnight, health officials said on Friday. Benjamin Netanyahu released a statement saying Israel 'deeply regrets that a stray ammunition hit Gaza's Holy Family Church' (Manuel Balce Ceneta/AP) Pope Leo meanwhile renewed his call for negotiations to bring an end to the 21-month war in a phone call on Friday with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, the Vatican said. The religious delegation to Gaza included two patriarchs from Jerusalem — Latin Patriarch Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa and Greek Orthodox Patriarch Theophilos III. The rare visit aimed to express the 'shared pastoral solicitude of the churches of the Holy Land', a statement said. Advertisement Israel has heavily restricted access to Gaza since the start of the war, though church leaders have entered on previous occasions, usually to mark major holidays. They visited the Holy Family Catholic Church, whose compound was damaged in the shelling. They were also organising convoys carrying hundreds of tons of food, medical supplies and other equipment to the territory — which experts say has been pushed to the brink of famine by Israel's war and military offensive — and the evacuation of those wounded in the church strike. In his call with Mr Netanyahu, Pope Leo 'expressed again his concern over the dramatic humanitarian situation for the population in Gaza, with children, the elderly and the sick paying the most heartbreaking price', the Vatican said in a statement. An Israeli official confirmed that Mr Netanyahu had placed the call and said that the Vatican's account was accurate. Advertisement Pope Leo expressed his concern over 'the dramatic humanitarian situation' (AP) In an earlier statement, the Pope had 'repeated his intentions to do everything possible to stop the useless slaughter of innocent people', and condemned 'the unjustifiable attack' on the church. The Vatican said the Pope had also received an update on the condition of Rev Gabriel Romanelli, the resident priest at the church, who was lightly wounded. The priest had regularly spoken by phone with Pope Francis, who died in April, telling the pontiff about the struggles faced by civilians in Gaza. Mr Netanyahu released a statement on Thursday saying Israel 'deeply regrets that a stray ammunition hit Gaza's Holy Family Church'. The Israeli military said it was still investigating. Israel has repeatedly struck schools, shelters, hospitals and other civilian buildings, accusing Hamas militants of sheltering inside and blaming them for civilian deaths. Palestinians say nowhere has felt safe since Israel launched its offensive in response to Hamas's attack on October 7 2023. Advertisement Israeli strikes killed at least 18 Palestinians overnight and into Friday, including a strike on a home in the southern city of Khan Younis that killed four members of the same family, according to morgue records at Nasser Hospital, which received the bodies. Associated Press footage of the aftermath of the strike showed people digging through the rubble in search of remains. Palestinians say nowhere has felt safe since Israel launched its offensive in response to Hamas's attack in 2023 (Ohad Zwigenberg/AP) Israel's military said it was 'operating to dismantle Hamas military capabilities' and that it takes 'feasible precautions to mitigate civilian harm'. Nasser Hospital said another three people were killed while heading towards an aid site run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), an Israeli-backed American contractor. A spokesperson for the foundation said there was no violence at its sites overnight and that crowds were 'docile'. Advertisement Since the group's operations began in late May, hundreds of Palestinians have been killed in shootings by Israeli soldiers while on roads heading to the sites, according to witnesses and health officials. GHF's four sites are all in military-controlled zones, and the Israeli military has said its troops have only fired warning shots to control crowds. There was no comment from the military on the latest deaths. Hamas-led militants killed some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, in the October 7 attack and abducted 251 people, most of whom have since been released in ceasefire agreements or other deals. Fifty hostages are still being held, less than half of them believed to be alive. Israel's retaliatory offensive has killed more than 58,600 Palestinians, according to Gaza's Health Ministry, which has said women and children make up more than half of the dead. It does not distinguish between civilians and militants in its tally. The ministry is part of the Hamas-run government but is led by medical professionals. The United Nations and other international organisations consider its figures to be the most reliable count of war casualties.
