‘Where's the proof?': Calls for Ntshavheni to answer for coup claims
The MK party is demanding proof about an alleged coup that has been foiled by the South African government.
This comes after Minister in the Presidency Khumbudzo Ntshavheni told parliament on Tuesday that the country's intelligence services managed to prevent a number of coup attempts, the latest being two weeks ago.
MK party spokesperson Nhlamulo Ndhlela told The Citizen on Wednesday that the minister must provide evidence to back her claims.
'She must tell us who, what and where. She has already told the public, now she must give us details and stop politicking,' he said.
Is state security still functional?
Despite Ntshavheni's praise of the country's intelligence services, Ndhlela said they are dysfunctional.
'If they have been closing on coups, why did they fail to prevent the July unrests four years ago?' he asked.
Ndhlela criticised President Cyril Ramaphosa for absorbing the intelligence portfolio into the office of the Presidency.
Efforts to discredit Mkhwanazi?
ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba also dismissed Ntshavheni's claims.
'This is nonsense. We do not have time for this. This is the first time we are hearing of it and I think this is just a plan to discredit [KZN police commissioner] Lt Gen Mkhwanazi,' he said.
ALSO READ: Ntshavheni assures SA is safe after detected potential coup risk
Mkhwanazi made several allegations against top police officials, including Minister Senzo Mchunu, accusing them of political interference and collusion with alleged criminal syndicates.
During a parliamentary meeting on Wednesday, National Coloured Congress member Fadiel Adams described Mkhwanazi's allegations as a threat to the country.
'He had what looked like an armed militia behind him. That was a threat to this country.
'He was trying to incite policemen to take action in the event of whatever it is he knows is coming,' he speculated.
'Very low risk' of a coup
Political analyst Ntsikelelo Breakfast told The Citizen that Ntshavheni's comments have the potential to alarm the public.
'She should not have said that. There are things that you are privy to as a leader of a cluster.
'If there is a threat, I think she should have kept the public at bay about that. We do not want to agitate people to pursue that agenda,' he said.
Breakfast said the intelligence service in the country had been weaponised in party politics.
'The intelligence apparatus has always been, and maybe still is, used in the factional battles of the ANC,' he said.
Another political analyst, Theo Neethling, said he was surprised by Ntshavheni's remarks.
'I can only say that the possibility of a coup in South Africa has always been regarded by analysts as a matter of very low risk – unlike what we've seen in recent years, for example, in West Africa. This announcement therefore comes as a complete surprise and even a shock,' he said.
Neethling said the announcement comes at a time when the police are in deep trouble.
'In addition, allegations of corruption and misconduct against ANC members and top police officials hang like a dark cloud in the air, creating major uncertainty about our national security,' he said.
NOW READ: Leave and a commission don't make Mchunu immune from prosecution, parliament hears
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
4 minutes ago
- IOL News
Positive mindset is vital to get South Africa to move the dial
Business leaders are key to moving South Africa faster along its current, generally upwards trajectory, says the author. Image: Picture: Henk Kruger/ Independent Newspapers Thirty years ago, if you told someone you were optimistic about the future of South Africa, they would lecture you about being a 'realist'. Well, now that we're in the future, it's time for this unrepentant optimist to engage in a little lecturing. The reality of 2025 is that South Africa is today an upper middle income country. Our gross domestic product (GDP) has doubled in 20 years and is similar to that of Bulgaria, Hungary and Serbia combined. Our national debt to GDP ratio is heading towards a manageable 75%. The richest nation on earth, conversely, is very good at dropping bombs but clearly hasn't figured out how to pay for them as it heads towards a debt to GDP ratio of 125%. While attention on mining fixates like it's still the only show in town, the last few decades have seen South Africa cement its successful transition from a primary, minerals-based economy to a services-based economy that contributes much more to GDP than mining. The City of Gold might as well now be called eRingRing for the proliferation of services-based contact centres. Inflation dropped below 3% this year. Unemployment is our bugbear but finally questions are being asked about how we measure this metric. It has never made any sense to me how a country can function with a third of workers not working. The truth is, more people are working and earning than is recorded. More South African children attend school now than at any point in our history. Our military is in bad shape because the biggest share of our budget goes to education and health. Smart nations on the rise do not direct money to the armed forces when people are hungry and need to be educated. Aggressors and victims build their militaries and we want to be neither. SA's sensible, soft power approach is cheaper and sustainable. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ South Africa has its priorities right and the reality shines through in the numbers that matter. If potholes were in this latter group, the UK, for instance, would be in deep trouble. That Daily Mail calls Britain's potholes an 'international embarrassment' with drivers there having to deal with 1.5m of them. And that's a small island - we have the world's 10th largest road network to maintain. The fundamentals of South Africa are largely sound and tell a story of a country making its way in the right direction. What we need to do, however, is move truth-telling of the kind above to the centre of our daily conversations. This will serve to motivate. Nobody feels like getting out there and fixing what's wrong when everyone is telling you it's too broken to fix. Let's take the example of Australia, one of the countries doing relatively well (I mean, if you take away the environment, drinking culture, domestic violence, biker gangs, gambling and cocaine). I don't think I have ever heard an Australian criticise the place. They always talk their country up, and the results are plain to see. Australia has, I would say, a very positive reputation that's overdone. South Africa, on the other hand, has the reverse. Yet, almost every visitor to our shores will remark how different the reality is on the ground to what's being reported overseas. This is partially our own fault. How many readers, like me, wanted to shrink into the floor when earlier this year we heard Johann Rupert randomly introducing the world to Cape Flats gangsterism in the White House, not to mention Retief Goosen going on about his parents living like virtual prisoners while Donald Trump looked on? Don't hide the truth, but my goodness, these South Africans had an audience with the President of the United States - in the full glare of the world's media - and could not think of a single positive fact about South Africa to perhaps help boost tourism, our economy and our future! Talk the truth, yes please, but don't make the situation look so beyond hope that negativity becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. Business leaders are key to moving South Africa faster along its current, generally upwards trajectory. So many are mentors to their employees and I would appeal to them to make educating younger South Africans about what's good about their country a priority. Mentorship is surely as much about motivating as it is about imparting wisdom. Employees cannot be expected to achieve greatness on the decks when they believe the ship is sinking. Ivan Booth is a PR consultant, an occasional author and amateur pothole enthusiast. Image: Supplied Ivan Booth is a PR consultant, an occasional author and amateur pothole enthusiast. *** The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of Independent Media or IOL. BUSINESS REPORT
The Citizen
15 hours ago
- The Citizen
New Ward 98 councillor promises action and accountability
Following a decisive win in the recent municipal by-election, newly elected Ward 98 councillor Mickey van der Westhuizen of the DA has promised to restore hope, service delivery, and accountability to one of Tshwane's most diverse and complex communities. Ward 98 consists of Clarina, Heatherdale, Klerksoord, Tileba, Winternest, Theresapark, Eldorette and Dorandia. The ward has been plagued by issues such as water outages, crumbling infrastructure, illegal dumping, and dysfunctional streetlights. With the DA securing 72.77% of the vote, up from 37.5% in the 2024 National and Provincial Elections, the party sees this victory as a signal that residents are ready for effective leadership. 'This result shows that residents are tired of promises and are looking for delivery. 'We have heard their frustrations, and now it's time to roll up our sleeves,' said Van der Westhuizen. In outlining his immediate plans, he emphasised basic service delivery as a top priority. 'I have been active working for the community, with the community, and I have done the blue ribbon campaign, where I identified more than 3 000 non-functional streetlights that need to be fixed by the metro. 'The lessons that I have learned are that as someone representing the community, you must not disappoint them. If you disappoint your people, and if you do not listen and care for your community, you will be voted out,' he said. He said streetlights are currently a main concern for everyone, and that's his main priority. 'I want to prioritise community safety. It's important for me to engage with my community leaders.' The 30-year-old Van der Westhuizen, who grew up in the ward and matriculated at the Hoërskool Gerrit Maritz, said not everything is going to be fixed immediately, but residents must have trust in the process. 'It won't be immediately like we all will hope for, but I will advocate for better service delivery in all areas of Ward 98. 'Clarina, Dorandia and Tileba are some of the oldest communities in the north, and all have asbestos pipes. Now, asbestos pipes, as soon as they feel a bit too much pressure, burst. They need to be replaced, and I intend to put it in my integrated development plan because the problem now is that every two, three days, we have water leaks,' he said. Van der Westhuizen also mentioned that the safety of electrical infrastructure is another problem that needs an immediate solution. 'I believe that a community should work with the councillor and everyone should work as one team, for one vision and one goal in mind, for the betterment of all residents in the area.' Ward 98 was once considered contested ground, with ActionSA capturing 17% of the vote during the 2021 local government elections. However, ActionSA did not contest the recent by-election. This, according to DA Tshwane caucus leader Cilliers Brink, created space for the DA to reconnect with disillusioned voters. 'Many former ActionSA supporters in Ward 98 are now backing the DA. This is a ward that reflects the future of our country, diverse, vibrant, but facing serious challenges. 'Our goal is to prove that good governance and local delivery still matter,' said Brink. DA's constituency political head Bronwynn Engelbrecht said it's important for Van der Westhuizen to be patient, as it's not easy to be a ward councillor. 'We needed somebody who's got a passion for the people, a passion for working hard because it's a hard job. You can't always be at home on your cellphone you must be there and meet your people. 'We were evaluating Van der Westhuizen, even though he didn't even know, and he proved beyond all expectations that he is always available.' Do you have more information about the story? Please send us an email to [email protected] or phone us on 083 625 4114. For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord's websites: Rekord East For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
The South African
16 hours ago
- The South African
Roland Schoeman accuses Cyril Ramaphosa's ANC of looting 'a trillion rand' in scathing tweet
South African Olympic gold medallist Roland Schoeman has ignited a storm of political controversy, this time accusing President Cyril Ramaphosa and the ruling African National Congress (ANC) of looting 'over a trillion rand' – a claim that drew mixed reactions from South Africans across the political spectrum. The 45-year-old swimming icon, who won gold at the 2004 Olympics in Athens in the 4x100m freestyle relay and has since become a prominent online political commentator, took to social media following Ramaphosa's latest address to Parliament, writing on X (formerly Twitter): 'Imagine where the country would be if you and your party didn't steal over a trillion rand.' The post, which quickly gained traction, triggered a polarising response – some users applauded his bluntness, while others condemned his remarks as simplistic, racially charged, or disconnected from South Africa's broader social and economic realities. While many users on social media agreed with Schoeman's anti-corruption message, others challenged his narrative, pointing out issues of historic inequality, white privilege, and deep-rooted systemic dysfunction that go beyond a single administration. @hopeinbetween replied: 'If they can stop pleasing whiteness, we could be in an even better and stronger position as a country!' @Vincent62343509 added: 'They allowed population growth to spiral with poor border control… compared to our economic growth, that's unsustainable.' Others were more scathing: @HumanOpinion1 wrote: 'Imagine trying to sell 'progress' after looting a trillion rand. That's like bragging about patching one pothole after burning down the whole highway.' The comment section revealed that, while frustration over corruption is shared across racial and political lines, Schoeman's tone and framing drew accusations of bias and oversimplification. Over the years, the swimmer-turned-commentator has regularly spoken out on issues including farm murders, racial identity politics, and EFF leader Julius Malema, once applauding the UK's decision to reject Malema's visa application. His use of terms like 'civilised nations' and support for greater US influence in South African affairs has also raised eyebrows, with some accusing him of promoting neocolonial sentiment. The Presidency has not responded directly to Schoeman's post, although the ANC has in the past dismissed similar public accusations as 'uninformed and populist'. Ramaphosa himself has consistently defended his administration's anti-corruption efforts, pointing to the Zondo Commission, reforms at SARS, and crackdowns on public sector fraud. Political analysts say Schoeman's remarks underscore a growing culture of online populism, where celebrities and influencers can shape national debate – often without accountability. 'Roland taps into a very real frustration many South Africans feel,' said political analyst Thami Ndlovu. 'But attributing all of South Africa's challenges to theft alone ignores the layers of complexity in our economy and society.' Others argue that voices like Schoeman's – while provocative – are reflective of a leadership vacuum and widespread disillusionment with post-apartheid governance. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
