Tourist chiefs call out Edinburgh on 'unworkable' levy
In a letter to the leader of City of Edinburgh Council, Jane Meagher, and all council members, a range of groups representing the Scottish tourism industry warn that the timeline for implementing the new levy 'remains unworkable at present'.
'The current roll-out timeline for business required to apply the levy places unnecessary and avoidable strain on the sector,' the letter states. 'With less than three months remaining before accommodation providers must begin displaying levy-inclusive pricing, there is still no practical or technical guidance from the council or VisitScotland, despite assurances this would be received like the guidance that was published for local authorities back in October 2024.
'While the levy may appear simple, its application is complex - particularly given the intricacies of accommodation pricing and booking systems. These challenges have been clearly communicated to the Scottish Government, VisitScotland, and the council and are at the heart of why guidance is imperative ahead of implementation. With no guidance, there can be no successful implementation. We urge the council to recognise the serious risk this lack of guidance poses - especially as [[Edinburgh]] leads the way as the first to charge a levy in Scotland.'
I love Scotland but returning from holiday made my heart sink
Edinburgh firm outguns forecasts after snubbing £1bn takeover approach
'We believe in Glasgow': Developer gives city huge vote of confidence
Scots legal giant cites 'resilience and ambition' as latest results revealed
The industry's frustration over the lack of guidance is the latest in a series of concerns business groups have highlighted over the operation of tourism taxes in Scotland.
In May, nearly 80 groups representing thousands of tourism and hospitality businesses wrote to Minister for Public Finance Ivan McKee to underline their fears about the implementation of the Visitor Levy (Scotland) Act.
In the letter, business chiefs stated that the legislation as it stands will place the burden for collecting the tax on companies already under pressure from protracted cost inflation, and warned that operating the levy could tip many small operators over the value-added tax (VAT) threshold. This could lead to some withdrawing from the accommodation market because it would be financially prohibitive, the letter stated.
Industry groups called for the legislation to be changed to make the system more workable. A proposal was tabled to replace the current model of charging tourists a percentage on the cost of an overnight stay with a fixed fee, and for a digital QR system to be introduced to remove the responsibility of collecting the tax from businesses.
More generally, tourism chiefs have expressed concern that adding a tax to overnight stays in Edinburgh could undermine its competitiveness on the global tourism stage.
The letter to City of [[Edinburgh]] Council, which was signed by bodies such as the Scottish Tourism Alliance, UK Hospitality (Scotland), [[Edinburgh]] Hotels Association, the Association of Scotland's Self Caterers, and the Association of Scotland's Visitor Attractions, adds: 'To be clear, as an industry we are not trying to halt the levy being applied in [[Edinburgh]] by July 24, 2026, but are asking for a realistic timeline for implementation ahead of this date to comply with what is legally required of us.
'This constitutes a new era for how accommodation is priced in Edinburgh and Scotland more broadly, and the levy will likely be with us for many years to come – it's therefore critical that the implementation is handled in a way that ensures long-term functionality and credibility.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
US vice-president JD Vance is set to take a summer break in Scotland with his family
Vice-president JD Vance is set to take a summer break in Scotland with his family, creating another 'security headache' for police. Mr Vance is coming to the Cotswolds next month with his wife and children - but the Mail understands he also intends to come north of the Border. It means police will face the prospect of more protests shortly after Donald Trump 's stay ends next week, piling more pressure on overstretched officers. One source close to the preparations said: 'It is another security headache for the police – another VIP who is likely to trigger protests. 'It won't be quite as big as the Trump operation but it will still be very significant.' Activists have vowed to ruin Mr Vance's Cotswolds family holiday when he visits the place where Trump-hating Ellen DeGeneres now calls home. The Vice-President is set to travel to the idyllic English countryside alongside his wife Usha, 39, and their three children, Ewan Blaine, Vivek and Mirabel, next month. But pro-Palestine activists, eco campaigners and trade unionists have vowed to wreak havoc with planned protests during his stay. The anti-Trump and anti-Vance protests are set to mirror recent demonstrations against Mr Vance during a family holiday to Disneyland. Last week visitors were left outraged after Mr Vance shut down rides so he could enjoy them with his children - and he previously faced protest placards during a skiing holiday in the US state of Vermont in March this year. The Stop Trump Coalition alliance is said to include pro-Palestinian activists, climate campaigners, and trade unions. Mr Vance and his family are expected to arrive in Britain soon after the President's five-day stay in Scotland. The Stop Trump Coalition has outlined plans to greet Mr Trump with banners and flags along roads and a beachside message visible from the sky. Further action is intended for his proposed state visit expected to take place in September. It has signalled similar opposition to Mr Vance's British break, with a spokesman saying: 'We are meeting Trump with protests in Aberdeen and Edinburgh this month, and then in London and Windsor in September. 'JD Vance is every bit as unwelcome in the UK as Donald Trump. 'We remember how Vance cut short his ski trip in Vermont because he was so enraged by the sight of a few protesters. 'We are sure that, even in the Cotswolds, he will find the resistance waiting.' The Vice-President strolled through Disneyland in Los Angeles, California, hand-in-hand with two of his children, Vivek and Mirabel, last Saturday - with a vast Secret Service security detail alongside them. In a speech in February, Mr Vance highlighted an SNP government law banning protest near abortion clinics, which critics said could be used to target people praying in their own homes, as an example of an attack on freedom of speech. Mr Vance claimed people who live within safe access zones had been sent letters by the Scottish Government warning them about praying in their homes. The Scottish Government had insisted that Mr Vance's claim was 'incorrect'.
Glasgow Times
2 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Campaigners to challenge Eaglesham battery plant ruling
Mum-of-three Morag Hannan is worried about the possible fire risk from lithium-ion batteries as the 40-megawatt storage plant is set to be installed opposite her home on Glasgow Road. Alongside her husband Craig, they have raised a petition for judicial review against East Renfrewshire Council. The couple have launched a crowdfunding campaign to cover the costs of the action, with almost £3,400 donated so far. Ms Hannan said she has 'many concerns about the safety risk as well as toxic fumes' from the site. She believes her family, and an elderly neighbour, would be forced to evacuate towards a fire, as there is no way out to the back of their properties. But they could become trapped if fire engines need to use a hydrant outside their driveway, the mum said. READ MORE: All the latest changes to Glasgow city centre streets explained GPC 1137 Ltd, a subsidiary of Apatura, had an initial bid refused by East Renfrewshire's planning committee last year, when councillors voiced concerns over fire risk, but a second application was later approved. After that decision, a reporter appointed by the Scottish Government rejected an appeal over the first plan. He found the proposal would lead to 'adverse visual effects in a greenbelt location'. Apatura wants to store surplus energy from the national grid in the batteries, which would then be returned when required. It has said the development will 'support the decarbonisation of the energy industry in the UK'. Judicial reviews focus on the process or legality of a decision, rather than the planning merits of the application. It is understood the review will centre on Cllr Paul Edlin, who the campaigners say was unable to vote at the second planning meeting following a complaint that he had 'prejudiced himself' with comments made about the project at a community council meeting. They believe this wasn't the case and Cllr Edlin faced 'undue pressure' not to attend the meeting, denying him an opportunity to 'partake in local democracy'. READ MORE: This is the plan for this iconic Glasgow city centre building Almost 3,700 people have signed a petition which calls for the decision to be overturned. Council officials are currently investigating the required legal steps and the cost of revoking permission, following a motion from Conservative councillors. They previously had a motion which pushed for revocation ruled incompetent. Ms Hannan said: 'The only remedy available to us is to take legal action ourselves and we are going to continue this fight until the decision is overturned.' East Renfrewshire Council is expected to defend its position. A spokesman said the authority is unable to comment due to the ongoing legal proceedings. Campaigners believe the case could be heard in September. The developers have previously said the application was 'accompanied by a suite of technical documents which demonstrate the proposal will not lead to significant adverse harm'. Ahead of the meeting where planning permission was granted, council officials reported the second application differed from the original as more information has been submitted on fire safety and a water tank is now proposed to be created underground.
Glasgow Times
2 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Balmanno House sale funds £1m boost for local charities
Balmanno House was a registered charity that provided residential care in the city's west end for more than 200 years. The home went into administration in April 2023, and efforts were made to ensure a smooth relocation of residents to other care facilities. Blair Milne (Image: Supplied) After receiving a considerable amount of interest, the property was sold to RSD Property Holdings Limited for residential development. The undisclosed sale amount ensured all creditors at the time of administration were paid in full, including statutory interest, redundancy pay, and other entitlements for former staff. Read more: Hamilton firm raises £7k at golf day for Scottish charities The insolvency process transitioned to a liquidation to wrap up the company's affairs and distribute funds to creditors. Blair Milne and James Fennessey, joint liquidators and partners with accountancy firm Azets, are overseeing the distribution of the surplus funds to various charities, in line with the wishes of the Balmanno House trustees. Mr Milne, head of restructuring and insolvency in Scotland at Azets, said: "It gives me great pleasure to see such a substantial sum being made available for distribution to charity. "It is very rare for all creditors to receive full repayment together with interest from any insolvency process, let alone such a substantial sum being made available to charities." Allan Carrick, speaking on behalf of the board of trustees, said: "The former trustees of Balmanno House are delighted with the outcome of the administration and subsequent liquidation and are very pleased that so many deserving charities of their choice will benefit from the distribution of the surplus funds." Mr Milne thanked the trustees for their role in the process. He said: "I would like to express my thanks to the board of trustees for their actions and their support prior to the administration appointment and throughout the insolvency process. "The actions of the trustees, particularly seeking early advice on cash flow management, helped to ensure an orderly winding down of the care home operation, an optimal outcome from sale of the company's property asset, and ultimately a substantial sum being distributed to charity at the end of the process." He acknowledged the challenges faced by the care sector in recent years, saying that many care homes had no choice but to enter insolvency due to rising costs, insufficient funding, staff shortages, and unstable occupancy levels. He said: "As can be seen from the outcome achieved with Balmanno House, taking early advice on restructuring and insolvency ensures that all options remain available, either to restructure and preserve the business or to maximise the value available to stakeholders from a sale of the company's assets." The charities benefiting from the funds include Glasgow East End Community Carers, able2sail, St Francis Care Home, CrossReach, Association for the Relief of Infirmity in the West of Scotland, Ayrshire Hospice, Tenovus Scotland Strathclyde, Glasgow Children's Hospital, and The Prince and Princess of Wales Hospice.
