CERC rejects CESC's 300 MW hybrid power tariff bid over procedural lapses
The power utility had failed to obtain prior approval for deviations in the bidding process from the appropriate authority, which in this case should have been the Centre and not the West Bengal government, the CERC said in its report.
Kolkata, Jul 15 (PTI) The Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) has rejected a petition by CESC Ltd seeking approval for the adoption of tariff for the long-term procurement of 300 MW power from grid-connected wind-solar hybrid projects, citing non-compliance with competitive bidding guidelines.
'We reject the adoption of the tariff so discovered, as the petitioner has not complied with the bidding guidelines under Section 63 of the Electricity Act. The petitioner may go for re-bidding, if so advised, strictly in accordance with the guidelines issued under Section 63 of the Act,' the CERC said in the order.
CESC had floated the tender on November 8, 2024, for procuring 150 MW wind-solar hybrid power with a greenshoe option for an additional 150 MW, aiming to meet its renewable purchase obligations. The project was proposed to be located in Mandsaur in Madhya Pradesh.
The final tariff was discovered through competitive bidding and an e-reverse auction conducted on December 27, 2024. Purvah Green Power Pvt Ltd, a subsidiary of CESC, emerged as the successful bidder for the entire 300 MW capacity.
CESC did not respond to requests for comments till the time of filing of this report.
The Commission noted that despite being aware from a previous case (Petition No. 365/AT/2024) that approval for deviations in inter-state transmission system (ISTS)-connected projects must be obtained from the central government, CESC proceeded with approvals from the West Bengal government.
The Commission also observed that CESC had misled the state government by not disclosing the ISTS nature of the project and continued the tender process despite being aware of the requirement to approach the Centre.
'The Commission had condoned this requirement once as an exception, but cannot make the exception a rule,' the order said, referring to a previous instance where similar deviations were allowed in view of exigencies.
'Acceptance of the petitioner's prayers in the instant petition would not be in consonance with the principles as contained in Section 63 of the Electricity Act, 2003,' it added.
CESC defended the higher-than-average tariff by citing two key advantages in the winning bid. First, the project promised a higher Capacity Utilisation Factor (CUF) of 50 per cent, well above the usual 30 per cent for comparable hybrid projects.
Additionally, the bidder committed to completing the project within 20 months, shorter than the standard 24-month timeline, which CESC claimed could result in potential savings of Rs 0.02 per kWh.
The Commission further pointed out that awarding the entire 300 MW capacity to a related party.
'Another interesting point to note is that in response to the RfS in Petition 365/AT/2024 as well as the present petition, the bidders participating in the bids are precisely the same, and the winning bidder, being a wholly owned subsidiary of the petitioner, is also the same. While this could be a coincidence, it raises a question mark on transparency,' the order noted.
The Commission also rejected CESC's justification of the higher tariff on the grounds of higher capacity utilisation and project timelines, noting that the company's comparison of the discovered tariff with short-term prices in the Green Day-Ahead Market (G-DAM) was misplaced.
CERC clarified that such comparisons are not valid under the guidelines, which require benchmarking against tariffs discovered through long-term competitive bidding.
The July 9 order advised CESC to go for re-bidding strictly in accordance with the guidelines issued under Section 63 of the Electricity Act. PTI BSM NN
This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
32 minutes ago
- Time of India
‘Adani group to invest Rs 96,000 crore in airports business over 5 years'
AHMEDABAD: Operating seven airports in India, including Mumbai CSMIA with Navi Mumbai set to join the list this Oct, the Adani group will invest close to Rs 1 lakh crore in its airport business over the next five years. This capex will be spread over both infra and real estate development. The conglomerate's airport head Jeet Adani (27), son of patriarch Gautam Adani , says the potential in India is so immense that it has no immediate plans to expand this vertical of business abroad. Excerpts: What are your investment plans for the sector? We do five-year rolling planning. In the next five years, our total investment planned in the airports ecosystem between infrastructure and real estate is almost Rs 95,000-96,000 crore. The biggest chunk of the capex will be at Navi Mumbai Airport, Mumbai Airport and real estate in these two places. The other big projects are to build new terminals at airports in places like Ahmedabad, Jaipur and Thiruvananthapuram in next four years. The recently-built terminal in Lucknow will be expanded. A new terminal at Guwahati is ready and will be commissioned this Oct-Nov. Do you have any plans to build and operate airports abroad too? Not immediately. We see too much opportunity in India and don't want to distract ourselves by going abroad. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Could Be the Best Time to Trade Gold in 5 Years IC Markets Learn More Undo We keep getting feelers from abroad. But at the end of the day, it's about our management bandwidth and where do we want to keep our capital. We believe India will see some serious growth in the next 10-15 years. There's so much growth opportunity here with 26 airports already identified for being developed PPP way. Our focus is on going deeper in India and establishing a broader presence here, rather than going abroad. Jeet Adani What is the investment that the upcoming Navi Mumbai will see? We clubbed phase I and II of that airport and will open with an initial capacity of 2 crore passengers annually (CPA) instead of building 1 CPA at a time. This has been built with a capex of Rs 19,000 crore. We have already started work on T2 for Navi Mumbai International Airport (NMIA) which could either be 3-CPA capacity at Rs 30,000 crore or 5-CPA capacity with a capex of Rs 40-45,000 crore. That decision will be taken shortly and T2 construction work will start in 6-12 months. Our overall capex on NMIA that will take it to the ultimate capacity of 9 CPA will be Rs 1 lakh crore. A completely new T1 at Mumbai CSMIA will be built by 2032 at a cost of Rs 5,000 crore. How do you plan to fund this capex? Equity we will put on our own. We have to refinance NMIA. The same lenders have already expressed willingness to participate in the next round. Our philosophy is to pre-invest in infra because we are willing to take a position on the growth of the aviation sector and growth of the economy of the cities we are in. The sector has some real tailwinds. What makes you so bullish on aviation, given the not so happy relation between airlines and airports here in the past? We are not here just as an airport operator but are here to drive the entire ecosystem forward. It is not a fight between airline and airport operators. Collectively, our aviation ecosystem has to get the traffic currently transiting between India and rest of the world through nearby hubs in the Gulf, Southeast Asia and even Europe (for North America market). Those places have a deep integration between airports and airlines, which as of now is not there in India. Fortunately as a group, we have fantastic relationship with IndiGo and the Tatas. We have spoken to both and have asked them to include us into their planning and be a part of our planning. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
Time of India
35 minutes ago
- Time of India
JSW Paints seeks CCI nod to acquire majority stake in Akzo Nobel India for ₹12,915 crore
NEW DELHI: Sajjan Jindal-led JSW Paints has sought approval from the Competition Commission of India (CCI) to acquire a majority stake in Dutch paint maker Akzo Nobel's India unit in a Rs 12,915-crore deal. The development came after JSW Paints announced in June this year that it will buy a 74.76 per cent stake in Akzo Nobel India for Rs 8,986 crore, followed by an open offer to buy another 25 per cent from open market for up to Rs 3,929.06 crore, totalling over Rs 12,915 crore, to become the fourth-largest player in the paint industry in the country. "The proposed transaction relates to the acquisition of up to 75 per cent shareholding in the target (Akzo Nobel India Ltd) by the acquirer (JSW Paints Ltd) through a share purchase agreement, and a mandatory open offer," according to a notice filed with the Competition Commission of India. The parties (JSW Paints and Akzo Nobel India) said the proposed combination does not raise competition concerns in any plausible relevant markets and therefore, the relevant market delineations may be left open. JSW Paints is a part of the USD 23 billion JSW Group, one of India's leading conglomerates with diverse interests across a range of B2B and B2C sectors, including steel, cement, energy infrastructure, automotives and paints. Akzo Nobel India Ltd (ANIL) is a decorative and industrial paint player and part of Netherlands-headquartered Akzo Nobel. In June, Akzo Nobel NV, in a global statement, said it has signed an agreement to sell its shareholding in Akzo Nobel India to the JSW Group. However, the Dutch parent firm also said the India Powder Coatings business and International Research Centre, both currently part of ANIL, will be "retained by Akzo Nobel" under full ownership. JSW Paints, with other group entities JTPM Metal Traders and JSW EduInfra, has also announced an open offer to acquire the remaining 25.24 per cent share of ANIL from the public shareholders for a total consideration of up to Rs 3,929.06 crore. The deal will help JSW Group expand its play in the paint segment, which it entered in 2019. JSW Paints Managing Director Parth Jindal said paints & coatings is one of India's fastest-growing sectors, and JSW Paints is among the fastest-growing paint companies. "Akzo Nobel India is home to some of the most globally renowned brands of paints & coatings like Dulux, International and Sikkens. We are excited to welcome them to the JSW family. Together, along with the Akzo Nobel India family -- employees, customers and partners -- we aspire to build the paint company of the future," he said. In October 2024, Akzo Nobel NV announced a strategic review of its portfolio in South Asia and is looking for strategic options, including partnerships, joint ventures, mergers or divestments. This is to deploy capital towards expanding its core coatings business. Its revenue from operations in FY25 was Rs 4,091.21 crore. The Indian paint industry is led by Asian Paints. Besides Berger, Kansai Nerolac, Akzo Nobel India (Dulux), Indigo Paints, Shalimar Paints, and Nippon Paints are the other top brands. In the last 5-6 years, several new players have entered the market, including Pidilite with Haisha Paints, Grasim with its Birla Opus, and JSW Paints.
Time of India
35 minutes ago
- Time of India
Kalpataru pre-sales jump 41% to ₹4,531 crore in FY25
MUMBAI : Realty firm Kalpataru Ltd has clocked a 41 per cent growth in its pre-sales to Rs 4,531 crore in the last fiscal, driven by higher demand for residential properties. Kalpataru Ltd, one of the leading real estate developers in the country, has recently been listed on the stock exchanges. "For the full FY25, pre-sales were at Rs 4,531 crore, up 41 per cent YoY (year-on-year)," Kalpataru Ltd said in a presentation to analysts and investors. In 2023-24, the Mumbai-based company sold properties worth Rs 3,202 crore. In the last fiscal, the company launched 7 new projects, totalling 6.5 million square feet of saleable area. Last fiscal, Kalpataru Ltd signed development agreements (DA) for two new society redevelopment projects with an estimated GDV (gross development value) of Rs 2,100 crore. During the entire 2024-25, Kalpataru Ltd posted a net profit of Rs 21.62 crore against a loss of Rs 94.98 crore in the preceding year. The total income increased to Rs 2,331.59 crore last fiscal from Rs 2,039.93 crore in the 2023-24. The company's net debt stood at Rs 9,310 crore at the end of March this year, down by Rs 673 crore compared to March 2024. Kalpataru Ltd raised Rs 1,590 crore in equity through IPO (Initial Public Offering) in June 2025. Out of this, Rs 1,192.5 crore have been utilised for debt repayment as on date in line with the objects of the issue. As a result, the net debt-to-equity number has further improved, the presentation said. Kalpataru Ltd has completed 77 real estate projects (18.4 million sq ft area). It has 35 ongoing, forthcoming and planned projects with a developable area of 47.3 million square feet. The company has a significant presence in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) and Pune markets.
