Experts warn against taxing freelancers, content creators
Pakistan Freelancers Association (PAFLA) Chairman Ibrahim Amin said the government must avoid creating an impression that a large number of content creators will be brought under the tax net, as this could discourage struggling freelancers and budding digital creators. However, he suggested that the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) could consider taxing a select group of high-earning entertainment content creators with substantial followings and revenues. Amin urged the government to categorise content creators carefully, exempting those who provide educational content and skills training to millions of subscribers in Pakistan and abroad from any new tax burden.
He pointed out that both the public and private sectors have invested heavily in developing freelancers and digital creators, who have used these skills to support their families and attract much-needed foreign exchange into the country. Despite challenges such as frequent internet disruptions and electricity outages, freelancers' income surged to $400 million during the nine months of FY25, according to the latest Pakistan Economic Survey. Amin pointed out that most freelancers already pay taxes on every transaction and also bear deductions charged by freelancing platforms and payment gateways for transaction services.
Estimates suggest there are around 2.37 million freelancers in Pakistan, making it the fifth-largest freelance workforce globally.
"If we double the size of this community, annual foreign exchange inflows could exceed the $1 billion mark," said the PAFLA chief.
Hisham Sarwar, a social media influencer and a well-known digital skills and freelancing trainer, said the government must support the freelancing sector's efforts to bring foreign exchange into Pakistan rather than introduce measures that may create fear and discourage digital workers. Citing Bangladesh as an example, Sarwar noted that tax holidays and cashback incentives for its IT sector and freelancers have driven rapid growth. Pakistan, he argued, should strengthen its high-potential IT sector similarly to boost exports to $10 billion per annum.
Sarwar described Pakistan's freelancing market as limited but fast-growing, thanks to the talent and creativity of its youth. The rising adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) tools, he said, would likely attract more skilled individuals to the IT industry, potentially revolutionising the services and product sectors and delivering greater foreign exchange earnings than the proposed tax revenues.
He warned the government against imposing new taxes inspired by the lifestyles of a small fractionless than 1%of luxury-living vloggers. Such measures, he said, would harm the entire industry.
Pakistan Software Houses Association (P@SHA) Senior Vice Chairman Muhammad Umair Nizam said the IT sector has already proven its ability to attract valuable foreign exchange and foreign investment, aided by government incentives, tax holidays, and aggressive marketing drives.
Nizam stressed that expanding IT exports would help reduce the country's current account deficit while empowering the youth to improve their living standards through employment in the IT and freelancing sectors.
He also reiterated his call for an extension of the Final Tax Regime (FTR) for freelancers and IT exporters by up to 10 years and urged the government to allocate funds in the budget for capacity building of IT professionals and students.
During July-March FY2025, IT and Information Technology Enabled Services (ITeS) achieved a trade surplus of $2.429 million, a 21.6% increase from $1.997 million last year, despite frequent internet disruptions during the fiscal year.
The Pakistan Economic Survey 2024-25 highlighted other key indicators for the IT and telecommunications sector, including $2.825 million in IT exports, $2.429 million in trade surplus for IT and ITeS, $400 million in freelancers' remittances, Rs803 billion in telecom revenues, 147.2 million broadband subscribers, and a total of 199.9 million telecom subscribers.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
15 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Widening the tax base
EDITORIAL: Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif while chairing a meeting to review progress of reforms in the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), a weekly meeting held on Mondays, reiterated a decades-long exhortation by his predecessors: 'widen the tax net and reduce the burden on the poor'. And like his predecessors his administration continues to focus on raising revenue rather than on undertaking structural changes that would render the structure fair, equitable and non-anomalous. Pakistan's tax structure to this day relies heavily on indirect taxes, whose incidence on the poor is greater than on the rich, which effectively implies that the burden on the poor continues. Direct taxes, based on the ability to pay principle, accounted for nearly 49 percent of total collections; however, this does not take account of the fact that 75 to 80 percent of these collections are withholding taxes levied in the sales tax mode, which is an indirect tax — an exercise that the Auditor General of Pakistan noted and recommended to the FBR to abandon though with no success. The Federal Finance Minister is on record as having stated that the extraordinary law enforcement powers of the FBR, approved in the Finance Bill 2025, envisage effective implementation of sales tax regimen rather than on income, and Chairman of the FBR, Rashid Mahmood Langrial, is on record as having stated that the increase in collections from sugar industry are attributable to improved enforcement. In this context, it is relevant to note that successive governments, including the incumbent, focused on increasing the number of filers through access to NADRA data; however, this led to a rise in the number of filers with little increase in revenue. At the same time the FBR continues with its long-term practice of: (i) sustaining the reliance on indirect instead of direct taxes to ensure that the relatively poorer sections of society are not paying the bulk of revenue collections. In this context, it is relevant to note that the steady rise in reliance on petroleum levy (even though it is not collected by the FBR) is budgeted to generate 1.468 trillion rupees this year, which is an indirect tax and impacts on the transport costs of the poor and vulnerable; (ii) making the tax structure non-anomalous by taxing all units operating within a sector equally irrespective of ownership; (iii) failure to rationalise digital infrastructure taxes with the intent to make them more competitive against a basket of countries and fixing the tax rates for at least 10 years and fixing future spectrum flood prices while delinking the price from the dollar as suggested by a recent Asian Development Bank report; (iv) resistance to taxing certain sectors to enable their manipulation, example being the low tax prevalent on the stock market. It is relevant to note that India on average collects more than 100 billion rupees from this source against Pakistan's less than 5 billion rupees per annum; and (v) farm income tax, tax on traders, and retailers and builders, sectors which under the ongoing IMF programme will be taxed from this year onwards; however, time will tell how successful they have been. The government would no doubt argue that the attempt to raise FBR collections through raising existing taxes or bringing more items under the sales tax net or better enforcement is to ensure that the budget deficit is sustainable yet a better option would have been to reduce its own current expenditure for the time that is required to implement these structural tax reforms. Sadly, the budget for the current year envisages a rise in all items (10 percent raise in civil administration) except subsidies (for the poor though they remain untargeted) and mark-up which is expected to decline not because government borrowing is budgeted to decline but because the cost of borrowing, dependent on the discount rate, is projected to decline which the IMF, as per its reports on its website, does not appear to regard as a done deal. To conclude, structural reforms to amend the existing tax structure are the way forward rather than the measures currently in focus to increase revenue. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
FBR notifies NEV adoption levy on local, imported vehicles
The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has notified the rate of New Energy Vehicle (NEV) adoption levy on locally manufactured/assembled vehicles and imported vehicles. The new tax regime targets internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles to promote the adoption of electric and energy-efficient alternatives. According to the First Schedule of the Finance Act, the manufacturer will pay 1% ad valorem of the invoice price, inclusive of duties and taxes, on all ICE motor vehicles assembled or manufactured in Pakistan with engine capacity less than 1300CC. Person importing ICE motor vehicle will pay 1% ad valorem of assessed value, inclusive of duties and taxes, on the import of all ICE motor vehicles with engine capacity less than 1300CC. The manufacturer will pay 2% ad valorem of invoice price, inclusive of duties and taxes, on all ICE motor vehicles assembled or manufactured in Pakistan with engine capacity from 1300CC to 1800CC. Meanwhile, the person importing ICE motor vehicle would pay 2% ad valorem of assessed value, inclusive of duties and taxes, on all ICE motor vehicles imported in Pakistan with engine capacity from 1300CC to 1800CC. The manufacturer will pay 3% ad valorem of invoice price inclusive of duties and taxes, on all ICE engine motor vehicles assembled or manufactured in Pakistan with an engine capacity of more than 1800CC. All ICE engine motor vehicles imported in Pakistan with an engine capacity of more than 1800CC would be subjected to 3% ad valorem of assessed value, inclusive of duties and taxes. The levy would apply to a person importing ICE motor vehicle. In addition, imported buses and trucks with combustion engines will be charged 1%, while locally assembled buses and trucks will see a levy of 1%.
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Illicit-cigarette trade causes economic, public health challenges: study
LAHORE: The illicit cigarette trade in Pakistan has become a pressing economic and public health issue, primarily driven by weak regulatory enforcement and a lack of awareness among retailers. This was revealed in a study conducted by Umeed-e-Sehar, a nonprofit organization dedicated to public health initiatives. As per findings of the study titled- Tax Stamps and Illicit Cigarette Sales in Pakistan: Understanding Retailers' Knowledge Gap, there are alarming gaps in retailers' awareness regarding tax stamps, pricing regulations, and legal packaging compliance in Pakistan's cigarette market. The study has highlighted the weak enforcement on the illicit cigarette trade, as 97 percent of retailers reported that FBR officials had never approached them for compliance guidance, while 86 percent were unaware of government-imposed penalties for selling illicit cigarettes. As many as 2,000 retailers across seven major cities, including Karachi, Lahore, and Islamabad were surveyed and as per findings of study, only 27 percent of retailers could differentiate between tax-paid and illicit cigarette packs. In contrast, a staggering 73 percent did not know the correct placement and purpose of tax stamps. As per study, the majority of retailers, about 86 percent, identified price as the primary indicator of cigarette legality rather than checking for tax stamps, which only 12 percent of them considered. Around 59 percent of retailers estimated that between 30 to 60 percent of cigarette packs in their inventory lacked tax stamps, while 29 percent believed that more than 60 percent of the stock was illicit. The findings underscore retailers' key role in Pakistan's illicit cigarette trade. With over 50 local and international companies and an estimated annual consumption of 80 billion cigarettes, the industry faces a major challenge as illicit trade continues to erode the market share of legitimate firms. The study also found that the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) introduced the TransAct App to help retailers verify tax stamps, yet 98 percent of the surveyed retailers were unaware of its existence, and 99 percent never used it. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
