Attorney aims to discredit criminal homicide charge with fatal accident statistics
Jun. 3—WILKES-BARRE — When Louis Weihbrecht was charged with an open count of criminal homicide for what District Attorney Sam Sanguedolce alleged was the deliberate killing of Mark Svadeba in September, Attorney John B. Pike is fostering a defense alternative.
Svadeba's death was simply an accident, Pike fiercely advocated during a motions hearing before Luzerne County Judge Joseph F. Sklarosky Jr. on Tuesday.
Weihbrecht, 56, proprietor of the Outsiders Bar on South Main Street, Wilkes-Barre, was charged by Plains Township police and detectives from the district attorney's office with the open count of criminal homicide, alleging he intentionally ran over Svadeba with his 2007 Chevrolet Silverado truck on Sept. 13, 2024.
Court records say Svadeba was standing next to his Harley-Davidson motorcycle in front of an auto-repair garage on North Main Street, Plains Township, when Weihbrecht showed up in the Chevrolet truck.
Svadeba and Weihbrecht exchanged words when Weihbrecht, court records allege, intentionally ran over Svadeba, dragging him nearly 30 feet. The two men were reportedly in a dispute about a woman.
Following Weihbrecht's arrest on Sept. 16, 2024, Sanguedolce, during a news conference, explained the open count of criminal homicide was filed as investigators believe Weihbrecht intended and deliberately ran over Svadeba.
During Tuesday's motions hearing, Pike used Pennsylvania and Luzerne County statistics of pedestrians killed by a motor vehicle, and none rose to the level of a criminal homicide offense. Pike countered by explaining Svadeba walked in front of Weihbrecht's truck.
"This was a motor vehicle accident versus a pedestrian, that's all this is," Pike argued.
Assistant District Attorney James L. McMonagle responded that there is clear and convincing surveillance footage that shows the two men arguing, and Weihbrecht accelerating his truck to run over Svadeba for nearly 30 feet and backing up the truck to run over Svadeba a second time. McMonagle further argued the parking lot was adequately illuminated by lights.
Pike is advocating Weihbrecht only intended to strike the Harley-Davidson motorcycle when Svadeba walked in front of the truck.
Other issues argued during the motions hearing were to limit the testimony of the prosecution's expert who inspected Weihbrecht's truck and to prohibit any personal opinions about the vehicle, and to prohibit prosecutors from identifying Svadeba as a "victim" before the jury.
Sklarosky said he will issue his rulings at a later date.
Weihbrecht's trial is scheduled for September. He remains jailed without bail at the county correctional facility.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
an hour ago
- The Hill
Country singer Conner Smith hits, kills woman walking dog in crosswalk, police say
NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WKRN) — A woman was killed when she was hit by a vehicle while walking a dog in the Germantown neighborhood of Nashville Sunday night. Investigators have identified the driver as 24-year-old Conner Smith, a country singer and Nashville native. According to local police, 77-year-old Dorothy Dobbins was walking from a dog park and was in a crosswalk when she was hit by a pickup truck. Dobbins was taken to Vanderbilt University Medical Center where she died. Investigators believe Smith was driving a Chevrolet Silverado pickup truck north on Third Avenue North as Dobbins was crossing when he hit her around 7:30 p.m. Police said Smith showed no signs of impairment. The preliminary cause of the crash was Smith 'failing to yield the right of way' to Dobbins, the agency said in a release. As of Monday, no charges had been filed. 'On June 8th, Mr. Smith was involved in a car accident that tragically claimed a life. His heart goes out to Ms. Dobbins' family during this incredibly difficult time. Mr. Smith continues to cooperate fully with the ongoing investigation,' Smith's attorney said in a statement to Nexstar's WKRN. Photos from a performance in Nashville were posted to Smith's official Instagram page Sunday, but there was no statement on the crash. Smith appeared to be back in his hometown for CMA Fest, a country music festival that took place over the weekend. His most popular songs include 'Creek Will Rise' and 'I Hate Alabama.'
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Rising country star Conner Smith ‘cooperating with police' after woman killed in car crash
Country music singer Conner Smith's is cooperating fully with an investigation into a fatal weekend car wreck, his reps have said. Smith, 24, is said to have been driving a Chevrolet Silverado pickup truck on Sunday in Nashville when he hit Dorothy Dobbins, 77, as she crossed the road inside a marked crosswalk at around 7:30 p.m. The crash took place on 3rd Avenue North near Van Buren Street. According to Metropolitan Nashville police, Dobbins, who lived nearby, was taken to Vanderbilt University Medical Center where she died. 'The preliminary contributing factor for this crash appears to be Smith failing to yield the right of way to the pedestrian,' the police statement said. 'He showed no signs of impairment.' The investigation is ongoing and there are no charges 'at present' against Smith, police said. In a statement shared with People, Smith's lawyer confirmed that the singer was 'involved in a car accident that tragically claimed a life'. 'His heart goes out to Ms Dobbins's family during this incredibly difficult time,' the statement said. 'Mr Smith continues to cooperate fully with the ongoing investigation.' The crash took place on the final day of the annual Country Music Association Fest, a four-day celebration of country music in Nashville. Smith, who was born and raised in the Tennessee music hub, released his debut album, Smoky Mountains, last year through Big Machine Records' Valory imprint. The album included the single 'Creek Will Rise', which became Smith's first Top 20 hit on the Billboard Country Airply chart in 2023. The musician was nominated for New Male Artist of the Year at the 2024 Academy of Country Music Awards, and opened for Luke Bryan that same year. His song 'Steal My Thunder' featuring fellow country singer Tucker Wetmore featured on the soundtrack to the 2024 American disaster film Twisters, which charted at No. 3 on the Billboard 200. He married surfer Leah Thompson last year.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Rising country star Conner Smith ‘cooperating with police' after woman killed in car crash
Country music singer Conner Smith's is cooperating fully with an investigation into a fatal weekend car wreck, his reps have said. Smith, 24, is said to have been driving a Chevrolet Silverado pickup truck on Sunday in Nashville when he hit Dorothy Dobbins, 77, as she crossed the road inside a marked crosswalk at around 7:30 p.m. The crash took place on 3rd Avenue North near Van Buren Street. According to Metropolitan Nashville police, Dobbins, who lived nearby, was taken to Vanderbilt University Medical Center where she died. 'The preliminary contributing factor for this crash appears to be Smith failing to yield the right of way to the pedestrian,' the police statement said. 'He showed no signs of impairment.' The investigation is ongoing and there are no charges 'at present' against Smith, police said. In a statement shared with People, Smith's lawyer confirmed that the singer was 'involved in a car accident that tragically claimed a life'. 'His heart goes out to Ms Dobbins's family during this incredibly difficult time,' the statement said. 'Mr Smith continues to cooperate fully with the ongoing investigation.' The crash took place on the final day of the annual Country Music Association Fest, a four-day celebration of country music in Nashville. Smith, who was born and raised in the Tennessee music hub, released his debut album, Smoky Mountains, last year through Big Machine Records' Valory imprint. The album included the single 'Creek Will Rise', which became Smith's first Top 20 hit on the Billboard Country Airply chart in 2023. The musician was nominated for New Male Artist of the Year at the 2024 Academy of Country Music Awards, and opened for Luke Bryan that same year. His song 'Steal My Thunder' featuring fellow country singer Tucker Wetmore featured on the soundtrack to the 2024 American disaster film Twisters, which charted at No. 3 on the Billboard 200. He married surfer Leah Thompson last year.
