Short term let owner says investment saved ‘neglected' building
Jitendra Naran, who lives in Sandford, Oxfordshire, has appealed to Scottish Ministers to intervene after East Lothian Council ordered him to stop using the flat on Dunbar High Street as a holiday let.
But while East Lothian planners said the short term rental was not compatible with residential living in the property, Mr Naran has appealed saying the flat contributes to the local economy and improved the look of the building.
In an appeal statement, he said: 'Significant investment has gone into refurbishing this long neglected property to bring it up to modern standards.
'Had the flat remained in its previous condition, it risked becoming detrimental to the conservation area. Instead, it is now an attractive, well-managed residence that contributes positively to Dunbar's town centre.
'There are a couple of other flats inhabited and one currently unsold recently coming to the market.'
Mr Naran has appealed to Scottish Ministers to reject an enforcement notice served by the council after planners rejected a retrospective application for a change of use of the flat from residential to short term let.
Planners said the use of the top floor flat in the Category B listed building as a short term holiday let was ' incompatible with and harmful to the
amenity of the occupiers of the properties within the residential building'.
However Mr Naran said he had appealed against the decision through the council;s Local Review system but received no reply.
He has asked Scottish Ministers to reject the enforcement notice issued by the council and seek 'clarification' over reasons for the refusal and demand to stop operating.
In his appeal to the council he said that the flat had been used during the pandemic to support key workers and he had worked with local businesses and community to build a relationship providing the accommodation for professionals who needed accommodation in the town.
He urged Ministers to intervene saying he was willing to work with the council to find a solution adding: 'I remain fully open to working with the council to regularise the works through retrospective consent or minor
amendments, if necessary.
'My request is for a balanced and reasonable approach that reflects the improvements made and the broader public benefit. This matter should be resolved constructively, not punitively.'
The appeal has lodged by the Scottish Government Reporter on the DPEA appeal website.
By Marie Sharp Local Democracy Reporter
Like this:
Like
Related
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Edinburgh Reporter
7 hours ago
- Edinburgh Reporter
Short term let owner says investment saved ‘neglected' building
A short term let operator claims his investment in a 'neglected' town centre flat saved it from damaging the surrounding conservation area. Jitendra Naran, who lives in Sandford, Oxfordshire, has appealed to Scottish Ministers to intervene after East Lothian Council ordered him to stop using the flat on Dunbar High Street as a holiday let. But while East Lothian planners said the short term rental was not compatible with residential living in the property, Mr Naran has appealed saying the flat contributes to the local economy and improved the look of the building. In an appeal statement, he said: 'Significant investment has gone into refurbishing this long neglected property to bring it up to modern standards. 'Had the flat remained in its previous condition, it risked becoming detrimental to the conservation area. Instead, it is now an attractive, well-managed residence that contributes positively to Dunbar's town centre. 'There are a couple of other flats inhabited and one currently unsold recently coming to the market.' Mr Naran has appealed to Scottish Ministers to reject an enforcement notice served by the council after planners rejected a retrospective application for a change of use of the flat from residential to short term let. Planners said the use of the top floor flat in the Category B listed building as a short term holiday let was ' incompatible with and harmful to the amenity of the occupiers of the properties within the residential building'. However Mr Naran said he had appealed against the decision through the council;s Local Review system but received no reply. He has asked Scottish Ministers to reject the enforcement notice issued by the council and seek 'clarification' over reasons for the refusal and demand to stop operating. In his appeal to the council he said that the flat had been used during the pandemic to support key workers and he had worked with local businesses and community to build a relationship providing the accommodation for professionals who needed accommodation in the town. He urged Ministers to intervene saying he was willing to work with the council to find a solution adding: 'I remain fully open to working with the council to regularise the works through retrospective consent or minor amendments, if necessary. 'My request is for a balanced and reasonable approach that reflects the improvements made and the broader public benefit. This matter should be resolved constructively, not punitively.' The appeal has lodged by the Scottish Government Reporter on the DPEA appeal website. By Marie Sharp Local Democracy Reporter Like this: Like Related
The National
7 hours ago
- The National
Anas Sarwar is generally useless but he's right about Gaza
FIRST Minister John Swinney is considering a proposal from Scottish Greens MSP and co-leader Ross Greer for the Scottish Government to adopt the principles of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) campaign, which intends to put economic pressure on Israel. Similar to the sanctions currently being imposed on Russia, and similar to the boycott campaigns against the racist apartheid regime in South Africa during the 1980s, the goal is to force Israel to halt its genocidal campaign against Gaza. It also hopes to stop the policy of ever-expanding illegal Israeli settlements in the West Bank, with its associated expropriation of Palestinian land and the demolition of Palestinian homes. Greer has written to the First Minister demanding that he adopt the principles of the BDS campaign. A Scottish Government spokesperson said ministers would 'consider' the proposal, which would see official guidance issued to businesses urging them to end trade with Israel, as was done with Russia in 2022. In his letter to the First Minister, Greer welcomed the acknowledgment that 'there is a genocide in Palestine.' However, he challenged Swinney's claim that he was 'doing everything [he] possibly can' to pressure Israel, arguing that the Scottish Government could and should be doing significantly more. READ MORE: Gaza teen launches fundraiser after being offered place at Scottish university Although Greer acknowledged in his letter that foreign affairs and most matters relating to international trade are reserved to Westminster, nevertheless there are still actions which the Scottish Government could take, writing: 'As we both know and have previously discussed, there is much more which the Scottish Government can be doing to put pressure on Israel to end its genocide in Palestine." He then called for the Scottish Government to scrap part of the Local Government Act 1988 to allow councils to bar companies from winning contracts if they participated in the illegal occupation of Palestinian territory, suggesting this could be achieved through an amendment to the Community Wealth Building Bill. He also suggested that the Scottish Government should cease funding arms companies via Scottish Enterprise as some of these companies have maintained links with Israel during the genocide. Greer also pressed the First Minister to ensure Scottish Enterprise halts all grants of public money to 'all other companies directly complicit in the occupation [of Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem]". The government agency Scottish Enterprise (SE) has given £8 million to 13 companies involved in weapons manufacturing since 2019 – although the SNP Government maintains that the funding doesn't go directly to the production of munitions and that 'due diligence' checks are thorough. READ MORE: 'Words are not enough': Ross Greer urges action on Scottish Israel boycott plan However, this has been called into question by campaigners who note that of the 199 human rights checks carried out by Scottish Enterprise between 2021 and 2023, no firm ever failed. Pressure has also built around some of the arms firms' links to Israel. Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes said in February that the Scottish Government did 'not believe that public funding should be spent on the manufacture of weapons or munitions' and that it would 'review and ensure" the most robust processes are in place for funding given to weapons companies. On conclusion of the review, it was determined that – despite funding the manufacture of parts for F-35s and other military technology – Scottish Enterprise had never funded munitions. The F-35 is a single-seat, single-engine, supersonic stealth strike fighter jet built by the American company Lockheed Martin. The Israeli military has made extensive use of F-35s in its bombing campaign in Gaza, which has reduced much of the territory to rubble and caused the majority of the estimated 60,000 plus deaths – mostly of civilians – since October 7, 2023. Now with Israel's on-going blockade of food and humanitarian supplies from reaching Gaza, the territory is experiencing a man-made famine. At least 200,000 children in Gaza are suffering from severe malnutrition, exacerbated by the lack of baby formula and nutritional supplements, according to the NGO Network in Gaza. The news broadcaster Al Jazeera has reported that the number of deaths in Gaza directly due to starvation has now reached 197, including 96 children. An additional 98 Palestinians, including 51 people seeking aid, have been killed in Israeli attacks in the past 24 hours, according to the Health Ministry in Gaza. The Israeli cabinet is meeting today to discuss Israel's next steps in the conflict. It is thought that the Israeli Government will announce that it intends to occupy the entirety of Gaza, which humanitarian organisations fear will lead to more Palestinian deaths and the permanent displacement of hundreds of thousands while Israel opens up the territory to illegal Israeli settlements. The annexation of Gaza and the West Bank, and even parts of Lebanon and Jordan, has long been the goal of the Israeli religious far-right, whose support is crucial to the administration of Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Such a move would be a fatal blow to hopes of a two-state solution to the long running conflict between Israelis and Palestinians, both of whom claim the same territory as their national home. It would guarantee decades more suffering for Palestinians, breeding a new generation of angry and alienated young Palestinian men who feel they have nothing to lose by mounting revenge attacks on Israeli civilians, thus perpetuating the cycle of violence and hatred. It's not often that this newsletter agrees with Anas Sarwar, a man whose opinions have all the substance of an empty crisps packet being blown about in the hot air of Keir Starmer's pronouncements, but he was correct when he noted at The Herald's Unspun event at the Edinburgh Fringe that the UK Government has relatively little influence on Israel, and that Benjamin Netanyahu doesn't listen to Keir Starmer. That, however, is no excuse for not speaking out forcibly against the genocide in Gaza and being forthright in condemnation of Israel's actions in both Gaza and the West Bank. It's about adding your voice and weight to collective global efforts to force Netanyahu to alter course and to be able to look those desperate Palestinian families in the eye and tell them that we are doing all we can to end their misery.
Scotsman
8 hours ago
- Scotsman
Scottish Secretary Ian Murray gives wealth tax verdict as deputy prime minister Angela Rayner pushes for move
The Scottish Secretary said a tax on the highest income earners would lead to 'flight' of wealthier people abroad. Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Scottish Secretary Ian Murray has dismissed calls from within the Labour Party to introduce a wealth tax, insisting it 'doesn't work', as the UK government comes under growing pressure to plug a £51 billion black hole in the public finances. Speaking at an event at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe on Thursday, Mr Murray said the cost of bringing in the wealth tax would be 'huge' and would lead to the 'flight' of wealthier people abroad. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Scottish Secretary Ian Murray is against a wealth tax. The assertion comes after former Labour shadow chancellor Anneliese Dodds said the Treasury should consider a wealth tax. She is among a growing number of the party's MPs calling for further wealth taxes to help raise money. A leaked memo previously showed Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner pushed for taxes targeting wealth ahead of the Spring Statement in March. Scottish Secretary Ian Murray | PA It has also become popular among unions and other left-wing parties, including the Greens and Jeremy Corbyn's new, unnamed party. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The Scotsman reported earlier this year that Scottish ministers were poised to ask the UK government for the power to introduce wealth taxes after the next Holyrood election. SNP Finance Secretary Shona Robison has called on Chancellor Rachel Reeves to 'seriously examine' introducing wealth taxes to ensure further boosts to defence spending does not come at the expense of drastic cuts to public services. The Bank of England said Ms Reeves's £25 billion National Insurance raid, announced in her first Budget last year, had contributed to sluggish growth and pushed up food prices, as it announced the fifth interest rates cut in a year on Thursday. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The UK's central bank chose to reduce the base rate to 4 per cent from 4.25 per cent, as it forecast inflation would rise to 4 per cent next month. Speculation has grown that Ms Reeves will be forced to raise taxes in her autumn Budget. Chancellor Rachel Reeves | Jane Barlow/Press Association Mr Murray was asked about the wider issue of wealth taxes while appearing as a guest on Matt Forde's Political Party show during the Fringe. Asked if those around the Cabinet table were coming round to the view there should be a wealth tax, the Scottish Secretary said: 'Well no, it doesn't work. You see that – the Laffer curve is there for everyone to see. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'So yes, you could bring in a wealth tax because it might make you feel principally better. 'e might bring in a few hundred million pounds, but the cost of doing that would be huge because there is just flight, whether we like it or not. 'The French did it really badly, the Norwegians really badly. So the places that have done a wealth tax have rowed back from it on the basis that it doesn't raise them any money. 'So every single principled decision we have to make has got to be on the basis of does it raise more money, is it fair, is it equitable, will it resolve the situation? If the answer to any of those questions is no, we shouldn't do it.'
